What do you think?
Rate this book
The Witch
Some secrets don't die―they wait.
When Julia Barlow loses her job and her apartment, she has nowhere left to go but Pemberton, her family's sprawling seventeenth-century estate in rural Massachusetts. Officially, she's there to check in on her aging grandmother. Unofficially, she's hoping the old house will give her a place to disappear.
Instead, Pemberton begins to unravel her.
Every night, the grandfather clock stops at exactly 3:41 a.m. The lights flicker without warning. And a disembodied voice cries for help outside Julia's bedroom door.
As Julia digs into the house's dark history, she uncovers the story of a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692―and realizes the past may not be finished with Pemberton yet. When decades of family lies begin to surface, Julia must confront a terrifying truth: Pemberton may be haunted by women whose voices refuse to stay silent.
From #1 New York Times bestselling author Freida McFadden comes The Witch, a chilling, twist-filled thriller about secrets―those we inherit, those we bury, and those people will burn to keep silent.
When Julia Barlow loses her job and her apartment, she has nowhere left to go but Pemberton, her family's sprawling seventeenth-century estate in rural Massachusetts. Officially, she's there to check in on her aging grandmother. Unofficially, she's hoping the old house will give her a place to disappear.
Instead, Pemberton begins to unravel her.
Every night, the grandfather clock stops at exactly 3:41 a.m. The lights flicker without warning. And a disembodied voice cries for help outside Julia's bedroom door.
As Julia digs into the house's dark history, she uncovers the story of a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692―and realizes the past may not be finished with Pemberton yet. When decades of family lies begin to surface, Julia must confront a terrifying truth: Pemberton may be haunted by women whose voices refuse to stay silent.
From #1 New York Times bestselling author Freida McFadden comes The Witch, a chilling, twist-filled thriller about secrets―those we inherit, those we bury, and those people will burn to keep silent.
352 pages, Hardcover
First published October 6, 2026
About the author
Freida McFadden
116 books303k followers#1 New York Times, USA Today, Wall Street Journal, Publisher's Weekly, and Amazon Charts bestselling author Freida McFadden is a practicing physician specializing in brain injury who has penned multiple Kindle bestselling psychological thrillers and medical humor novels. She lives with her family and possessed cat in a centuries-old three-story home overlooking the ocean, with staircases that creak and moan with each step, and nobody could hear you if you scream. Unless you scream really loudly, maybe.
Note that I am maxed out on friends, so I apologize in advance that I can't friend anyone back!
Note that I am maxed out on friends, so I apologize in advance that I can't friend anyone back!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 13,638 reviews
October 14, 2026
Oh wow okay.
March 6, 2026
4.5⭐️- FREIDA ENTERING HER SPOOKY SEASON ERA?! 👻🍂 Because honestly, I am HERE FOR IT! 🕯️🔮
This was definitely a breath of fresh air, with all the things Freida knows how to do best, but with a slightly different flavour. I absolutely loved the spooky, gothic vibes! 🏚️🌫️🦇 Although I wouldn’t say the book was particularly scary, it had such an eerie atmosphere that made it perfect for this time of year. 🎃🖤
The writing also felt more mature, and I genuinely loved seeing a different side of Freida’s writing. ✍🏻✨ While the present-day timeline didn’t completely grab my attention, the historical timeline had my whole heart. ❤️🔥 I was so much more invested in the past, and those chapters were easily my favourite!
Did I vaguely guess some of the twists and foresee where the story was heading? Yes. 👀🔍 Did that take away from my overall enjoyment? Absolutely not! 😂🙌🏻 Sometimes the journey is just as satisfying as the destination.
And as always, Freida delivers what she does best: an addictive thriller that practically reads itself and can easily be devoured in one sitting. 📚⚡️
Freida, if this is your spooky season era, please STAY HERE. We are loving the atmosphere, the witchy vibes and this new side of your writing! 🧙🏻♀️🖤🍂
————————————
Pre-read:
At this point I’m not worried about Freida using AI… I’m starting to wonder if Freida IS the AI 🤖📖 - said whilst adding to TBR 📚
This was definitely a breath of fresh air, with all the things Freida knows how to do best, but with a slightly different flavour. I absolutely loved the spooky, gothic vibes! 🏚️🌫️🦇 Although I wouldn’t say the book was particularly scary, it had such an eerie atmosphere that made it perfect for this time of year. 🎃🖤
The writing also felt more mature, and I genuinely loved seeing a different side of Freida’s writing. ✍🏻✨ While the present-day timeline didn’t completely grab my attention, the historical timeline had my whole heart. ❤️🔥 I was so much more invested in the past, and those chapters were easily my favourite!
Did I vaguely guess some of the twists and foresee where the story was heading? Yes. 👀🔍 Did that take away from my overall enjoyment? Absolutely not! 😂🙌🏻 Sometimes the journey is just as satisfying as the destination.
And as always, Freida delivers what she does best: an addictive thriller that practically reads itself and can easily be devoured in one sitting. 📚⚡️
Freida, if this is your spooky season era, please STAY HERE. We are loving the atmosphere, the witchy vibes and this new side of your writing! 🧙🏻♀️🖤🍂
————————————
Pre-read:
At this point I’m not worried about Freida using AI… I’m starting to wonder if Freida IS the AI 🤖📖 - said whilst adding to TBR 📚
Want to Read
March 7, 2026Freida, blink twice if you need help.
October 6, 2026
Woah this might be a new Freida favorite. I might be in the minority here but I genuinely think this was much better than the Housemaid. Though, if I'm being fair, the writing style is so different here, it works brilliantly.
I believe what worked for me was the atmosphere of this book. I'm not a thriller reader, not unless I want a break from fantasy or dark romance. So the paranormal vibes, the eerie tones and grim setting is pretty much coded for me to have an immersive experience. Apart from that, if I enjoy myself, I get invested in the characters emotionally. And Freidadoesat hauntingly well here. The witch trials are a part of history every woman knows all too well. And the way it tugged at the root of my soul with so much rage and hurt, props to the writing imo.
We follow two timelines: Caroline's in 1692 and Julia's present day. And they both hold up their own. But I must say, I found Caroline's narrative more powerful than Julia's. They both carry this twinge of innocence about them but both righteous to a fault and powerful in their quiet ways. To understand them, you really have to walk with them at their pace. Apart from the two women, I really adored Jonas' character, however predictable it may be.
The ending was pretty good imo. I predicated Caroline's ending about 40% in, still satisfying to see it unravel. Though Julia's went in a manner I did not expect. I was off about a lot of things so points on taking me by surprise. Overall, perfect read for a spooky season.
~•~•~
So excited to start this one. Seems really fun and perfect for spooky season 🤭
I believe what worked for me was the atmosphere of this book. I'm not a thriller reader, not unless I want a break from fantasy or dark romance. So the paranormal vibes, the eerie tones and grim setting is pretty much coded for me to have an immersive experience. Apart from that, if I enjoy myself, I get invested in the characters emotionally. And Freidadoesat hauntingly well here. The witch trials are a part of history every woman knows all too well. And the way it tugged at the root of my soul with so much rage and hurt, props to the writing imo.
We follow two timelines: Caroline's in 1692 and Julia's present day. And they both hold up their own. But I must say, I found Caroline's narrative more powerful than Julia's. They both carry this twinge of innocence about them but both righteous to a fault and powerful in their quiet ways. To understand them, you really have to walk with them at their pace. Apart from the two women, I really adored Jonas' character, however predictable it may be.
The ending was pretty good imo. I predicated Caroline's ending about 40% in, still satisfying to see it unravel. Though Julia's went in a manner I did not expect. I was off about a lot of things so points on taking me by surprise. Overall, perfect read for a spooky season.
~•~•~
So excited to start this one. Seems really fun and perfect for spooky season 🤭
October 17, 2026
This felt like a breath of fresh air from Freida and I really enjoyed it! It reminded me of a Darcy Coates book a bit, like a popcorn/lite horror read with just the right amount of spooky, witchy vibes. Fun!
April 19, 2026
I FEAR THIS WAS A ME PROBLEM AND NOT THE BOOK
WELP… well this is a first, where I have actually not completed a Freida book in one sitting. No matter how ridiculous or outlandish I have found her books, she had that just ‘one more chapter’ poison sprinkled that I couldn’t help but continue committing to the madness.
The Witch for the first half gave me NOTHING… not a little tickle or a thrill. So, I put it down. But when I picked it back up it did start to get somewhat a little more interesting. The book is told in two timelines. One in 1692 and the other in present day. I must say I did enjoy the former more.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔BUT˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
I know I am being very picky but the language in the past chapters was so cringy. It read way to simplistic and the dialogue was not delivering how Freida probably intended it too.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔THE CHARACTERS˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
I enjoyed reading about Caroline and Julia’s character… everyone else for me just read one dimensional and ‘there’ for story purposes.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔SUPERNATURAL˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
The whole supernatural elements also landed flat for me. Listen this is not a bad book by any means I think I just wasn’t the right audience for it.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔THE TWISTS˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
Cute. Not Jaw dropping or life altering but it was good. I didn’t guess it but I wasn’t also screaming in shock when it was revealed.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔FINAL VERDICT˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
Even though not a favourite for me. I must say Freida’s writing is getting so much better. The was no repetition or an inanimate object constantly being thrown in our face! The Witch was an ok read but nothing memorable personally.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔pre read˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
ME: FREIDA... WHAT ABOUT WRITERS BLOCK!?
FREIDA: I DONT KNOW HER!
Here we go again!.. 🥹🥹🥹
WELP… well this is a first, where I have actually not completed a Freida book in one sitting. No matter how ridiculous or outlandish I have found her books, she had that just ‘one more chapter’ poison sprinkled that I couldn’t help but continue committing to the madness.
The Witch for the first half gave me NOTHING… not a little tickle or a thrill. So, I put it down. But when I picked it back up it did start to get somewhat a little more interesting. The book is told in two timelines. One in 1692 and the other in present day. I must say I did enjoy the former more.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔BUT˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
I know I am being very picky but the language in the past chapters was so cringy. It read way to simplistic and the dialogue was not delivering how Freida probably intended it too.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔THE CHARACTERS˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
I enjoyed reading about Caroline and Julia’s character… everyone else for me just read one dimensional and ‘there’ for story purposes.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔SUPERNATURAL˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
The whole supernatural elements also landed flat for me. Listen this is not a bad book by any means I think I just wasn’t the right audience for it.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔THE TWISTS˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
Cute. Not Jaw dropping or life altering but it was good. I didn’t guess it but I wasn’t also screaming in shock when it was revealed.
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔FINAL VERDICT˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
Even though not a favourite for me. I must say Freida’s writing is getting so much better. The was no repetition or an inanimate object constantly being thrown in our face! The Witch was an ok read but nothing memorable personally.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔pre read˙⋆✮⋆˚࿔
ME: FREIDA... WHAT ABOUT WRITERS BLOCK!?
FREIDA: I DONT KNOW HER!
Here we go again!.. 🥹🥹🥹
October 8, 2026
The witch and I had more chemistry than this book had sense.
October 7, 2026
3.5⭐️ The Witch is a supernatural mystery thriller with witchcraft, family secrets and two timelines, following Julia in the present day and Caroline in 1692.
Julia arrives at the house to help look after her grandmother, who has dementia, and her aunt. Within about five minutes, she nearly gives the groundskeeper a heart attack with her scream and then gets mistaken for her 80-year-old great-aunt.
Julia is only 27, by the way.
A fairly eventful first five minutes. Great start, I suppose.
The house was one of my favourite parts. It’s old, neglected and musty, and I could practically smell it through the pages. The creepy stairs, the smelly attic, crying in the hallway at night, the swinging chandelier and the clock stopping at the same time every night all gave the house that feeling that something wasn’t quite right.
But scary? No.
Eerie, definitely. Frightening, not so much. I wouldn’t class this as horror at all. It’s much more of a supernatural mystery thriller with witchcraft and plenty of things to make you wonder what is actually going on.
I also preferred Caroline’s 1692 chapters. Her story grabbed me much more than Julia’s present-day one, especially once the witchcraft accusations started to unfold. Caroline’s chapters just had more about them for me, and I was much more interested in what was happening to her.
Freida McFadden’s writing is easy to get into, straightforward and quick to read. The short chapters certainly keep things moving, although I did find a few that felt completely unnecessary.
There was one in particular where a guard comes in to give her some food, there’s a bit of banter, and then he walks out again.
And that was the chapter.
I’m all for short chapters, but sometimes you need a little more to happen. Two short pages of nothingness just isn’t it.
I’m not going to say much more about the actual plot because I know a lot of people will be reading this one, and I think some things are better discovered for yourself.
Overall, I enjoyed the creepy old house, the witchcraft and the 1692 storyline much more than the present-day one. It wasn’t scary, but it did have an eerie atmosphere that worked well for this time of year. A few chapters could have been left out, but I still found myself wanting to know what was really going on.
Julia arrives at the house to help look after her grandmother, who has dementia, and her aunt. Within about five minutes, she nearly gives the groundskeeper a heart attack with her scream and then gets mistaken for her 80-year-old great-aunt.
Julia is only 27, by the way.
A fairly eventful first five minutes. Great start, I suppose.
The house was one of my favourite parts. It’s old, neglected and musty, and I could practically smell it through the pages. The creepy stairs, the smelly attic, crying in the hallway at night, the swinging chandelier and the clock stopping at the same time every night all gave the house that feeling that something wasn’t quite right.
But scary? No.
Eerie, definitely. Frightening, not so much. I wouldn’t class this as horror at all. It’s much more of a supernatural mystery thriller with witchcraft and plenty of things to make you wonder what is actually going on.
I also preferred Caroline’s 1692 chapters. Her story grabbed me much more than Julia’s present-day one, especially once the witchcraft accusations started to unfold. Caroline’s chapters just had more about them for me, and I was much more interested in what was happening to her.
Freida McFadden’s writing is easy to get into, straightforward and quick to read. The short chapters certainly keep things moving, although I did find a few that felt completely unnecessary.
There was one in particular where a guard comes in to give her some food, there’s a bit of banter, and then he walks out again.
And that was the chapter.
I’m all for short chapters, but sometimes you need a little more to happen. Two short pages of nothingness just isn’t it.
I’m not going to say much more about the actual plot because I know a lot of people will be reading this one, and I think some things are better discovered for yourself.
Overall, I enjoyed the creepy old house, the witchcraft and the 1692 storyline much more than the present-day one. It wasn’t scary, but it did have an eerie atmosphere that worked well for this time of year. A few chapters could have been left out, but I still found myself wanting to know what was really going on.
October 7, 2026
As someone who has read EVERY Freida McFadden book, this felt so different from anything she’s done before and I absolutely flew through it.
LOVED the dual timelines, especially the chapters set in the 1600s as they were so different for the author and for my normal style. There was this constant feeling of unease and while her twists in this one weren’t AS shocking as her other books I absolutely loved the direction it took
Such a fun, slightly supernatural thriller and PERFECT for October 🌙🧙🏻♀️🕯️
LOVED the dual timelines, especially the chapters set in the 1600s as they were so different for the author and for my normal style. There was this constant feeling of unease and while her twists in this one weren’t AS shocking as her other books I absolutely loved the direction it took
Such a fun, slightly supernatural thriller and PERFECT for October 🌙🧙🏻♀️🕯️
October 11, 2026
One of my favorite Frieda books now! This is a great spooky season thriller and kept me turning the pages.
Want to Read
March 8, 2026At this point Frieda McFadden publishes faster than I read 😅
March 7, 2026
absolutely insufferable. same time next month? 🩷
October 14, 2026
one thing about freida is she KNOWS how to hook you from the very first page
Did Not Finish
October 21, 2026Mam w dupie tę książkę, te fabułę, tych bohaterów, dosłownie nie da się mieć niczego bardziej w dupie niż ja mam tę książkę
June 6, 2026
Whoa this was so good! Dark, atmospheric, super witchy.. and actually creepy! 1680s, what an awful time to be a woman. Freida, you’ve given us a much different book this time around. It’s gripping, tense, historically accurate. Honestly her best work in a long time.
Full review tomorrow!
Little summary
In present day, Julia loses her apartment and her job and returns to her old family estate in Massachusetts under the pretense she wants to check on her grandmother but in reality she just wanted an escape from her current problems. She quickly discovers that the house is haunted. Every night, the grandfather clock stops at exactly 3:41 AM, the lights flicker on and off and she begins hearing cries and moans from the attic.
In 1692, the timelines follows Caroline who lives in the era of Salem witch trials. She's married to a wealthy merchant, struggles with infertility and befriends an older woman with a knowledge of herbal remedies. When the older woman falls ill, Caroline saves her but instead of being praised she becomes the target of suspicion and accusations of witch craft.
The two timelines eventually converge, connecting present day to Salem witch trial era!
Full review tomorrow!
Little summary
In present day, Julia loses her apartment and her job and returns to her old family estate in Massachusetts under the pretense she wants to check on her grandmother but in reality she just wanted an escape from her current problems. She quickly discovers that the house is haunted. Every night, the grandfather clock stops at exactly 3:41 AM, the lights flicker on and off and she begins hearing cries and moans from the attic.
In 1692, the timelines follows Caroline who lives in the era of Salem witch trials. She's married to a wealthy merchant, struggles with infertility and befriends an older woman with a knowledge of herbal remedies. When the older woman falls ill, Caroline saves her but instead of being praised she becomes the target of suspicion and accusations of witch craft.
The two timelines eventually converge, connecting present day to Salem witch trial era!
October 8, 2026
4⭐️
It’s been a minute since my last Freida McFadden book, and this one seemed like the perfect choice to get back into her books. I definitely felt that it was a little different from her usual work, which was a nice change of pace. I genuinely had fun reading it, and it kept me entertained throughout.
The ending let me down a little, TBH. I was hoping for something that would leave a bigger impression, but overall, I’d say this is definitely among her better books. I don’t usually enjoy her FMCs, but this one was an exception. All in all, a solid, entertaining read and a good reminder of why I keep coming back to Freida! ❤️
It’s been a minute since my last Freida McFadden book, and this one seemed like the perfect choice to get back into her books. I definitely felt that it was a little different from her usual work, which was a nice change of pace. I genuinely had fun reading it, and it kept me entertained throughout.
The ending let me down a little, TBH. I was hoping for something that would leave a bigger impression, but overall, I’d say this is definitely among her better books. I don’t usually enjoy her FMCs, but this one was an exception. All in all, a solid, entertaining read and a good reminder of why I keep coming back to Freida! ❤️
October 11, 2026
4.64
🧙♀️ The Witch by Freida McFadden ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Well, THIS was a pleasant surprise! Easily the best book I’ve read by Freida in quite some time. 👏🏻
With its creepy old house, unsettling atmosphere, and a mystery that weaves together the past and present, this one had me hooked. The historical elements added SO much to the story and made it stand out from her other books.
And Caroline’s POV?! I absolutely ATE IT UP! 😩 I was so freaking pissed for her. I felt every bit of that frustration, and her perspective was easily one of my favorite parts of the entire book.
I’ve seen a lot of people say they guessed the plot twist, but somehow, I didn’t see it coming this time! 😂 And honestly, I love when a book manages to surprise me like that.
The creepy vibes, the historical details, the mystery… Freida, you did your thing with this one! 🙌🏻
This is definitely going to be one of those books that sticks with me long after I’ve finished it. Absolutely loved it! 🖤
🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛
*•*PRE-READ*•*
I have to jump on this wagon with everyone and see what I’m missing with Mrs Freida’s new book. LETS GOOOO!
🧙♀️ The Witch by Freida McFadden ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Well, THIS was a pleasant surprise! Easily the best book I’ve read by Freida in quite some time. 👏🏻
With its creepy old house, unsettling atmosphere, and a mystery that weaves together the past and present, this one had me hooked. The historical elements added SO much to the story and made it stand out from her other books.
And Caroline’s POV?! I absolutely ATE IT UP! 😩 I was so freaking pissed for her. I felt every bit of that frustration, and her perspective was easily one of my favorite parts of the entire book.
I’ve seen a lot of people say they guessed the plot twist, but somehow, I didn’t see it coming this time! 😂 And honestly, I love when a book manages to surprise me like that.
The creepy vibes, the historical details, the mystery… Freida, you did your thing with this one! 🙌🏻
This is definitely going to be one of those books that sticks with me long after I’ve finished it. Absolutely loved it! 🖤
🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛******🐈⬛
*•*PRE-READ*•*
I have to jump on this wagon with everyone and see what I’m missing with Mrs Freida’s new book. LETS GOOOO!
July 29, 2026
imma be real honest when I say that I only keep up with these new books because they are bingeable lol 🤡 but HOW does she come up with all these book ideas?!?!
October 17, 2026
joke’s on me for thinking this would be witchy.
any enjoyment was ruined for me when i guessed every plot twist. every. single. one.
the old timey writing? i don’t want to talk about it.
as always, a bingeable and quick read by Freida. that’s about it.
any enjoyment was ruined for me when i guessed every plot twist. every. single. one.
the old timey writing? i don’t want to talk about it.
as always, a bingeable and quick read by Freida. that’s about it.
August 19, 2026
Wow. That was mind-blowing. I’ve never been a fan of Freida, but this new book kept me up all night—for all the right reasons.
This is very different from the usual domestic thrillers she’s been putting out for years. Her classic “fast-paced chapters” are still very much effective, as I breezed through the pages, barely noticing that I was almost finished after only starting this morning. That’s how engaging it was.
The characters were all well-developed. I personally liked Caroline’s POV. She was a kind soul, a good-natured girl who was betrayed by almost everyone around her. The dual timelines also worked for me as a reader. As we go along the history of Pemberton and its masters, uncover the secrets buried in the backyard, and encounter the ghosts within its walls, we realize that human beings are far more dangerous and deceiving than ghosts.
Also, one or two characters will make your blood boil, your nostrils flare, and your teeth grit because of how cruel and malicious they are. But don’t worry—everyone will get what they deserve in the end.
To Freida: I am becoming a fan. Hopefully, my next read from you will be another win, since you seem to publish a new book every week. No rest for the wicked, indeed.
This is very different from the usual domestic thrillers she’s been putting out for years. Her classic “fast-paced chapters” are still very much effective, as I breezed through the pages, barely noticing that I was almost finished after only starting this morning. That’s how engaging it was.
The characters were all well-developed. I personally liked Caroline’s POV. She was a kind soul, a good-natured girl who was betrayed by almost everyone around her. The dual timelines also worked for me as a reader. As we go along the history of Pemberton and its masters, uncover the secrets buried in the backyard, and encounter the ghosts within its walls, we realize that human beings are far more dangerous and deceiving than ghosts.
Also, one or two characters will make your blood boil, your nostrils flare, and your teeth grit because of how cruel and malicious they are. But don’t worry—everyone will get what they deserve in the end.
To Freida: I am becoming a fan. Hopefully, my next read from you will be another win, since you seem to publish a new book every week. No rest for the wicked, indeed.
October 22, 2026
Freida officially put a spell on me with this one. 🎃🧙♀️
This was such a fun October read... creepy house, family secrets, witch accusations, dual timelines, mystery, and just enough “what the heck is going on?!” to keep me hooked.
Caroline’s 1692 storyline was definitely my favorite. Every time it switched back to Julia, I was basically thinking, Okay… but can we get back to Caroline now? 😂 I was completely invested in what was happening to her.
I also loved the humor. Julia’s 85-year-old grandmother casually offering to murder her ex because a life sentence wouldn’t mean much at her age absolutely cracked me up. 😂
And the twists? Yep… she got me. 😳 There was more than one moment where I just sat there thinking, WHAT?! I did not see some of those reveals coming, and I loved how everything finally came together.
And can we talk about the physical book?! 😍 The sprayed edges with the teal webbing and fiery details are gorgeous. It looks made for spooky season.
My only complaint? I wanted even MORE witchcraft. Because hello… October. Give me all the witches. 🧙♀️😂
Creepy, fun, twisty, witchy, and perfect for this time of year. 🎃🕯️🔮
This was such a fun October read... creepy house, family secrets, witch accusations, dual timelines, mystery, and just enough “what the heck is going on?!” to keep me hooked.
Caroline’s 1692 storyline was definitely my favorite. Every time it switched back to Julia, I was basically thinking, Okay… but can we get back to Caroline now? 😂 I was completely invested in what was happening to her.
I also loved the humor. Julia’s 85-year-old grandmother casually offering to murder her ex because a life sentence wouldn’t mean much at her age absolutely cracked me up. 😂
And the twists? Yep… she got me. 😳 There was more than one moment where I just sat there thinking, WHAT?! I did not see some of those reveals coming, and I loved how everything finally came together.
And can we talk about the physical book?! 😍 The sprayed edges with the teal webbing and fiery details are gorgeous. It looks made for spooky season.
My only complaint? I wanted even MORE witchcraft. Because hello… October. Give me all the witches. 🧙♀️😂
Creepy, fun, twisty, witchy, and perfect for this time of year. 🎃🕯️🔮
October 10, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Well, this was a different side of Freida McFadden! The Witch is definitely unlike her usual books, but the psychological thriller elements are still very much present, woven together with a historical thriller. And don’t worry—Freida still delivers the twists we’ve all come to expect!
I especially loved the historical timeline. I’ve been fascinated by the Salem Witch Trials since high school, when I read Arthur Miller’s The Crucible and ended up writing a term paper about the trials. So, this part of the story was right up my alley! I really enjoyed the way Freida blended the historical elements with the psychological suspense.
So, why not five stars? Well, I wasn’t crazy about the ending (and that’s all I’m saying about that 🤐). I also felt that Julia’s character development was a little lacking. I wanted a bit more from her.
Overall, I really enjoyed seeing Freida try something a little different while still including the psychological twists that make her books so much fun to read.
I’ll be back for more, Freida! 📚
Well, this was a different side of Freida McFadden! The Witch is definitely unlike her usual books, but the psychological thriller elements are still very much present, woven together with a historical thriller. And don’t worry—Freida still delivers the twists we’ve all come to expect!
I especially loved the historical timeline. I’ve been fascinated by the Salem Witch Trials since high school, when I read Arthur Miller’s The Crucible and ended up writing a term paper about the trials. So, this part of the story was right up my alley! I really enjoyed the way Freida blended the historical elements with the psychological suspense.
So, why not five stars? Well, I wasn’t crazy about the ending (and that’s all I’m saying about that 🤐). I also felt that Julia’s character development was a little lacking. I wanted a bit more from her.
Overall, I really enjoyed seeing Freida try something a little different while still including the psychological twists that make her books so much fun to read.
I’ll be back for more, Freida! 📚
October 15, 2026
⠀︵⠀ pre-read [ 10.14.2026 ] 🤍 ࿐ . ۫
⤿ isn't this like freida's 4th book this year already 💔 i'm starting to think she's being forced to write.
buddy reading with my favie taskin ♡
⤿ isn't this like freida's 4th book this year already 💔 i'm starting to think she's being forced to write.
buddy reading with my favie taskin ♡
October 9, 2026
Freida McFadden just reached a new level. 🧙♀️
I don’t typically gravitate toward haunted house stories, but this is Freida McFadden, so let’s be honest, I was going to read it anyway. The Queen of Twists has officially entered her haunted house era, and honestly? She understood the assignment.
Blending a creepy haunted house mystery with a psychological thriller and a dual timeline that jumps between the present day and the Salem witch trials era, Freida delivers a story that feels tailored for October reading.
The historical timeline was especially compelling. Reading the perspectives of women accused of witchcraft was genuinely gutting. It made me think about what life must have been like for women during that time, when being different (or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time) could have devastating consequences.
Were the twists as jaw dropping as some of Freida’s previous books? Not quite. But they were still clever, well executed, and kept the story engaging. She may have traded some of her signature shock factor for an eerie, atmospheric mystery, but she made it work.
The verdict: Freida has added haunted house mystery to her thriller resume, and I’m here for it. A creepy, twisty read that’s perfect for curling up with in October.
Spoiler Free Synopsis
When Julia Barlow loses her job and apartment, she retreats to Pemberton, her family’s sprawling seventeenth century estate in rural Massachusetts, hoping for a fresh start while checking on her aging grandmother.
But Pemberton is anything but peaceful.
Every night, the grandfather clock stops at exactly 3:41 a.m. The lights flicker without explanation, and a mysterious voice cries for help outside Julia’s bedroom door.
As Julia investigates the strange occurrences, she uncovers the disturbing story of a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692. The deeper she digs into her family’s past, the more unsettling secrets she discovers and the harder it becomes to separate the truth from something far more sinister.
With a haunting history, family secrets, and mysteries that refuse to stay buried, Julia must uncover what is really happening at Pemberton.
Is the house haunted, or is something far more human hiding behind the mystery?
I don’t typically gravitate toward haunted house stories, but this is Freida McFadden, so let’s be honest, I was going to read it anyway. The Queen of Twists has officially entered her haunted house era, and honestly? She understood the assignment.
Blending a creepy haunted house mystery with a psychological thriller and a dual timeline that jumps between the present day and the Salem witch trials era, Freida delivers a story that feels tailored for October reading.
The historical timeline was especially compelling. Reading the perspectives of women accused of witchcraft was genuinely gutting. It made me think about what life must have been like for women during that time, when being different (or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time) could have devastating consequences.
Were the twists as jaw dropping as some of Freida’s previous books? Not quite. But they were still clever, well executed, and kept the story engaging. She may have traded some of her signature shock factor for an eerie, atmospheric mystery, but she made it work.
The verdict: Freida has added haunted house mystery to her thriller resume, and I’m here for it. A creepy, twisty read that’s perfect for curling up with in October.
Spoiler Free Synopsis
When Julia Barlow loses her job and apartment, she retreats to Pemberton, her family’s sprawling seventeenth century estate in rural Massachusetts, hoping for a fresh start while checking on her aging grandmother.
But Pemberton is anything but peaceful.
Every night, the grandfather clock stops at exactly 3:41 a.m. The lights flicker without explanation, and a mysterious voice cries for help outside Julia’s bedroom door.
As Julia investigates the strange occurrences, she uncovers the disturbing story of a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692. The deeper she digs into her family’s past, the more unsettling secrets she discovers and the harder it becomes to separate the truth from something far more sinister.
With a haunting history, family secrets, and mysteries that refuse to stay buried, Julia must uncover what is really happening at Pemberton.
Is the house haunted, or is something far more human hiding behind the mystery?
October 13, 2026
This one didn’t quite feel or sound like a typical Freida McFadden novel, for better or worse! Overall, the story worked for me, but it definitely had some pros and cons compared to her usual books.
I appreciated that it felt fresh and different, and the story idea itself was clever. I enjoyed both POVs, but Caroline’s chapters were a particular highlight for me. I liked the twists in her storyline and how everything ultimately played out. The historical aspect was also a nice touch, and it still made for a good spooky-season read!
That said, this one was slower than I’m used to from Freida and didn’t have me on the edge of my seat like her usual thrillers. It wasn’t nearly as twisty, and at times, it barely felt like a thriller at all. I also missed her signature sarcastic humor, which is usually part of the fun! One thing that threw me off was the writing in Caroline’s chapters, which sometimes jumped between old-fashioned and modern-day language in a way that felt a little awkward.
Overall, I enjoyed the story for what it was, but it didn’t quite deliver the fast-paced, twisty, darkly funny experience I typically expect from a Freida McFadden book. Still a fun Halloween read though!
I appreciated that it felt fresh and different, and the story idea itself was clever. I enjoyed both POVs, but Caroline’s chapters were a particular highlight for me. I liked the twists in her storyline and how everything ultimately played out. The historical aspect was also a nice touch, and it still made for a good spooky-season read!
That said, this one was slower than I’m used to from Freida and didn’t have me on the edge of my seat like her usual thrillers. It wasn’t nearly as twisty, and at times, it barely felt like a thriller at all. I also missed her signature sarcastic humor, which is usually part of the fun! One thing that threw me off was the writing in Caroline’s chapters, which sometimes jumped between old-fashioned and modern-day language in a way that felt a little awkward.
Overall, I enjoyed the story for what it was, but it didn’t quite deliver the fast-paced, twisty, darkly funny experience I typically expect from a Freida McFadden book. Still a fun Halloween read though!
October 17, 2026
I must say that this was a refreshing book by McFadden. It had humor and the witch angle was fun.
October 15, 2026
I only take advice from women who would've been burned at the stake back in the days
-----------------------------------------------------
pre-read
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
Gotta lock tf in life, just like Freida did 😝| BR with my other half aoife ‹𝟹
-----------------------------------------------------
pre-read
─── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ──
Gotta lock tf in life, just like Freida did 😝| BR with my other half aoife ‹𝟹
March 14, 2026
This was different than Freida’s normal writing, but in a good way! It felt spookier, more supernatural than normal to me. 🖤
I really enjoyed this. The two timelines were so good at weaving such a suspenseful story. I was really rooting for Caroline and wanted nothing to happen to her. I also wanted to know how everything connected and was Caroline really haunting the house?
I think I would have actually preferred a more supernatural ending than what we got, even though there were still supernatural elements at play. Overall, very good and definitely would like to see her write another one like this.
I really enjoyed this. The two timelines were so good at weaving such a suspenseful story. I was really rooting for Caroline and wanted nothing to happen to her. I also wanted to know how everything connected and was Caroline really haunting the house?
I think I would have actually preferred a more supernatural ending than what we got, even though there were still supernatural elements at play. Overall, very good and definitely would like to see her write another one like this.
October 14, 2026
⋆ 𐔌 𝑹𝒂𝒕𝒊𝒏𝒈ˑ !!꒱⭑- 3.25 🌟
𝒓𝒆𝒗𝒊𝒆𝒘⋆˚꩜｡⋆
This was definitely different from what I'm used to getting from freida and honestly I liked that. The whole witchy atmosphere and the dual timelines made the story interesting, but I found myself more invested in the historical storyline of Caroline's than the present one.
I did enjoy the mystery and seeing how everything connected, but the twists weren't as shocking as I hoped and some parts felt a little slow. I still had a good time reading it tho and I wouldn't mind seeing Freida explore more stories like this.🖤
𝑪𝒐𝒏𝒄𝒍𝒖𝒔𝒊𝒐𝒏⋆˚꩜｡⋆
Not my favourite of hers but a pretty enjoyable read for spooky season! 🎃🖤
୨♡୧𝑷𝒓𝒆-𝒓𝒆𝒂𝒅୨♡୧
I'm really curious about this one because of the ratings, so let's see what the hype is about 👀
𝒓𝒆𝒗𝒊𝒆𝒘⋆˚꩜｡⋆
This was definitely different from what I'm used to getting from freida and honestly I liked that. The whole witchy atmosphere and the dual timelines made the story interesting, but I found myself more invested in the historical storyline of Caroline's than the present one.
I did enjoy the mystery and seeing how everything connected, but the twists weren't as shocking as I hoped and some parts felt a little slow. I still had a good time reading it tho and I wouldn't mind seeing Freida explore more stories like this.🖤
𝑪𝒐𝒏𝒄𝒍𝒖𝒔𝒊𝒐𝒏⋆˚꩜｡⋆
Not my favourite of hers but a pretty enjoyable read for spooky season! 🎃🖤
୨♡୧𝑷𝒓𝒆-𝒓𝒆𝒂𝒅୨♡୧
I'm really curious about this one because of the ratings, so let's see what the hype is about 👀
Want to Read
March 11, 2026freida mcfadden needs a holiday
Displaying 1 - 30 of 13,638 reviews