Professional fan fiction, it's bound to become a trend (if it hasn't already, I don't know of similar books or I've forgotten). Authors are fans too, what a great way for everyone to make money, I bet many publishers will hop on board the train if and when it makes sense for their authors and series too. Everyone wins. Unless you're the kind of really strict fan who feels that only Harris's voice works for the characters. Now that I think of it, in some ways I guess movie, TV and video game tie-in books are sort of fan fiction in the same way that this is, maybe that's part of why several of the authors who were chosen are very experienced in writing those books. When you see how excited Kevin Hearne is to be writing a Star Wars book it's clear that it's definitely fan fiction, though I'm sure that many times when an author takes on a tie-in novel it's just a job too. But it's a skill to be able to step into an established world and write a story that readers will love. I was impressed at how well almost everyone in this book did it. And how good all of the stories were. There were no actual stinkers. There were a few that I had some quibbles with, that it would be fun to talk to someone about and say, "Hey, what did you think about this..." But most of these voices worked for me much more than the dark and dreary tone of the TV show, which I never could come to enjoy. And many, by choosing lesser known supporting characters, don't have to be measured as strictly against the original since they aren't as familiar. I was impressed with how well the authors captured the tone of the series, I generally felt like I was in the familiar world where I expected to be, if looking at it from some different angles and perspectives than normal. But that was fun, many of those perspectives were ones that I've always wanted to know more about. Some were characters I didn't remember at all, but that's fine too, in the right author's hands some of those stories were able to be a bit more... creative maybe?... without as many restrictions as the more well known voices. Like Nicole Peeler's story, she chose such a minor character, or even though I critiqued it a lot, Leigh Evans had a lot of latitude to write a more creative story, as opposed to writing about Bubba, Alcide, Pam or Eric, all characters who's situations and personalities leave less leeway for playing. Which is it's own kind of fun and interesting challenge I'd think. But anyway, I enjoyed seeing what all of them did and how they did it and made it feel natural.
There were a lot of stories where people were essentially thinking most of the story to themselves, basically internal monologues. The more successful were those with interaction and actual action, plot, beginnings/middles/and ends.
I really hate getting to the end of books and finding things that would have been really helpful to have known were there all along, like glossaries, or in this case author biographies. I should have looked, they're usually there in anthologies, I just didn't think of it. I wasn't really thinking of this as an anthology, for that matter. The bios were actually helpful with a few of them, the condensed format has the information I wanted and didn't really find looking them up on Goodreads or in Wikipedia. Oh well!
Rachel Caine - Kevin and Kenya are trying to capture a criminal and get a bit caught up in the vampire scene in Dallas. Caine always writes good short stories. She did a very good job of making me feel like I was reading a story that was a part of the genuine Sookie universe, despite being from a different POV. The details were all there and the tone was right, the emotions and motivations felt genuine. It felt right and it was an interesting story. Plus I always wanted to know more about how those two got together.
Christopher Golden - What the heck have I read of his before? His book list is endless between his many series and the many TV tie-ins he's authored. I have no idea what I read and his book list is so overwhelming it's actually a turn-off, I can't see the original series from the TV series to find the ones I know I read. Other than some interest in some of his comic books I just don't want to wade through it all. (I wish I'd seen the bio in the back, I'd have been less frustrated to know about the comic books he's writing with Harris and the other books he's aiming for us to focus on.) But the story about Quinn the weretiger was...uneven. At the beginning I felt for his love for his mother and his frustration with not being able to make things better for her in her older years. A lot of us have been in that place in various ways with our parents. And then it got worse. Not it was a bad story-worse, but upsetting it's a good story-worse. It wasn't something I could relate to, thank goodness, but it was all too believable, sadly. Too often when I read fiction I wish that what I'm reading wasn't possible, that the authors were making up the depths of what despicable things people will do to each other to get what they want, but I know that they're really just making up the circumstances and it hurts my heart. So that part was good, in a way, it was good writing if not happy writing. And the story had a good twist at the end. But the overall pace was off, it's all build up then it's over but not actually resolved, his mother is still in danger and the story just ends. It doesn't feel at all like a complete story. Maybe he's planning on writing another story to continue it in another anthology, I've seen that plenty of times, but it felt incomplete and unsatisfying.
Leigh Perry - When Harris calls her, "my friend" in her intro she meant it, it's Toni Kelner. No wonder she got Diantha, her favorite character is many people's. I've read a number of very good stories by Kelner, but this one was just kind of cute, it didn't have the depth that I expected from her. Diantha wasn't exactly doing anything, I mean she was investigating something but there was no plot or story or jeopardy. It was mostly description. So cute, not thrilling.
Jeffrey J. Mariotte - This is another author where knowing that the bio in the back existed would really have helped me. I couldn't find anything under his full name for some reason (he's written quite a few books under that name) and got swallowed up by the huge Jeff Mariotte list of licensed properties/tie-ins of books and graphic novels based on TV shows: Angel, Charmed, CSI, etc. His bio was much more helpful again. So...The story is about Andy Bellefleur dealing with the awful aftermath of the night he got drunk and got a ride home from his sister, and then found something terrible in his car the next day. I liked the detail that Mariotte picked to explore in Bon Temps history, slotting it naturally into the flow of familiar story as though it could have been there all along. It fit very well into the mythology of the series and captured the tone very well. I guess he's an expert at doing that with all of his experience writing in universes he didn't create but has the responsibility to expand. He did a really nice job of capturing the town, all of the little details, and capturing Andy and maybe expanding our understanding of him just a little bit too. It was really very well done for this book.
Seanan McGuire - Seanan always writes good short stories too. She captured how annoying Amelia can be, and yet there's still that something about her that's kind of fun. And she showed a little bit of why Amelia takes the chances she does, what the draw of magic is for her, what risks she'll take and where she draws the line.
Jeanne C. Stein - It was fine. She tried to show why Adele, Sookie's grandma, did what she did and I think she explained it exactly right. It's certainly a story that belongs in this book.
Jonathan Mayberry - An action-packed story about Mustafa that showcased the darker side of this world. The change of pace to a darker tone and the action story was good editing.
Nicole Peeler - What a nice surprise to turn the page and see her name! She's one of my favorite authors and she doesn't do a lot of anthologies. I don't remember Bethany or Desiree or even the Bat's Wing bar in Dallas that apparently inspired quite a few of our authors/fans in their fiction. But it didn't matter, it was still a good story just with the basic concepts of what vampires and shifters are in this world. With a few edits the story could stand on it's own in another anthology and still be very good. I liked the personal elements of the story, the intimate level of it was immediate and bold and real. And the political level of the story as well, the bigger picture that Nicole brought in which added so much depth, it wasn't just about these few people and their jeopardy, they were placed in the world and it's politics and economics. It was an interesting and timely projection to think about how the vampire and shifter situation would influence immigration and the border situation, since they've been such big news in the real world for the last couple of years. So it was a smart story to use those elements and project a potential situation that a woman running from Dallas could get into. Even if the character wasn't one that some fans would be excited to read about because she's so minor in the Sookie universe.
Leigh Evans - Finally a new author who interests me! Remember when anthologies had just a couple of big names and then a bunch of lesser known authors, which was a great way to get introduced to new authors you might like? Especially an anthology like this that can feature mixed genres, fantasy and mystery authors would both work in Sookie-land, it could be really fun. It's nice to see familiar names and know the story will be good, but I'd like more variety. Without having to pick up books as huge as GRRM and Gardner Dozios's massive editing collaborations to do it. It was a cute story. But...I'm not exactly sure it's message about women's body image hit the target. The main character was obsessed with being too heavy because she was bloated from PMS when she was turned into a vampire, and because she was a dancer, a showgirl. And she figured out by the end that it was also because of when she was born. She had a breakthrough when she realized that Renaissance women loved being plump and the men then loved that about them. Which helped her get over the anxiety she'd been carrying around from a relationship with her ex-boyfriend, who it turns out was from the Renaissance, so that's why he was always impatient with her obsession with her weight. OK, great, good for her for getting over him, but she didn't get over her obsession with her weight or realize that she was just as beautiful at any size or any of those healthy body image things. In fact her bad body image was actually kind of rubber stamped, like saying well that's what our generation likes so she should go for being as skinny as possible. Even though she's starving herself and it's idiotic for a vampire who can't actually lose weight. And it never crosses her mind maybe her boyfriend was concerned about her starving herself, or annoyed because she was being ridiculous, she just chalked the whole thing up to him liking plumper women. And the other woman in the story was this smart, take charge totally successful hard ass who dropped it all because she found out that the guy she was supposed to marry was a famous artist. OK, I get it, if Van Gogh was suddenly alive and sane I'd probably go all fan girl wild, just like a lot of women would, makes sense, except it stole the sense of her being so cool. First she seemed like a brat, then when she said she was managing everyone's money and a major businesswomen she seemed different, then suddenly she was a gushing girl and it was all over for her. The story said she'd probably be back to being strong in a week, but it stole my enjoyment of her character. I'm not usually so critical, but it just bugged me that she wrote these women who were so messed up. And body image stuff always really bothers me, I really dislike women who are so down on themselves and it especially bothers me that I don't think the author would even say the story was negative. I think she thinks it was a woman getting over her issues, so it bothers me more that she doesn't see that the character is so hung up on her weight in a really unhealthy way. On the surface the story was cute, fluffy and enjoyable to read, but there were so many underlying problems with the characterization that will make me cautious going into her books.
Bill Crider - The ultimate in fan fiction, just a light story closely mirroring the incident that I even kind of remember when Bubba helped Sookie and Eric rescue Bill from Russell's compound. Harris including Bubba in her stories is fan fiction anyway, and this was just a fun, fluffy fantasy of a story and captured the Southern Vampire tone quite well.
Nancy Holder - I got excited when I saw her name because I thought it was Nancy Holzner. I have had this Nancy on my to-read list for a long time but never got around to her. She had so many books she originated and she's another one who's book list is really hard to wade through because of the huge number of novelizations of TV shows - Buffy, Angel, Charmed, many more, some co-written with Jeff Mariotte even. Is this a publisher connection? I'm sure dozens of authors would had liked to be included in this book. They're all very well-known authors for all of their work, the worlds they created and the tie-ins are all very successful, I've just never seen so many authors with such huge tie-in book lists in one anthology. Or maybe I didn't notice. I'm familiar with Christopher Golden but I never noticed his tie-ins before, I probably didn't look because I was familiar with him. Anyway, this was a dark and sad story about Alcide that tried to have a happyish ending but it was already too late for that and it wasn't believable. Some broken things can't be fixed.
Miranda James - a good reminder that I liked her first Charlie and Diesel cozy mystery. Diesel is a cool cat. And it turns out from the bio and Miranda is really Dean, so I can check out his books now too, which is the point of writing in anthologies, getting now readers, a success for him. Didn't Claude turn out to be a right bastard though, am I remembering wrong? It's funny that this author was still so interested in him. Maybe not so much him but them now that I've read the story. And I didn't remember any of how Claudette died or who killed her, so I could totally be wrong anyway.
Suzanne McLeod - Now here's someone I like who isn't in anthologies much, such a nice surprise. It took forever just to get the most recent book (4) in her Spellcrackers.com series in the US, the publishers were playing very annoying games. This was a good story about Luna the werebat, another character from Dallas, though not in Texas this time. It also featured Sookie's nephew and his dad. It was a little bit, I don't know, distanced somehow, but I liked Luna and it was nice to read a story from her that was so different from Spellcasters. And I liked the the idea of the werebat a lot, the small non-agressive flying shifter has a lot of storytelling possibilities.
Dana Cameron - It's funny how Harris introduces so many of the chapters, ..."Pam is a favorite of this author..." Well duh, of course she is, she's everyone's favorite, just like Alcide is and Eric is and Diantha is and so many of the characters are. They had rich pickings. I do wonder if there was a bidding war over Pam though. Maybe Cameron had to give a big check to charity or she won a huge game of rock/paper/scissors. But I didn't entirely get the story. On the one hand, it was exciting, it captured a bit of Pam's spirit in a joie de vivre kind of way. Though I'm not sure I always though of her that way, I could buy into that being some of what's going on under the surface that she never could or would explain to Sookie or let her see. But it skipped right over why Eric turned her and it still seems so completely out of character the way it was described here, they were total strangers, she wasn't dear to him, why would he do that? Again, maybe it was in the books and I've forgotten, but it should be in the story briefly too then, I shouldn't have to remember. And if I was supposed to care who this Morgan guy was and why he was after Eric, well I didn't. I kind of digged Pam the hero, juxtaposed with Pam the violent killer vampire, and Pam the slightly romantic, it was effective. But there were also some too convenient things, like all the stuff with Quinn being in here at all (he came off as kind of dumb, which he is not), her just happening to fit into the show perfectly in the dress of the one woman who didn't show. It just didn't sit right at times, like those novels where the author is so excited to showcase the ideas she's become attached to that she can't or won't edit or realize that she's trying too hard to make them work beyond what's even fantasyland believable. I just didn't buy into a lot of it.
MaryJanice Davidson - Lucky MJD got the Eric of the future. Unfortunately, I thought this was the least successful story in the book. It didn't sound particular like Eric to me, whatever that means. He was stiff and robotic. It was an oddly difficult and confusing story to read, unfortunately like her other stories going to the future have been actually. Several times I had to go back several paragraphs and re-read to try to figure out what was going on. I get the points she was trying to make with it about the choices Eric made versus the choices Sookie made and that part was good, though the implication that Sookie wasn't happy with her choices was odd to me because I think she made the right choice and Eric in this story sure emphasized that, she had no place in the world he created, she was a creature of the sun. I just don't get all of the choices MJD made in writing the story. It was jumbled up somehow. She used to be such a clear and easy to read writer, I don't know where her flow went.