I divide poetry (and indeed much of literature) into three categories:
1. The brilliant. The stuff that was written for you. The stuff where the author went inside your head and saw everything you felt, thought, loved, believed and then wrote it down in a way that was so much better than you could ever have imagined, and yet it was perfect. Perfect.
2. The good. The stuff that is interesting or thought-provoking or well done or beautiful, but doesn't really speak to you. A subset of this category includes the stuff that describes things differently to the way you personally experienced it, but which is still beautiful/interesting/thought-provoking/well done. But mostly beautiful.
3. Everything else.
I don't think any of Plath's poetry fitted into my first category - maybe there was the odd line here and there, but nothing that stood out. There were a few lines (for example the last two of Maudlin, quoted below, a few bits from Face Lift) and a few whole poems (The Babysitters, Night Shift) which belonged to the second category. The other poems all go into the third category.
I'm not sure that I really have anything meaningful to say about Sylvia Plath, but dang it I'm going to go ahead and say it anyway. I felt like her poems were shutting me out, like those gold Yves Klein paintings. I want poems that are like blue Yves Klein paintings, that suck you in and distort your soul and break holes in your universe all at the same time. Anyway. I have a great deal of difficulty identifying with people who are depressed much of the time, who complain about how hard it is to be a woman (or anything else), who write poems about death and suicide and plastic surgery. These days we call that 'emo', people, and we use it as an insult. This is wrong of me, I know. I'm working on it. Also I know it's a huge oversimplification.
It's just that I have an incorrigibly buoyant disposition: it takes quite a lot to get me depressed. And so I find it hard to understand what she feels like. On the other hand it means I'll never write her off, because if I was just born happy, without anything particular happening in my life to make me so, why shouldn't other people just be born sad? It's the way the brain is wired, and brains work in mysterious ways.
But there are so many authors out there who can make me truly empathise with something without me even having to try, just because they write so well. Plath herself did it, I think, with The Bell Jar (but I actually was kind of depressed when I read it, so that could be why). So this brings me to admit that I am lazy, and I can't be bothered sitting around all day trying to empathise with her poems. I got stuff to do! Today I realised that I've half-forgotten how to factorise, for goodness' sake! I don't have time for this! Which should be irrelevant, because most of the time thinking about books is effortless and enjoyable and I do it whether I have time or not, but with Plath it's laboured and I really just don't want to. I feel like it shouldn't be an effort.
The final point is that I don't read much poetry, because it all seems to end up like Plath to me: a disappointment. But maybe I just need more practice. So the way I see it there are three possibilities here: a) I've missed something b) I'm just not trying hard enough or c) Plath is just not for me (there's always the possibility of a d) she's just not that good, but I don't believe that).
Which leaves me to emphasise that THIS IS NOT MY FINAL WORD. I am studying this poetry sometime this semester which is why I'm reading it in the first place, and so my opinions will almost certainly change when someone tells me what to think. Nah, but sometimes I just need a nudge that makes me look at something from a slightly different angle, and suddenly it's beautiful and I love it. Let's hope that happens with Plath.
_____________________________
So I was trundling along happily with Plath, until I reached this poem. What in hell does it mean? (I'm not going to google it... yet).
Maudlin
Mud-mattressed under the sign of the hag
In a clench of blood, the sleep-talking virgin
Gibbets with her curse the moon's man,
Faggot-bearing Jack in his crackless egg:
Hatched with a claret hogshead to swig
He kings it, navel-knit to no groan,
But at the price of a pin-stitched skin
Fish-tailed girls purchase each white leg.