I absolutely loved this series as a whole, but the last book didn't measure up for me. Mostly, I'm not a fan of "a slice of life" stories, and that's what the majority of this book is about. There were, however, some issues that I thought harmed the book as a whole.
Rodek didn't really feel in character throughout the book for me. I didn't buy into his thought process during the event we've been waiting for for over 6 books now. It was suppose to be the biggest build up in the book, considering it had a firm footing in the TV series, but it felt underwhelming, and rushed (or poorly thought out) to the point that I didn't buy into it.
Also, I never quite understood the whole reason they recalled the ships. Yeah, I understood the excuse given, but I didn't feel it was the least bit plausible. It seemed odd to me that Klingons could die so easily because of an insult, or because they didn't repair something quick enough, yet we have this childish (and seemingly pointless) behavior that wastes the time of the entire fleet, but no one is punished. It was just bizarre.
The ending of the book also left so many questions. I thought the author was going in a specific direction, but it never got there. Worse yet, it seemed like he wrote himself into a corner, and an entire story line (if not two) felt entirely unresolved. Perhaps, this book was suppose to be a book 1 of a new series? That's all that I could fathom from how it ended. I would have liked to see a little hint about what was to come, you know, just in case another book was never made.
Even with the trouble I had buying any of the explanations for any of the events, I do believe the book is enjoyable and worth reading, especially since it's the last of the series. While the plot points seemed to be rather superficial, the characters were fun to read.
ST books, on average, tend to be a bit sub-par, in my experience. In comparison, the Gorkon series was a step (if not two) above the rest. It's probably the only series that I would consider reading again, sometime in the future. I hope those that have not given it a try (and care at all about Klingsons) would do so. I'd also like to thank the author for doing such a good job.
Qapla'