This is my second review of this book, having reread it. My First Review is below.
This is a difficult one to rate.
If you take this book as a collection of linked short stories, it would rate a three. Technically competent and interesting but nothing special.
If you read this as what it really is, which is a collection of super-hero graphic novels, but without the artwork, it would rate a five. As an example of the super-hero stories which many of us grew up reading, by Marvel and DC, it is outstanding.
Hence the four.
This book has a fascinating history, starting from a MMORG, in the days when text and speech was supreme and visuals in their infancy, progressing to a series of podcasts, and then finally a book. It is a rare example of the spoken word coming first, and then the book, not the other way around.
If you like US comics, the you will enjoy this book. If you don't like comics, then I would think twice before reading.
My First Review in 2011.
This review is actually from the e-book, ARC, off webscription.
The authors credit the MMORPG 'City of Heroes' as the inspiration for this book, the first in a new series. The reality is more complex. It owes a lot to the 'Wild Cards' series of books, without which I very much doubt this new series would exist. It owes something to the Golden and Silver age comics, with their fighting the Axis themes and heroes, but not nearly as much as they try and insinuate in the first couple of chapters. It borrows ideas from sources as diverse as 'Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow' and Dennis Wheatley. In short it is a collage, a pastiche, with very little that is actually new. But the old adage applies "Steal from one place it's plagiarism, steal from several places, it's research".
Having said all that it is a good read. The joins from it being a multiple author work are sometimes a little too obvious. The writing takes itself a little serious serious and threatens to become preachy. But it is a coherent story, it has good narrative redundancy, it reaches a climax, if a slightly hurried one, and it sets the stage for an extended series with at least two viable sub-plots giving scope for off the main branch books.
I enjoyed it, with all it's faults. I am looking forward to more books, and I think that being able to slow the pace with less required exposition will make for some really good sequels.
Most important of all there is a large cast of characters, all very much individual, all well written, and almost all of whom I really want to know more about, both their past and their future.
I recommend it.