This latest installment in the Jake Cashen series was among my favorites. This novel leans heavily into themes of family and whether it’s defined by blood or emotional bonds.
This plot begins decades earlier with a kidnapping. Two years later, the boy’s remains are found and the case is closed. In the present, the now-elderly mother of the missing child receives a letter telling her the facts were manipulated to hide the crimes and her child had not only lived but thrived. Jake’s in a no-win situation. He doesn’t want to give the woman false hope. Doesn’t want to cast doubt on the original officer’s investigative abilities (a man who is both friend and mentor to him). And if the letter is right, he doesn’t want to destroy the life of the boy—now man—who apparently overcame the trauma of his abduction to live a happy life.
What Jake discovers during his investigation is shocking. Threads of so many different families are woven together into a knotted mess that eventually makes a complex yet beautiful tapestry.
And more than one romance starts to bloom. (What a wonderful side plot in a novel where everyone’s motivations are inspired by love, even when expressed in toxic ways.)
I would have loved to have seen more of Gemma and Max, and I think the ending was a little rushed, but all told, this was one of the best of the series. 4.5 stars.