Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Dallying with Demons #3

Claiming a Demon

Rate this book
As an exuberant extrovert, Zach has been known to adopt nervous introverts and take them under his wing. So when he sees the quiet demon struggling to find a gift for his friends, he can’t help but step in. So maybe he’s also drumming up business for his job. Who says you can’t multitask? But this demon is in need of more than a massage, and Zach finds himself falling head first. The only problem is… does his new demon boyfriend feel the same way? Or will he toss Zach away when he no longer needs him?

Mal has always been quiet. When you grow up with six older sisters, if you want to avoid being dragged into an argument, you keep your mouth shut. So when the most important person in his life gets sick, he thinks it's best to keep it to himself. But the little pixie who keeps rescuing him won’t let that fly. Zach is determined to help him. And Mal doesn’t put up a fight.

But when Mal’s dad takes a turn for the worse, their new relationship is put to the test. The question is, can they handle the pressure?

Zach adopts an introvert, protectiveness, size difference, opposites attract, spa treatment, accidental erections, Zach’s in charge, Mal likes it, Shadow plague, emotional hurt/comfort, snuggles, Zach has the best shower, bossy bottom, family drama, Mal learns to rely on others, witches make the best friends, too many sisters, hospital chairs are uncomfortable, caretakers need help sometimes too

212 pages, Kindle Edition

First published June 4, 2024

143 people are currently reading
53 people want to read

About the author

Amy Padilla

24 books124 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
314 (45%)
4 stars
236 (34%)
3 stars
122 (17%)
2 stars
10 (1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews
848 reviews5 followers
May 29, 2024
3.25/5 This one didn’t work quite as well for me as the others in the series. Maybe there was a little too much packed in there for the length of the novel, and so I felt like things were dealt with really quickly or just didn’t have room to expand. I found Zach a bit too pushy at times, and Mal a bit too much of a pushover, and sometimes it spilled into the relationship.

It took me a little while to get into the relationship, I think because Mal was so guarded and quiet at the beginning, he’s a bit of cypher. But the set up is clear: Zach is the bubbly extravert, and he’s bringing Mal out of his shell, and Mal likes everyone about Zach and is ready to take him as he is. It’s going well but fast, but this is a short book, I’m okay with that. And then Zach hit 100% unreasonable for me: he announces they’re boyfriends (a fake out during a confrontation), then leans into it. Mal doesn’t object. Then when Zach’s brand new, laconic boyfriend who is struggling with his father’s illness doesn’t immediately announce his current struggles to Zach, but instead wants physical comfort, Zach decides this must mean Mal isn’t really into him, he’s going to cool it on the boyfriend front, but they can still be friends—which he demonstrates by being distant and busy and not very available for the next week. For someone who supposedly wants to help Mal have a voice, Zach seemed big on making a lot of choices for him. Sometimes, they’re really bad at communication, and it doesn’t feel like they actually know one another that well.

Mal also demonstrates at points that maybe Zach is right and he’s not in a great place for a relationship. He doesn’t notice Zach’s discomfort during the “distraction” intimacy, he doesn’t notice Zach has left the hospital and doesn’t think about him at all. (There *is* a lot on his mind, but that’s kind of the point.) He rages at his family in a very unhealthy way, and it never gets dealt with. There’s a successful outcome, but I think he would seriously benefit from therapy.

Most of the time, I don’t much like the way his siblings treat him, nor his parents, nor his friends. Zach is presented as the only one who understands and can read Mal, and while that’s nice from the “mate” perspective, it makes me pretty sad about the rest of his life and how it seems like none of these caring people tried very hard with him. (His friends couldn’t come even once to the fancy restaurant where he cooks? To support their friend even though it’s not super their thing? No?)

Mal is able to assert his opinion in more healthy ways at some points. Felix defends Mal, Callum is there when Mal needs him, Mal’s parents demonstrate he’s not the only one who makes dumb decisions, Zach lets himself be taken care of occasionally…. There are sweet and supportive moments in the book, it just didn’t quite balance right for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Latecia Jennings.
2,287 reviews10 followers
June 7, 2024
**First time reader**

This was good. Being a first time reader of Amy Padilla, she got me interested by the blurb and the characters. So, coming in on book 3 wasn't too bad. I could tell other characters were there from previous books but it didn't cause me to be lost in the sauce. I enjoyed this demon story immensely. Mal and Zach was so good together. This was not real angsty...a little communication issues that was ultimately dealt with but I will say this romance was all sweet with heat. Zach was the right amount of sunshine to Mal's quiet nature. I love opposites and this didn't disappoint. Lovely romance...wonderful HEA. I will definitely continue on with the series.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
1,997 reviews15 followers
June 3, 2024
Zachariah intercedes when bullies try to harm Malakai, a demon. Zach is a delightful, energetic human and so sweet and kind. Mal is quiet and reserved, hiding his emotions. They are perfect together, complimenting each other's needs. They form a friendship that grows into love and support through Mal's angst and Zach's illness. Their's is a gentle, caring kind of love, nurturing and enabling. I am enjoying this series of humans and demons in relationships. I received a copy of this book and this is my voluntary opinion.
Profile Image for Natalie  H.
3,726 reviews30 followers
August 26, 2025
August 2025
Kindle edition

I had to read the blurb to try and remember this one. So far Zach and Mal have been the characters with the least presence. All I really remember about this one is meditation and massages. Not one that stuck with me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Abigail Beckwith.
1,574 reviews
June 12, 2024
I was recently introduced to Amy Padilla and her Dallying with Demons series. The third book is "Claiming a Demon."
["As an exuberant extrovert, Zach has been known to adopt nervous introverts and take them under his wing. So when he sees the quiet demon struggling to find a gift for his friends, he can’t help but step in. So maybe he’s also drumming up business for his job. Who says you can’t multitask? But this demon is in need of more than a massage, and Zach finds himself falling head first. The only problem is… does his new demon boyfriend feel the same way? Or will he toss Zach away when he no longer needs him?

Mal has always been quiet. When you grow up with six older sisters, if you want to avoid being dragged into an argument, you keep your mouth shut. So when the most important person in his life gets sick, he thinks it's best to keep it to himself. But the little pixie who keeps rescuing him won’t let that fly. Zach is determined to help him. And Mal doesn’t put up a fight.

But when Mal’s dad takes a turn for the worse, their new relationship is put to the test. The question is, can they handle the pressure?"]

And the bonus tags (because they're arguable better than the blurb itself): ["Zach adopts an introvert, protectiveness, size difference, opposites attract, spa treatment, accidental erections, Zach’s in charge, Mal likes it, Shadow plague, emotional hurt/comfort, snuggles, Zach has the best shower, bossy bottom, family drama, Mal learns to rely on others, witches make the best friends, too many sisters, hospital chairs are uncomfortable, caretakers need help sometimes too"]

God, how does one feel SO. MUCH. of what BOTH Zach and Mal were feeling? Both too afraid to rock the boat and say something, but feeling as if you're too much for people? Holy. Shit. Moving on from that not-needed-atm-life-revelation...

These two were freaking adorable. Mal felt uncomfortable almost everywhere, always hiding away his thoughts and emotions (and facial expressions), until he met Mal and just accepted that this pixie-shaped-person was his new security blanket slash emotional support person. Zach always wanted to help people, to take care of people (but was never truly taken care of back) and when his walking dream man stumbles into his life needing help and care? He was a goner, all "I volunteer as tribute" style. Together, they were a force to be reckoned with.

Trigger Warnings: life threatening illnesses, sick fathers, emotional struggles, feeling too much for most people to handle, and more

#datingademon #tamingademon #claimingademon #lovingademon #savingademon #dallyingwithdemons #dallyingwithdemonsseries #amypadilla #books #queerbooks #queererotica #bodicerippers #bookstagram #bookphotography #ilovebooks
502 reviews15 followers
June 16, 2024
3.5 stars

I strongly enjoyed books 1 and 2 but felt this one was the weakest of the series so far. Mal is the soft spoken friend of the demon group. He is easy to get along with, mostly because he keeps his opinions to himself because he doesn’t like making waves due to his upbringing. Zach is a bubbly human who stands up for Mal when he’s being bullied by anti-demon humans.

I really felt for Mal here. His friends are quick to question his new relationship, questioning his boyfriend’s motives and his family completely ignore his concerns and opinions and when things come to a head no one apologises to him for an entire life of being treated poorly. Mal’s friends need to do better supporting him and they definitely need to apologise for the derogatory things they said about Zach.

In my opinion, Mal really deserved better from anyone in his life but Mal’s reaction regarding his family wasn’t the healthiest and I do actually agree with Zach when he tells him that he probably isn’t in the best place to be pursuing a relationship. I really liked both characters separately but not sure how much I loved them as a couple. At first it seems like a good balance being that Mal doesn’t like to speak up as he hates confrontation and being in the spotlight, and Zach is opinionated (not in a bad way) and is more than willing to speak his mind on issues. However, it sort of felt like he was pushing his own agenda at times and telling Mal how he should act. Still an enjoyable offering in the series, but unfortunately my least favourite.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
Profile Image for Flick.
980 reviews8 followers
June 5, 2024
I really love this series

I am loving this series and the couples in it and Zach and Mal are no different. What I find interesting with this series is that the characters are not ‘perfect’ friends. Often you have a group of incredibly close characters (each of whom gets a book) and they’re perfect with each other. Amy doesn’t have a perfect friend group. They make mistakes, sometimes huge ones (like Felix and Callum and then with how everyone but Felix reacts to Zach). But that happens. People get tunnel vision or start seeing people in one light. There’s nothing wrong with that as long as you’re able to come back from it and these guys do. They work to get past the not so great moments. Zach and Mal do have a harder time with their relationship internally in this book. Mal is going through a lot and that combined with Zach’s need to help and support mean that communication between them isn’t awesome 100% of the time. It also doesn’t help that Mal has trained himself to never voice his opinion. Once they actually talk all those issues disappear pretty quickly (which is often the case because mind reading doesn’t work even if you can actually do it). What’s left is a really sweet ending that makes you feel happy these two put in the effort to support each other and work through the iffy spots. I’m super excited to see what’s coming for Hen - especially as we didn’t really get a glimpse of his person in the sneak peek!
Profile Image for Melissa.
299 reviews1 follower
June 3, 2024
I was so busy trying to protect myself, I forgot that sometimes love was worth the risk.

I really enjoyed Mal and Zach! I mean, what introvert doesn't want to be adopted and cared for by an extrovert?! Zach stands up for Mal from day one. That kind of strength and care taking were lovely scenes in the book. Watching them navigate their friends to lovers situation with relatable confusion made me want to hug them both and force them to say the scary thing of 'I like you and I love you'.

Both Mal and Zach have some hang ups and past trauma, but they find a way to support each other and understand each other along the way. They might be my favorite couple?!

While I would have liked a couple more chapters to tie up some issues I had with Mal's family in particular, overall I had a great time reading this book! And am looking forward to our demon rockstar finding love in book 4.


Claiming a Demon is book 3, and can be read standalone, but personally I think best to be read in order.

MM Human/Demon
Size Difference
Found family
Open door spice
Introvert/Extrovert
On page bigotry
Illness/palliative care (not our MCs)

*advanced reader. thoughts and opinions my own*
Profile Image for Marion.
1,661 reviews
June 10, 2024
This is the third book in the Dallying with Demons series. While you might be able to enjoy this as a standalone, you really should read the series in order. This is the story of Malakai and Zachariah. Mal is a demon who is shy and stoic. Zach is a human massage therapist. He is like lightening in a bottle. Full of positive energy, cheerfulness and an overwhelming urge to help. The two meet when Zach steps in to a racist attack upon Mal. Zach immediately take Mal under his wing. He wants to help him and maybe coax a smile out of him. In spite of the odds, the two become friends. I liked how Zach respects Mal's limits and slowly tries to bring him out of his shell. And how Mal enjoys Zach's boundless enthusiasm and doesn't find it annoying like people usually do. This is their story. I really enjoyed this book. It is well written and easy to read. Of course, the course of true love doesn't run completely smoothly. Mal has issues to deal with and Zach supports him a 100%. I liked how Mal tried to show Zach how much he means to him. I look forward to the next book in this series.

I received a complementary advanced review copy from the author and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for SNik.
583 reviews17 followers
May 27, 2024
Third in series (Dallying with Demons), best if read in order. Paranormal. Opposites attract. Hurt/comfort. Dual POV. Heed content warnings.

When Mal goes looking for a present for some human friends he doesn’t expect to get help from a charismatic, energetic human that somehow comes to his rescue. Zach doesn’t mind that Mal hardly talks, he enjoys getting to know him and helping Mal relax either by being his massage therapist or his friend. Mal and Zach easily fall into friendship and then can’t deny the attraction they both feel, and neither try to change the other, finding happiness in being together.

I really enjoyed their sweet interactions, Zach doesn’t push Mal out of his introverted comfort zone and Mal appreciates Zach’s effervescent personality. The story has some helpful secondary characters, some nice and spicy scenes, and two main characters that aren’t afraid to show vulnerability and care while supporting each other and falling in love. Really enjoyed this opposites attract addition to the series.
1,850 reviews6 followers
May 31, 2024
Loved Mal but wanted more showing than telling

I loved the first two books and I loved sweet, quiet Mal here. Zach was a good character too.
The connection between them grew as the story continued but I felt as though we were missing a lot, as when they spent time together, we were just told they talked about lots of things. I didn't need a transcription of every conversation they had but would have loved to see some of their chats to really see them bonding.
I wasn't keen on Mal's family, especially how his sisters treated him and what effect that had on him. I felt as though his friends all overlooked him, just because he was quiet. Mal faded into the background at times while Zach spoke for him, and I felt so sorry for Mal when Zach charmed all Mal's family while Mal was the villain for finally standing up to his mother and sisters.
Apart from that, I did love Mal and I liked Zach for him, once they found a balance when Mal came out of his shell.
I can't wait to read Aziel's story but Hendrix is next. A demon rock star? Yes, please.
Profile Image for Monika .
2,333 reviews39 followers
July 29, 2024

**3.5 Stars**

I absolutely loved the previous books in this series but this one fell just a tiny bit short. I'm not sure exactly why, maybe because there was so much to unpack here in so little time and it felt a bit rushed at times. *shrugs* I absolutely adored the MCs and I loved the extrovert/introvert human/demon pairing there was just something about the rest of the story that didn't have the same excitement.

I still really enjoy Zach and Mal's story and would recommend this series. Looking forward to more!

● Paranormal/Fantasy
● Introvert/Extrovert
● Human/Demon
● Size difference
● Opposites attract
● Magic
● Some really sweet moments
● Made me laugh
● Steamy but not overly
● Family issues
● Dealing with a sick parent
● Great friends
● Loved the MCs
● Racism
● Satisfying HEA
● Loved the bonus epilogue you can download at the end
● Part of a series and IMO NOT a stand-alone
● Characters from previous books play a big role
Profile Image for Belinda Zamora.
2,479 reviews8 followers
June 9, 2024
Great addition to the series

Mal is reserved and stoic.
Growing up with female, teenage demons and being the baby of the family, he learned it was best to stay quiet.
As a result, he's suppressed himself.
When he meets Zach, who's very outgoing he's intrigued.
As they slowly get to know each other, Mal begins to depend on Zach to help him express himself.
These two were so sweet and steamy together.
When an issue arises back home for Mal concerning his family, he's unsure of how to deal with it.
Zach immediately offers to help him because he knows Mal might be too overwhelmed and not be able let his family know what he's going through.
Some tensions due to slight miscommunications occurs but thankfully they're able to resolve it.
Now I can't wait for Hen to meet his mate.
Profile Image for C..
353 reviews
June 1, 2024
I've read all of the books in this series so far and they have all been good. This is one of those series that gets better with every book and is becomming a favorite.

Mal is dealing with a lot of family stress and he has held his feelings back most of his life. Zach is full of energy and caring and feels a need to help Mal. Their friendship grows and eventually develops into love. This is a relationship that took time to progress. The couple knew each other for weeks and were friends before it progressed to romance. It was nice to see.

I look forward to reading more books in the series and hope for many more books from this author.

I was given a copy of this book and this is my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Jeanette Waters.
1,878 reviews4 followers
June 6, 2024
Claiming a Demon, the newest book in Amy Padilla's Dallying with Demons series is a love story about a shy demon who hides his feelings behind a stoic mask, and a human who is a natural caretaker and the only person who can see the demon behind the mask. They display a sweet protectiveness towards each other. And have excellent chemistry in and out of the bedroom.
Claiming is a fun, quick read. Not a standard cookie cutter demon/human romance, Padilla touches upon species prejudice and terminal disease with a light, respectful touch. A well earned HEA.
An excellent book. An outstanding, original series. The next two books are in the works. And I can't wait.
I received an advance copy of this book and this is my review.
Profile Image for Fernanda Fatio.
424 reviews2 followers
August 16, 2024
I loved Zach and Mal dynamics. Zach stepping up to be the voice Mal needed without speaking up for him was important. Mal understanding that by staying silent, he did not “keep the peace” as he thought but rather became invisible was an important development. Of course, with that it came the emotional dysregulation that happens when people keeps things bottled up for a long time. I liked how Zach defended Mal from his shocked family and friends while gently telling him that are better ways to make himself be heard.
What I didn’t like was how Aziel used the derogatory terms to Zach and their friends all ganged up to basically tell him he didn’t know how to be adult and decide things on his own simply because he kept quiet on most times. The lack of confidence his friends have on him was heartbreaking and the fact that Aziel never apologized bothered me a lot.
4,169 reviews
June 30, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Zach and Mal might be my favorite pairing yet. Zach’s bright, confident energy and Mal’s quiet, guarded nature make for an irresistible dynamic. Zach doesn’t just flirt: he cares deeply and never hesitates to show it. Mal is used to staying silent, but Zach sees him, understands him, and slowly pulls him out of his shell. The way their relationship builds through care, touch, and emotional honesty was beautiful. I also loved that Zach had his own moments of vulnerability, especially in the caretaking scenes. The spa setting, the emotional intimacy, and the physical tension all came together perfectly. This is opposites attract done right, and their bond feels as healing as it is hot.
Profile Image for Rai.
933 reviews25 followers
August 20, 2025
Improving a bit in the story, I liked this couple a lot. Malakai is a quiet ,taciturn, lachonic person, keeps to himself, has a poker face. Zach is the opposite shoes his emotions on his face , is very outgoing and sociable, and doesn't have a shy bone in his body. So how they click. Zach calms Malakai in a way that's so special he has never felt like that with anyone, Zack understand Malakai even if he does not speak his mind at the beginning , he noticed by how his body responds he know when he is tense , or is struggling to speak about something ...

Malakai changes through out the story and speaks his mind more , communicates what he wants to convey, and stands for himself. Something he did not do.

Overall was cute and I Liked this couple a lot.
887 reviews7 followers
May 27, 2024
Malakai and Zachariah story was sweet and quirky, with lots of laughs, caring, sweet loving moments and connecting to the family.
I simply adored Zach's personality as his way of taking care of people as well as taking charge, and expressing his mind without a care.
Mal was adorable and I really liked when he took matters in his own hands and made his opinion known.
I liked the way they interacted, the way the learned to express their feelings was a learning curve, and the support they had for each other was so sweet and adorable.
I really loved the story and I'm looking forward to see what happens next.
Profile Image for Demetra Roussakis.
1,449 reviews14 followers
May 28, 2024
This is book 3 in the series and recommend they be read in order. This one features Malakai and Zach. Mal is in a gift shop trying to find a gift for his friends who just got engaged. Zach stepped in when he was struggling to figure out what he wanted to buy. When Zach suggested couples massage, Mal was all in. When Mal went to get a massage where Za h works, he was able to relax. This is how their relationship slowly started with finding out why Mal was stressed and how Zach was able to help him get out of his shell. Great world building, high heat and chemistry. Cannot wait for the next book in the series.
968 reviews36 followers
June 5, 2024
Mal and Zach are total opposites yet something draws them together. There is no denying the attraction they have for each other. I enjoyed watching their relationship build as they spend time together. The two are good together and it was nice to see the trust grow between them. Zach is certainly a handful but he is loyal to those that he cares about. Mal may be quiet but he has a heart and deals with so much. I loved seeing Zach step up and help Mal right from the start. I was quickly immersed in their story and engaged all the way to the end making this a good addition to the Dallying with Demons series.
412 reviews
June 8, 2024
I enjoyed this book, but not quite as much as the others in the series. I honestly felt so bad for Mal, and his lack of support from his friends and family. Zach is definitely there for him, but almost too much in a way. At one point, Zach questions whether Mal is really in a headspace for a relationship, and honestly, I kind of agree. Don't get me wrong, the story is good, the characters are engaging, and the plot resolves itself in a decent way, I just feel like maybe the relationship progressed a bit too quickly considering Mal's emotional state. Still absolutely worth the read, and I look forward to the rest of the series.
Profile Image for Lois.
1,023 reviews3 followers
May 29, 2025
I think this is my favourite of the series so far. I've always liked quiet Malakai, but it wasn't until this book that we find out why he's so reserved. Zach is a tornado in tiny (compared to a demon) human form and was the perfect amount of comfort and confidence to bring Mal out of his shell. I loved their dynamic and the way the relationship evolved. Mal's family were overwhelming, but Zach was always there to steady him and boost his confidence and when they finally got together it was hot. The epilogue and bonus were sweet, when Mal decides it time for him to be the carer for a change.
550 reviews1 follower
September 7, 2025
I am loving these books! Malakia and Zach are two sides of the same coin! Mal has always faded into the background and lost his willingness to speak up for himself, while Zach is the most extrovert of extroverts! He also right away stands up for Mal, with his friends, with his family, with everyone around him! He slowly builds Mals confidence in himself, while giving him a place to be himself! and Mal takes care of Zach while Zach takes care of those around him! it's freaking adorable!

Favorite quote:

"I know you don’t like to argue with people, but you deserve to be heard. I’ll be your voice if you need me to be.”
508 reviews
May 29, 2024
Zach is awesome, and I'm glad Mal realized it pretty early on. These two worked on so many levels, and yay to the author for such lovable & relatable & fleshed out characters! Love the world-building and especially the external family drama (thankfully not the usual kind). All of this, add in the friend drama on several levels, & the love/mates thing - and you end up with an enjoyable, entertaining, sweet with heat Paranormal romance with the most perfect grand gesture HEA - so sweet! Love this series, these demons & their mates & found family. Keep em coming!
Profile Image for Cynthia M Brow.
1,201 reviews16 followers
June 1, 2024
Claiming a Demon is the 3rd book in the Dallying with Demons series. Each book can be read as a standalone but I feel they are best read in order so why not enjoy the whole series. This book is about Zach a human and Mal a demon. Mal is an introvert while Zach is an extrovert. I love how these two just work together. I love the way Amy writes her characters and the world she has created. There is a lot put in the story so at times it felt a little rushed but that didn't take away from the story. I would definitely recommend this book and series.
3,007 reviews47 followers
June 7, 2024
Claiming a Demon is the third book in the Dallying with Demons series by Amy Padilla. It is best if read in order.
Demon Mal is a quiet introvert who is drawn to outgoing extrovert Zach. These two just fit together. Like all their missing pieces click into place.
I liked the way they interacted, the way the learned to express their feelings was a learning curve, and the support they had for each other was so sweet and adorable.
I really loved the story and I'm looking forward to see what happens next.
61 reviews
June 4, 2024
The relationship between Mal and Zach was very sweet and I like the acceptance and support they gave to each other. Again, most of the angst was caused by outside sources. Although Mal's family dynamics were enough to make me want to hide too, I liked that he was letting go of his mask with Zach's help and finally speaking up. Looking forward to the next book.

I noted only about a dozen proofreading issues in the ARC, which I sent to the author, so they may be fixed already.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.