Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
新たな魔女探しをはじめた山田の前に、突如あらわれた謎のパンクコンビ・ナンシー&シド!! 山田のコピー能力について探っていた様子のナンシーは、質問に答えなければ「アンタの記憶を消す」と脅迫する。こいつはもしかして‥‥!!? さらに、新たな魔女・萌黄ことりの存在が確認される! その能力は彼女のクラス全員に及んでいるというが、その能力の正体とは!? 魅惑的な能力に、山田がついに敗北‥‥!?

192 pages, Paperback

First published July 17, 2014

8 people are currently reading
94 people want to read

About the author

Miki Yoshikawa

211 books70 followers
Also known as 吉河美希.

吉河 美希(よしかわ みき、1982年 - )は、日本の漫画家。女性。A型。天秤座。

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
81 (29%)
4 stars
116 (42%)
3 stars
70 (25%)
2 stars
4 (1%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
Profile Image for Mark.
2,810 reviews272 followers
January 3, 2020
3.5 stars, rounded up because this series, for its faults, is always a fun read. The two biggest problems here are the sprawling cast and the redundancy of the plot.

The whole big climax to the first arc with Shiraishi and Yamada getting together is kind of brushed aside - the story clearly has no idea what to do with half the cast, but sidelining Shiraishi in particular seems glaring.

And plot permutations aside, the story is constantly recycling the witch concept (if the end of this volume is to be believed, the extent of this is approaching ludicrousness). It definitely feels like they said what they had to say and then decided to say it again.

Despite that, spending time with the cast again in this volume was a lot of fun. The comedy is usually pretty good, the stories are interesting, the art is always a treat. Sid & Nancy make great foils for Yamada and the arc in the first of this volume is interesting. The second one was fun too; it’s easy to overlook the flaws when that’s the case.
Profile Image for Vanessa Kay.
916 reviews22 followers
December 28, 2019
When I first saw the anime adaptation of this series, I know I'm going to read its manga soon. And the time has come, haha.

It's pretty obvious that I love the anime, and my! I couldn't be happier because I love the manga as well. The drawing were so good and those facial expressions were hilarious!

I also love the story line, I know witches idea can be cliche, but I love how the author made this story different. Why it was different? You've got to find it out for yourselves ;)

It was doing pretty good actually until after the part of the first ceremony. I think they just added a twist to it to make it longer and I'm not specially a fan of those lots of memory lost moments. But oh well, the author redeem herself because of that very cute HEA! What more could you wish for eh?
Profile Image for Drine Psylook.
1,303 reviews7 followers
December 24, 2019
Je ne me suis pas ennuyée même si je n’aime pas trop le personnage de Kotori, par contre j’ai bien rigolé avec Chikushi. J’apprécie également le duo Nancy-Sid et je me demande ce qu’ils vont devenir surtout après la demande finale de Miyamura.
J’ai beaucoup aimé ce treizième tome et ça me motive pour lire la suite.
https://psylook.kimengumi.fr/2019/12/...
Profile Image for Cassandra.
2,551 reviews22 followers
January 25, 2025
This is kind of a mess now and there are doooo many characters and not enough cute romance for me in this volume. But it is ALWAYS fun. I laughed several times from the ridiculousness of the story. It is still sting with light pervert themes for some reason (always surprised this is written by a woman) but I’m loving this ride.
Profile Image for AsianMerr.
449 reviews6 followers
November 17, 2024
Nancy is…interesting I guess, I wonder who she is and I feel like there’s a small chance they don’t explain it till way later and I won’t care anymore, the new witches are okay, also wow…14 of them now…might be oversaturating them
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for David Doel.
2,447 reviews6 followers
October 17, 2025
New witches means a lot of new characters. My favorite character is an old one, Urara Shiraishi. She is studious; I am studious. She is introverted; I am introverted. She is also humble and kind. As long as she has a major role in the story, I'll continue to like it.
Profile Image for Amara.
1,376 reviews3 followers
December 19, 2017
4,5 stars. I love the new characters, but I'm really, really missing the old gang! Especially Yamada x Shiraishi storylines.
Profile Image for elle.
427 reviews20 followers
June 28, 2019
*2.5/5 geez the story just got more confusing stop milking it (BUT THAT COVER IS BY FAR THE BEST)
Profile Image for Khari.
3,119 reviews75 followers
January 10, 2020
いや、言葉がない。

山田君はとにかくなぜ17歳の高校生の女の子がまだ人形遊びするの?変だよ。山田は妹がいるしバカだし少し分かるけど。。。女子高生はいつも人形を持って学校に通っているの?。。。。

はい、わかる、これはコメディー。だけど、それはちょっと。な?
Profile Image for Stephen Theaker.
Author 94 books63 followers
August 6, 2022
Yamada encounters some quirky new witches, making it a bit more interesting than the previous book, but I probably won't read any more of these now.
Profile Image for Utha.
824 reviews402 followers
December 3, 2017
Makin rumit~ penyihirnya ada sebelum Klub Occult berdiri~
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.