What do you think?
Rate this book
Alderland #1
The Abandoned Theater
Deep in the woods of the Winnodov property sits the abandoned theater. Something mysterious happened during the last performance there - the same night Mr. Winnodov disappeared. Eight years later, it’s happening again. A group of mischievous teenagers sneaks into the theater. And now, one is missing. When 12-year-old Beth Shoner learns who the missing teen is, she sets off with two friends to find him. But what they discover is more astonishing than they could ever have imagined. Now, Beth must defeat an evil plan unleashed long ago that threatens to destroy countless worlds, including their own.
184 pages, Paperback
First published May 1, 2025
1 person is currently reading
36 people want to read
About the author
Dana Robertson
1 book3 followersDana Robertson lives in Oshawa, Ontario, Canada. She writes fantasy, mystery, science fiction and middle grade fiction. The Abandoned Theater is her debut novel and book one of the Alderland Series.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
May 19, 2025
I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.
4.5 stars
When the author reached out to me to review this story, I had no idea what to expect. I'd never heard of the author prior to this, but I wanted to take a chance on what sounded like a fun middle grade fantasy mystery. And I was not disappointed. I thought perhaps reading multiple middle grade portal fantasy books back to back would skew my rating a bit, but this one stood out in all the best ways.
When 12 year old Beth discovers one of her friends went missing in the Winnodov's theater thought to have claimed another local years before, she and her two friends, Teri and Stan, find themselves on the grounds searching for answers. Instead, what they find is a portal to Alderland, a world of knights, tigers, scary creatures, healing muses, and a man whose evil plans threaten not just Beth's home, but all the worlds that exists.
Beth was so curious and brave, and Teri and Stan were great "side" characters that helped balance out Beth's headstrong nature with their cautiousness and observations. All of the characters came together nicely and I feel like they all got a decent amount of screen time overall, although there are definitely many that I would love to explore further as the series continues.
The setting was descriptive enough to help me imagine what Alderland, as well as many of the creatures, looked like while not being overly descriptive or boring. I'd certainly enjoy seeing more of what the place had to offer, and definitely more tigers and muses.
The Abandoned Theater is a wonderfully fast pace and captivating story full of fun and adventure, but also grief and pain and secrets. It combines fantasy with a perfect mix of mystery to keep us intrigued while exploring a new world and guessing what all secrets are going to be revealed. I look forward to Beth's future adventures in Alderland - and possible other worlds - as her character grows into the role destiny has for her.
4.5 stars
When the author reached out to me to review this story, I had no idea what to expect. I'd never heard of the author prior to this, but I wanted to take a chance on what sounded like a fun middle grade fantasy mystery. And I was not disappointed. I thought perhaps reading multiple middle grade portal fantasy books back to back would skew my rating a bit, but this one stood out in all the best ways.
When 12 year old Beth discovers one of her friends went missing in the Winnodov's theater thought to have claimed another local years before, she and her two friends, Teri and Stan, find themselves on the grounds searching for answers. Instead, what they find is a portal to Alderland, a world of knights, tigers, scary creatures, healing muses, and a man whose evil plans threaten not just Beth's home, but all the worlds that exists.
Beth was so curious and brave, and Teri and Stan were great "side" characters that helped balance out Beth's headstrong nature with their cautiousness and observations. All of the characters came together nicely and I feel like they all got a decent amount of screen time overall, although there are definitely many that I would love to explore further as the series continues.
The setting was descriptive enough to help me imagine what Alderland, as well as many of the creatures, looked like while not being overly descriptive or boring. I'd certainly enjoy seeing more of what the place had to offer, and definitely more tigers and muses.
The Abandoned Theater is a wonderfully fast pace and captivating story full of fun and adventure, but also grief and pain and secrets. It combines fantasy with a perfect mix of mystery to keep us intrigued while exploring a new world and guessing what all secrets are going to be revealed. I look forward to Beth's future adventures in Alderland - and possible other worlds - as her character grows into the role destiny has for her.
May 16, 2025
This is the first book in this new and exciting Alderland series and also my first read by this author.
I was drawn in by the front cover which looked a little creepy, but also because I love the theatre.
This was a super quick read for me and although I'm a little beyond the target audience age, I really loved this!
I used to read stories like this when growing up and this would definitely have ignited my love of a good mystery/thriller.
There were some great elements in this book which had me on edge - creating a spooky vibe throughout but the mystery was intriguing and the adventure exciting and this kept us reading on.
I liked the diverse characters and the friendship that they shared.
When Brent goes missing, the friends set off on a mission to discover what's really going on at the theater, but what they encounter there, takes them beyond anything they'd have ever imagined.
Beth's character is well presented and it's clear from early on that there's something a little 'other worldy' going on here.
The writing style was great. With some good, descriptive world building, it's easy for us to visualise the settings and feel the atmosphere created at each point.
I did find that some elements were easily guessed - but then I think this is set just right for the age it's aimed at.
An exciting read and I'm excited to see what comes next in this series.
I was drawn in by the front cover which looked a little creepy, but also because I love the theatre.
This was a super quick read for me and although I'm a little beyond the target audience age, I really loved this!
I used to read stories like this when growing up and this would definitely have ignited my love of a good mystery/thriller.
There were some great elements in this book which had me on edge - creating a spooky vibe throughout but the mystery was intriguing and the adventure exciting and this kept us reading on.
I liked the diverse characters and the friendship that they shared.
When Brent goes missing, the friends set off on a mission to discover what's really going on at the theater, but what they encounter there, takes them beyond anything they'd have ever imagined.
Beth's character is well presented and it's clear from early on that there's something a little 'other worldy' going on here.
The writing style was great. With some good, descriptive world building, it's easy for us to visualise the settings and feel the atmosphere created at each point.
I did find that some elements were easily guessed - but then I think this is set just right for the age it's aimed at.
An exciting read and I'm excited to see what comes next in this series.
May 4, 2025
This was an enjoyable series. I enjoyed it immensely. I loved the concept of the book. It was wonderfully magical.
The book was very well written and flowed beautifully. There were no plot holes or unanswered questions. The world building was devine. The town the kids lived in and then Alderland itself. Simply stunning.
The characters were great. They all worked very well together to make it so enjoyable. The kids were fun and all so different. They were Beth, Teri, Brent and Stan. Stan really spoke to me! He reminded me of myself at his age! All good fantasies need a dastardly villain - Darthius did not let me down! I liked all the other characters we met along the way too!
The book is written in third person from Beth's which works very well.
I definitely recommend this to you all. It was thoroughly enjoyable.
The book was very well written and flowed beautifully. There were no plot holes or unanswered questions. The world building was devine. The town the kids lived in and then Alderland itself. Simply stunning.
The characters were great. They all worked very well together to make it so enjoyable. The kids were fun and all so different. They were Beth, Teri, Brent and Stan. Stan really spoke to me! He reminded me of myself at his age! All good fantasies need a dastardly villain - Darthius did not let me down! I liked all the other characters we met along the way too!
The book is written in third person from Beth's which works very well.
I definitely recommend this to you all. It was thoroughly enjoyable.
December 30, 2024
Received advance copy and really enjoyed! Particularly liked the creation of a new fantasical world. The characters kept my interest. I`d like to see this done in a movie!!!! Highly recommend for middle graders, although all ages would probably enjoy,
May 14, 2025
The following is an abridged version of my review. The full length version can be found on my site www.readinghasruinedmylife.com
Thank you to Collective Ink and Our Street Books for sending me an advanced copy of The Abandoned Theater. They aren't paying me for my review, they just sent me the book for free. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
First things first, this is a children’s book. When I read and review children’s literature I attempt to view the book in question as I would have in my childhood. I am in my late twenties, and children are not in my life in any way shape or form so I really am not the target demographic for this read, but I can still offer my opinion and attempt to view the book as I would have as a child. With that little note we now can get to the review proper.
Fantastical lands will always get me. They will always pull me in. Please let me travel to a faraway fantasy world with magic and dragons! That’s all I want in life, and I will never get it so I must make do with fantasy novels. Alas the world of Alderland left me wanting much more. There’s nothing to it. It comes across as a generic fantasy world without much of the charm that typically comes with one. There are tigers who are friendly and would probably let me pet them, so that’s nice. But they don’t talk, so that’s upsetting. There are different races/species of inhabitants in Alderland, but readers don’t learn about them other than one race who are a part of the villain's army and all that’s told of them is they are evil. Alderland’s worldbuilding could have been handled so much better.
I found the lore surrounding the Winnodov’s theater to be much more interesting. Theater truly comes alive in this place, and as a theatre aficionado, I love that so much. How I would kill to see a performance in a place where the show becomes real. Dana Robertson, please tell me more about this theater! I love it so much. Honestly, the Winnodov theater is a perfect example of magical realism. I don’t think it can get much better than this.
What could be a lot better though is the pacing and flow of the story. Every single sentence is written as a statement. In fact, it felt as if the author was writing a bulleted list of the story's events. Essentially Dana Robertson would write something akin to “Beth reached for the item.” Followed by, “Teri pulled Beth away, reprimanding her friend.” Because the story is written in this way, far too many things happen in a single short paragraph leading to moments of excitement closely followed by pages of the story dragging on before the cycle repeats.
Listen, this book isn’t for me. I’m not the target demographic. I think The Abandoned Theater is a decent read for young readers. I believe it can be used as a gateway book for the fantasy genre. This is a read that can grab a child’s attention for a few hours and foster a love of reading. Yes, I have problems with the book, but the magical realism is excellent and the characters are likable.
Thank you once again to Our Street Books and Collective Ink for sending me a copy of this read. It means a lot to me every time I get offered a book. Thank you, thank you!
Again, the full length version of my review can be found on my site www.readinghasruinedmylife.com; I post new reviews every Wednesday at noon EST.
Thank you to Collective Ink and Our Street Books for sending me an advanced copy of The Abandoned Theater. They aren't paying me for my review, they just sent me the book for free. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
First things first, this is a children’s book. When I read and review children’s literature I attempt to view the book in question as I would have in my childhood. I am in my late twenties, and children are not in my life in any way shape or form so I really am not the target demographic for this read, but I can still offer my opinion and attempt to view the book as I would have as a child. With that little note we now can get to the review proper.
Fantastical lands will always get me. They will always pull me in. Please let me travel to a faraway fantasy world with magic and dragons! That’s all I want in life, and I will never get it so I must make do with fantasy novels. Alas the world of Alderland left me wanting much more. There’s nothing to it. It comes across as a generic fantasy world without much of the charm that typically comes with one. There are tigers who are friendly and would probably let me pet them, so that’s nice. But they don’t talk, so that’s upsetting. There are different races/species of inhabitants in Alderland, but readers don’t learn about them other than one race who are a part of the villain's army and all that’s told of them is they are evil. Alderland’s worldbuilding could have been handled so much better.
I found the lore surrounding the Winnodov’s theater to be much more interesting. Theater truly comes alive in this place, and as a theatre aficionado, I love that so much. How I would kill to see a performance in a place where the show becomes real. Dana Robertson, please tell me more about this theater! I love it so much. Honestly, the Winnodov theater is a perfect example of magical realism. I don’t think it can get much better than this.
What could be a lot better though is the pacing and flow of the story. Every single sentence is written as a statement. In fact, it felt as if the author was writing a bulleted list of the story's events. Essentially Dana Robertson would write something akin to “Beth reached for the item.” Followed by, “Teri pulled Beth away, reprimanding her friend.” Because the story is written in this way, far too many things happen in a single short paragraph leading to moments of excitement closely followed by pages of the story dragging on before the cycle repeats.
Listen, this book isn’t for me. I’m not the target demographic. I think The Abandoned Theater is a decent read for young readers. I believe it can be used as a gateway book for the fantasy genre. This is a read that can grab a child’s attention for a few hours and foster a love of reading. Yes, I have problems with the book, but the magical realism is excellent and the characters are likable.
Thank you once again to Our Street Books and Collective Ink for sending me a copy of this read. It means a lot to me every time I get offered a book. Thank you, thank you!
Again, the full length version of my review can be found on my site www.readinghasruinedmylife.com; I post new reviews every Wednesday at noon EST.
December 2, 2024
What worked:
The story follows Beth as she wants to investigate the disappearance of a friend named Brent. Readers may be surprised to learn that her two best friends are starkly different from each other. Stan is an unpopular nerd with unusual quirks; he thinks dressing in green shorts, a green shirt, and a green fedora will act as camouflage in the woods. On the other hand, Teri is tall and pretty and she’s one of the most popular girls in school. Readers will know there’s something different about Beth as she wears an amulet that appears to glow. She dreams of places she’s never been only to discover they actually exist. She’s told she was lucky to escape the car accident that killed her parents when she was four but her aunt won’t talk about it. Beth has questions and the answers make her wonder about what she’s been told.
The theater is portrayed as a spooky, dangerous place that is off-limits to everyone. The theater owner disappeared years ago and now Brent is gone too. Beth’s aunt makes Beth promise that she’ll stay away from it but readers know that promise will soon be broken. Stan’s uncle was in the audience when the owner disappeared but he’s unable to recall any details from that night. No one fleeing the theater can remember exactly what happened. This leaves readers to speculate about the possibilities. Are the owner and Brent dead, murdered by an unknown villain? Did the owner’s wife commit the crime? The police bring her in for questioning. Perhaps something more magical is happening that might explain Beth’s amulet and premonitions. Could there be a hidden portal leading to another world?
The author artfully uses words and language to create moods and set scenes. When the kids first travel to the theater, they must maneuver a raft across a lake to reach it. At first, the lake has “gentle waves”, and fresh air “at this early hour”, and the raft drifts as the sun rises. The scene shifts once they make it across as “the sun’s rays flickered”, “an ominous shadow fell over the raft”, and the ground below the cliff was “untamed, overgrown”. Swaying branches seemed to “beckon them forward with long, slender fingers.” Once inside the theater, the kids hear clicking sounds that are “massive black crows” pecking at the skylight, blocking out the sun, “casting a shadow through the theater”.
What didn’t work as well:
The truth behind Beth’s past isn’t too hard to predict for experienced readers. The clues are all there and a character later in the book even tells Beth that she’s probably already figured it out on her own.
The final verdict:
The book’s second half has more action than the first as Beth starts to unravel the truth about her life. Shocking reunions await and Beth becomes an important factor in a war to save all worlds. There’s a medieval feel later in the story with magical elements mixed in. Overall, this should be a fascinating series to follow and I recommend you give this first book a shot.
The story follows Beth as she wants to investigate the disappearance of a friend named Brent. Readers may be surprised to learn that her two best friends are starkly different from each other. Stan is an unpopular nerd with unusual quirks; he thinks dressing in green shorts, a green shirt, and a green fedora will act as camouflage in the woods. On the other hand, Teri is tall and pretty and she’s one of the most popular girls in school. Readers will know there’s something different about Beth as she wears an amulet that appears to glow. She dreams of places she’s never been only to discover they actually exist. She’s told she was lucky to escape the car accident that killed her parents when she was four but her aunt won’t talk about it. Beth has questions and the answers make her wonder about what she’s been told.
The theater is portrayed as a spooky, dangerous place that is off-limits to everyone. The theater owner disappeared years ago and now Brent is gone too. Beth’s aunt makes Beth promise that she’ll stay away from it but readers know that promise will soon be broken. Stan’s uncle was in the audience when the owner disappeared but he’s unable to recall any details from that night. No one fleeing the theater can remember exactly what happened. This leaves readers to speculate about the possibilities. Are the owner and Brent dead, murdered by an unknown villain? Did the owner’s wife commit the crime? The police bring her in for questioning. Perhaps something more magical is happening that might explain Beth’s amulet and premonitions. Could there be a hidden portal leading to another world?
The author artfully uses words and language to create moods and set scenes. When the kids first travel to the theater, they must maneuver a raft across a lake to reach it. At first, the lake has “gentle waves”, and fresh air “at this early hour”, and the raft drifts as the sun rises. The scene shifts once they make it across as “the sun’s rays flickered”, “an ominous shadow fell over the raft”, and the ground below the cliff was “untamed, overgrown”. Swaying branches seemed to “beckon them forward with long, slender fingers.” Once inside the theater, the kids hear clicking sounds that are “massive black crows” pecking at the skylight, blocking out the sun, “casting a shadow through the theater”.
What didn’t work as well:
The truth behind Beth’s past isn’t too hard to predict for experienced readers. The clues are all there and a character later in the book even tells Beth that she’s probably already figured it out on her own.
The final verdict:
The book’s second half has more action than the first as Beth starts to unravel the truth about her life. Shocking reunions await and Beth becomes an important factor in a war to save all worlds. There’s a medieval feel later in the story with magical elements mixed in. Overall, this should be a fascinating series to follow and I recommend you give this first book a shot.
January 3, 2026
My all-time favorite genre is fantasy, but I have in the past few years been trying to diversify my reading and exploring other genres and getting out of my comfort zone. It has been a while since I last read a fantasy novel, and I miss it a lot. So when I started The Abandoned Theater by Dana Robertson, it has given me a deep sense of comfort, like I am finally coming back to what I love and enjoy. I am so thankful to have been introduced to this novel. The title alone drew my attention.
Deep in the woods, there sits an abandoned theater, shut down a long time ago due to mysterious things that have happened to it. The mystery involves the disappearance of Mr. Winnodov, who owns the property. Now, twelve-year-old Beth Shoner, along with her friends Stan and Teri, has decided to go deep into the woods and inspect the abandoned theater after learning that a group of mischievous teenagers have recently sneaked in, resulting in another disappearance—a friend of Beth’s.
“That theater was amazing. A truly magical world hidden deep in the woods.”
The mystery of real-life abandoned places always intrigue me, whether it is a library, a town, an underground shelter or a whole island. And as someone who loves to read about inquisitive characters exploring strange, new, magical lands and discovering secret doors, passageways, or portals of any kind that lead to another world, I have found Beth, Stan and Teri’s exploration of the deep woods and the old town theater thrilling. What was inside the theater? Was anyone still living there? What exactly happened to it all those years ago? Why did it have to be abandoned? Was there a world beyond the theater? And most of all did Beth have any connection to it?
“As your story unfolds, embrace what happens, do not fear it. You are about to learn the secret of the theater.”
The way the author slowly revealed the secrets of the theater was unique. The world she has built is the kind of fantasy world I love imagining. (On a side note, there is something just truly magical about a carousel, don’t you think?) It is the perfect story for when you need to get away from reality and daydream. But aside from the fantastical elements of the book, there are also the terrifying situations that Beth and her friends have to face, such as encountering evil knights. And there were several moments, especially towards the end, when I didn’t know anymore whom to trust. It is a perfect blend of fantasy and mystery.
If you enjoy reading about magical worlds, mysterious characters and perplexing secrets (or if perhaps you just love going to the theater like I do), then The Abandoned Theater by Dana Robertson is the book for you.
“What does that mean?”
“It means we have to act out the play.”
I’ve received a free copy from the author in exchange for an honest review.
Deep in the woods, there sits an abandoned theater, shut down a long time ago due to mysterious things that have happened to it. The mystery involves the disappearance of Mr. Winnodov, who owns the property. Now, twelve-year-old Beth Shoner, along with her friends Stan and Teri, has decided to go deep into the woods and inspect the abandoned theater after learning that a group of mischievous teenagers have recently sneaked in, resulting in another disappearance—a friend of Beth’s.
“That theater was amazing. A truly magical world hidden deep in the woods.”
The mystery of real-life abandoned places always intrigue me, whether it is a library, a town, an underground shelter or a whole island. And as someone who loves to read about inquisitive characters exploring strange, new, magical lands and discovering secret doors, passageways, or portals of any kind that lead to another world, I have found Beth, Stan and Teri’s exploration of the deep woods and the old town theater thrilling. What was inside the theater? Was anyone still living there? What exactly happened to it all those years ago? Why did it have to be abandoned? Was there a world beyond the theater? And most of all did Beth have any connection to it?
“As your story unfolds, embrace what happens, do not fear it. You are about to learn the secret of the theater.”
The way the author slowly revealed the secrets of the theater was unique. The world she has built is the kind of fantasy world I love imagining. (On a side note, there is something just truly magical about a carousel, don’t you think?) It is the perfect story for when you need to get away from reality and daydream. But aside from the fantastical elements of the book, there are also the terrifying situations that Beth and her friends have to face, such as encountering evil knights. And there were several moments, especially towards the end, when I didn’t know anymore whom to trust. It is a perfect blend of fantasy and mystery.
If you enjoy reading about magical worlds, mysterious characters and perplexing secrets (or if perhaps you just love going to the theater like I do), then The Abandoned Theater by Dana Robertson is the book for you.
“What does that mean?”
“It means we have to act out the play.”
I’ve received a free copy from the author in exchange for an honest review.
December 6, 2024
Thank you to Netgalley for an ARC of this book!! 3 Stars to Dana Robertson's The Abandoned Library. This was a fun, fast-paced story with an interesting plot and entertaining characters.
The Winnodov Theater was once an enchanting showplace. Adorned with crystal chandeliers, rich carpeting, and golden decorations, the theater held magic deeper than its appearance. Each show was brought to life with enchanting tales of heroes and courage. But one night, the audience ran from the theater in what can only be defined as raw terror. No one can tell what happened that night. There are no words for what they saw or the fear they felt. The theater is closed, never to be opened again.
Years later, Beth and her friends enter the town's abandoned theater hoping to find their lost friend, Brent. They reenact the theater's final play, looking for a clue to Brent's disappearance and what happened all those years ago. It isn't long before the friends find themselves in a world they never knew existed. Guided and protected by the golden knights and the Muses, the friends take on the task of dethroning a villainous traitor and restoring the land to light.
what I liked:
- this book was fast-paced and entertaining. A quick read, I finished it in a few hours.
- falling into another world... always interesting and opens a lot of room for worldbuilding
- the characters had their own lives and stories unfolding alongside the main story, making them more genuine and likable.
This book reads as an older elementary to middle-grade story. As a reader in my late teens, I'm not quite the target audience for this book, though I still enjoy many middle-grade stories. Some things that didn't work for me may still work for readers within the intended audience.
- the pacing felt off. So many things would happen, and then it dragged before picking up again.
- not long enough. A lot is given to the audience, including background information, history, and characters without enough time to develop most of it. This resulted in some areas falling flat, and the plot twists were obvious long before they occurred in the story.
These points did not hinder my enjoyment of the story. Any other issues I had were purely grammatical, and will likely be fixed before publication.
This was an entertaining read for my afternoon. Good for readers of middle-grade fiction and fantasy. There is so much potential for this series, and I look forward to what the next book will bring :)
The Winnodov Theater was once an enchanting showplace. Adorned with crystal chandeliers, rich carpeting, and golden decorations, the theater held magic deeper than its appearance. Each show was brought to life with enchanting tales of heroes and courage. But one night, the audience ran from the theater in what can only be defined as raw terror. No one can tell what happened that night. There are no words for what they saw or the fear they felt. The theater is closed, never to be opened again.
Years later, Beth and her friends enter the town's abandoned theater hoping to find their lost friend, Brent. They reenact the theater's final play, looking for a clue to Brent's disappearance and what happened all those years ago. It isn't long before the friends find themselves in a world they never knew existed. Guided and protected by the golden knights and the Muses, the friends take on the task of dethroning a villainous traitor and restoring the land to light.
what I liked:
- this book was fast-paced and entertaining. A quick read, I finished it in a few hours.
- falling into another world... always interesting and opens a lot of room for worldbuilding
- the characters had their own lives and stories unfolding alongside the main story, making them more genuine and likable.
This book reads as an older elementary to middle-grade story. As a reader in my late teens, I'm not quite the target audience for this book, though I still enjoy many middle-grade stories. Some things that didn't work for me may still work for readers within the intended audience.
- the pacing felt off. So many things would happen, and then it dragged before picking up again.
- not long enough. A lot is given to the audience, including background information, history, and characters without enough time to develop most of it. This resulted in some areas falling flat, and the plot twists were obvious long before they occurred in the story.
These points did not hinder my enjoyment of the story. Any other issues I had were purely grammatical, and will likely be fixed before publication.
This was an entertaining read for my afternoon. Good for readers of middle-grade fiction and fantasy. There is so much potential for this series, and I look forward to what the next book will bring :)
February 24, 2025
I was privileged to receive and read the ARC of this book, here's my review:
Beth Shoner is just your average 12-year-old enjoying life as usual, making plans with friends, and looking forward to summer—until strange events unfold in the old abandoned theater deep in the woods. When their friend vanishes, Beth and her two companions set off to find him. On their daring rescue mission, they discover an evil plan that threatens their world. Will these three unlikely friends rise to the challenge? This debut novel by Dana Robertson follows young Beth and her comrades as they become the heroes they never expected to be.
This story evoked the same sense of adventure I felt when I read The Lion The Witch and The Wardrobe as a child. Like Lewis’s classic, this book explores the timeless battle between light and darkness; courage and hope, versus the corrosive nature of anger, fear, and revenge. With good character-trait lessons such as bravery in the face of danger, deepening friendship bonds, and standing up for what you believe in, it’s a great read for its pre-teen target audience, and I would definitely recommend it.
One of the book’s greatest strengths is its fast pace. I never found myself waiting too long for the next clue or twist. The intrigue remains high throughout, with a steady flow of revelations. The author’s writing style is clear and easy to follow, making it perfect for young readers. I also appreciated the short chapters and child-friendly descriptions, maintaining engagement without unnecessary complexity.
I particularly liked that the antagonist had a backstory that explains the origin of his darkness. From a mom’s perspective, this is a powerful lesson—young readers can learn that people’s actions often stem from deeper experiences, and it’s worth seeking to understand before passing judgment.
The world-building, while solid, didn’t break new ground. That said, in an era of highly cinematic fantasy storytelling, achieving something wholly original is no small feat. While it may not be revolutionary, it was consistent and immersive enough to support the story well.
There’s room to expound on certain elements in the coming books, as this is Book One in the series. I would love to see more dimension and growth in the characters, creatures, and worlds in the following books, and maybe a few more twists.
With its engaging adventure, strong themes, and solid storytelling, this book is a great read for pre-teens (and their parents!). I give it 4 out of 5 stars and look forward to the rest of the series.
Beth Shoner is just your average 12-year-old enjoying life as usual, making plans with friends, and looking forward to summer—until strange events unfold in the old abandoned theater deep in the woods. When their friend vanishes, Beth and her two companions set off to find him. On their daring rescue mission, they discover an evil plan that threatens their world. Will these three unlikely friends rise to the challenge? This debut novel by Dana Robertson follows young Beth and her comrades as they become the heroes they never expected to be.
This story evoked the same sense of adventure I felt when I read The Lion The Witch and The Wardrobe as a child. Like Lewis’s classic, this book explores the timeless battle between light and darkness; courage and hope, versus the corrosive nature of anger, fear, and revenge. With good character-trait lessons such as bravery in the face of danger, deepening friendship bonds, and standing up for what you believe in, it’s a great read for its pre-teen target audience, and I would definitely recommend it.
One of the book’s greatest strengths is its fast pace. I never found myself waiting too long for the next clue or twist. The intrigue remains high throughout, with a steady flow of revelations. The author’s writing style is clear and easy to follow, making it perfect for young readers. I also appreciated the short chapters and child-friendly descriptions, maintaining engagement without unnecessary complexity.
I particularly liked that the antagonist had a backstory that explains the origin of his darkness. From a mom’s perspective, this is a powerful lesson—young readers can learn that people’s actions often stem from deeper experiences, and it’s worth seeking to understand before passing judgment.
The world-building, while solid, didn’t break new ground. That said, in an era of highly cinematic fantasy storytelling, achieving something wholly original is no small feat. While it may not be revolutionary, it was consistent and immersive enough to support the story well.
There’s room to expound on certain elements in the coming books, as this is Book One in the series. I would love to see more dimension and growth in the characters, creatures, and worlds in the following books, and maybe a few more twists.
With its engaging adventure, strong themes, and solid storytelling, this book is a great read for pre-teens (and their parents!). I give it 4 out of 5 stars and look forward to the rest of the series.
May 1, 2025
The Abandoned Theater: Alderland Series – Book One
by Ms. Dana Robertson
Publisher: Our Street Books
Release Date: April 29, 2025
Length: 185 pages
Triggers: Mild peril, references to parental loss
Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
An Imaginative Adventure That Balances Light Horror, Friendship, and Courage
Ms. Dana Robertson’s The Abandoned Theater is a fast-paced and heartfelt start to the Alderland Series, perfectly crafted for middle-grade readers and the adults lucky enough to read alongside them. From the eerie, long-forgotten Winnodov theater to a realm of golden knights, muses, and creeping shadows, the book draws readers into a fantasy mystery that feels both new and comfortingly nostalgic.
What begins as a small-town mystery quickly escalates into something far more epic. When 12-year-old Beth Shoner and her friends go searching for a missing boy, they stumble into a hidden world linked to Beth’s forgotten past. The pacing is brisk, the stakes are high, and the sense of wonder is real.
What I Loved
📖 The characters felt distinct and realistic—especially Beth, who shows quiet courage and natural leadership as the story unfolds.
📖 The theater itself becomes a character, steeped in suspense and mystery, with vivid, moody imagery that will keep readers on edge.
📖 The friendships are honest and evolving, with a dynamic trio that feels like a modern Narnia squad—flawed, curious, and full of heart.
📖 Light romance elements were handled age-appropriately and with care—ideal for preteens navigating their own emotions.
📖 The themes of grief, divorce, and finding one’s place are explored without overwhelming the core adventure.
Vibe Check
Think The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe meets Stranger Things (middle-grade edition) with hints of The School for Good and Evil. If magical portals, secret amulets, creepy theaters, and ride-or-die friendships are your jam, this one’s for you.
Perfect for Readers Who Love:
📖 Middle-grade fantasy with mystery and heart
📖 Light horror with rich, cinematic settings
📖 Adventure stories with strong female leads
📖 Stories about friendship, identity, and growing up
📖 Books with just enough spook to keep you up a little later than planned
Reviewed by Robin’s Review
by Ms. Dana Robertson
Publisher: Our Street Books
Release Date: April 29, 2025
Length: 185 pages
Triggers: Mild peril, references to parental loss
Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
An Imaginative Adventure That Balances Light Horror, Friendship, and Courage
Ms. Dana Robertson’s The Abandoned Theater is a fast-paced and heartfelt start to the Alderland Series, perfectly crafted for middle-grade readers and the adults lucky enough to read alongside them. From the eerie, long-forgotten Winnodov theater to a realm of golden knights, muses, and creeping shadows, the book draws readers into a fantasy mystery that feels both new and comfortingly nostalgic.
What begins as a small-town mystery quickly escalates into something far more epic. When 12-year-old Beth Shoner and her friends go searching for a missing boy, they stumble into a hidden world linked to Beth’s forgotten past. The pacing is brisk, the stakes are high, and the sense of wonder is real.
What I Loved
📖 The characters felt distinct and realistic—especially Beth, who shows quiet courage and natural leadership as the story unfolds.
📖 The theater itself becomes a character, steeped in suspense and mystery, with vivid, moody imagery that will keep readers on edge.
📖 The friendships are honest and evolving, with a dynamic trio that feels like a modern Narnia squad—flawed, curious, and full of heart.
📖 Light romance elements were handled age-appropriately and with care—ideal for preteens navigating their own emotions.
📖 The themes of grief, divorce, and finding one’s place are explored without overwhelming the core adventure.
Vibe Check
Think The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe meets Stranger Things (middle-grade edition) with hints of The School for Good and Evil. If magical portals, secret amulets, creepy theaters, and ride-or-die friendships are your jam, this one’s for you.
Perfect for Readers Who Love:
📖 Middle-grade fantasy with mystery and heart
📖 Light horror with rich, cinematic settings
📖 Adventure stories with strong female leads
📖 Stories about friendship, identity, and growing up
📖 Books with just enough spook to keep you up a little later than planned
Reviewed by Robin’s Review
February 7, 2025
Really excited to have found this series.
I have been having a lot of trouble finding works that I and my sisters can enjoy together. The biggest issue I have had is finding something that wont offend their step mothers 'sensibilities'. I have finally found a couple of books, this one included that have passed muster.
There is a instant connection with Beth, and I believe my sisters were more excited about us sharing a name. The relationship she builds with two friends in particular is one that really hit home for my siblings, who are entering middle school and are worried that they are not making as many friends as some others and this really hit home that it is about Quality not Quantity when it comes to finding your tribe, and it really stuck out that they could create friendship groups with people who weren't exactly like them. This story is absolutely focused on adventure, but the friendships that have been created between the characters give a realistic feeling to the struggle for acceptance that all young people go through. While in the real world we hopefully aren't trying to solve a murder in a spooky theatre, we all go through the same pre-teen and teen-hood issues of not only accepting ourselves but learning how to accept others for who they are and sharing those struggles.
One thing that wasn't expected was the romance impact. Looking back at my 12 year old self, this is much tamer. Now that I am a teacher of this age group, I think it is absolutely important to show the truth of what its like to be a pre-teen and what they are focused on. One of the reason I found myself focusing so hard on a new relationship was the fact no one really showed what a healthy relationship at that age was in media or books. The author is very precise with how she wrote these areas and created a loving relationship built on trust and friendship, exactly what I wish I had looked for at the time.
I highly recommend this work to anyone who is a kid this age or has kids this age. It is amazing to feel better in touch with not only your kids and what they are dealing with, but also getting to take a moment to look back at yourself a while and what you could have done better. Five stars all around.
I have been having a lot of trouble finding works that I and my sisters can enjoy together. The biggest issue I have had is finding something that wont offend their step mothers 'sensibilities'. I have finally found a couple of books, this one included that have passed muster.
There is a instant connection with Beth, and I believe my sisters were more excited about us sharing a name. The relationship she builds with two friends in particular is one that really hit home for my siblings, who are entering middle school and are worried that they are not making as many friends as some others and this really hit home that it is about Quality not Quantity when it comes to finding your tribe, and it really stuck out that they could create friendship groups with people who weren't exactly like them. This story is absolutely focused on adventure, but the friendships that have been created between the characters give a realistic feeling to the struggle for acceptance that all young people go through. While in the real world we hopefully aren't trying to solve a murder in a spooky theatre, we all go through the same pre-teen and teen-hood issues of not only accepting ourselves but learning how to accept others for who they are and sharing those struggles.
One thing that wasn't expected was the romance impact. Looking back at my 12 year old self, this is much tamer. Now that I am a teacher of this age group, I think it is absolutely important to show the truth of what its like to be a pre-teen and what they are focused on. One of the reason I found myself focusing so hard on a new relationship was the fact no one really showed what a healthy relationship at that age was in media or books. The author is very precise with how she wrote these areas and created a loving relationship built on trust and friendship, exactly what I wish I had looked for at the time.
I highly recommend this work to anyone who is a kid this age or has kids this age. It is amazing to feel better in touch with not only your kids and what they are dealing with, but also getting to take a moment to look back at yourself a while and what you could have done better. Five stars all around.
March 1, 2025
I’ve just finished The Abandoned Theater by Dana Robertson, and I have to say, it’s one of those books that you don’t want to put down once you start. At first glance, it seems like a book meant for kids, but the depth, suspense, and emotional rollercoaster it takes you on makes it perfect for readers of all ages. I could relate to Beth’s journey and was completely drawn into her world.
The story begins with Beth, the main character, walking out of Abigail Public School, tossing her school notebooks into the trash, and breathing in the fresh air. But things quickly take a mysterious turn when she witnesses a police car speeding by and a woman, Mrs. Winnodov, who’s been a recluse in the town, getting arrested. It’s just the beginning of a series of strange events that will change everything for Beth and her friends.
The book's mix of mystery, friendship, and personal growth hooked me. Beth and her friends are soon drawn into the mysterious disappearances at Mrs. Winnodov's abandoned theater. As they dig deeper, secrets begin to unravel, and Beth discovers unexpected truths about her past. The story seamlessly blends mystery with a touch of fantasy, adding an unexpected and captivating dimension to Beth’s journey.
The book also beautifully explores themes of courage, resilience, and the power of friendship. As Beth faces the unknown, she learns that even when things seem impossible, you can find strength in your friends and yourself. Dana Robertson’s writing of the characters makes you root for them. Beth’s growth throughout the book, from being unsure of herself to becoming brave and independent, is truly inspiring.
The Abandoned Theater is a must-read if you love mysteries, adventure, and fantasy stories that make you think and feel deeply. It’s not just about solving a mystery—it’s about finding strength, facing fears, and understanding what truly matters in life. I was deeply moved by the characters' emotional depth and courage, and I would highly recommend this book to everyone.
The story begins with Beth, the main character, walking out of Abigail Public School, tossing her school notebooks into the trash, and breathing in the fresh air. But things quickly take a mysterious turn when she witnesses a police car speeding by and a woman, Mrs. Winnodov, who’s been a recluse in the town, getting arrested. It’s just the beginning of a series of strange events that will change everything for Beth and her friends.
The book's mix of mystery, friendship, and personal growth hooked me. Beth and her friends are soon drawn into the mysterious disappearances at Mrs. Winnodov's abandoned theater. As they dig deeper, secrets begin to unravel, and Beth discovers unexpected truths about her past. The story seamlessly blends mystery with a touch of fantasy, adding an unexpected and captivating dimension to Beth’s journey.
The book also beautifully explores themes of courage, resilience, and the power of friendship. As Beth faces the unknown, she learns that even when things seem impossible, you can find strength in your friends and yourself. Dana Robertson’s writing of the characters makes you root for them. Beth’s growth throughout the book, from being unsure of herself to becoming brave and independent, is truly inspiring.
The Abandoned Theater is a must-read if you love mysteries, adventure, and fantasy stories that make you think and feel deeply. It’s not just about solving a mystery—it’s about finding strength, facing fears, and understanding what truly matters in life. I was deeply moved by the characters' emotional depth and courage, and I would highly recommend this book to everyone.
April 16, 2025
Eight years ago, a mysterious event took place at the Winnodov theatre, resulting in the disappearance of Mr. Winnodov, himself. Now, twelve year old Beth lives in the nearby town of Springdale with her aunt, and she has no memory of the first years of her life. When Beth discovers that her aunt is harboring secrets that could connect Beth both to her parents and to the events at the now abandoned theatre, Beth is compelled to look deeper. And when another person goes missing under similarly mysterious circumstances as Mr. Winnodov’s disappearance, Beth and her friends may be the only people who can uncover the truth. This mystery-centered, first in its series middle grade novel is told in the third person from Beth’s perspective. Brief chapters and approachable characters make the book appealing to young readers, and the storytelling style incorporates occasional text messages alongside the traditional narrative and dialogue. While this novel can be enjoyed by middle grade-aged readers, the protagonists are more mature than their ages would imply, and elements of danger and peril amplify the intensity of the novel, as well. Because of these features, young adults may also be drawn to this story thanks to its blend of accessibility and relatability. Elements of light horror are woven into the storytelling, especially as the mystery takes on a more sinister edge both with missing people and with a person of interest who seems to have been present at both events. Additionally, Beth’s backstory has a paranormal bent as the circumstances behind her arrival in Springvale are unclear and secrets abound. Readers will enjoy piecing clues together alongside the protagonists as the narrative unfolds. This series starter is well designed, and readers will look forward to future installments.
June 6, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Spooky, heartfelt, and full of promise — a magical mystery for young adventurers
I took a chance on The Abandoned Theater because the title (and delightfully eerie cover) hooked me, and I’m so glad I did! This fast-paced middle grade fantasy-mystery is full of adventure, heart, and just the right amount of spooky tension to keep readers of all ages engaged.
Twelve-year-old Beth Shoner is a wonderfully headstrong and curious heroine. When a local teen vanishes after sneaking into the long-abandoned Winnodov Theater, Beth sets off with her friends Teri and Stan to unravel the mystery—only to discover a doorway to another world and a dark secret that connects her to it all. The group dynamic was especially charming: Beth’s boldness is well balanced by Teri and Stan’s thoughtfulness and caution, and each character felt distinct and valuable to the story.
The writing is accessible and vivid without overwhelming younger readers. Dana Robertson brings Alderland to life with just enough rich detail—its creatures, its shadows, and yes, even its tigers and muses! The world feels mysterious, magical, and ripe for further exploration. The second half ramps up with high-stakes action, a touch of medieval fantasy flair, and a twist that begins to uncover Beth’s larger role in the fate of multiple worlds. I especially loved how the story explores themes of grief, courage, and belonging alongside its magical mystery.
Though some plot points were a little predictable for an adult reader, I think they’re just right for its intended middle grade audience. As a theatre adult, I also loved the atmospheric setting of the abandoned theatre—a perfect stage for secrets and adventure.
A great pick for fans of The Spiderwick Chronicles, Nevermoor, or Pages & Co.. I’m already looking forward to Book Two and seeing how Beth’s destiny unfolds in Alderland—and beyond.
I took a chance on The Abandoned Theater because the title (and delightfully eerie cover) hooked me, and I’m so glad I did! This fast-paced middle grade fantasy-mystery is full of adventure, heart, and just the right amount of spooky tension to keep readers of all ages engaged.
Twelve-year-old Beth Shoner is a wonderfully headstrong and curious heroine. When a local teen vanishes after sneaking into the long-abandoned Winnodov Theater, Beth sets off with her friends Teri and Stan to unravel the mystery—only to discover a doorway to another world and a dark secret that connects her to it all. The group dynamic was especially charming: Beth’s boldness is well balanced by Teri and Stan’s thoughtfulness and caution, and each character felt distinct and valuable to the story.
The writing is accessible and vivid without overwhelming younger readers. Dana Robertson brings Alderland to life with just enough rich detail—its creatures, its shadows, and yes, even its tigers and muses! The world feels mysterious, magical, and ripe for further exploration. The second half ramps up with high-stakes action, a touch of medieval fantasy flair, and a twist that begins to uncover Beth’s larger role in the fate of multiple worlds. I especially loved how the story explores themes of grief, courage, and belonging alongside its magical mystery.
Though some plot points were a little predictable for an adult reader, I think they’re just right for its intended middle grade audience. As a theatre adult, I also loved the atmospheric setting of the abandoned theatre—a perfect stage for secrets and adventure.
A great pick for fans of The Spiderwick Chronicles, Nevermoor, or Pages & Co.. I’m already looking forward to Book Two and seeing how Beth’s destiny unfolds in Alderland—and beyond.
September 30, 2024
I was fortunate to get an advanced reader copy through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. In this compelling young adult novel, the Springvale theater, a relic of past performances, holds dark secrets from eight years ago when Mr. Winnodov mysteriously vanished during what ultimately became the last show. Fast forward to the present, and a new mystery unfolds as a group of children sneaks into the theater—only for one to go missing.
Beth Shoner, who discovers that the missing child is someone she knows, is propelled into a race against time with her friends to uncover the truth. As they delve deeper, Beth realizes that the past eight years of her life may not be what they seemed, and she finds herself in a pivotal role—her choices could mean the difference between rescue and disaster.
This story is a briskly paced adventure, making it an easy and engaging read. However, the rapid tempo occasionally leaves little room for deeper exploration, which might leave some adult readers craving more nuance. Nevertheless, its accessibility makes it a perfect fit for middle-grade readers.
The novel masterfully weaves together elements of thriller, mystery, and fantasy, all while tackling significant themes like grief, divorce, and the complexities of young friendships. The character development is particularly strong, allowing readers to form genuine connections with Beth and her companions.
Overall, this book is a delightful journey filled with suspense and heart, making it a must-read for young adults and anyone who enjoys a well-crafted tale of discovery and resilience.
Beth Shoner, who discovers that the missing child is someone she knows, is propelled into a race against time with her friends to uncover the truth. As they delve deeper, Beth realizes that the past eight years of her life may not be what they seemed, and she finds herself in a pivotal role—her choices could mean the difference between rescue and disaster.
This story is a briskly paced adventure, making it an easy and engaging read. However, the rapid tempo occasionally leaves little room for deeper exploration, which might leave some adult readers craving more nuance. Nevertheless, its accessibility makes it a perfect fit for middle-grade readers.
The novel masterfully weaves together elements of thriller, mystery, and fantasy, all while tackling significant themes like grief, divorce, and the complexities of young friendships. The character development is particularly strong, allowing readers to form genuine connections with Beth and her companions.
Overall, this book is a delightful journey filled with suspense and heart, making it a must-read for young adults and anyone who enjoys a well-crafted tale of discovery and resilience.
February 17, 2025
Cover: Whimsical.
Now this is a cute, engaging story!
The Abandoned Theater is a middle-grade book that mixes both fantasy and a touch of (age-appropriate!) spooky mystery, resulting in a blend that has been a pleasant surprise for me. Besides, this is the author’s debut, a detail that makes it even more impressive.
First of all, both grammar and sentence construction read spotless. This means Robertson and her editorial team (her husband, going by the notes?) work well together, something that really adds value to a book. The pacing is quick enough to engage the reader’s attention, paired with a pleasant rhythm overall.
Beth reads well as a main character, and her relationships with her friends has been developed with ease, as the supporting cast has distinctive voices and personalities. Maybe I would have gone a little deeper into her psyche, adding some flaws and turning her into a more complex person. The sprinkle of romance is written in a gentle and again age-appropriate way.
The major flaw of The Abandoned Theater is the length. With fifty or seventy pages more, the psychology of the characters would have had more time to develop while maintain the fast pacing Robertson picked for her story—a choice I 100% support, mind. Nothing beats a quick-paced book!
4,5 stars on GR.
Now this is a cute, engaging story!
The Abandoned Theater is a middle-grade book that mixes both fantasy and a touch of (age-appropriate!) spooky mystery, resulting in a blend that has been a pleasant surprise for me. Besides, this is the author’s debut, a detail that makes it even more impressive.
First of all, both grammar and sentence construction read spotless. This means Robertson and her editorial team (her husband, going by the notes?) work well together, something that really adds value to a book. The pacing is quick enough to engage the reader’s attention, paired with a pleasant rhythm overall.
Beth reads well as a main character, and her relationships with her friends has been developed with ease, as the supporting cast has distinctive voices and personalities. Maybe I would have gone a little deeper into her psyche, adding some flaws and turning her into a more complex person. The sprinkle of romance is written in a gentle and again age-appropriate way.
The major flaw of The Abandoned Theater is the length. With fifty or seventy pages more, the psychology of the characters would have had more time to develop while maintain the fast pacing Robertson picked for her story—a choice I 100% support, mind. Nothing beats a quick-paced book!
4,5 stars on GR.
March 20, 2025
The Review
What a compelling and engaging read. The author does a marvelous job of balancing the relatable, heartfelt character development with the visceral fantasy world-building that the author was able to create. The imagery in the author’s writing made the world the characters stumbled into feel alive on the page, and the mythology the author was able to drive into the narrative not only ramped up the drama quickly but honed in on some of the more personal mysteries tied to the characters themselves.
What stood out was how much this story seemed to embody the themes and nostalgia that so many projects in this genre have established beforehand while still creating a fresh and remarkable story. Whether it was Steven Spielberg’s E.T. or the modern-day Stranger Things, the idea of young people having to confront the strange and the unknown and face their own looming adulthood in the process was thoroughly presented in this narrative.
The Verdict
Action-packed, magical, and entertaining author Dana Robertson’s “The Abandoned Theater” is a must-read middle-school/YA fantasy read. The magical world-building that the story takes on and the rich and relatable character dynamics of this novel make this a remarkable narrative that readers won’t be able to get enough of and will be eager for the next entry into the series.
What a compelling and engaging read. The author does a marvelous job of balancing the relatable, heartfelt character development with the visceral fantasy world-building that the author was able to create. The imagery in the author’s writing made the world the characters stumbled into feel alive on the page, and the mythology the author was able to drive into the narrative not only ramped up the drama quickly but honed in on some of the more personal mysteries tied to the characters themselves.
What stood out was how much this story seemed to embody the themes and nostalgia that so many projects in this genre have established beforehand while still creating a fresh and remarkable story. Whether it was Steven Spielberg’s E.T. or the modern-day Stranger Things, the idea of young people having to confront the strange and the unknown and face their own looming adulthood in the process was thoroughly presented in this narrative.
The Verdict
Action-packed, magical, and entertaining author Dana Robertson’s “The Abandoned Theater” is a must-read middle-school/YA fantasy read. The magical world-building that the story takes on and the rich and relatable character dynamics of this novel make this a remarkable narrative that readers won’t be able to get enough of and will be eager for the next entry into the series.
February 21, 2025
*Spoiler free* just touches on light details without giving anything away**
The Abandoned Theater is a thrilling tale about friendship, mystery, loss, and community in two different worlds. The fantasy aspect of the story was very interesting and different from what is normally seen especially in tween/teen aged books. It had some gothic/horror themes in the villains and the evil aspect of the world that left you feeling creeped out as you imagined just how the descriptions looked. It had very light romance which was fitting for the age group. As for friendship, Beth’s friends were ride or die for her, and as the story went on they evolved even more as a group, which I loved.
The story throws curveballs at you that you weren’t expecting which keeps you on your toes and hooks you into reading to find out more information and get to the bottom of things.
The only negative thing I have to say is that I wish there was more to it (which isn’t that negative). The situations were a bit rushed through and could have used more detail, but again this is aimed for a younger reader so it makes sense. I hope book 2 delves deeper into the world building and how certain characters relate to the main character, Beth!
The Abandoned Theater is a thrilling tale about friendship, mystery, loss, and community in two different worlds. The fantasy aspect of the story was very interesting and different from what is normally seen especially in tween/teen aged books. It had some gothic/horror themes in the villains and the evil aspect of the world that left you feeling creeped out as you imagined just how the descriptions looked. It had very light romance which was fitting for the age group. As for friendship, Beth’s friends were ride or die for her, and as the story went on they evolved even more as a group, which I loved.
The story throws curveballs at you that you weren’t expecting which keeps you on your toes and hooks you into reading to find out more information and get to the bottom of things.
The only negative thing I have to say is that I wish there was more to it (which isn’t that negative). The situations were a bit rushed through and could have used more detail, but again this is aimed for a younger reader so it makes sense. I hope book 2 delves deeper into the world building and how certain characters relate to the main character, Beth!
August 20, 2025
This is a middle-grade fantasy story, and it is the first part in the series. A group of teenagers visits an abandoned theater to search for their missing friend, only to enter a magical world through a portal.
The story is magical, with fantasy elements that are enjoyable to middle school kids. My son, who is in 5th grade, loved the story. Kids who love Percy Jackson and Arushi kind of stories will love this series.
The story is fun with twists. The characters are cool teenage kids like Beth and Tina. Beth learns some unexpected news about her family and lineage after entering the portal. All kids, together with their friends, can overcome problems and can come back to their world safely.
I love that the story shows friendship and helping each other. I enjoyed the twists in the story. Loved the characterization. The book cover and title are apt.
What might have been better?
For me, the information after they enter the portal is overwhelming. I didn't like that everyone around Beth tries to hide her lineage until the last minute. I felt that the way the information about other worlds and the background is revealed it might have been better.
My Rating: 4/5
PS: I received a review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The story is magical, with fantasy elements that are enjoyable to middle school kids. My son, who is in 5th grade, loved the story. Kids who love Percy Jackson and Arushi kind of stories will love this series.
The story is fun with twists. The characters are cool teenage kids like Beth and Tina. Beth learns some unexpected news about her family and lineage after entering the portal. All kids, together with their friends, can overcome problems and can come back to their world safely.
I love that the story shows friendship and helping each other. I enjoyed the twists in the story. Loved the characterization. The book cover and title are apt.
What might have been better?
For me, the information after they enter the portal is overwhelming. I didn't like that everyone around Beth tries to hide her lineage until the last minute. I felt that the way the information about other worlds and the background is revealed it might have been better.
My Rating: 4/5
PS: I received a review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 8, 2024
I liked it, yet I struggled with this book too! What I liked: The adventure and world building into this new fantasy land, basically I wished this whole story took place in Alderland. What I struggled with: 1) Romance. At 12 years old I really don't like when romance is included, it's just too young! Multiple times characters kissed and then also had extra feelings from the kiss (flushed cheeks, etc). Just too much for such a young age in my opinion. 2) Pacing. The adventure was fun but it was just one thing to the next without deeper character development. I didn't feel like I had adequate time to take in each scene before the next began. 3) Character relatability. The main character just seemed too good, with no flaws. I can't really relate to a character that is always doing the right thing and doesn't make mistakes or mess up really like normal. Honestly, I think we need more characters who have flaws so that we can see and experience character development and changes. I don't think I will continue on in the series mainly due to the content already added for this target age group. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
December 30, 2024
The abandoned theater, this book follows the MC Beth as she investigates the disappearances that happened at the theater.
I’m going to be honest the beginning of the book was hard to get into, I kept picking up the book and putting it back down, it wasn’t until about 20 % into the book that I actually started to enjoy it enough for it to keep my attention .
Unfortunately that didn’t last long and by about 40 % the book had lost my attention again, I struggled through this book every page I read I wanted to set this book down more and more and never pick it up again.
I am not sure if it’s the writing style that I was having such a hard time with because the plot interests me and is clearly a good plot I just could not get into this book for the life of me.
I ended up DnFing this book at 50% read I tried but the amount I was struggling to get into it was stressing me out because I disliked the book that much.
I think this book has a cute plot and that a lot of people will love it but this book was a miss for me, I do hope however that this finds the audience that I know will adore it .
Thank you NetGalley, collective ink limited, and our street books for the arc
I’m going to be honest the beginning of the book was hard to get into, I kept picking up the book and putting it back down, it wasn’t until about 20 % into the book that I actually started to enjoy it enough for it to keep my attention .
Unfortunately that didn’t last long and by about 40 % the book had lost my attention again, I struggled through this book every page I read I wanted to set this book down more and more and never pick it up again.
I am not sure if it’s the writing style that I was having such a hard time with because the plot interests me and is clearly a good plot I just could not get into this book for the life of me.
I ended up DnFing this book at 50% read I tried but the amount I was struggling to get into it was stressing me out because I disliked the book that much.
I think this book has a cute plot and that a lot of people will love it but this book was a miss for me, I do hope however that this finds the audience that I know will adore it .
Thank you NetGalley, collective ink limited, and our street books for the arc
January 13, 2026
It starts with a genuinely creepy local legend, and I like how the story keeps widening. What begins as a small-town mystery turns into something much bigger without losing the heart of the friend group. The abandoned theater works especially well as a setting and carries real atmosphere.
The author clearly understands her audience. The book’s reading age is for 9-12. So to make books work for that reading age, you need short chapters, crisp dialogue, and keep the action moving. The author did all of that very nicely. I have read way too many books that claim to be for middle-schoolers but are either too basic or like Game of Thrones; this one got it just right.
If this is going to be a longer series, I would personally enjoy seeing the characters work a little harder for some of the bigger plot moments and letting certain developments stretch out over multiple books, but that is the long book-loving Game of Thrones reader in me talking, and it comes down to personal taste.
That said, the friend group dynamic is a real strength here. It worked for The Goonies, Stand by Me, and Stranger Things, and it works here, too.
The author clearly understands her audience. The book’s reading age is for 9-12. So to make books work for that reading age, you need short chapters, crisp dialogue, and keep the action moving. The author did all of that very nicely. I have read way too many books that claim to be for middle-schoolers but are either too basic or like Game of Thrones; this one got it just right.
If this is going to be a longer series, I would personally enjoy seeing the characters work a little harder for some of the bigger plot moments and letting certain developments stretch out over multiple books, but that is the long book-loving Game of Thrones reader in me talking, and it comes down to personal taste.
That said, the friend group dynamic is a real strength here. It worked for The Goonies, Stand by Me, and Stranger Things, and it works here, too.
December 10, 2024
Beth and Brent have a special connection but don’t see each other as much as they used to. When one of Beth’s friends goes missing, Beth and her friends decide it’s time to face their fears and explore a haunted, abandoned theater. As they explore, they stumble into a portal to another world. Beth and her friends are suddenly thrown into a battle between light and dark, and Beth discovers more about herself than she could ever imagine.
The fantasy piece of this book is nothing new. Hidden portal. Family secrets. Good versus evil. It is a good story which keeps the reader interested in finding out who will prevail. On occasion, the story jumps ahead or time progresses quickly, and it required me to reread to make sure I understood what was going on. The characters are easy to relate to, especially the turmoil Beth is going through. It is the first in a series so be prepared to wait to find out what happens next. Overall, this book is a solid fantasy with a few good twists and turns.
The fantasy piece of this book is nothing new. Hidden portal. Family secrets. Good versus evil. It is a good story which keeps the reader interested in finding out who will prevail. On occasion, the story jumps ahead or time progresses quickly, and it required me to reread to make sure I understood what was going on. The characters are easy to relate to, especially the turmoil Beth is going through. It is the first in a series so be prepared to wait to find out what happens next. Overall, this book is a solid fantasy with a few good twists and turns.
July 30, 2025
What an amazing and wonderful middle grade book. We have a mysterious theater, said to have swallowed up people in the past, a young girl and two friends who have chosen to figure out the mystery. Then there is the whole portal to another world. What story like this would be complete without someone who wants to take over all worlds? The mystery genre has been my favorite since I was in elementary school. Throw in a fantasy world and I have the best of both genres.
If you have ever been in an old theater, especially at night you know the eerie feeling you get. It is a bit creepy. That feeling is definitely in the this theater. The author has done an excellent job of creating twists and turns at just the right place.
I received a copy from the author to facilitate my review. Since I teach middle school and I am always looking for great books for my classroom shelves, I am glad Dana reached out. I can’t wait to do my first book tasting and book talk. This will be the first book I recommend to my students. I am looking forward to the second book in this series.
If you have ever been in an old theater, especially at night you know the eerie feeling you get. It is a bit creepy. That feeling is definitely in the this theater. The author has done an excellent job of creating twists and turns at just the right place.
I received a copy from the author to facilitate my review. Since I teach middle school and I am always looking for great books for my classroom shelves, I am glad Dana reached out. I can’t wait to do my first book tasting and book talk. This will be the first book I recommend to my students. I am looking forward to the second book in this series.
April 20, 2025
A confusing quest😕
This story could not hold my interest. After a promising start and the introduction of a small group of friends upset and mystified by a schoolmates disappearance, the plot took them on a journey into the forest to find their missing friend and after that it devolved into constant movement that seemed to have no focus. I also thought the story allowed little room for character development because it kept jumping to a new mystery or danger without a break. After a while I could not get interested in where the adventure was taking Beth and her friends. Too bad, because I would have liked to know how she was connected to the theater's history. But I just couldn't force myself to stay engaged past the first half.
Thanks to Collective Ink Limited and NetGalley for sharing a complimentary advance copy of the book; this is my voluntary and honest opinion.
This story could not hold my interest. After a promising start and the introduction of a small group of friends upset and mystified by a schoolmates disappearance, the plot took them on a journey into the forest to find their missing friend and after that it devolved into constant movement that seemed to have no focus. I also thought the story allowed little room for character development because it kept jumping to a new mystery or danger without a break. After a while I could not get interested in where the adventure was taking Beth and her friends. Too bad, because I would have liked to know how she was connected to the theater's history. But I just couldn't force myself to stay engaged past the first half.
Thanks to Collective Ink Limited and NetGalley for sharing a complimentary advance copy of the book; this is my voluntary and honest opinion.
May 6, 2025
Full of adventure, secrets, magic and mystery, The Abandoned Theater is an exciting read for everyone. Hidden in the forest lies an abandoned theater where a sinister event occurred with a man missing and leaving witnesses traumatised. Nobody knows what actually happened all those years ago. Now one of Beth’s friends has gone missing in the theater. She and her friends Stan and Teri set out to find him, making a shocking discovery. I loved how this story played out with the world through the portal. The characters were great as well. I really loved Stan! He was a great sidekick for
Beth. The detailed descriptions throughout made the story seem larger than life. I hope, from the way it ended, that there is more to come from these characters in the future.
Beth. The detailed descriptions throughout made the story seem larger than life. I hope, from the way it ended, that there is more to come from these characters in the future.
October 25, 2025
The Abandoned Theater is an imaginative and suspenseful middle-grade adventure that blends mystery, friendship, and fantasy in a way that feels timeless. What begins as a local investigation into a missing teenager quickly transforms into a much bigger journey when twelve-year-old Beth and her friends stumble upon a hidden world beyond the walls of an abandoned theater.
Dana Robertson’s storytelling is rich and vivid, capturing the thrill of discovery and the courage it takes to face the unknown. The pacing builds beautifully, shifting from eerie tension to fast-paced fantasy as the friends unravel long-buried secrets. Beth is a brave, clever heroine, and her friendship with the others feels real and warm, grounding the fantastical elements with genuine emotion.
Dana Robertson’s storytelling is rich and vivid, capturing the thrill of discovery and the courage it takes to face the unknown. The pacing builds beautifully, shifting from eerie tension to fast-paced fantasy as the friends unravel long-buried secrets. Beth is a brave, clever heroine, and her friendship with the others feels real and warm, grounding the fantastical elements with genuine emotion.
November 27, 2024
*thank you to NetGalley for giving me access*
3 ⭐️
This book was middle grade and while I like reading that genre, I am a 23-year-old woman and therefore not the target audience. The book did not interest me that much and I felt it dragged in certain places and then skipped ahead too much in others. It also had a few grammatical issues at the start of the book but I'm sure this will be fixed before publication.
I did like the concept of this book and while I may not be the target audience, I think it has potential to be popular with younger readers and hopefully the author gets the chance to write a sequel because this book does end on a cliffhanger.
3 ⭐️
This book was middle grade and while I like reading that genre, I am a 23-year-old woman and therefore not the target audience. The book did not interest me that much and I felt it dragged in certain places and then skipped ahead too much in others. It also had a few grammatical issues at the start of the book but I'm sure this will be fixed before publication.
I did like the concept of this book and while I may not be the target audience, I think it has potential to be popular with younger readers and hopefully the author gets the chance to write a sequel because this book does end on a cliffhanger.
April 28, 2025
I started this book looking for action in a story for a young audience that would be detailed and eventful.
I found the writing to be good, the friendship between the characters to be interesting, and the main character to be likeable. I think the setting is put together really well, and it pulls you into a whole new world.
The second part of the book is much better constructed, and it's able to handle and channel a greater concentration of action and fun into its pages. Anyway, it was a great read. I'd definitely recommend it, and I think it's perfect for a young audience who like their thrills.
Really thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.
I found the writing to be good, the friendship between the characters to be interesting, and the main character to be likeable. I think the setting is put together really well, and it pulls you into a whole new world.
The second part of the book is much better constructed, and it's able to handle and channel a greater concentration of action and fun into its pages. Anyway, it was a great read. I'd definitely recommend it, and I think it's perfect for a young audience who like their thrills.
Really thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.
May 6, 2025
Any who knows me, knows that not only do I love books, but i also love the theatre, so I had to read this book. And I have to say that middle grade aged me would have loved it. 40 year old me enjoyed it a lot too!
I thought it was well paced and the writing level was perfect for the recommended age group. The chapters were nice and short, which means they'd hold the attention at the younger end of the middle grade range. I thought the fantasy elements were perfect and really enjoyed the magical theatre world.
I think this is a really good start to a series and look forward to sharing it with the small people in my life.
I thought it was well paced and the writing level was perfect for the recommended age group. The chapters were nice and short, which means they'd hold the attention at the younger end of the middle grade range. I thought the fantasy elements were perfect and really enjoyed the magical theatre world.
I think this is a really good start to a series and look forward to sharing it with the small people in my life.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews