This was one of the first comics I ever collected as a young kid, and among my first introductions to the Aliens comics line after having seen the first two films when I was like 12. I remember basically liking it, but not really understanding what was happening in the story. So, I revisited it recently as an adult.
It's not much better now. I tried to read pretty carefully, to figure out what exactly is driving the plot, and it's not there. I'd love to interview the various guys who were involved in writing this, just to ask what the actual story framework was, what the cause and effect relationships were supposed to be between travel/story points, and the grand plan the villains had, etc. As it stands, the characters come and go from locations, only occasionally offering any rationalization before they get there. Everywhere they go is infested by the Aliens, including the ocean planet full of fish or whale Aliens (whalians?) that were infected by aquatic facehuggers I guess. The implication of an ocean full of Aliens is terrifying, considering humans would have virtually no way to combat such a propagation. Have no fear, the characters don't consider this for a second. It's just the premise for a cool looking battle on the surface and some arguing with colonists who are never relevant to the story again.
And it's really kind of a shame. There is a bonkers amount of stuff going on, and some interesting ideas afloat here. The idea that the royal jelly can mutate people into human/alien hybrids chief among them, and the ability for those mutants to psychically bond with the Alien creatures. Was this the next step of the evolutionary chain for the Alien creature (it's often been suggested in the films/comics that the Alien was designed, not natural)? If so who was the first hybrid and how?
Well, you're not getting the answers. The troublesome Colonial Marine lieutenant Joseph Henry takes his motley crew of discipline cases and their hard pressed no-nonsense sergeant from space station to space station, from planet to moon, to more space stations, shooting Aliens every time they get to one, and the gallons of acid blood fortunately never vent the things to space by corroding holes through the outer bulkheads. We get the unexplained one-off appearance of a "Professional Bug Hunter" character who got to the planet they were on... somehow, and disappears again in the same issue. There's a brief one-issue foray to a moon full of low level AI robots because conveniently the company man character stashed weapons and a spaceship there, which just seems like a cool idea some guy had (he only wrote that one issue in the ten part series) and whoever was in charge at Dark Horse agreed because "Who cares? This story is a mess anyway."
Eventually, Lieutenant Henry begins to lose his mind for reasons that are passed off to the reader in ways only someone who had watched a lot of movies but knew nothing about actual psychosis could. He becomes obsessed with finding this mysterious figure named "Father" and he does, because the original print run was supposed to be 12 issues, but at some point was cut down to 10, likely because the results of this comic had been a disaster and they just wanted to get it over with. The final two issues slam the door on this thing with an abrupt and nearly incomprehensible punch-out ending.
This story has all the continuity of the Disney Star Wars sequel trilogy, in that a small group of main characters appear in every issue, with the supporting cast sometimes appearing and disappearing without explanation, and the story definitely wasn't plotted out ahead of time. The film Aliens is a classic because of its characters. Even some of the Colonial Marines that die at the halfway point of the film in the first big battle are remembered fondly and clearly by the audience because they've been given memorable personalities and distinctive looks. Not so here. It's not ever even clear how many Marines are part of this unit, or who a lot of them are. Some of them change appearance, such as the blonde man who wears glasses who dies early on, only for a blonde male character with glasses to return to the story, with an entirely different name, a name attached to a Marine who has been seen without glasses on multiple occasions. He also sometimes has a little goatee, and doesn't later. Another character is clearly part of the Navy in early episodes, being in charge of stuff aboard their ship, only to be unfortunately absent from the ship later when it needs to crash because nobody is at the controls. He later reappears dressed as a Colonial Marine. A couple characters don't even appear in the final issue, despite being in the 9th one.
So please. If you were part of the writing/art team for this comic, message me. I'd love to actually know the full story behind this train wreck. At 12 issues planned and 10 delivered, it was one of the most ambitious Aliens comics ever done (the average story was 4-6 issues), but the end result is almost hilariously bad, with a story that makes almost no sense.