Rate this book

Ratings & Reviews for

Only Enchanting

Mary Balogh

5 stars

2,273 (30%)

4 stars

3,112 (41%)

3 stars

1,805 (23%)

2 stars

297 (3%)

1 star

68 (<1%)

Displaying 1 - 30 of 780 reviews

Duchess Nicole

1,258 reviews1,527 followers

October 31, 2014

4.5 Stars!!

Mary Balogh is like the Mona Lisa compared to a Picasso. She's dignified and lovely, serene and quietly mysterious. There's nothing about her books that screams "READ ME!" and yet, I always do. I sink into her stories and roll around in another time, another place, another way of thinking.

This was the fourth story in the Survivor's Club series, of which I've only read two. I'll certainly go back and read the others and continue the series though. One thing that struck me about this book was how Flavian (what a name!) is just not my normal kind of hero. He's the smirking type, the kind that you expect to swindle you or something. But our heroine, Agnes, sees through all that to the insecure, hurting man beneath. Just as he sees more than the somewhat dowdy, quiet woman with a bit of a crush.

This is where Balogh excels. She writes characters that are insightful and intuitive, and then she makes the reader see what they see. And makes me fall in love with them all. In this genre, loud and flowery seems to be the norm, but Balogh's characters are all so normal and peaceful. And yet they still have fantastic love stories to tell.

This was...if you couldn't tell...a wonderful book about a man who's seen too much and lived through some awful experiences. Flavian has a bit of a stutter, the only thing left over from his horrific injuries in the war. His fiancee left him to marry his best friend when he was deemed a madman. Now, he's back, he's normal, but a little bitter. He's doing some soul searching, I think, and Agnes comes along at just the right time and place. Agnes is the yin to his yang, and their romance was hold-your-breath beautiful!

Advance copy provided by the publisher for review

4-star-read arc-for-review arc-net-galley

♥Rachel♥

1,851 reviews847 followers

September 7, 2015

4.5 Stars

Flavian, Viscount Ponsonby is one six friends that call themselves “The Survivors Club” after recovering together from grave injuries suffered during the Napoleonic War. It took Flavian some time to recover from being shot in the head, and still he suffers the effects of his injury. As if that wasn’t bad enough, when he finally became lucid he found out his betrothed, Velma, ended their engagement so she could marry his best friend, Len, after thinking Flavian would never fully recover. Now years later, Len dies leaving Velma a widow and the way open for them to be together. Both of their family’s pressure to put these two together again, but Flavian wants nothing to do that.

In the present, meeting the young widow Agnes Keeping and pursuing her is a pull Flavian can’t resist.
It’s not that Agnes is stunningly beautiful, but there’s something about her that becomes more enchanting every time they meet. It’s as if his unconscious mind knows exactly what he needs.

He wanted to claim her body for his own.
And he would be safe.
Strange thought—and it was not the first time that it had popped into his head like an alien thing.
Safe.
Safe from whom?
And from what?

Agnes has avoided passion and falling in love since it brought hurt and ruin to her family. When she married Mr. Keeping it was for companionship and because he was a logical match, but she was hardly overcome with desire. Five short years later she was widowed at the age of twenty-three. Now Agnes lives with her beloved sister, contented in life even if she is a little lonely at times. When Viscount Ponsonby comes to Agnes’ little town to visit with his Survivors Club friends, her attempts at avoiding passion and love go out the window. After a whirlwind of stolen meetings and steamy encounters, Flavian proposes and Agnes, in spite of her hesitancy, can’t help herself and so they marry.

To outward appearances Flavian’s intention when he chose to marry Agnes was an avoidance tactic at best, and at worst a means of revenge on Velma for leaving him after his injuries all those years ago. At first this is what it seems to poor Agnes when she discovers the history, and it was a knife to her heart! I ached for her and wanted to smack Flavian for a bit! But things are not as they seem, and there is much more at play here that Flavian doesn’t immediately clue into because of holes in his memory. But all along his subconscious registered what his conscious mind didn’t recall. AND it becomes obvious that Flavian really cares for Agnes and he wanted to marry her just as she wanted to marry him.

I loved that even when the situation felt so very hurtful to Agnes she didn’t throw everything away by running, but rather she thought things through. She was a truly sensible, understanding and kind woman, perfect for an injured soul like Flavian. He more than redeems himself as the story plays out and my heart swelled with happiness for these two. They had an immediate attraction that was at first fueled by passion and longing, but then grew into a beautiful bond of love.

I don’t read many historical romances but I loved this story so much! I felt like I was transported into a time something like what’s portrayed in Sense and Sensibility, one of my all-time favorite period movies! Ms. Balogh’s compelling writing had me high on emotions ranging from despair and anger for Agnes and Flavian to joy and happiness over how it all turned out!

I definitely want to check out the rest of this series, and I hope there will be a romance written for Dora, Agnes’ sister. There were hints of one stirring.

A copy was kindly provided by Signet in exchange for an honest review.

This review is also posted on The Readers Den.

favorites historical romance

Lady Wesley

927 reviews320 followers

March 20, 2016

Only Enchanting is only excellent -- one of Mary Balogh's best ever.

This is the fourth installment in Mary Balogh’s Survivor’s Club series, and while all of them have been good, this one is first-rate. It delivers what we’ve come to expect from Balogh – engaging, fully-developed characters, impeccable plotting, and a happily ever after that is not easily earned. I couldn’t wait to find out what would happen next, the result being that I read it in less than one day

As the book opens, it’s time for the members of the Survivors Club to gather for their annual reunion, but instead of going to Penderris Castle in Cornwall, they journey to Middlebury Park, the Gloucester estate of Vincent Hunt, Viscount Darleigh. This change in venue came about because Vincent’s wife, Sophia, had recently given birth, and he would not leave her.

Living near Middlebury Park is Sophia’s closest friend, Agnes Keeping, a widow who resides with her older sister Dora, a music teacher.

At the age of twenty-six, Agnes Keeping had never been in love or ever expected to be -- or even wished to be. She rather chose to be in control of her own emotions and her own life, such as it was.
Agnes was married at age 18 to an older man, “a neighboring gentleman of sober address,” and while there was no love between them, there was affection, and Agnes was content. She leads a prosaic life in the village of Inglebrook and is satisfied with painting, tending house, and visiting with neighbors. She is wary of romantic passion, which was, as we learn later, her mother’s downfall.

Agnes and Dora attend a Harvest Ball at Middlebury Park and into her life strolls Flavian Arnott, Viscount Ponsonby. Flavian is handsome, witty, charming, and aloof, but his affable exterior masks enduring scars. He inherited his title only upon the death of his beloved brother, David. Shortly thereafter, Flavian suffered grievous head injuries in the Peninsular Wars. He was brought home unable to speak or even think coherently. When his fiancée, Velma, jilts him to marry his best friend, all he can do is fly into a fit of sputtering rage. Fortunately, he was taken in by the Duke of Stanbrook and spent three years recuperating with the other members of the Survivor’s Club, but he still speaks with a stammer and suffers from memory loss, headaches, and occasional outbursts of temper.

At the Harvest Ball, Flavian dances with Agnes, twice, and almost against her will Agnes falls ridiculously, hopelessly in love. The next day, Flavian leaves, and Agnes expects never to see him again. Six months later, though, he returns for the Survivor’s Club gathering, and although he can’t quite remember Agnes’s name, he is pleased to see her again. He does recall dancing with her though and later tells her, “I expected you to be s-sensible, but your were enchanting instead.”

Flavian and Agnes spend time together, exchanging the stories of their lives along with a few kisses. When Flavian suddenly proposes marriage, it is hard to know who is more surprised, but eventually Agnes accepts, and they are married by special license the next day. But there are surprises in store when they arrive at Arnott House in London, for awaiting them there are Flavian’s family along with the now-widowed Velma and her parents. All of them are expecting Flavian and Velma to reunite and marry, and they are unhappily surprised to learn that Flavian has married a nobody from nowhere. Moreover, Agnes is unhappily surprised to learn that Flavian has married her in order to be free from his family’s manipulations.

Flavian and Agnes are faced with a choice, and Agnes’s first inclination is to flee – back to her lonely but safe life in Inglebrook. But it turns out that Agnes is made of sterner stuff, and Flavian is desperate to keep her in his life. They are young, but mature beyond their years, and they address their problems directly and candidly.

Agnes is a wonderful heroine. It was great fun to watch her stand up to Flavian’s mother, to Velma, and even to the dragon ladies of the ton, who have their claws out after the truth about Agnes’s mother comes out. As Agnes comes into her own, Flavian begins to remember more about David’s death and about his own troubled relationship with Velma. Agnes and Flavian talk to one another about their problems like mature adults, which happens all too seldom in romance.

With her trademark faultless execution and insight, Mary Balogh shows how these two emotionally scarred people work together to address their problems and find the true meaning of love. They make a beautiful couple, and I highly recommend this book.

My thanks to Signet and NetGalley for an advance copy of this book.

2014-faves amz-rev arc

Alba Turunen

659 reviews208 followers

May 16, 2021

4 Estrellitas. Otra buena novela de éste Club de los Supervivientes. Aunque el primer libro de la serie fue algo flojillo, me alegro de que los siguientes hayan tenido una tónica similar, y la novela es tan encantadora como todas las de Mary Balogh.

En éste caso tenemos el cuarto libro de la serie, y "Only Enchanting" es la novela de Flavian Arnott, el vizconde Ponsonby y Agnes Keeping.

Admito que sentía mucha curiosidad por Flavian, a parte de su inocente tartamudez, no sabía qué le había pasado para ser uno de los escacharraditos dignos de entrar en el Club, y por fin lo descubrimos.

En las guerras napoleónicas, Flavian fue soldado y además, herido en batalla, pero la peor parte se la llevó su cabeza. Durante un tiempo no respondía, sufriendo amnesia, fuertes dolores y perdió la capacidad de comunicación. En ése estado, la que era su prometida, rompió el compromiso para casarse con su mejor amigo. Lo que hizo que Flavian se encolerizara violentamente, y su familia llamó al duque de Stanbrooke, el gran sanador de éste particular grupo.

Si soy sincera, no recuerdo al personaje de Agnes Keeping, pero es muy posible que apareciera de pasada durante el libro de Vincent y Sophia, pues Agnes es la dama que hizo que se publicaran las novelas infantiles de ésta entrañable pareja.

Agnes Keeping es una dama viuda. Se casó con un caballero, un vecino suyo, sin intención de que fuese un buen matrimonio o muy pasional. Si algo sabe Agnes, es que la pasión puede destruir a las personas, pues su madre abandonó a su padre para fugarse con su amante. Tras cinco años de matrimonio y ahora viuda, Agnes no se siente satisfecha en su casa, que ha heredado un pariente de su marido, tampoco en la casa de su padre, ni en la de su hermano; así que lleva menos de un año viviendo con su hermana mayor, Dora, también soltera, y que es la profesora de música de Vincent y Sophia.

Como es de suponer, Flavian y Agnes se conocen en la fiesta de la cosecha, que están celebrando Vincent y Sophia en Middlebury Park, su mansión campestre. Una noche en un baile, Sophia le pide a Flavian que baile con su amiga Agnes, y en ése primer encuentro, algo empieza a nacer entre ellos.

Han pasado seis meses y se acerca Marzo, la época en que el Club de los Supervivientes se reunirá en Cornualles. Pero Vincent y Sophia acaban de ser padres, y convencen al resto del Club para que la reunión se celebre en su casa. Flavian y Agnes volverán a encontrarse, y ésta vez lo suyo irá a más.

A Agnes, Flavian le parece un pícaro descarado y encantador, podría parecer algo tímido por su tartamudez, pero es todo menos eso. Aunque Agnes no es una gran belleza, algo de ella atrae a Flavian y de ahí su intención de pasar más tiempo del debido en su compañía. Tanta será la atracción que siente Flavian por Agnes, que no descansará hasta que sea suya.

Pero Flavian tiene también otras intenciones. Su ex prometida, la que le abandonó, acaba de enviudar, y ha vuelto a casa de sus padres. Entrarán en escena la madre y hermana de Flavian para hacer de casamenteras, pero Flavian no se dejará manipular ésta vez, y está dispuesto a cometer cualquier locura.

Esto es lo que nos presenta "Only Enchanting". Una historia muy centrada en los personajes y con unos secundarios de oro, muy bien hilada. Me han gustado ambos protagonistas y tiene las suficientes dosis de tensión, amor, pasión, y sí, también sus discusiones, en éste caso justificadas. Pero, he sentido más debilidad por Agnes, me ha encantado ésta protagonista, que Flavian.

En general he acabado muy satisfecha con ésta lectura y la recomiendo si te gusta la autora y has leído los anteriores de la serie, no decepciona, está muy en la línea de todo los demás. Espero no tardar en leer los siguientes, que veo que como es común en Mary Balogh, va a dejar lo mejor para el final.

2021 regencia-inglesa

Vintage

2,392 reviews446 followers

August 18, 2017

Re-read:

A little mood music for the review… Harry Nelson’s Jump into the Fire

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w8X6m...

Somehow I’ve hooked back into the “Survivor’s Club” series by Mary Balogh. For those who don’t care for some of MB’s more depressing romances, this is a wonderful change.

All the characters of the “Survivor’s Club” are woven together and have huge presences in each book. I hate reading a book with a wonderful character only to find in that the next the series that they have been marginalized. Not so here. What a band of brothers. MB truly throws the concept that nice guys (and girls) are boring. I want the “Survivor’s Club” crew as my friends although not only are they fictional, they are dead.

Back to this fun couple, Agnes (yes her name is Agnes and her poor older sister is…DORA. Bad parents just for their names alone) is a sweet, honorable widow. Flavius is the hero, and he’s a blonde one which is so unfortunate, but he overcomes it with his seductive ways. Unlike many heroes he limits his abilities to seduce solely to the heroine, and even that is limited as he respects her as much as he wants her. He is, however, a charming, wannabe cad that just can’t push through to true rogue/cad status. In one moment he admits he lusts after the heroine with no words of love then the next moment he is carrying his blind friend’s baby boy home mentoring him on the ways of men. Okay, umm, too cute!

Sweet and eventful romance between a rakish but honorable hero who knows a good thing when he sees it, and the h that is willing to jump into the fire with him.

Toss in the aforementioned best friends, a presumptuous and truly evil OW that doesn’t get what she wants, and, hey, a great romance!!!

Jump into the fire lyrics
You can climb a mountain, you can swim the sea
You can jump into the fire but you'll never be free
You can shake me up or I can break you down
Oh, oh
We can make each other happy
Oh, we can make each other happy
We can make each other happy
Oh, we can make each other happy

Old review:
This has one of my favorite tropes or plot points, when the evil other woman gets her comeuppance. Or the very least, the H doesn't take anything lying down.

There is obviously much more to this story, but this is one of my hot buttons.

Both the MC's are wonderful and nice people. Flavian's slight stutter is frankly adorable and quite appealing. Both my father and I stutter a little so I have a fondness for this weakness/idiosyncracy whatever you want to call it.

The Survivor series is overall well-done Regency, but this is one of the better ones.

bad-best-friend bad-ex best-hero-ever

Starr (AKA Starrfish) Rivers

939 reviews272 followers

December 6, 2018

I like this book best out of the whole Survivor's Club series, I think. I've always had a soft spot for Flavian Ponsonby, he of the gorgeous golden-ness and lover extraordinaire! He of the affected boredom and rakishness with a stutter and broiling passion and a heart of gold.

It def helped me fall more in love with him when I imagine Mr. Blondie Bun, my ongoing model obsession, as his fictional incarnation as far as looks go, down to the arching eyebrow!:

description

I really like the heroine too - no-nonsense, made him work for it, level-headed, brave and stands up for herself. She took on the scheming female arch enemy and his scheming family all by herself. He needs someone with a backbone like hers. It's prob why he feels "safe" with her - bc she stands up for both of them. She helps him fight his demons. And instinctively, he knows he loves her. His heart knew before his mind did. And his body certainly took the lead :P

I like that he really, really worked for her. She gave him so many chances to change his mind, to be sure of what he wants, and he kept returning each and every time. He wanted her enuf to stuff his pride and keep coming after her. I felt bad for him every time she asked another "why" and turned him away. I wanted to shake her and scream at her! But he never gave up. I love that about him.

And he never gave up on their marriage and begged her to stay and try just like he persisted in marrying her. He's not the type to give up. It just shows how loyal and true he really is.

I really, really love Flavian. (Especially when he looks like Mr. Blondie Bun!!)

description

favorite-books historical-romance

Caz

2,676 reviews1,011 followers

September 7, 2016

This is the fourth instalment in Mary Balogh's Survivor's Club series, and while I have enjoyed each of the other books, Only Enchanting is the best to date. It's a beautifully wrought and gently moving story of two emotionally wounded people trying to navigate their way through the issues that have shaped them in order to forge a lasting and loving relationship and I adored every minute of it.

Flavian Arnott, Viscount Ponsonby, returned from the Peninsula unable to speak or understand much of what was said to him as the result of a severe head injury. His terrible frustration at both his inability to express himself and at the large gaps in his memory manifested itself in frequent bouts of savage violence and his family were planning on having him confined to an institution. Fortunately for him, George, Duke of Stanbrook, heard of his situation and arrived to bear him off to his Cornish estate, Penderris, where Flavian lived for three years while he recovered, thanks to the patience and understanding of his host and the other members of the “club”.

Mrs. Agnes Keeping is a widow of twenty-six who married an older man when she was just eighteen. She was not unhappy in her marriage (although she would have liked children); her husband was a decent, kind man and she cared for him. She never wanted to fall in love, believing love and especially passion to be destructive forces, and far preferring the safety of unromantic companionship.

Agnes and her sister Dora, who is the local music teacher, live close to Middlebury Park, which is the home of Viscount Darleigh (hero of Book Two, The Arrangementand his new wife Sophia. Agnes and Sophia have become good friends, and the new bride invites the sisters to attend the ball they - the Darleighs - are giving in order to celebrate their recent marriage, which will also be attended by some of Vincent’s fellow Survivor’s Club members.

After two dances with Flavian, Agnes is stunned and annoyed to discover herself in the grip of an unexpected and unwanted emotion – love. But the charming viscount is leaving the next day, and she is confident that as she is unlikely to ever see him again, those feelings will soon fade.

A few months later, Flavian is returning to Middlebury which has temporarily replaced Penderris as the venue for the Survivors’ annual gathering due to the fact that Vincent is reluctant to leave his very pregnant wife. Approaching the house, Flavian passes a young woman he recognises – but can’t for the life of him remember her name. The one thing he can recall is that, for some reason, he’d called her "enchanting".

Agnes and Flavian spend some time together during his visit, exchanging stories and kisses, and when Flavian suddenly proposes marriage, it’s as much a surprise to him as it is to her! She tells herself she would be a fool to accept, that her feelings for Flavian pose a real danger to a peace of mind – yet Agnes just can’t bring herself to turn him down. For his part, Flavian tries to convince himself that what he really wants is someone to take to bed on a regular basis, although it’s clear to the reader that he’s been smitten with Agnes from the very start.

After the wedding, the couple travels to Arnott House in London where an unpleasant surprise is awaiting them. Flavian’s mother, sister, and brother-in-law have all descended on the house in expectation of his arrival, but their precipitate departure from the country means they have not received the letter advising them of his marriage. To turn things from bad to worse, also present is Velma, Lady Hazeltine, the beautiful young woman to whom Flavian had been betrothed before going to war, and who had jilted him for his best friend when it seemed as though he was never going to recover.

Flavian is well aware that his mother had hoped they would finally marry, which leads to some unpleasant realisations for Agnes. At first, her inclination is to flee back home to safety and her old life, but then it’s as though a switch flips and she realises she has something worth fighting for. And fight she does, making it clear to Flavian’s mother and to Velma that she’s here to stay. Together, she and Flavian talk to each other and work through their problems – quite a refreshing change in a romantic novel! – and with her support, he is able to regain some of the missing pieces of his memory.

I admit that at the start of the book, I wasn’t sure I was going to warm to the rather dour, overly practical Agnes. But I needn’t have worried, because the author has created a multi-layered, very human character, who quickly begins to emerge from her shell and shows herself to be a passionate, clever and determined woman with a backbone of steel.

Flavian is a man whose wounds are not visible, but which nonetheless go very deep; and not all of them are attributable to his wartime experiences. He’s beautiful to look at, witty and kind, but his laconic, affable exterior masks a man who is still prone to anger and frustration, for all that he has learned to control them more effectively. He speaks with a slight stammer, which worsens when he is upset or angry, and is still haunted by his older brother’s death, the fact that he wasn’t with him when he died, and because he can’t remember why.

One of the things that works really well in the book is the way the author explores what happens after the marriage (and not just in terms of the sex, which is not explicitly written, but pretty hot nonetheless). While Flavian and Agnes do share a deep connection, they don’t know each other all that well, and there are moments when each of them displays emotions towards the other which might not be particularly appealing, but which feel very real given their situation. There’s a moment, for example, when Flavian resents Agnes for the feelings she’s stirring up in him – “nothing like this ever happened at Penderris”, and one later in the book when Agnes believes he married her simply to thwart his mother’s matchmaking scheme and she hurls at him: “There was nobody worth knowing inside that beautiful body after all, was there?” In both cases, they are able to see past those feelings of resentment and anger and to move on in a way that “real people” have to do, which adds notes of depth and maturity to the story.

Another strength of the novel is the way Ms. Balogh writes the relationships between the survivors. The unconditional love and mutual understanding they feel for one another is palpable; here are people who know when someone needs pushing and when to leave them alone, and the way they support each other is lovely to see.

Only Enchanting is beautifully written, the characters are fully-rounded and the romance is emotionally satisfying. Flavian and Agnes are engaging characters who make a well-matched couple and their HEA feels all the more deserved because of the difficulty of the journey they have undergone in order to achieve it. I really can’t recommend it highly enough.

aar arc romance-1800-1850

Geo Marcovici

1,239 reviews297 followers

June 14, 2020

“O dragoste neașteptată” este povestea lui Flavian Arnott, viconte Ponsonby, și a lui Agnes Keeping, o tânără pe care o cunoaște în casa unui bun prieten.
Această carte se dovedește a fi o poveste intensă, cu foarte multe emoții, care ne face să îi îndrăgim pe cei doi.
Fiecare dintre ei are un trecut care le-a afectat prezentul.
La vârsta de 5 ani, Agnes și frații ei au fost abandonați de mamă iar tatăl lor a divorțat.... Asta este tot ce știe Agnes. De aici pornește și rezerva ei de a avea încredere în iubire și pasiune.
Pe de altă parte, Flavian are parte de propriile sale cicatrici, la propriu și la figurat. Rănit în războiul din Peninsulă, rămâne cu o amnezie parțială și un ușor bâlbâit.
Momentul când cei doi se întâlnesc pentru prima dată nu prevestește tot ceea ce urmează. Dar, câteva luni mai târziu, Clubul Supraviețuitorilor se reunește la Vincent și Sophie acasă. Astfel, Agnes îl reîntâlnește pe Flavian și, în decursul a trei săptămâni, cei doi tineri ajung să se căsătorească.
Odată ajunși în Londra, avem parte de multiple răsturnări de situație, de drame care riscă să-i îndepărteze unul de celălalt, mai ales când fosta logodnică a lui Flavian își face apariția.
Autoarea Mary Balogh a reușit și de data aceasta să ne arate puterea vindecătoare a dragostei, încrederea pe care o oferă că fericirea este posibilă chiar și pentru cei aspru loviți de soartă.
Cu pași mici, suntem martorii iubirii care se naște în sufletele celor doi.
O poveste încântătoare și plină de speranță!

Dagmara Pageturner

201 reviews32 followers

June 13, 2022

I don't think I've ever read a series so quickly as the Survivor's Club. Absolutely transfixed. It is exactly what I've been wanting to read. I adored Flavian's story so much. More compelling and authentic characters that we get to know deeply. Mary Balogh your writing is a gift to this world.

✨ Gramy ✨

1,382 reviews

January 6, 2022

I listened to the audible version of 'Only a Promise', written by Mary Balough, and narrated by Rebecca De Leeuw. I was grateful to have access to the series through my local, public library.

This was the second book in this series and it continues the series with a new hero and heroine. The array of unique characters of the group called 'The Survivors Club' is interspersed inside this book, But the tale is focused on Sir Benedict Harper and Samantha McKay.

In the fourth novel of New York Times bestselling author Mary Balogh's Survivors' Club series, Flavian, Viscount Ponsonby, finds salvation in the love of a most unsuspecting woman... Agnes Keeping has never been in love—and never wishes to be.

Will she agree to become his bride or will his former fiancee win back his devotion?

The stigma of the past did not mar the H.E.A.
.

four-shelf-i-really-liked-it

Miranda Davis

Author 5 books268 followers

May 27, 2016

I'm enchanted. Deftly portrayed characters whose wounds physical and emotional make them complicated, vulnerable and heroic in not so typical ways meet, marry and sort things out. This is a quiet story about a widow who fears passion and its chaos and one of the survivors' club, who struggles to reclaim his memories after healing from head wounds and fears what he cannot recall in his past. Very sweet, yet never cloying. It's a fast read, just an evening, but the sleepy-eyed viscount and the prim widow keep it interesting, touching and somehow real. Sort of ends hanging, wish there'd been more.

4-5-stars

Mei

1,881 reviews414 followers

March 18, 2015

I really don’t know how to rate this book!

The first 100 pages or so were so much drawn out that I really considered DNF, but I kept in my mind all the high ratings my friend here gave, so I forced myself to continue reading.

In those pages almost nothing happened, or better, something happened, but it was lost (to me) in all the descriptions, questions, etc.

Just an example: the daffodil painting. A lot of pages were spend on daffodils that I was yawning. But when I rethink about them I get that that was the moment where Flavian first really noticed Agnes.
But, as I said, the overflowing of descriptions just swallowed that important moment.

Maybe some like that type of writing, but I prefer more “clear” and direct way. But, again, that’s only my opinion! :)

The things got more animated when they got married, but at that moment we’re at the middle of the book!

All the best parts happen in the second part of the book and they’re really, really good!

Agnes becomes more clearheaded. She start thinking in a linear way and acting with a strenght that I wasn’t expecting from her. She admits to herself her love for Flavian and applies herself to make the best of her marriage.
I really appreciated how she acted and reacted to some very nasty things that I would not spoil for you, but I’m sure you’ll recognize if you read this book! ;)

Flavian too is better. In the first part he is in a zombi state, but after his marriage he start becoming a person. Agnes’ presence seems to be invigorating. She seems to bring him in the land of living. It was excellently done and I loved it!

Their love story after the marriage was very endearing, because they both understood that they had something very precious growing between them and I loved it!

I decided for the above reasons not to give it a 5 rating. I said to myself: I would give 2 stars to the first half, but 6 stars to the second, so 2+6=8 and 8/2=4, so 4 stars it is! :)

historical

Manda Collins

Author 35 books1,227 followers

November 9, 2014

I think this is my favorite of the Survivors Club series so far. I love the pairing of flirtatious Flavian with practical Agnes, and it was fun to watch them learn to fit into one another's lives. I predict this will become a favorite among Balogh fans and newcomers alike. I'll certainly be rereading it soon!

regency-historical

Kathleen

1,330 reviews29 followers

November 19, 2014

3.5 stars. I have only read two other books in this series. This one was good, but not tremendously compelling. I stopped reading it several times. Took frequent breaks. Even though I enjoyed it, I couldn't immerse myself fully in the evolving relationship. I didn't understand how Flavian fell so fast for Agnes. Why did he instantly feel such a sexual pull toward her? Why did he instantly find her so enchanting? This was not well developed, IMO.

Furthermore, the book sort of meanders along, with few pivotal plot points, and lots of introspection from both the hero and the heroine. The pace felt slow. I cannot put my finger on any one scene that really moved me, except the scene with Agnus, Flavian, and his loyal relatives at the London party with the malicious gossip-monger. That scene felt authentic. I liked!

In the first half of the book, the supposedly touching scenes between the Survivors' Club members failed to tug on my heart strings. No, I felt a little tug. But mostly, it was a classic case of telling me how much these wounded veterans love each other, not showing it to me.

There is a lot of sex in this book, but it's not very graphic (thank goodness) compared to some books. I couldn't feel the passion between these two. I have never felt the passion in Balogh's books. I really can't put my finger on why not. I don't like a lot of explicit graphic sex scenes, so that's not the problem. I wonder if she needs to develop a male voice more fully. Lord knows I cannot write, but I know when I read a moving love scene.

I got tired of reading Agnes's thoughts. She thinks about Flavian's masculinity a lot at the beginning, but...it felt redundant and prosaic. I liked Agnes better later in the book, when she faced the werewolves of London. At the end, I wanted to see the spiteful B getting the boot, but alas.

I liked Flavian, but at times he felt like a cardboard character, with his ever-present sleepy gaze, mocking eyebrow, hooded eyes. These expressions held Flavian at bay from me. In my view, the author portrayed his mocking face to excess. She did a better job with his stuttering.

Below are no spoilers, but a character description, courtesy of The Kind and Gracious Lady Wesley, from her review and commentary:

Heroine: Agnes Keeping is a 26- year old widow. She married at 18 and had no children with her older husband. She lives with her sister Dora, a music teacher. These sisters live in a village near Middlebury Park, the Gloucester estate where we find the stars of The Arrangement: Vincent Hunt, Lord Darleigh (blind) and his pregnant Sophia.

Hero: Flavian Arnott, Viscount Ponsonby is a wounded Waterloo vet. He stutters, has some memory loss, and repressed rage, buried in the lost memories. He is handsome, witty, charming, and aloof, but his affable exterior masks enduring scars. He inherited his title only upon the death of his beloved brother, David. Shortly thereafter, Flavian suffered grievous head injuries in the Peninsular Wars. He was brought home unable to speak or even think coherently. When his fiancée, Velma, jilts him to marry his best friend, all he can do is fly into a fit of sputtering rage. Fortunately, he was taken in by the Duke of Stanbrook and spent three years recuperating with the other members of the Survivor’s Club, but he still speaks with a stammer and suffers from memory loss, headaches, and occasional outbursts of temper.

*** Info about all books in the series and the 7 veterans (survivors), from Balogh's website, with a few additions by Lady Wesley:

These are the stories of six men and one woman, all severely wounded in one way or another during the Napoleonic Wars before ending up convalescing together at Penderris Castle in Cornwall, the home of the Duke of Stanbrook, who lost his only child (a grown son) in the war, after which his duchess took her own life, while he watched in horror.

The Proposal is the story of Hugo Emes, Lord Trentham. Hugo is dealing with what today would be called PTSD. He marries Lady Gwendolyn Muir, a secondary character in the Bedwyn series.

The Suitor, an e-novella, is the story of Julian Crabbe, the Duke of Stanbrook's nephew and heir. He marries Philippa Dean, whose parents had tried to marry her to Viscount Darleigh. (So far they have not reappeared.)

The Arrangement is Vincent, Viscount Darleigh's story. He lost his sight and hearing, and while his hearing has returned, his sight has not. When the Dean family arrives at his estate, Vincent flees rather than marry the young lady (Philippa Dean) selected by his over-protective family. During his road trip, he meets quiet, unassuming Sophia Fry and they enter into a marriage of convenience.

The Escape features Major Sir Benedict Harper's story. His legs were horribly mangled, but he determined to walk again. He marries Samantha McKay after helping her escape from her late husband's dour, autocratic family.

This book: Only Enchanting features Flavian and Agnes. See above.

Only a Promise, due out in May 2015, is Ralph, Earl of Stockwood's story. He was severely wounded during a cavalry charge moments after seeing his three best friends blown to bits. His heroine is the flame-haired Chloe Muirhead, who has troubles of her own to contend with.

Only a Kiss, finished and probably out in 2015, is Imogen Hayes, Lady Barclay's story. She is paired with Percy, Earl of Hardford, who has arrived at the age of thirty with neither a trouble nor a care in the world—though that, of course, is his problem.

Only Beloved will be the seventh and final installment, with the middle-aged Duke of Stanbrook as the hero. It hasn't been written, but MB has said that she doesn't want to match him with a younger lady, so that should be interesting.

impaired-character regency romance-historic

Emilia Redington

261 reviews11 followers

July 4, 2021

3.5☆☆☆☆

4-stars

Jacob Proffitt

2,937 reviews1,547 followers

September 21, 2015

Book four in a series you really shouldn't skip around in. And having read the previous three, you know about what to expect with this one . . . but only roughly, really. I've been wondering what Balogh would make of Flavian as he is obviously cynical and very, very guarded. I knew it'd take some doing to be true to that and still have him fall in love. Oh, and I loved that he fell for Agnes (Sophia's friend from The Arrangement).

I fell for these two singly and as a couple right from the start. Even Agnes' insta-love didn't phase me (mostly because she didn't use it as an excuse for putting up with bad behavior and Balogh didn't use it as an excuse to forgo important relationship progression). Flavian is, in many ways, more damaged than the others have been, even if that damage is far less evident. Indeed, he's fully physically healthy and capable. I was very happy to see that Balogh did so well with Flavian's purely psychological struggles and how adroitly she handled his memory issues (i.e. without making them seem merely plot devices or conveniently placed goads to action).

Fair warning that again, the story is heavily influenced by modern sensibilities, particularly with regards to Flavian's mix of PTSD and recovery from physical brain damage. I can see that Balogh has done some research so the story isn't fantastical so much as it is informed by modern notions of the brain and trauma both mental and physical. As before, I didn't mind and mention it because others might. Of course, this is the fourth book in, so you'd think readers would be aware and ready for it.

I really liked the relationship dynamic, even as I winced in advance with some of Flavian's blunders. He really is the most guarded of them so far and he does make some poor choices that I could see would end up hurting poor Agnes. Balogh turns that anxiety to good effect, however, by using it to show Flavian's growth as he not only learns what not to do but also internalizes those lessons to great effect later on. Indeed, his handling of Agnes' familial troubles was outstanding and cemented my hopes for their future as a couple.

So this is my second favorite of the series, so far. I love what Balogh has done with these survivors and look forward to the next in some anticipation.

A note about Steamy: This was on the low side of my middle range. There are three or so explicit scenes, but they're more summarized than they are explicated (and hence also on the short side). They're more remembered than they are experienced and that actually works rather well for this couple in this story. Indeed, it was an interesting choice that I think actually paid off.

romance steamy

746 reviews25 followers

September 9, 2019

I simply loved this book! Agnes is such a strong and admirable character. She comes from scandal, a boring marriage without passion, the loss of such husband, dull life with her unmarried sister and yet she is full of strength and freshness.
I love how Viscount Posonby gets tangled without realizing, how believable are the conflicts he faces and most of all, how lovely and caring and beautiful he is inside and out.
This book also develops better the side characters, and it shows how people can be manipulative, insensitive and mean. I like how his family is deceived by his former fiancée and, most of all I loved how Agnes fights for her man, stands her ground and succeeds in her happily ever after.
Great book! Can't wait to read the story of her sister Dora and the Duke of Stanbrook.

books-i-love good-stories great-stories

Sophia

Author 5 books334 followers

October 26, 2014

The Survivor's Club series is such a unique concept for a Historical Romance series. I was on-board from the beginning mostly because I'm already a long fan of the author, but also because I love it any time a book/series is connected to a military theme or characters past or present. The Survivor's Club is a band of veterans or survivors of the Napoleonic War who were brought together to heal and support each other by an older man who lost his son followed by his wife due to the war. They came to him all with different types of wounds and injuries and in their three years healing, they became closer than many families. Each book in the series takes a different survivor and tells his or her (yes, there is one lady of the group) story. This time it's Flavian, Lord Ponsonby's story.

This is the fourth book in the series. I suppose in a pinch it can be read out of order, but I wouldn't recommend it. There is an assumption that the previous books have been read and the reader is familiar with the Survivor Club world and its characters along with the previous stories. The inter-connections going on would probably be tedious to someone unfamiliar with the stories of the three survivors who already got their backgrounds and stories told.

If one were to be exacting with the chronological sequence of events, this story's beginning parallels one of the final scenes at the end of the last book just with the perspective changing to that of the new hero and heroine. It opens at the ball/wedding reception given by Vincent and Sophie when they come home to Vincent's family home and establish themselves in the neighborhood. The widowed Agnes Keeping and her sister live in the village and are particular friends of Sophie so they are pleased to be invited to the ball. Agnes has ordinary looks at best and is dressed in a gown that is out of fashion, but she is determined to enjoy perhaps her first and only ball. The night grows into something more when one of Vince's friends, the handsome, stylish Lord Ponsonby requests her for the first dance and later for a waltz. They get on well even through his flirting kindness, but an unexpected connection happens while Flavian whirls Agnes around the ballroom floor. He calls her enchanting, but then he is gone and she is left with her warm feelings for him slowly diminishing into a pleasant warm memory. Until he comes back and stirs her up again.

Flavian puts a smiling light manner on to hide the pain and frustration below the surface. He has physically healed from his head injury, but he still experiences debilitating headaches and has blanks in his memory. Some things he remembers all too clearly. He remembers ditching his dying brother to go to a ball and then leave to go back to the front and having David die the next day. But why did he do that? He remembers when he came back wounded and still out of his mind from his injuries and his fiancee announced that she will always love him, but now she is marrying his best friend who never did come to see him and Flavian never went to see him before he died with stuff left unresolved between them. But just being in the presence of his fellow survivors during their once a year meet-up and rediscovering the enchanting Agnes whose very person makes him feel safe and peaceful, relieves him some of that. That is until his mother sends a letter happily informing him that his former fiancee is now free of mourning and back home with her family right next door to his. Flavian's feelings are mixed, but on one thing he is certain to home he will not be returning for Easter. He is also suddenly very certain that he wants to marry the sensible, steady Agnes and he will use all his wiles to persuade her. He doesn't believe in love, but neither does she right? He'll figure out how to tell her about the rest later.

Hmmm, so this one is set at Middlebury Park in Gloucestershire Viscount Darnley's family seat. The countryside is bucolic and simple. The book's pace takes its tone from the setting and meander's its way along for some time too. It establishes who everyone is and their backgrounds and connections and proceeds with a gentle romancing of sort between Flavian and Agnes. Both of them have serious hang-ups about relationships due to their pasts so it really is slow going until Flav shakes things up a bit and blurts out a marriage proposal that takes them both by surprise. Honestly, up until this point, I'm pretty sure only a big fan of the series is going to be interested in the long build up through the Survivor Club reunion and tolerate it. Not to say that I was bored as I am a fan. I totally love the Survivors and the wives and I loved the interactions. For me, it wasn't the reunion that had me impatient, but I wanted some thing to happen between Flav and Agnes long before it did. And I mean anything- highway robbers, scandal, whatever just something other than Agnes of the tight governess lips trying to convince herself that her bland life was just perfectly perfect and Flavian trying to convince her that there is nothing wrong with living a little. Flavian cracked me up several times especially when he took to shocking Agnes just to trick a response from her

It wasn't until this interesting marital pair gets to London that the story took off and the fun began. Between Flavian's secrets and flawed memory along with a truly conniving witch, I had all the excitement I could want from the story. Wowsers, Agnes got a trial by fire as her first days as Viscountess Ponsonby took place. I was a bit unsure of dour, disapproving Agnes who is terrified to live life with passion in it, but that all changed when she set her chin and took on Flav's family, Flavian, his ex, Flavian again and the Ton in that order. Flavian got so much more than he bargained for and probably deserved at first. I truly felt sorry for him and he was doing the best he could, but he really knew how to get himself in the dog house without much effort.
"Oh you are not going to get off that lightly," she said. "It is to be a marriage forever, Flavian. You married me. It does not matter why you did it. You married me and you will jolly well live up to that commitment. I will not allow you not to. And I married you. It does not matter why I did it. For better or worse, we are married. People marry for all sorts of reasons. It is not those that matter. It is what they do with their marriages that counts. We are going to make this a good marriage. Both of us." p. 288, Agnes from Only Enchanting.

And that passion that Agnes was scared to feel? Not a problem between these two. They set the sheets on fire though most of their encounters weren't detailed out. The reader gets the idea and gets to fill in the blanks with their own imagination. They were so good together and good for each other once they ironed out their issues.
"Agnes," he said. "Were you waiting for me there? At Middlebury? Were you always waiting for me? And was I always waiting to meet you?"p. 344, Flavian from Only Enchanting

A few things that really struck me were that I appreciated that Flavian's war wounds were mostly the kind that people couldn't see. His traumatic head injury left him without the power of speech when he was first recovering and his frustration and anger left him violent. He worked hard to get back his speech and control that added anger he came home with. Later he learned that he had forgotten bits and pieces of his past so he has to go around fearful and wondering what he forgot because he doesn't know until he is confronted with evidence that he forgot something. Reminded me to keep this in mind personally about people bearing scars that aren't visible.

Another thing was that Agnes is the product of divorced parents which was a serious, monster big deal back then and it taints her in the eyes of society. Not to mention the scars of being abandoned by her mother and not knowing if she is even legitimate. Interesting dynamic for the heroine.

I really only had one niggle beyond the pacing of the first half of the book. Little miss villain never really got a true comeuppance. Call me bloodthirsty, but I totally would have been good with seeing her pay in a painful, public way for the lies and the greedy, malicious intent behind them that hurt and ruined not just Flav and Agnes, but Flav's brother and Flav's best friend. She was a horrid woman and I truly hated on her.

Ralph is the next survivor and I look forward to his story. And at some point, I really need to go back and get Hugo's story. He's so larger than life in each of his scene appearances.

To wrap up, the end was a good recovery, the characters were engaging as was their romance. I would recommend the series for Historical Romance lovers who don't mind the plot to take its time developing and who like things more at the sweet end of the romance spectrum though there is a touch of spice.

My thanks to Penguin and Net Galley for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

historical-romance miltary-romance-contemp-fut-hist net-galley-reads

Dorine

600 reviews31 followers

October 28, 2014

A Recommended Read! Will also be posted at TBRMountainRange.com with other Recommended Reads.

Enchanting aptly describes Mary Balogh's newest release in the SURVIVORS' CLUB series, ONLY ENCHANTING. It may be Flavian's, Viscount Ponsonby's, impression of Agnes Keeping when he first meets her, but I was just as enchanted with Flavian and his interaction with Agnes throughout this beautifully written novel. Author Mary Balogh made me laugh within the first few pages and I knew at that moment that this was a book to savor. What great characterization—so entertaining!

At twenty-six, Agnes Keeping had already been abandoned by her mother as a child, married and widowed, and now lives a quiet life with her elder sister, Dora Debbins, in a small cottage in Gloucestershire. Agnes' dearest friend is the newly married Sophia, wife of Viscount Darleigh, who has invited the sisters to a ball at their mansion, Middlebury Park. The ball was to be a rendition of a harvest ball years past but it is also a reception for the newly married couple who had done so quietly without much fuss. This first ball for Agnes is where she falls in love or lust; she's not really sure which emotion stands out more, but neither are what she envisioned for herself.

Viscount Ponsonby, known by his closest friends as Flavian "Flave" Arnott, has recovered as much as possible, or more so than expected, from his time at war. As one of the seven Survivors' Club members, he looks forward to their annual gathering at Penderris Hall. This year their meeting has been unanimously agreed upon to be moved to Middlebury Park rather than Penderris Hall, as his dear friend Viscount Darleigh, who is blind, doesn't want to leave his wife so soon after she gave birth to their son. Flavian still struggles with words and memory, so although he recognizes the woman he met at the ball months ago, when he encounters her again on the way to the Survivors' Club meeting, he can't for the life of him remember her name. He does remember he thought her to be enchanting but why that word, he can't imagine.

This is the first novel I've read by author Mary Balogh and it's easy to recognize why her books are so popular. I was completely mesmerized by chapter one and laughed immediately at the sisters' perception of the ball, the attendees and most especially, Viscount Ponsonby. Flavian's mocking eyebrow, hooded eyes and his rogue way of posturing, while his slight stutter seems to be his only fault, struck my funny bone from the very beginning.

Agnes Keeping has Flavian's measure right from the start, and her sense of humor, as well as her heart, is a joy to witness as these two soon-to-be-lovers banter their way to marriage. I laughed a lot but also there was such deep emotion locked away inside each of them that was evenly distributed throughout their story. It's not an easy journey but what they learn along the way makes the reader feel as if this couple will have a long lasting love.

It's rare to find an author who can pull me in within a few paragraphs and make me feel the ambiance of this era in history, but also make me laugh at the sensibility of those times as well. Mary Balogh has a keen eye for mannerisms which make her characters come alive, sometimes with imperfections that stand out in glorious hues.

As book four in the SURVIVORS' CLUB series, ONLY ENCHANTING easily reads as a standalone, but if you're anything like me, you'll want to repeat the experience by gathering up the rest of the series for a marathon. I wasn't confused while I read, I just felt left out by not having read what seems like a thoroughly enjoyable series about healing after being at war. Each of the Survivors' Club members were injured in some way so their camaraderie and care with each other is endearing. I can't wait to know the rest of their stories after reading this one.

ONLY ENCHANTING is captivating and delightful, full of humor, forgiveness and love, exactly what a great romance should be. A Recommended Read!

Reviewed by Dorine, courtesy of Romance Junkies.

favorites historical wounded-heroes

Wendy

269 reviews125 followers

September 30, 2015

Only Enchanting...another winner, this series just gets better. Mary Balogh's years of experience shows, but instead of running out of ideas her novels just get richer, more empathetic and entrancing. How has she managed to come up with the diversity shown in this series alone? Number four in the series and each story is different, each character endearing, charismatic and loveable and definitely worthy of his (the men so far) happy ever after.

This story is Flavian's, Viscount Ponsonby. Rich, bored, cynical, handsome, he is nevertheless a very unhappy and unfulfilled man. Enter plain...at least on first sight...Agnes Keeping, widowed and virtuous. She believes passion and love have no place in marriage, in spite of this, at the ball given by her friend, Sophia, wife of Vincent, Lord Darleigh a fellow survivor, she is completely captivated by Flavian after dancing with him on two occasions. He on the other hand prepares himself to be charming but bored, he is instead enchanted, by this no frills, sweet young widow with a sense of humour and no guile.

Flavian has suffered devastating injuries in the Napoleonic wars and is rescued in the nick of time and carried off to the home in Cornwall of George, Duke of Stanbrook where his terrible head injuries can heal in the company of others with horrific injuries of their own. The Survivors Club becomes the salvation for all seven members, although supporting each other through the healing process, they cannot save each other once they finally face the world again, forever changed to their families and loved ones. Flavian's life threatening head wounds have healed, at least on the outside but he still suffers from memory loss, severe headaches and temper outbursts brought on by frustration at his inability to remember, huge chunks hovering just out of range, tantalisingly close. He knows something devastating happened, but can't catch it from his subconscious. It is somehow all wrapped up with his ex fiancé Velma, who ended their betrothal on his return from the wars, to all intents and purposes a madman. Now that he is, at least on the surface, recovered, Velma would like to resume their relationship as she is recently widowed, both her parents and his family support the match. Flavian has other ideas.

Mrs Agnes Keeping is the object of Flavian's attention, he can't explain to himself why he must marry her, he just knows she makes him feel safe. Eventually he wears down her misgivings and they marry by special license. Agnes is, against her better judgement, madly and deeply in love with Flavian, they enjoy a close and loving relationship until she discovers his previous relationship, and feels he has married her simply to wreak revenge on his ex fiancé Velma. Her gut reaction is to leave him, Flavian has discovered that Agnes is much more to him than 'safe' and does all in his power to keep her by his side.

Agnes decides to stay and with her love and care, slowly helps Flavian to unlock the secrets of his mind, he in turn helps her to face her own demons, those same demons who insist that passion has no place in marriage.

Mary Balough has crafted another fabulous page turner from her talented pen. The characters of the Survivors Club are in attendance, though slowly finding peace and love. I'd love to see George settle down, he the saviour of this group of damaged human beings, offering them help and refuge, and definitely should find his own HEA. I reckon it will be Agnes's elder sister Dora, who captures George's heart, I hope so. Again for pure entertainment value and originality...5 stars.

Julie

4,026 reviews58.9k followers

October 21, 2015

Only Enchanting by Mary Balogh is a 2014 Signet Publication.

This the fourth book in the Survivor's Club series.

Flavian, Viscount Ponsonby, suffered a brain injury which cost him his fiance' who quite abruptly married one of his oldest friends. Now, several years later, it seems the lady is a widow, and Flavian feels some guilt about having kept his distance from the couple all this time. But, the thought comes to mind that it could be his chance to rekindle the romance with the lady who once deserted him.

However, when Flavian meets Sophia's friend Agnes, he finds himself drawn to her. She is not like any lady he has ever spent time with. She is calm, sensible, and reliable. She makes him feel safe, and he wants her in his life. But, Agnes is not so sure that's a good idea for either of them. However, once he finally convinces her to marry him, she learns she is a pawn and that her husband is only using her. Is the marriage doomed or can Flavian convince his new wife that he loves her and only her?

This is a tender love story that will touch your heart. Mary Balogh is a master at writing Regency period romance, and this book is a solid example of her skills. I liked the mature characters, and although poor Flavian still has trouble with his memory and doesn't always say things in the most eloquent of ways, he is simply divine and so very charming, in spite of himself.

Agnes is a woman terrified of her own inner passions, and prefers an orderly, dependable, but predictable life. However, meeting Flavian ensures her of a life that will be none of those things. If Flavian can prove his love for Agnes, she will find her husband to be everything she needs and much, much more.

The story is a little understated at times, with the passion between the couple hanging in the atmosphere and not necessarily acted upon like two hormonal teens, but it's there and it's palpable. The tone is light, the banter is witty and sharp, and utterly delightful. This couple was most assuredly destined to be together and although they remain pragmatic about effusive happy ever afters, we all know they finally got theirs.

4 stars.

e-book historical-romance overdrive

Tin

340 reviews108 followers

November 13, 2014

When I first met Flavian in Hugo's book, I wondered what happened to him and why he was part of The Survivors' Club because he didn't seem to belong there. The rest of the members (except for Flavian and Imogen) were clearly/visibly injured by the war: Benedict is crippled, Vincent is blind, Ralph is scarred, but Flavian only has his stutter -- and, even in the previous books, he didn't seem to have been affected that much by his experiences because he was jolly and light-hearted -- always teasing Vincent and his musical aspirations.

Now that I've read Flavian's story, I wonder how he could've survived what had happened to him: getting shot in the head, then falling off his horse (and landing on his hand) and then getting trampled. It is a miracle that the only reminder/remainder from his injuries is a stutter and some gaps in his memory. One of the greatest gaps in his memory is the circumstances of his brother's death, his relationship with Velma Frome, and his return to the Peninsula, which resulted in his devastating and near-life-ending injury.

In most stories, the key to the soul of a damaged/tortured hero is to look at those moments that shaped his character and personality -- but, in Flavian's case, I was a bit worried and afraid to unravel him. It is clear that he has been to hell and back, so why ask that he revisit it? Why dredge up all those painful memories and run the risk of shattering him? The state of his memory is both a blessing and a curse, and we secretly hope, for our hero's sake, that he has forgotten the worst of his ordeal.

As more and more members of The Survivors' Club find love and a reason to move forward in their lives, Flavian slowly considers his next move and it seems that the stars are finally aligning in Flavian's favour: Velma Frome (now the widowed Lady Hazeltine) is coming out of her year of mourning and their families are eager to get them "reacquainted", but Flavian isn't sure this is what he wants in his life right now and is grateful for the short respite (annual meeting) with his friends at Middlebury Park, Vincent's estate. It is the same mistake the people in Flavian's life make: they assume that the war is over, that he has survived, and that he has recovered, and that all is well. But, like the other members of The Survivors' Club, Flavian knows that he is still fighting a battle (a greater one inside of him) and that all is not well. We see in their stories the many different shades of guilt, of loss, of fear, of shame, etc -- but, in those same instances, we see the radiance of hope and determination.

He meets Agnes at Middleburg Park (for a second time) and it's very telling that he can remember some details about her, considering that they had only spoken briefly and shared two dances a few months ago. Agnes Keeping seems unassuming upon first glance: a proper widow now living with her spinster older sister in a small, quiet, provincial town -- there doesn't seem to be much to her story, but Mary Balogh shows us that we are mistaken in our assumptions. Agnes is a woman of surprising depth and passion. My favourite scene of Agnes is of the daffodils, and how she wasn't satisfied with her already-wonderful painting of the daffodils and had decided to view the daffodils from a different point of view.

...she knew she was seeing only half the picture and maybe not even that much. For the trumpets of the daffodils were lifted to the sky. The petals about them faced upward. If the flowers could see, as in a sense she supposed they could, then it was the sky, rather than the grass beneath them, upon which they gazed. She, on the other hand, was looking down upon the flowers and the grass.She turned her face upward to see that the sky was pure blue, with not a cloud in sight. But now, of course, she could no longer see the daffodils.
- Chapter 3

Flavian needed someone like Agnes, someone who has been tested and strengthened by her own life experiences -- someone who views the world a little bit differently because of those experiences.

This morning she had been wearing a simple cotton dress and no bonnet. Her hair had been caught back in a plain knot at her neck. Her posture had been prim and self-contained, her expression placid. He had tried to tell himself that she was quite without sexual appeal, that he must be very bored indeed out here in the country if he was weaving fantasies about a plain, prim, virtuous widow.

Except that he was not bored. ...

...

And she was not plain. Or prim. And if she was virtuous -- and he did not doubt she was -- she was also full to the brim of repressed sexuality.
- Chapter 6

And Agnes needs someone like Flavian. Agnes is so afraid to step beyond her comfort zone, because she is afraid to get hurt or be betrayed. Passion is Agnes's problem. She has never experienced it and doesn't want to, so she made a sensible (but passionless) first marriage. Her mother surrendered to her passions and it destroyed their family and Agnes doesn't want that to happen to her, which is why Agnes needs someone like Flavian, who has been to the breaking limits of life, felt the most extreme of all emotions, embraced madness and betrayal and helplessness, and survived.

"You fear passion?" he asked her.

"Because it is uncontrolled," she cried. "Because it is selfish. Because it hurts -- other people if not oneself. I do not want passion. I do not want uncertainty. U do not want you yelling at me. Worse than that, I do not want me yelling back. I cannot stand it. I cannot stand this."
- Chapter 11

Daffodils represent the opportunity that each one presents to the other. As time passes, the daffodils will fade and wither and give way to the changing seasons -- Agnes only has this chance to paint these flowers properly. And Flavian only has this chance to be with Agnes. Flavian knows that, when he leaves Middlebury Park, he will have to accede to his family's wishes and end up with Velma. It might seem that this is what he had wanted and waited for all these years, but Flavian cannot shake the doubts and questions that loom in his mind. It's truly amazing how memory is both fragile and incredibly resilient -- how it can be lost and recreated, and how it can be recovered and etched forever in our memories.

The flirtation and courtship comprise a huge chunk of this book, but there's a reason for it: as the blurb mentions, there are doubts about Flavian's motives for pursuing Agnes. Is it petty revenge against Velma? Is it rebellion against his family's expectations? It's difficult to discuss this part without spoiling it, and I've been sitting and writing this review for three days now, trying to figure out a way to talk about the latter part of the story, but I can't.

I've mentioned in my other reviews of Mary Balogh's books, I am in absolute awe of her talent. Her stories unfold so naturally, like the petals of a flower (a daffodil, perhaps? ^_^) and continue to delight days after you have reached the end and put the book down. There really is so much more to say about how amazing this book is, but I will leave it with this: this story promises enchantment, and it delivers. ^_^

2014

Shabby Girl ~ aka Lady Victoria

538 reviews78 followers

August 28, 2015

This series, The Survivors Club, really shows why I love Mary Balogh as one of my most favourite authors and why her books are auto buys for me. This book, plus the previous two really are the most lovely, wonderful books.

This one is about Agnes and Flavian. You could ask, and I do, how I could love a couple with names such as that, and I do wonder why this author really does sometimes pick the most awful names, but I loved these characters anyway. Flavian is the muddle headed hero injured in the war who has recovered with certain problems, such as loss of memory and a stutter, and Agnes really is the most unromantic heroine you could ever find, but she is a very practical woman who I liked. But I so loved their story, and it was such an unexpected one. It certainly kept me glued to the pages. The hero’s marriage proposal really made me laugh, as did other parts of the book. I really liked the hero, he was different for sure, but I finished this book yesterday and today whenever I think of him I either laugh or have a smile on my face. He is very endearing.

I was going to give this book four stars for the first half, for whilst I like it a lot, it didn't love it, but I knew by the end I would give it five stars. I really did love this book in the end. This couple don't have what I'd call a really passionate romance, like the last two books, but I did believe their gradual love as the story went on. The heroine fell passionately in love with the hero on first meeting at a ball six months earlier (quite profound as she is not a frivolous woman at all). The hero I think took his time, but was smitten for some reason at the same ball, and took his time to get there over the length of the book, quite a healthy and believable scenario for these two. I really do believe that this couple will both grow in affection for each other and will have an abiding love for their whole lives. There isn't any action in this book, it's a character driven romance, and is just the type of thing I love. There are misunderstandings which are inevitable with this hero, I think, and I'm still smiling when I think of him, but they are sorted in good time with the characters talking to each other.

I was just reading on Balogh’s website that she has already written the next two books, Ralph next and then Imogen, and actually has the heroine in mind for the last of the survivors to fall in love, George, the Duke, but she hasn’t written it yet. I am hoping it is a character we already know and that I know who she might be, so I’ll look forward to seeing if we agree who she has in mind. I so hope it’s who I think it might be!

This book is not for people who want action and fast pace, it's a character driven, slow paced, lovely romance written by a very, very good writer ... the best I think.

ETA: 28/08/15 - I WAS RIGHT! DORA for George! Woohoo!!

five-star-books top-100-fave-books

Olga Godim

Author 12 books71 followers

September 28, 2015

In this Regency romance, Flavian, Viscount Ponsonby, meets a woman. That’s how all romance novels start, but Mary Balogh explores the topic from a different angle in her Survivors Club series. All the members of the Club were severely injured in the Napoleonic wars. It took them years to heal, but all of them still bear scars, mental and physical. Now, years later, all of them found inner strength to move on, to build a new life. To find love. Flavian is one of the Survivors.
He suffered head injuries in the war, and the brain damage he sustained on the battlefield affects his whole existence. Headaches, inexplicable urges for violence, and memory lapses plague him. His symptoms sometimes resemble the beginning of schizophrenia, and it wasn’t nice to read about his inner struggles. That’s why the first third of the book was unpleasant for me: I don’t like reading about mental illness. If some chapters were not written from the female protagonist’s POV, I’d probably have abandoned the book.
Agnes is a young widow, prim and quiet. She was fond of her husband while he lived but she didn’t love him. She doesn’t trust passion or love to bring happiness. In her experience, passions often breed disasters. She resists Flavian mad advances, but his suave manners and easy charm touch the hidden places in her heart, places she didn’t know about. His raw masculinity ignites her body. She can’t resist for long.
These two damaged people, drawn to each other through chance and circumstance, build a family together, and the deeper I immersed myself in their quiescent adventures the more I liked it. The last half of the book was almost perfect.

historical romance

2,894 reviews43 followers

April 27, 2022

Angsty H, suffering from war wounds and the loss of his brother. The h is calm, not at all sweet, she's rather prickly, perhaps because she fell in love with the H at first meeting. All he knows is that she makes him feel safe. There is a mystery as to what caused him to not feel safe. She was such a strong person, willing to fight for him as he fell even deeper in love with her. I really liked this couple.

loved-it

Cee (The Mistress Case)

253 reviews161 followers

August 17, 2015

The first half wasn't for me. The second half was so much better. I'm looking forward to checking out the rest of the series :)

Jaclyn

783 reviews167 followers

October 29, 2014

Only Enchanting is the fourth installment in Mary Balogh’s amazing Survivor’s Club series. Each time I finish one of Balogh’s historical, I close the book thinking damn this woman can write. Balogh stands out in the historical romance genre in that she creates such fully realized characters that are often imperfect, and deeply emotional. What I like about Balogh’s romances is that I find them wholly realistic. The hero and heroine are capable of petty thoughts towards each other, and can be spiteful in their anger, but each time I read these scenes they never come off as a token nod to resistance to romance; rather, I can imagine anyone in a relationship thinking these things. Balogh’s romances tend to be subdued, but it’s the relationships that she creates that continually stand out in her novels. Only Enchanting is no exception.

Mrs. Agnes Keeting is a widow at twenty-six. She wasn’t in love with her husband, who died three years ago, but she misses that contentment. Since coming to live with her older sister, she has found happiness, but she is rocked back on her heels when she meets Flavian, Viscount Ponsonby, when he visits his friend Viscount Darleigh. She has no idea what to do with these new found feelings that she’s never experienced before; she does not want to feel this out of control. But, Agnes is tempted to take a risk and is convinced by Flavian to marry him.

For his part, Flavian is attracted to Agnes. He does not love Agnes, but he wants to marry her to “be safe.” It’s an odd thing to characterize this as a motivation to marry, and Flavian himself is not sure what he means by it. On the surface, he wants to avoid the matchmaking schemes of his mother and his former fiancé, Lady Hazeltine, and by marrying Agnes he escapes a marriage he does not want and gets revenge on the woman that jilted him when he came back wounded from the war. However, Flavian’s emotions go much deeper than this. In the war he was shot in the head and it has taken a long time for him to recover, he still cannot speak without a stutter and there are huge gaps in his memory. He’s not happy and often feels angry, but with Agnes he does feel different and he wants to continue feeling that way, that feeling of safety, and the only want to do that is through marriage.

This somewhat hasty marriage has promise, at least until Agnes learns that the husband she loves has apparently married her to revenge himself on his former fiancé. Hurt, Agnes and Flavian have to deepen the foundation of their relationship if there’s any hope of their marriage surviving.

Only Enchanting is an extremely touching romance. As usual with Balogh, her narrative arc goes beyond the couple "getting together" and explores what happens after the happily-ever-after, something that intrigues me as an avid romance reader. Only Enchanting is more than the build up to two people finally recognizing their feelings for one another, it’s a depiction of their relationship, along with all the struggles and feelings that come up along the way. One particular example of this, is when Flavian admits to feeling somewhat resentful towards Agnes:

Suddenly, and quite unfairly, he resented her. And this place and the change of venue this year. Nothing like this ever happened at Penderris (p. 111).

I don’t think these types of emotions are often acknowledged in enough romances. It seems obvious the people are going to have these fleeting emotions in relationships, and I love that it is acknowledged here, and in many of Balogh’s other romances. I think Flavian's fleeting resentment is unheroic, but it's utterly understandable.

I also love Agnes as a character. She was strong and vulnerable, and refreshingly un-dramatic. When she first learns about Flavian’s revenge she is furious and lashes out:

"I do not ever know who you are," she said.

"But you knew I was s-somebody," he said. "Somebody you w-wanted to know. Somebody you wanted to spend a l-lifetime getting to know. It was not just lust."

"More fool me, then," she said. "There was nobody worth knowing inside that beautiful body after all, was there?" (p. 269)

Her anger is justified, but what I love is that she also moves beyond her anger; she has more complex emotions. Agnes wants to move past Flavian's betrayal, and she wants to make their marriage work:

One more week. To piece together a marriage. Or to bring it to an end in a lifelong separation. But the sense of defeat in that last thought filled her with sudden anger.

She would be...Oh, what was the very worst word she could think of? She would be damned before she would give up her marriage after two weeks just because Flavian had once loved a beautiful woman who had chosen spite over stoical dignity when he had married her. She would be...Well, she would be double damned.

So there!

He wanted to give their marriage a chance.

Well, then. So did she. More than a chance. She was going to make a marriage of what they had. See if she didn't (p. 279).

Again, I can’t help but feel that this makes Only Enchanting something more in the romance genre. Steam is not coming off the pages, but I felt there was something more important going on here than your run of the mill romance (which I also adore). Balgoh’s formula for a romance depends on her characters having maturity and consideration, and Agnes’ willingness to move forward from betrayal show this.

Ultimately, Only Enchanting is an absolutely wonderful read, and I argue that is a read that those outside the romance genre would also be interested in. Any reader that is driven to more emotional reads will enjoy Only Enchanting. It’s more than a basic happily ever after, it’s what comes next. And I cannot wait to see what’s next in this series.

Originally published with similar reads at The Book Adventures.

*Review copy provided by the publisher via NetGalley.

arc class-difference historical-romance

Mary

559 reviews6 followers

October 30, 2014

A sweet but anticlimactic book

I really like most of Mary Balogh's books. Her characters are varied and interesting, their emotions and choices complex, and the working out of whatever plot conflicts and dangers are dependably welldone. This book, however, simply meandered to an end. The two leads started off with a lot of possibility, especially Agnes, but they seemed more to fall into relationship without very much reason offered for why they did. And when Velma,the villainess of the piece, tried to turn Agnes against her new husband, Florian and Agnes had little difficulty remaining married, again with little reason shown. I'd expected Velma to show up again before the end of the book, ready to make more and worse trouble, but that was it, she never reappeared, and the scandal she tried to stir up just petered out somehow. It was just all too easy, and I never felt much connection with Florian, despite the excellent setup Balogh gave his character and his past tragedies. At one point early in the book, Agnes describes Florian as a man who hides behind a mask of indifference and she wonders what it would be like to delve deeper and deeper until she uncovered the man himself. I wish this book had taken us there with her, rather than presenting us with a fait accompli, as if they'd somehow discovered the truth of one another and built a relationship without our noticing.

Misfit

1,637 reviews278 followers

December 31, 2014

Lovely book, but this Amazon review pretty much sums up my feelings. Go and give her a helpful vote. My only quibbles are 1) the heavy handed use of words in italics and I so wished the 'baddie' of the piece would have received a good comeuppance. Can't have everything.

Kindle copy obtained via library loan.

Barbara Rogers

1,507 reviews141 followers

August 14, 2015

So far, I've loved ALL do the Survivors' Club books. This is #4. I like the hero and I like learning more about what his injuries were and how he copes with those. I also liked the heroine -- who, of course -- is also wounded inside. What I didn't like was that the 'villain' in the book never got her come-upance. While she certainly wasn't the worst of villains, she had a long history of doing harm to others.

Displaying 1 - 30 of 780 reviews

Ratings & Reviews for

Only Enchanting

Mary Balogh

Loading...

Loading...