i really wanted to love this cookbook - i knew it wasn’t going to be another salt, fat, acid, heat, and i was perfectly fine with that - but the mix and match, improv styles of so many of these recipes just limits the utility of it for me.
nosrat talks a lot in the introduction about her struggle with the idea of writing a book of recipes when she doesn’t want cooks to have to rely on recipes, and to move beyond the recipe’s “mindless repetition”. as a result, the book is formatted so there are many smaller, explicitly written recipes, paired with ideas of how to combine them with ingredients or other recipes into larger dishes. this works better for some meal types than others - the salad dressings, each providing ideas for three different loosely described slaw/salad/veg/bowl pairings, work rather well (though not even samin nosrat can sell me on aquafaba). the section on boiling/roasting/sautéing vegetables (which had almost no distinct, vegetable-specific directions) on the other hand, did nothing for me.
i respect nosrat’s stance on not relying on recipe following, but i also think it misses the core draw of a recipe for people who are time limited, good but not great home cooks like myself: recipes are easy. i don’t have so much time or money that i want to spend a bunch of both trying to combine multiple different smaller recipes (or vague combination suggestions) in order to create one normal meal - especially when that meal is of middling quality because i don’t have a feel for the proportions or preparations involved yet. maybe i’m just a lazy cook who wants to think less and follow instructions more, and i don’t particularly want to “approach my everyday cooking as ritual” to sanctify it and infuse it with meaning (especially after a long shift), but the style of this cookbook just didn’t work for me.
i’d give it three and a half stars, rounded up to four for the obvious care and love put into it. it really is a beautiful and well-written book (though i wish the pictures had captions so you could identify dishes), and i’m really loving a couple of the smaller recipes from it. it’s just a bit too involved and complicated to be useful to my life.