"You don't know that, Mr. Carter. You have no idea." His eyes get wide. He's as surprised as I am that I talked back. "You're right, Sam," he says. "What I do know is you have a shot to be great today. I think you should take it."
I wasn't too sure how I'd like this book, but I picked it up because it caught my eye on the book list for my adolescent literature class because I have always had a passion for slam poetry. In middle school I actually went to a few poetry slams, but lost the practice of writing for slams and lost the desire to go once I was around people that talked down/made fun of the art of slam poetry. I don't know why, but people my age (I am currently twenty-one) loved making fun of slam poetry for some reason, but it's always been something I love. Since I no longer do it and was never really that good at it, I thought that maybe this book would give me some slam poetry nostalgia and maybe spark my love for producing slam poetry again. I mean, I think it's a given that this book DID get me back into the poetry vibe, especially that of slam poetry, but it did SO MUCH MORE than that.
This book follows the story of Samuel, a boy who was raised in Aberdeen for the early part of his life then shipped off to live with his grandparents, so his mother could go somewhere filled with sun. In Aberdeen, Sam and his two friends planned to start a band, to be the next Nirvana. If Nirvana could find their way into stardom out of Aberdeen, Sam, Rupe, and Dave could find their way out too. They wrote songs and aspired to be musicians, but the opportunity never arose, because he had to leave. His mother left to Arizona and the last thing she said to him was "GOOD-BYE, SAM!" which is what his grandparents' bird spoke to him every time he entered or left the house. This makes Sam hate the bird, Gilbert, because it reminds him of that day and constantly makes him sad. Since his mother left, and made him move away from all his friends, Sam became a "slacker" in school and decided all he wanted out of his life was to blend into the background, until one day a kid named Luis joins his classes and is made to sit next to him in every single one. Luis is suspected to be involved in a gang, just like his brother and father, so he has a reputation for being someone to be scared of around the school. Sam quickly notices that Luis follows the same "slacker" rules that he does, that is, until their teacher, which Sam calls Cassidy, decides that she's not going to let them get away with hiding in her classroom. They get assigned a poetry project for the poetry slam and that is when their relationship grows from being hesitant seat partners to being really good friends. They work their butts off for the project, and actually grow really close. Then, something happens to change it all, and Sam is changed forever.
This book was actually a journey I wasn't expecting to go on. It was full of twists that I would have never thought would happen within the novel from just reading the description, and I never knew what was coming next. I felt like I didn't know much of Sam's prior life and I was fine with that, because I really enjoyed getting to watch him make a life for himself at his grandparents' house, which he eventually saved into his phone as "home."I was worried that this book would be too focused on rock music because of Sam's obsession with Nirvana, but I was very pleased to find that the novel only mentioned Nirvana to further the story and add deeper connections to it, and didn't focus the entire thing on Nirvana lyrics and Kurt Cobain. I think it incorporated Nirvana into the story just enough to where it isn't too much but really emphasizes the story. This was a beautiful story that I wasn't expecting to come out of this novel, but I absolutely loved it. There were so many moving parts that I always had something jump out that I wasn't expecting. The poetry incorporated within the novel was absolutely gorgeous, and I think the combination of prose and poetry really worked well together. All in all, this story is absolutely beautiful and I recommend it to anyone who might be interested in poetry, Nirvana, or just a wonderful story of a lonely kid finally finding friends and motivation through self-expression.
There are a lot of things textually going on within this novel that I thought were very beautiful and intricate. The novel is written in Sam's voice and he is the sole narrator, but throughout the novel there are interruptions with poetry written by Luis that no one has any knowledge of other than Luis. He doesn't advertise poetry-writing, but the poems not only show his passion for poetry but also give an insight and backstory into Luis's life that we don't get from the character himself or from Sam's interactions with him. Luis is fairly quiet as a character in the novel but his poetry speaks volumes. I really loved this change in perspective, because not only did it provide an alternative point of view and information about a character, but it incorporated the beauty of poetry within a novel. I have always loved poetry in novels, especially when dispersed into prose, so I thought this fit very well. I recently read the novel Gabi, A Girl in Pieces by Isabel Quintero, and it also contained poetry mixed in with prose. I just think it combines two very fun styles of writing to tell a story. It's important to see, to, because it shows people reading the novel that you can write works that don't just utilize one method of writing. I also really liked the way that the teachers were addressed as just their last names, not with any prefixes (like Ms., Mrs., or Mr.) I felt that it was more personal that way because it's how Sam and Luis would be addressing their teachers when talking to one another, and I think it also showed how personal the relationships between teachers and students are in the school. Another thing I was a fan of was the way Ms. Cassidy addressed Sam and Luis as "Luisandsam" because it is what followed them throughout the rest of their novel. Being paired like that strengthened their relationship, led tot heir friendship, and resulted in Sam finding his own place in the world once the pair broke up. The short chapters were also a huge plus because they allowed information to be explained more concisely and also helped hold my attention as I read. I really enjoyed the stylistic elements of this novel AND the story itself, and I am so glad that I chose to read this for my class.
When it comes to my future as an educator, I believe I could find many ways to incorporate this novel into my classroom. It involves stylistic elements that could spark great discussions and incorporates poetry alongside the teaching of poetry, even with a few sample worksheets/assignments scattered in. I think this could be a great novel to incorporate into classrooms, and I believe it is just a wonderful novel to read overall. I loved this book and couldn't put it down after I'd picked it up. This is a story that will stick with you for a long time, and it's absolutely beautiful. I think this novel would be appropriate for late middle students onward, and I even think adults could get something great out of it. I highly recommend this novel for anyone that might be interested in reading it, and I hope you enjoy it as much as I did!