The Gotenks fight used to be my favorite of the franchise, and it’s still pretty fantastic in my eyes. It’s really drawn out to create the most anticipation possible, but it’s always funny at the same time. The idea to fight in the room of spirit and time is so cool, it lets the character illustrates themselves really pop, and Toriyama can get really creative with the visual highlights.
Gotenks and Super Boo bounce so well off of each other. They are equally immature and equally nonsensical. The fact that Boo can regenerate through his smoke is as ridiculous as Gotenks making self-destructive clones of himself. It’s just creative and fun. Piccolo is the perfect straight man for all this nonsense, although I do wish he played more of a role.
Even though screaming a hole through dimensions doesn’t really make sense, it lets the fight rampage through Earth in a surreal and satisfying way. You wouldn’t think it’s cool for Kami’s palace to get ruined, but it’s pretty awesome. Seeing the two fly through buildings and incinerate cities is a whole new level of batshit crazy. But it all gets cut short once Gotenks powers down. And with his power decline comes the decline in quality for the rest of the volume.
The next hope lies in Gohan, who’s been building energy for over a volume now. His introduction into the battlefield is incredibly satisfying, he pummels Boo and the end is in sight. It’s not even a fight. And that’s kind of why it’s not as good. I counted, Gohan is given 6 pages of dominance over Boo. That prolonged and forced training arc results in 6 pages. After that, he becomes the punching bag.
Remember when Dragon Ball fights were intense? When there wasn’t a dominant power destined to win? Yes, Goku was that dominant power in the early early days, but the Saiyan arc is so special because it’s a struggle on both ends of the battle. When there is a clear winner or loser, you already know that some outside force is gonna turn the tables.
Toriyama couldn’t truly commit to the “New Generation of Heroes” concept, and it’s really disappointing to me. I really don’t understand why he had to force Goku back to life for a third time, in the most ridiculous way possible. The older Lord of Lords is a character we were just introduced to, and he gives his life to Goku so he can save the day once again. But like every other sacrifice in Dragon Ball, it doesn’t mean much, as he is still in the picture complete with a halo.
I haven’t even mentioned the potara yet. What makes the fusion dance so cool is its specificity. Yes, it’s an insane power boost, but it takes a long time to get right. And it only lasts for 30 minutes. This trade-off leads to some real tension. But the potara earrings bypass all of that tension. It’s just another example of a superficial and boring power boost. The third one in two volumes, after Super Saiyan 3 and Gohan’s “potential.”
But at the end of the day, despite this volumes narrative pitfalls, I still think it’s pretty damn cool. Boo has become one of my favorite villains despite his inconsistencies, and there are plenty of twists and turns to keep you engaged.