⭐️⭐️⭐️ three stars -
“Octavia” is a problematic, dated Jilly Cooper. It’s getting three stars from this reviewer because I like Cooper, and I always thoroughly enjoy the trip back in time with each of her reads. Also, Cooper’s books get to fall into my elusive “if this was written by anyone else” category, because really, with all the misogyny it should really get two stars, but again, this is Cooper, so it gets three stars from me 💁♀️
This story was originally published in 1977 with a plot that includes our heroine, Octavia, as a spoilt, pampered trust fund baby of the 1970s. This popular Cooper tale was originally penned by the author as a weekly serial, and in parts it does read like this, but overall she did a great job sewing it all up and finessing it all together; as only Cooper can do.
I thoroughly enjoyed the points Cooper always excels at: the fantastic world building and scene setting of the upper crust members of society. What I didn’t like are the dated sexist attitudes towards women; and in particular, the Hero’s blatantly sexualized comments, which border on sexual harassment. He continually slings barbed, overly sexual remarks towards our heroine and other side characters, and it was cringe-inducing.
Are unwanted sexual remarks a form of sexual harassment that needs to be viewed as a product of the 1970s? Does this attitude need to be accepted as part of the plot, and a mark of the era? Maybe, but nevertheless, it made me uncomfortable and brought back flashbacks of being catcalled on the streets as a young woman back in the day. Or even moments of everyone’s favorite; being told by random strangers to, “smile, beautiful”. I’m personally glad those days are long gone when men felt so entitled to accost women on the streets as sexual objects. Could it be that I’ve aged, and no longer fall into that category? Maybe lol, but I like to think that times have changed and women don’t have to put up with being made to feel uncomfortable anymore. I’m all for these evolved modern attitudes!
Back to the book…. I enjoyed it, and will most likely read this again, all problematic misogyny aside, it’s still well-written, it’s still Cooper, and the character development for our heroine is top-notch. I don’t quite buy the romance, but I do enjoy the story.
Important to note: if you’ve taken a look at other reviews, you will notice that nearly everyone has issue with the fact that our Hero here spanks the heroine - and not in a good way 🤣 there is nothing sexy about it; he spanks her because he’s angry, and it’s the early 1970s and men didn’t need to control their tempers, and it was somewhat acceptable (in print, anyway) for a man to “take a woman in hand” 🤮
Also of note, the edition I read was the newest Kindle version (published in 2005), and it did not include the line from the Hero about how Welsh men know how to put their women in place by manhandling them.
The text that nearly every poor review here mentions, has been scrubbed clean, and the line from the very last scene has been revamped (I’m going to guess by Cooper herself, since she’s still alive - or at least by the guidance of the punisher since this book is a reputable Penguin Random House UK publication), and now reads as follows:
“I’m going to wear the trousers. You’re going to do what I tell you, and if you start upstaging me, I’ll put you down. The boys in the Valley are like that with our women, but we know how to love them.”
I’m not surprised about the cleaning up of this line; maybe other parts of the book have been whitewashed, too? I don’t know, myself, as this is the first time I’m reading this one. I do know that it makes sense that an attempt would be made to modernize it, as much as it can be anyway, since this is a very popular Cooper. It’s a story that’s gone from a weekly serial (as mentioned above), to a TV movie (released in 2009 on UK television). Maybe it’s been worked up for the movie? That would make sense to me, since modern viewers would most likely have trouble swallowing a lot of the blatant sexism in this tale.
This twentieth century take on “The Taming the Shrew” is a story that many will enjoy, as Octavia is a wonderfully multi-faceted character. I just loved the complete character development of our heroine in this one.
Would I recommend? Yes, but keep in mind that you’re going to get a hefty dose of the bad parts of the 1970s. If you go into it knowing that this is what you need to expect, then you might just enjoy this tale of a poor little rich girl. Overall, and taken at surface level, it’s a wonderful read.
Do recommend when you need a good Cooper fix, and are craving a quick, easy read. This one was emotional to me, and I hope you find that part, too, when you read between the lines of the story.