e-book freebie for signing up for their newsletter
This collection features winter/Christmas themed romance stories throughout history from the Middle Ages to the early 20th-century. The characters hail from Ireland, the United States and England.
"The Road to Cavan Town" by Sarah M. Eden - In 1864 the roads to Cavan Town, County Cavan, Ireland feature a number of young bachelors headed to lake country to court the belle of the county, each hoping for a single word from the beauty. Alice Whatley is no beauty but she knows she would make Isaac Dancy a better wife than Miss Sophia Kilchrest. Alice is used to the hard work of life in service and caring for her aging relatives. Traveling back and forth she's gotten to know Isaac very well. He owns a good farm that survived the Great Hunger and he hopes to proper more. Isaac is proud of his farm and doing the backbreaking labor himself. He seeks a wife who will help connect him with the community and unite everyone with smiles and good grace. Alice wonders how he can expect a fine lady like Miss Kilchrest to give up her fancy house with servants and move to a farm. How can Alice convince Isaac that she is the one for him?
This is a cute story and I liked it best of all the stories in this collection. Alice is practical not a beauty; she's intelligent and though she's in love, she's not lovesick. She knows her limits of friendship and how much she's willing to accept. Alice won't give in to anything except true love. Isaac is a wonderful hero though completely blind to Alice as anything other than a friend. Like Edmund Bertram in Mansfield Park he sees a pretty face and elegant facade and thinks he's in love. Sophia doesn't deserve him. The introduction of Billy was a little bit too much of a plot device for me. He didn't quite fit the story but serves to show the characters of both women. The final courtship scene is so adorable. I dare you not to smile!
"It Happened Twelfth Night" by Heidi Ashworth- Luisa is eager to be reunited with her childhood sweetheart Percy after his trip abroad. Their summer kisses were so delicious and Luisa has waited for the promise of more. Somehow they will convince his noble parents that the daughter of their gatekeeper will make an excellent wife for their son. Months later Luisa slips into Percy's family's Twelfth Night ball, eager to be alone with her love at last. Instead she finds her heart broken and loses her way in the servants quarters. If found, it will lower her reputation even further than it already has. With the help of a mysterious stranger she finds her way out of her difficult situation.
Hmmm I'm not entirely crazy about this story. On one hand it takes place all in one night and I don't buy that timeline as a true love story. However, I did enjoy the details about the Mummers and the Twelfth Night activities in the Regency period. Luisa is no longer young and longs for romance and adventure. I can see why she falls in love but will it last? The mysterious man was a bit of a surprise and my instincts were telling me to run and not give in to chivalry. Is it real? Both Luisa's men lie to her for different reasons. If this story had a longer timeline and an epilogue it might appeal to me more.
"Un Unexpected Proposal" by Annette Lyon takes place in the wilds of Utah in 1880. Caroline is working as a maid in a logging camp to earn money to help her younger sister who is ill with a form of tuberculosis. Caroline doesn't mind the work except for serving the evening meal when that awful Butch Larson makes every attempt to touch her inappropriately against her will. Her boss, Mrs. Hansen, doesn't quite believe Caroline but her childhood chum James does and worries about her. James is ready to challenge Butch despite Butch being a relative of the Hansens who run the camp. Caroline doesn't feel this chivalry is necessary. It's not Jamie's place to protect her and it never will be. She dreams of being swept off her feet by a handsome, roguish man who will dance with her all night. When winter comes Caroline discovers some unexpected things about her own heart but it may be too late.
I liked this story the least. First, in a clean and secular collection this story doesn't fit the criteria exactly. It's Little House on the Prairie Mormon style with a #MeToo plot driving the romance. There's no overt preaching but it's mentioned the men read the Scriptures in the evening and Caroline doesn't even know what alcohol smells like pointing out the characters come from a religious community. The sexual harassment plot was a surprise and out of place in this otherwise light and fluffy anthology. The romance wrapped up quickly and sweetly but the rest of the story is a dud. I felt sorry for Caroline that she was being harassed and that was about the extent of my feelings for her. I liked Jamie much better. He's kind, caring, sweet and a hard worker. What's not to love in the wild west? Really, I would marry him! She doesn't have a lot of other options. I would recommend skipping this story if you prefer your romances fluffy.
"Carols on the Lawn" by Joyce DiPastena is unlike any other romance I've ever read. It's set in 1151 in England at Christmastime early on in the history of Christmas celebrations. The heroine, Isabel, and her sister Agnes are daughter of a Lord who has invited a number of knights and ladies to celebrate the Christmas season with them. Isabel has promised to choose a husband before the guests leave. One man is the same as the other as far as she's concerned. The one she will NOT marry is Lucian de Warrene. His kisses were divine but he is too controlling, too strong for Isabel. She is determined to rule her husband as she has ruled her father these many years. When she receives a ring mysteriously from an anonymous suitor she vows to marry whoever sent the ring. First though, she must figure out who sent it and how much she can control him.
I really liked this story more than I thought I would, mostly for the Christmas traditions. I had no idea Christmas carols were originally dances. "The Holly and the Ivy" is featured in this story and learning about the development of the dance is fascinating. The mystery sucked me in too. I could relate very much to headstrong Isabel. She isn't much of a medieval maiden though.
Isabel has a quick temper, is stubborn and incredibly strong willed. I didn't like how she wanted to rule her husband. Why not an equal partner? Agnes is sweet but she too seems to want some more control over her husband. Agnes would like to be allowed to do the accounts. Isabel's reasons for being the way she is are valid and I understand why but she is a little too annoyingly stubborn even for me. The gentlemen are not all that appealing. Sir Theo is kind and chivalrous but not too bright so he is a good candidate for husband material. I wouldn't want to marry him just to rule him. He's nothing but kind. Sir Eustace on the other hand is a dandy and possibly a medieval rake. I don't trust him. Sir Tristan is the male version of Isabel. He is a manly man-strong, brave, tough and really proud. Their sparks are a bit too mean to be delightful. The only other woman in the story is a spoiled beauty stereotype with no original personality traits.
I do recommend this story for the original setting and historical details.
"A Winter's Night" by Donna Hatch-In 1813 England Clarissa Fairchild is on her way home to celebrate Christmas with her family. As she passes the legendary Wyckburg Castle she can't help but imagine the terrifying lords who were said to have murdered their wives. How delicious! If only she could meet a murderous Earl! (Dun dun dun...) A carriage accident in a snowstorm may grant Clarissa her wish.
Clarissa is of a similar type to Jane Austen's Catherine Morland. Clarissa is young with a head full of silly gothic novels. She thinks the fantasy is more appealing than the reality of the dull suitors she's met in London. Clarissa is a bit more mature than Catherine. She doesn't let her imagination rule her mind. When she discovers the reality of the situation she is compassionate and kind. While I keep saying I hate brooding heroes, I guess I do like them because Christopher de Champs, Early of Wyckburg is a sympathetic hero. He's led a tragic life which causes his brooding. He's not cruel like Mr. Rochester or Heathcliff though. Christopher is understanding yet resigned to his terrible fate. I wasn't thrilled with the silly reason for that fate but it could just be a coincidence. The insta-love is a bit too much but I can see why they both fall in love with what they know about one another. The epilogue satisfied my curiosity. I liked this story a lot.
"A Fortunate Exile" by Heather B. Moore- In New York City in 1901 a lady should never cause a scandal. What will the papers say? Lila Townsend has done just that by getting caught in an unseemly position with her neighbor Roland, a bachelor. Lila's father is outraged and forces her into exile on her Aunt Eugenia's farm. Aunt Eugenia is old, a religious fanatic and cheap (or has money troubles which one would never admit). Lila is miserable. The only bright spot in her life is Aunt Eugenia's young distant cousin Peter Weathers. Peter is a Yale student staying with his relative and pinching pennies until he can help his family recover from disaster. Peter is instantly attracted to the young maiden in exile though she is a Society girl like his lost love Danelle. He knows to guard his heart but if he can make his young friend's life a little easier he will do it despite Aunt Eugenia's strict rules.
I did not like this story. I'm too old for silly, bratty heroines. Not that I wouldn't have acted the same way myself as a teenager but I didn't care for Lila. She's almost a victim of the "Why buy the cow when you can have the milk for free?" school of thought. Certainly that was Roland's intention. I do empathize with Lila's exile. It sounds horrendous and I think her life could be in danger. Aunt Eugenia is just awful and doesn't care about Lila at all. Lila's father only cares about his reputation and her mother is too weak to do anything to support her only child. It sounds like they blame Lila for something that happened long ago and they favorited their golden haired angel over her. That backstory is not fully developed. The romance happens too quickly for me and I need an epilogue. There's NO WAY that is going to work as is. Peter is a fun character. He has a sense of humor and is very kind. I can see Lila falling in love with him because of the situation and staying in love because of his personality. What he sees in her besides a maiden to be rescued I don't know. This is my second least favorite story of the collection.