What do you think?
Rate this book
A Court of Thorns and Roses #6
A Court of Splintered Harmony
Not yet published
Expected 27 Oct 26What was broken will be remade.
Deep in the heart of the continent, Koschei the Deathless is stirring. Though he's been bound to a mountain lake for millennia, the insidious threat of his return now spreads across the Fae territories, attracting powerful allies hell-bent on reclaiming what was once theirs: the human lands.
The Night Court will not stand idly by while innocents are attacked. But with Prythian still piecing itself together in the wake of the devastating Hybern War, the task of uniting is proving more difficult by the day.
To make matters worse, those who rule and protect the Night Court are reeling from recent betrayals and revealed truths. The rifts dividing them seem insurmountable.
But to defeat Koschei's creeping shadow, they must find a way back to each other and resurrect their former alliances. To survive, they must find a way to repair the splintered harmony all around them.
Deep in the heart of the continent, Koschei the Deathless is stirring. Though he's been bound to a mountain lake for millennia, the insidious threat of his return now spreads across the Fae territories, attracting powerful allies hell-bent on reclaiming what was once theirs: the human lands.
The Night Court will not stand idly by while innocents are attacked. But with Prythian still piecing itself together in the wake of the devastating Hybern War, the task of uniting is proving more difficult by the day.
To make matters worse, those who rule and protect the Night Court are reeling from recent betrayals and revealed truths. The rifts dividing them seem insurmountable.
But to defeat Koschei's creeping shadow, they must find a way back to each other and resurrect their former alliances. To survive, they must find a way to repair the splintered harmony all around them.
352 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication October 27, 2026
About the author
Sarah J. Maas
119 books586k followersSarah J. Maas is the #1 bestselling author of the Throne of Glass, Court of Thorns and Roses, and Crescent City series. Her books have sold millions of copies and are published in thirty-eight languages. She lives in New York City with her family.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 858 reviews
Review of advance copy
BUCKLE UP BITCHES 🗣‼️ i'm here to rant
I know that this story is split into 4 parts and scattered across three books. My rating for this book might change when the others are out, but for now, I am only judging it for what it is presented as.
SPOILERS OF COURSE !!! - (dont come crying in the comments later on)
Wow - we finally got another ACOTAR book 5 years later 😭 It honestly felt surreal to have it in my hands and read it. It was only 320 pages, but it did read like an ACOTAR book - in fact, it felt like reading ACOTAR all over again 🫣 I'm settling for a 3.5 for now because of how inconsistent I felt things were.
So, lets start.
The writing - idk why, but it felt so weird 😭 I was talking to my 10/10 absolute diva of a friend (some of you might know her as buket), and she told me that the writing was already bad 😭😭, and that we're just developing our frontal lobe now, so we're noticing - and I couldn't even disagree because some of the scenes (NOT ALL) were not well written, but the book was still enjoyable. I was hooked. It had me on it for ten hours straight, like I genuinely don't know what drugs were infused in it because I couldn't put it down despite the underwhelming writing. I binged it in a span of 12-13 hours. The plot saved the book. It was well handled, and the way it's moving makes it sound very promising, especially with how things ended.
I honestly think we're at this stage with SJM where we can criticize her writing if it's lacking 😭 because she's written multiple books, she has delivered time and time again, and if there is this lingering pattern creeping up where her writing is deteriorating (first HOFAS and now this), we can say it out loud. Some of the scenes were honestly so hard to read. The second-hand embarrassment I got from those scenes. The insane 'tell not show' thing going on, it felt more like a recap of the previous four books rather than a start of a new story (had me feeling a bit iffy at the start). I really miss the days when we would actually get characters on journeys in books. It added so much character depth, it would actually flesh them out, and make us root for them. It added a lot of value to the story but now there's zero importance regarding this and its barely in books. Especially here the characters are somehow transporting near the mortal lands, then to summer court, then back to the night court in like a span of a chapter 🙄
Also, i don't understand her fixation on some particular things, she would focus so much on such irrelevant stuff and bring it up at the most critical parts of the book 😡 (for example: Feyre breastfeeding or thinking about leaking milk 😭 rhys and feyre thinking about banging each other while talking abut alliance, Cassian and Nesta having argument and Cassian getting hard and wanting to bang.)
However, as the book progressed, I think I got more used to the writing because I started to enjoy the book and look past the problems that I had initially. I hate publishing restrictions because I would have loved to just read the entire thing in one go, and I think that would have encouraged me to give this book a higher rating because there are so many things that are clouding my thoughts right now, and only more answers can get it cleared up. I do believe that she ended this book at the right moment. The entire monologue between Nesta and Amren at the end felt so cinematic - that part was well written (credit where credit is due). I also think the next book is going to fare better since it has fewer problems to tackle. The wait time is three months instead of five years, so managed expectations and recent exposure to the characters and plot would make the experience better. The plot is also shaping up to be something grand, and I am excited to see where the Valkyrie cycle goes and if it's going to live up to its name.
I liked that the tension throughout the book was high, with Koschei the Deathless having this lingering dreadful feeling without even making a single appearance, the whole court drama, the human lands being at the risk of invasion, the Bryaxis jumpscare. It's safe to say it made this book not only eventful but easy to read through. It was atmospheric and tense, and you could, UNLIKE SOME CHARACTERS 😒, feel the urgency of the situation (ik ik, it feels conflicting when I praise it like that). Her prose might be subpar for the most part here, but her ability to write about high-stakes environments, creating an eerie atmosphere, is certainly not being put to question. Idk where she is going wrong with her prose or rather the execution of it because TOG had some of her best moments. Anyways, I love that we are moving forward in terms of the world as well, exploring new areas and more magical items - I'm a sucker for a book that gives its world building and magic system equal importance.
My ratings are more so based on what I've said above, but WE HAVE TO talk about the characters AND the romance.
We get multiple perspectives, with the most going to, I think, Azriel, then Feyre, then Nesta, then Cassian, and some small chapters for Lucien, Gwyn, and Mor (1-2 max).
Lets start with Azriel. From what I had read from ACOTAR to ACOSF, going into this book, my perception of Azriel was based on that, and we didn't know much of him. He's always been a mysterious character, so naturally, given the circumstances and how those books cater to his character through other characters' perspectives, is how you make your own thoughts and expectations of him. Being in Azriel's head was a totally different experience. I got whiplash going through it 😭 I loved the prologue. I think getting a perspective from his past was what I needed, and I wish we got to see more of him and his struggles alongside his mother. BUT I also do get that he has that part buried deep and isn't ready to talk it out, but knowing that part of his character gave us some answers and made his character more fleshed out. It also gave some reasoning to his actions - to an extent, and his behavior. Azriel might be caring, loving (to his family), protective, and aloof, but um 🫣 that's not all.
He's stubborn as hell, he's reckless, immature, entitled, impulsive, self-destructive. I think most of these emotions stem from his past and some from envy or jealousy of seeing his "brothers" have mates while he does not. I liked his perspective at the beginning because there was actually something happening 😭 but oh my god, after like 30%, his character read like a child throwing a tantrum. ITS CLEAR that this guy needs a massive healing arc - like he's in desperate need of it. I'm sorry, but you cannot be horny enough to be willing to risk such an important alliance, knowing that the threat this time is so much bigger. I always thought that he was going to be smart/clever and calculated, but boy, he was the opposite of that. He and Elain hooked up for a month, and out of those hookups, Rhys found out twice and had warned him a year before all this started. SO it's not even like this bitch didn't know the severity of the situation 😭 He was full-on lipsing with Elain in the kitchen, and when Rhysand appears and is like, mind you, very civil and logical, Azriel starts throwing tantrums and, mind you, f bombs. 😭 Rhysand says I have too much on my plate and I cant handle your shit. 500-year-old Azriel proceeds to say fUcK yOu. Never have I ever wanted to slap someone so fucking hard.
Then we get to the second scene before I start my rant for this (I was the biggest Azriel fan out there 😭 but the sheer aura loss that he suffered from in this scene was so heartbreaking and icky I cant). So Azriel is fondling Elain's boobies, and Lucien steps in - Azriel isn't warned because his shadows can't stand to be with him in the same room as Elain and they, like me (😝), are repulsed. He knows what he did is wrong, he knows that the woman that he did it with is humiliated, crying, and isn't even saying anything other than that this was a misunderstanding, and he knows her mate is there and what he is feeling. And keep this in mind: Rhysand told him his experience of WHAT HE FELT when he knew that Feyre was his mate and was with Tamlin, but still goaded him on and on - KNOWING that everything, every threat, is hanging on by a thread. ALL OF HIS FAMILY are there, and this bitch is there arguing with his fucking dick out 😭😭 like at least wear some damn pants because your shadows weren't covering you either CUZ THEY REFUSED TO LISTEN. He didn't think, he just did, and he ruined everything 😭 like literally Lucien, who could have helped them with Autumn and Spring Courts AND had Jurian and Vassa alongside him. The disdain and disappointment etched in everyone's face was so damn satisfying to see because he honestly deserved it, and he needed to be called out. When Mor slapped the shit out of him, it was so peaceful.
Feyre and Rhysand, oh my days 😭😭😭 Reading Feyre's perspective after 7ish years felt so damn weird. I enjoyed Feysand moments because they have their cute moments. I liked that beach scene a lot because I feel like it's important for relationships to have moments like that. I am also behind Rhysand on the High King thing because I DO NOT want him to be High King. We dont get Rhysand's perspective, so thankfully, we missed out on 400 mentions of my mate, but we did get a lot of Feyre's perspective. I was so scared that she was going to make Feyre only act as a mother and forget that she's super powerful and is also a High Lady, but I'm so glad that she did not do that because Feyre had that fire here, which I loved. Rhysand, I also liked. He was harsh, but he was super rational, and his decisions made sense 100%. Her, Rhys, and baby Nyx were soooo cute. I don't mind Feyre constantly mentioning breast leaking milk 😭 because she just gave birth to Nyx half a year ago, I think, and it would make sense for this to be mentioned, but it's done at the most weird times istg 😭 The smut scenes were so damn bad, like omg, I did not miss the smut chapters at all. The constant innuendo was so hard to read, and the sex scenes overall were an instant skim because I could not read borderline lactation kink pls 😭
Nesta and Cassian, GUYS 😭😭😭😭 I genuinely don't know how this happened BUT 😭😭😭 I LOVE NESTA?? Like, that's actually crazy. I was not fond of her at all. I think it's because she carried so much emotion in this book. She lowk carried the entire book on her back, so I will say thank you to her. I think I liked her so much more in this book because I agreed with her decision to give Bryce the mask. I know in the courts' eyes, it's a sign of betrayal, but it was the right choice. They knew it was the right choice, and they would have made the same choice if they had some time. Them being mad was justified, but them prolonging it was so damn stupid. Idewtt about Azriel rn because he NEEDS that desperate healing arc. Nesta did not deserve all the shit she got, especially from Cassian. Nesta single-handedly saved everyone's asses. Her scenes with Gwyn 😭 not this book living up to its name. I loved her and her bond with her sisters and her sisterhood. I loved how strong she was. Her single-handedly going against Bryaxis was so badass, and her drive to push against her abilities was so amazing to see. Also, Nesta clocking Elain at the end was so peaceful to see and was definitely needed, given how coddled she is. The next book will definitely have her as an integral part, given how it ended. Cassian is hard to hate, and I know that he's loyal to his High Lord, but some things are meant to be between you and your MATE. I think he should have the common sense to keep it that way, and also, him shutting her out for so long just pissed me off.
Amren and Mor, idc if I'm High Lord or Lady - if a 15000-year-old female comes up to me and says this wont work, and do this, I'll save my time and do that (no shade). Morrigan, the woman that you are. We got one slice of POV from her, and I ate it up. I cant wait for her book. I love her for slapping the shit out of Azriel and giving him shit because he DESERVED it. I'll be sending her prayers. Poor girl is stuck with Elain. I ALSO BETTER NOT HEAR ANY MOR IS EVIL allegations.
Gwyn, I'm super excited for where we are going with her character. There must be some importance to the highlight on the bonus chapter and her getting her own POV - I'm super excited. I don't think she's going to be evil as many think - Az calls himself a monster and a demon literally, so idt if Gwyn feels that, given how she has a traumatic past and how things are unraveling for her, is out of pocket. I think the second book's title also has to do something with her or the priestess in general. Idt SJM would use her in a villainous role, and also, isn't she based on her best friend?? Also she says she hates illyrian men but so does Az and cass 😭 and that she enjoyed killing those men in the rite but baby so did manon, lysandra, and aelin 😭 so let's not go there to justify her being a villain.
Lucien, I felt soooo bad for him, especially after I read his POV. This man has been nothing but kind and respectful, and I hate to see him being betrayed and broken like that.
Elain, omg, I hate her so much. She is the most useless character ever. I hate her with burning, raging passion, like I have not hated a character like her. She is so useless, like omg, and she says that don't coddle and don't infantilize me, and she gets herself in the worst position and then starts crying, like fucking crying. Bitch, what the fuck are you crying for?? Did you not think about the consequences at all?? Like, if she wants to sleep with Azriel, that's OKAY, she CAN, but like, have the decency to end things with your mate. Why is she stringing him around? I dOnT LiKe LuCiEn. I wAnT nOtHiNG tO dO WiTh HiM. Then break the damn bond and put both you and him out of that misery. She's actually so dumb, I can't, like she just pisses me off.
She says I can be useful and that she's a seer, but that stupid girl always talks in codes that by the time they figure things out, they would happen. I can see why no one asks her for help - also, she literally starts crying at every single thing. OMG, her victim complex is so strong, like she's also VERY much entitled and A RAGING PICK ME. Her going to Nesta and Feyre, apologizing for the plans she's destroyed because she knows they would forgive her, but when Nesta doesn't, she gets all defensive and starts backtracking, like bitch, weren't you here to apologize? ISTG SJM needs to do massive work on her character cuz I can't stand her character. ALSO, SHE'S A FUCKING SEER BUT HER DUMBASS IS CRYING 24/7 MAKING IT SO EASY FOR THE READERS TO FORGET THAT SHE HAS THINGS SHE CAN HELP WITH BUT OH NO ONE ASKS SO SHE WONT.
The romance, honestly 😭😭 this version of Azriel can stay the FUCK away from Gwyn. I don't think Elriel is endgame. If it is, I think there is a longggg way to go, LIKE a long way to go. Elain is in Vallahan, and I think her story will somehow tie up to Lucien's, while Azriel is in the House of Wind with Nesta. I think what's important here is that AZRIEL can get a proper arc and get his shit together and actually process his emotions and consider himself worthy of being loved because I'm sorry, their relationship felt super lusty. Not Azriel trying to open up, but Elain stops and says they should find a room to bang in, like hoe?? Is you fr?? Elain also needs to get her shit together. We need actual POV from her and to get inside her head and see what's going on so we can understand her. A majority of you havent read Tog and it shows 😭 sarah can easily switch up on who she wants as endgame. I do think with Azriel being in the House of Wind and his arc overlapping Gwyn's, I think that IN MY OPINION, there might be a high chance of that happening. Elucien 🫣 hopefully- idk, but hopefully.
Overall, I had fun ngl. It was messy and enjoyable.
Special mention to Areeba, Fiza and Hoda for going through this tough time with me
Special mention x2 for Shifu/Areeba for proof reading this review
___
Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel.
I know that this story is split into 4 parts and scattered across three books. My rating for this book might change when the others are out, but for now, I am only judging it for what it is presented as.
SPOILERS OF COURSE !!! - (dont come crying in the comments later on)
Wow - we finally got another ACOTAR book 5 years later 😭 It honestly felt surreal to have it in my hands and read it. It was only 320 pages, but it did read like an ACOTAR book - in fact, it felt like reading ACOTAR all over again 🫣 I'm settling for a 3.5 for now because of how inconsistent I felt things were.
So, lets start.
The writing - idk why, but it felt so weird 😭 I was talking to my 10/10 absolute diva of a friend (some of you might know her as buket), and she told me that the writing was already bad 😭😭, and that we're just developing our frontal lobe now, so we're noticing - and I couldn't even disagree because some of the scenes (NOT ALL) were not well written, but the book was still enjoyable. I was hooked. It had me on it for ten hours straight, like I genuinely don't know what drugs were infused in it because I couldn't put it down despite the underwhelming writing. I binged it in a span of 12-13 hours. The plot saved the book. It was well handled, and the way it's moving makes it sound very promising, especially with how things ended.
I honestly think we're at this stage with SJM where we can criticize her writing if it's lacking 😭 because she's written multiple books, she has delivered time and time again, and if there is this lingering pattern creeping up where her writing is deteriorating (first HOFAS and now this), we can say it out loud. Some of the scenes were honestly so hard to read. The second-hand embarrassment I got from those scenes. The insane 'tell not show' thing going on, it felt more like a recap of the previous four books rather than a start of a new story (had me feeling a bit iffy at the start). I really miss the days when we would actually get characters on journeys in books. It added so much character depth, it would actually flesh them out, and make us root for them. It added a lot of value to the story but now there's zero importance regarding this and its barely in books. Especially here the characters are somehow transporting near the mortal lands, then to summer court, then back to the night court in like a span of a chapter 🙄
Also, i don't understand her fixation on some particular things, she would focus so much on such irrelevant stuff and bring it up at the most critical parts of the book 😡 (for example: Feyre breastfeeding or thinking about leaking milk 😭 rhys and feyre thinking about banging each other while talking abut alliance, Cassian and Nesta having argument and Cassian getting hard and wanting to bang.)
However, as the book progressed, I think I got more used to the writing because I started to enjoy the book and look past the problems that I had initially. I hate publishing restrictions because I would have loved to just read the entire thing in one go, and I think that would have encouraged me to give this book a higher rating because there are so many things that are clouding my thoughts right now, and only more answers can get it cleared up. I do believe that she ended this book at the right moment. The entire monologue between Nesta and Amren at the end felt so cinematic - that part was well written (credit where credit is due). I also think the next book is going to fare better since it has fewer problems to tackle. The wait time is three months instead of five years, so managed expectations and recent exposure to the characters and plot would make the experience better. The plot is also shaping up to be something grand, and I am excited to see where the Valkyrie cycle goes and if it's going to live up to its name.
I liked that the tension throughout the book was high, with Koschei the Deathless having this lingering dreadful feeling without even making a single appearance, the whole court drama, the human lands being at the risk of invasion, the Bryaxis jumpscare. It's safe to say it made this book not only eventful but easy to read through. It was atmospheric and tense, and you could, UNLIKE SOME CHARACTERS 😒, feel the urgency of the situation (ik ik, it feels conflicting when I praise it like that). Her prose might be subpar for the most part here, but her ability to write about high-stakes environments, creating an eerie atmosphere, is certainly not being put to question. Idk where she is going wrong with her prose or rather the execution of it because TOG had some of her best moments. Anyways, I love that we are moving forward in terms of the world as well, exploring new areas and more magical items - I'm a sucker for a book that gives its world building and magic system equal importance.
My ratings are more so based on what I've said above, but WE HAVE TO talk about the characters AND the romance.
We get multiple perspectives, with the most going to, I think, Azriel, then Feyre, then Nesta, then Cassian, and some small chapters for Lucien, Gwyn, and Mor (1-2 max).
Lets start with Azriel. From what I had read from ACOTAR to ACOSF, going into this book, my perception of Azriel was based on that, and we didn't know much of him. He's always been a mysterious character, so naturally, given the circumstances and how those books cater to his character through other characters' perspectives, is how you make your own thoughts and expectations of him. Being in Azriel's head was a totally different experience. I got whiplash going through it 😭 I loved the prologue. I think getting a perspective from his past was what I needed, and I wish we got to see more of him and his struggles alongside his mother. BUT I also do get that he has that part buried deep and isn't ready to talk it out, but knowing that part of his character gave us some answers and made his character more fleshed out. It also gave some reasoning to his actions - to an extent, and his behavior. Azriel might be caring, loving (to his family), protective, and aloof, but um 🫣 that's not all.
He's stubborn as hell, he's reckless, immature, entitled, impulsive, self-destructive. I think most of these emotions stem from his past and some from envy or jealousy of seeing his "brothers" have mates while he does not. I liked his perspective at the beginning because there was actually something happening 😭 but oh my god, after like 30%, his character read like a child throwing a tantrum. ITS CLEAR that this guy needs a massive healing arc - like he's in desperate need of it. I'm sorry, but you cannot be horny enough to be willing to risk such an important alliance, knowing that the threat this time is so much bigger. I always thought that he was going to be smart/clever and calculated, but boy, he was the opposite of that. He and Elain hooked up for a month, and out of those hookups, Rhys found out twice and had warned him a year before all this started. SO it's not even like this bitch didn't know the severity of the situation 😭 He was full-on lipsing with Elain in the kitchen, and when Rhysand appears and is like, mind you, very civil and logical, Azriel starts throwing tantrums and, mind you, f bombs. 😭 Rhysand says I have too much on my plate and I cant handle your shit. 500-year-old Azriel proceeds to say fUcK yOu. Never have I ever wanted to slap someone so fucking hard.
Then we get to the second scene before I start my rant for this (I was the biggest Azriel fan out there 😭 but the sheer aura loss that he suffered from in this scene was so heartbreaking and icky I cant). So Azriel is fondling Elain's boobies, and Lucien steps in - Azriel isn't warned because his shadows can't stand to be with him in the same room as Elain and they, like me (😝), are repulsed. He knows what he did is wrong, he knows that the woman that he did it with is humiliated, crying, and isn't even saying anything other than that this was a misunderstanding, and he knows her mate is there and what he is feeling. And keep this in mind: Rhysand told him his experience of WHAT HE FELT when he knew that Feyre was his mate and was with Tamlin, but still goaded him on and on - KNOWING that everything, every threat, is hanging on by a thread. ALL OF HIS FAMILY are there, and this bitch is there arguing with his fucking dick out 😭😭 like at least wear some damn pants because your shadows weren't covering you either CUZ THEY REFUSED TO LISTEN. He didn't think, he just did, and he ruined everything 😭 like literally Lucien, who could have helped them with Autumn and Spring Courts AND had Jurian and Vassa alongside him. The disdain and disappointment etched in everyone's face was so damn satisfying to see because he honestly deserved it, and he needed to be called out. When Mor slapped the shit out of him, it was so peaceful.
Feyre and Rhysand, oh my days 😭😭😭 Reading Feyre's perspective after 7ish years felt so damn weird. I enjoyed Feysand moments because they have their cute moments. I liked that beach scene a lot because I feel like it's important for relationships to have moments like that. I am also behind Rhysand on the High King thing because I DO NOT want him to be High King. We dont get Rhysand's perspective, so thankfully, we missed out on 400 mentions of my mate, but we did get a lot of Feyre's perspective. I was so scared that she was going to make Feyre only act as a mother and forget that she's super powerful and is also a High Lady, but I'm so glad that she did not do that because Feyre had that fire here, which I loved. Rhysand, I also liked. He was harsh, but he was super rational, and his decisions made sense 100%. Her, Rhys, and baby Nyx were soooo cute. I don't mind Feyre constantly mentioning breast leaking milk 😭 because she just gave birth to Nyx half a year ago, I think, and it would make sense for this to be mentioned, but it's done at the most weird times istg 😭 The smut scenes were so damn bad, like omg, I did not miss the smut chapters at all. The constant innuendo was so hard to read, and the sex scenes overall were an instant skim because I could not read borderline lactation kink pls 😭
Nesta and Cassian, GUYS 😭😭😭😭 I genuinely don't know how this happened BUT 😭😭😭 I LOVE NESTA?? Like, that's actually crazy. I was not fond of her at all. I think it's because she carried so much emotion in this book. She lowk carried the entire book on her back, so I will say thank you to her. I think I liked her so much more in this book because I agreed with her decision to give Bryce the mask. I know in the courts' eyes, it's a sign of betrayal, but it was the right choice. They knew it was the right choice, and they would have made the same choice if they had some time. Them being mad was justified, but them prolonging it was so damn stupid. Idewtt about Azriel rn because he NEEDS that desperate healing arc. Nesta did not deserve all the shit she got, especially from Cassian. Nesta single-handedly saved everyone's asses. Her scenes with Gwyn 😭 not this book living up to its name. I loved her and her bond with her sisters and her sisterhood. I loved how strong she was. Her single-handedly going against Bryaxis was so badass, and her drive to push against her abilities was so amazing to see. Also, Nesta clocking Elain at the end was so peaceful to see and was definitely needed, given how coddled she is. The next book will definitely have her as an integral part, given how it ended. Cassian is hard to hate, and I know that he's loyal to his High Lord, but some things are meant to be between you and your MATE. I think he should have the common sense to keep it that way, and also, him shutting her out for so long just pissed me off.
Amren and Mor, idc if I'm High Lord or Lady - if a 15000-year-old female comes up to me and says this wont work, and do this, I'll save my time and do that (no shade). Morrigan, the woman that you are. We got one slice of POV from her, and I ate it up. I cant wait for her book. I love her for slapping the shit out of Azriel and giving him shit because he DESERVED it. I'll be sending her prayers. Poor girl is stuck with Elain. I ALSO BETTER NOT HEAR ANY MOR IS EVIL allegations.
Gwyn, I'm super excited for where we are going with her character. There must be some importance to the highlight on the bonus chapter and her getting her own POV - I'm super excited. I don't think she's going to be evil as many think - Az calls himself a monster and a demon literally, so idt if Gwyn feels that, given how she has a traumatic past and how things are unraveling for her, is out of pocket. I think the second book's title also has to do something with her or the priestess in general. Idt SJM would use her in a villainous role, and also, isn't she based on her best friend?? Also she says she hates illyrian men but so does Az and cass 😭 and that she enjoyed killing those men in the rite but baby so did manon, lysandra, and aelin 😭 so let's not go there to justify her being a villain.
Lucien, I felt soooo bad for him, especially after I read his POV. This man has been nothing but kind and respectful, and I hate to see him being betrayed and broken like that.
Elain, omg, I hate her so much. She is the most useless character ever. I hate her with burning, raging passion, like I have not hated a character like her. She is so useless, like omg, and she says that don't coddle and don't infantilize me, and she gets herself in the worst position and then starts crying, like fucking crying. Bitch, what the fuck are you crying for?? Did you not think about the consequences at all?? Like, if she wants to sleep with Azriel, that's OKAY, she CAN, but like, have the decency to end things with your mate. Why is she stringing him around? I dOnT LiKe LuCiEn. I wAnT nOtHiNG tO dO WiTh HiM. Then break the damn bond and put both you and him out of that misery. She's actually so dumb, I can't, like she just pisses me off.
She says I can be useful and that she's a seer, but that stupid girl always talks in codes that by the time they figure things out, they would happen. I can see why no one asks her for help - also, she literally starts crying at every single thing. OMG, her victim complex is so strong, like she's also VERY much entitled and A RAGING PICK ME. Her going to Nesta and Feyre, apologizing for the plans she's destroyed because she knows they would forgive her, but when Nesta doesn't, she gets all defensive and starts backtracking, like bitch, weren't you here to apologize? ISTG SJM needs to do massive work on her character cuz I can't stand her character. ALSO, SHE'S A FUCKING SEER BUT HER DUMBASS IS CRYING 24/7 MAKING IT SO EASY FOR THE READERS TO FORGET THAT SHE HAS THINGS SHE CAN HELP WITH BUT OH NO ONE ASKS SO SHE WONT.
The romance, honestly 😭😭 this version of Azriel can stay the FUCK away from Gwyn. I don't think Elriel is endgame. If it is, I think there is a longggg way to go, LIKE a long way to go. Elain is in Vallahan, and I think her story will somehow tie up to Lucien's, while Azriel is in the House of Wind with Nesta. I think what's important here is that AZRIEL can get a proper arc and get his shit together and actually process his emotions and consider himself worthy of being loved because I'm sorry, their relationship felt super lusty. Not Azriel trying to open up, but Elain stops and says they should find a room to bang in, like hoe?? Is you fr?? Elain also needs to get her shit together. We need actual POV from her and to get inside her head and see what's going on so we can understand her. A majority of you havent read Tog and it shows 😭 sarah can easily switch up on who she wants as endgame. I do think with Azriel being in the House of Wind and his arc overlapping Gwyn's, I think that IN MY OPINION, there might be a high chance of that happening. Elucien 🫣 hopefully- idk, but hopefully.
Overall, I had fun ngl. It was messy and enjoyable.
Special mention to Areeba, Fiza and Hoda for going through this tough time with me
Special mention x2 for Shifu/Areeba for proof reading this review
___
Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel. Gwnyriel. Gwynriel.
Want to Read
March 19, 2021This book will most likely centre around the Inner Circle; a multi-POV that will introduce a wider story, and the focal point will be Elain Archeron, whether she will have a point of view in this book or the next.
Elain is an Acheron sister. The ACOTAR series is known for trios. SJM won't skip Elain for a new character (sorry), and there is a lot of textual evidence that points towards her.
Elain is a seer, which is what the next novel needs to locate the fourth trove to stop Koschei. There are pressing matters that are going on in the courts, and there is political tension. This is a fantasy series with serious issues going on, not a contemporary NA where the main couple has the time to get to know each other. This is ACOTAR. Elain and Azriel have already established a friendship, and their interactions are entangled with Lucien due to the mating bond.
Elain and Azriel's relationship has been foreshadowed since A Court of Mist and Fury and scattered throughout the series. In the bonus POV, Azriel made it obvious that he has feelings for Elain. Rhys had only told Azriel to stay away from her because it would trigger a blood duel with Lucien and potential war between courts. But Azriel admitted it would take him no effort to win that blood duel, meaning he is willing to fight for Elain.
Azriel had given Elain a personalized rose necklace that she returned due to Rhys's interruption, which is similar to how Cassian had given Nesta a gift during her first Winter Solstice (that she rejected), but they ultimately got together. Not to mention that Azriel had looked at and thought about Elain's gift to him for an entire year until the next one, when they exchanged gifts again.
Up until now, Elain has been visibly uncomfortable around Lucien. You can find that evidence throughout the series, and she told Lucien that he had betrayed them. She had never shown interest in him, but it is evident she is interested in Azriel, which is mutual. That is a setup for the next book, which would be about CHOICE.
Those who say Elain and Azriel's relationship would be obvious and cliché are missing the fact that two mated individuals (Elain and Lucien) getting together would also be obvious, cliché, and repetitive. Reading about choice and free will, choosing what you want instead of allowing "fate" to decide feels much more liberating to read. To say that Elain should be with Lucien because he is her mate is stripping her of the choice before she even gets to make it in her novel, so that argument is invalid.
Also, notice how Azriel has heightened hearing, and Elain can see things others can't. Azriel said in ACOWAR that they needed a seer. Both have special abilities that would be used for spying on other courts and kingdoms, which is most likely the plot for the next book, in addition to the blood duel and forbidden-love aspect and miscommunication trope, finding Koschei and the fourth trove, which would be one of Sarah's finest works.
Overall, I can't see Elain with Lucien when he told Elain they were mates right away, not giving her a choice, which was a mistake because, to Elain, choice matters. Usually, two people accept the bond normally when they are unaware of it; they become friends first and then lovers. Elucien is the only mating bond that had been known right away, which means it was doomed from the start because it makes them feel equally shackled.
Therefore, Elain most likely won't end up with a man who's a reminder of what was taken from her- a choice- the same person that ignored both their feelings. However, I do believe Lucien will be the person that supports her choice and encourages it, whatever it is, and I also believe he will be getting his own love interest that may have already been suggested.
As for Azriel and Gwyn. Gwyn deserves better than potentially receiving a second-hand gift from Azriel, whether Clotho had given it to her or not. Clotho knew it wasn't meant for her when she noticed how sad the Shadow-Singer's face was. That gift was meant for Elain. It was a rose necklace, and roses symbolize love, romance, and secrecy. Azriel had then gone to the House of Wind to distract himself from Elain. He thinks he doesn't deserve her, despite Elain returning those same feelings. Please don't ignore four books of build-up; you're just ignoring canon at this point.
But we'll see more in the next book.
Therefore, I have many reasons to believe that Elucien and Gwynriel are not endgame because SJM would have taken her time fleshing out/developing those ships in the previous novels. Instead, she suggested that they will be platonic friendships. For example, Elain is uncomfortable around Lucien, and Gwyn was someone Azriel trained with for a few scenes.
Now, to those who think Elain is boring, her character has not been fully fleshed out yet for a reason (because it's reserved for her own book). We will learn more about her, which is why we don't know much about her, but we know this: she's a seer, a flower-grower, a kingslayer, a hero of Prythian. That is by far impressive.
In Feyre's bonus POV after ACOSF, Rhys says, "We haven't yet seen all that she has to offer." And if you still think Elain's "boring" or "annoying," we don't know much about her. Some readers judge her before giving her a chance. Remember that Nesta was heavily hated prior to receiving her book; therefore, what makes you think Elain would not capture an audience? No one is asking you to read the books if you don't like Elain, so move on if that's not what YOU wanted. Mind you, the author gets to write what she wants to write; Elain haters do not dictate that at all.
To be frank, I am disappointed in the ACOTAR fandom for making sexist and misogynistic jokes about Gwyn and Elain, reducing their characters and worth to a ship. I've seen people compare their reproductive systems. Pliant bones? Not being able to have children? What are y'all on about?
***
Edit: I wrote this in 2021 & it's 2026. After finding out Sarah is writing three novels based on the same storyline, I believe ACOTAR 6 might be multi-POV, alluding to Elain and Azriel's story in ACOTAR 7. Since ACOTAR 6 is significantly smaller, it seems like it will be an introduction to a wider story. If ACOTAR 6 & 7 were about two couples, wouldn't you think they would be equal in pages? Also, Sarah had shared that this book is one whole story that could not be physically bound in one book.
Regardless, I am excited for Elain's story! Also, I love all the comments! Thank you <3.
Elain is an Acheron sister. The ACOTAR series is known for trios. SJM won't skip Elain for a new character (sorry), and there is a lot of textual evidence that points towards her.
Elain is a seer, which is what the next novel needs to locate the fourth trove to stop Koschei. There are pressing matters that are going on in the courts, and there is political tension. This is a fantasy series with serious issues going on, not a contemporary NA where the main couple has the time to get to know each other. This is ACOTAR. Elain and Azriel have already established a friendship, and their interactions are entangled with Lucien due to the mating bond.
Elain and Azriel's relationship has been foreshadowed since A Court of Mist and Fury and scattered throughout the series. In the bonus POV, Azriel made it obvious that he has feelings for Elain. Rhys had only told Azriel to stay away from her because it would trigger a blood duel with Lucien and potential war between courts. But Azriel admitted it would take him no effort to win that blood duel, meaning he is willing to fight for Elain.
Azriel had given Elain a personalized rose necklace that she returned due to Rhys's interruption, which is similar to how Cassian had given Nesta a gift during her first Winter Solstice (that she rejected), but they ultimately got together. Not to mention that Azriel had looked at and thought about Elain's gift to him for an entire year until the next one, when they exchanged gifts again.
Up until now, Elain has been visibly uncomfortable around Lucien. You can find that evidence throughout the series, and she told Lucien that he had betrayed them. She had never shown interest in him, but it is evident she is interested in Azriel, which is mutual. That is a setup for the next book, which would be about CHOICE.
Those who say Elain and Azriel's relationship would be obvious and cliché are missing the fact that two mated individuals (Elain and Lucien) getting together would also be obvious, cliché, and repetitive. Reading about choice and free will, choosing what you want instead of allowing "fate" to decide feels much more liberating to read. To say that Elain should be with Lucien because he is her mate is stripping her of the choice before she even gets to make it in her novel, so that argument is invalid.
Also, notice how Azriel has heightened hearing, and Elain can see things others can't. Azriel said in ACOWAR that they needed a seer. Both have special abilities that would be used for spying on other courts and kingdoms, which is most likely the plot for the next book, in addition to the blood duel and forbidden-love aspect and miscommunication trope, finding Koschei and the fourth trove, which would be one of Sarah's finest works.
Overall, I can't see Elain with Lucien when he told Elain they were mates right away, not giving her a choice, which was a mistake because, to Elain, choice matters. Usually, two people accept the bond normally when they are unaware of it; they become friends first and then lovers. Elucien is the only mating bond that had been known right away, which means it was doomed from the start because it makes them feel equally shackled.
Therefore, Elain most likely won't end up with a man who's a reminder of what was taken from her- a choice- the same person that ignored both their feelings. However, I do believe Lucien will be the person that supports her choice and encourages it, whatever it is, and I also believe he will be getting his own love interest that may have already been suggested.
As for Azriel and Gwyn. Gwyn deserves better than potentially receiving a second-hand gift from Azriel, whether Clotho had given it to her or not. Clotho knew it wasn't meant for her when she noticed how sad the Shadow-Singer's face was. That gift was meant for Elain. It was a rose necklace, and roses symbolize love, romance, and secrecy. Azriel had then gone to the House of Wind to distract himself from Elain. He thinks he doesn't deserve her, despite Elain returning those same feelings. Please don't ignore four books of build-up; you're just ignoring canon at this point.
But we'll see more in the next book.
Therefore, I have many reasons to believe that Elucien and Gwynriel are not endgame because SJM would have taken her time fleshing out/developing those ships in the previous novels. Instead, she suggested that they will be platonic friendships. For example, Elain is uncomfortable around Lucien, and Gwyn was someone Azriel trained with for a few scenes.
Now, to those who think Elain is boring, her character has not been fully fleshed out yet for a reason (because it's reserved for her own book). We will learn more about her, which is why we don't know much about her, but we know this: she's a seer, a flower-grower, a kingslayer, a hero of Prythian. That is by far impressive.
In Feyre's bonus POV after ACOSF, Rhys says, "We haven't yet seen all that she has to offer." And if you still think Elain's "boring" or "annoying," we don't know much about her. Some readers judge her before giving her a chance. Remember that Nesta was heavily hated prior to receiving her book; therefore, what makes you think Elain would not capture an audience? No one is asking you to read the books if you don't like Elain, so move on if that's not what YOU wanted. Mind you, the author gets to write what she wants to write; Elain haters do not dictate that at all.
To be frank, I am disappointed in the ACOTAR fandom for making sexist and misogynistic jokes about Gwyn and Elain, reducing their characters and worth to a ship. I've seen people compare their reproductive systems. Pliant bones? Not being able to have children? What are y'all on about?
***
Edit: I wrote this in 2021 & it's 2026. After finding out Sarah is writing three novels based on the same storyline, I believe ACOTAR 6 might be multi-POV, alluding to Elain and Azriel's story in ACOTAR 7. Since ACOTAR 6 is significantly smaller, it seems like it will be an introduction to a wider story. If ACOTAR 6 & 7 were about two couples, wouldn't you think they would be equal in pages? Also, Sarah had shared that this book is one whole story that could not be physically bound in one book.
Regardless, I am excited for Elain's story! Also, I love all the comments! Thank you <3.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Imagine finding an early copy days before publication anyhow
Pre read because i got myself a copy
—-
The cover looks like the instagram logo i was hoping for a yellow or sum
Pre read because i got myself a copy
—-
The cover looks like the instagram logo i was hoping for a yellow or sum
Want to Read
May 10, 2020I was waiting for Azriel and Elain but now I'm here for Az and Gwyn.
We got just one scene with them and I'm ready for the ship to sail!
Although, after reading HOSAB I don't even know what's going on anymore.
Also... can Eris get a bigger part in this book? I'm officially a fan.
We got just one scene with them and I'm ready for the ship to sail!
Although, after reading HOSAB I don't even know what's going on anymore.
Also... can Eris get a bigger part in this book? I'm officially a fan.
Want to Read
January 11, 2021if Azriel and Gwyn doesn’t end up together in this book I'll set myself on fire. Along with the book.
Want to Read
February 17, 2021this book is going to piss off half the fandom no matter which couple ends up being endgame lmao
Want to Read
February 23, 2021Let me be clear: I would rather die than see Az and Elain get together.
Want to Read
February 25, 2021OUR STORIES ARE WORTH TELLING. THE VALKYRIE CYCLE LETS GOOO ⚔️🩷🧚🏼♀️✨
Just a few more weeks to go 🥹
Just a few more weeks to go 🥹
Want to Read
March 5, 2026After mulling over it for what seems like hours, this one definitely seems like a bridge story. I doubt we're gonna take a full step into Elain's narrative instantly. Sure, we're gonna get her pov. But the art of storytelling is that it has to be consistent and coherent. And as much as we want to see the ship wars resolved, we left ACOSF with the Valkyries. It makes absolute sense, we continue the narrative from there. It makes sense that the story starts with Nesta, Emerie and Gwyn.
Elain has to actually step into the story in a proper narration to take the lead. And the wording for the blurb here matters, cause imo it suggests that there's going to be glimpses of her Cauldron experience which ties directly to Koschei. Now that's where you actually give her the frontal point to move.
And it also brings Azriel to more of a central MMC for the books. His character has a lot of loose threads that need to be strung along, starting with Eris and Mor; Elain; Gwyn and beyond that? His own Illyrian heritage that seems a wound waiting to be poked. Sure, some of the community has narrowed him down to shadows and wingspan but there's a lot of unresolved history that's about to blow up.
Amongst all that, HOFAS left him and Nesta with a lot of Dusk Court imagery and future... buildups. You gotta get things in order before we dive into any ship wars.
Elain has to actually step into the story in a proper narration to take the lead. And the wording for the blurb here matters, cause imo it suggests that there's going to be glimpses of her Cauldron experience which ties directly to Koschei. Now that's where you actually give her the frontal point to move.
And it also brings Azriel to more of a central MMC for the books. His character has a lot of loose threads that need to be strung along, starting with Eris and Mor; Elain; Gwyn and beyond that? His own Illyrian heritage that seems a wound waiting to be poked. Sure, some of the community has narrowed him down to shadows and wingspan but there's a lot of unresolved history that's about to blow up.
Amongst all that, HOFAS left him and Nesta with a lot of Dusk Court imagery and future... buildups. You gotta get things in order before we dive into any ship wars.
Want to Read
May 4, 20172/20/2021
Okay, so I am thinking this book will actually wind up being about Azriel. And I just have to say that I am now on board the Azriel and Gwyn ship, so fingers crossed it happens! Gwynriel for the win y’all 💖
I shall thus reserve all my Lucien predictions for book 6 LOL
--
12/9/2020
I think, at this point, the remaining full-length books will be about the remaining members of the night court. Maybe the novella will be about Lucien.
---
2016
Let this book be about Lucien!!!
He was so underutilized in both ACOMAF and ACOWAR. I need more Lucien in my life.
My fangirl hopes/predictions/theories:
But honestly, with Lucien's story, there is still so much to tell. Whether it’s his relationship with Elain, his fractured friendship with Tamlin, or his near non-existent relationship with his family. In ACOWAR, we were hit with two major Lucien-related realizations. Both of which he was not even privy to. I really hope Feyre tells him the truth, and I hope he cares enough to seek to confront those truths. Anyways, I want Lucien to mend fences and really grow as a character.
Okay, so I am thinking this book will actually wind up being about Azriel. And I just have to say that I am now on board the Azriel and Gwyn ship, so fingers crossed it happens! Gwynriel for the win y’all 💖
I shall thus reserve all my Lucien predictions for book 6 LOL
--
12/9/2020
I think, at this point, the remaining full-length books will be about the remaining members of the night court. Maybe the novella will be about Lucien.
---
2016
Let this book be about Lucien!!!
He was so underutilized in both ACOMAF and ACOWAR. I need more Lucien in my life.
My fangirl hopes/predictions/theories:
But honestly, with Lucien's story, there is still so much to tell. Whether it’s his relationship with Elain, his fractured friendship with Tamlin, or his near non-existent relationship with his family. In ACOWAR, we were hit with two major Lucien-related realizations. Both of which he was not even privy to. I really hope Feyre tells him the truth, and I hope he cares enough to seek to confront those truths. Anyways, I want Lucien to mend fences and really grow as a character.
Want to Read
February 25, 2021You know what, I was just thinking and I actually feel really bad for the author. Literally no matter which ship she decides on, she’s going to get so much hate by people. Even though these are her babies and her characters, whether she decides on Elriel or Gwynriel she’s bound to disappoint some of her fans and we all know that some people transform their disappointment to hate and cyber bullying. I’m talking about this now cz I was just online and I saw some comments that were truly appalling. I, myself would love for Az to end up with Gwyn but if that doesn’t happen, then for God’s sake people that definitely does NOT give me the right to hate on the author OR on the people who would be happy with the ship that Maas decided on. Either way, please just be nice y’all😂
_____________________________
🔹Random thoughts:
〰 Although it was hinted at in ACOMAF, my soul will leave my body and never return if this turns out to be about Azriel and Elain.
〰 I hope this isn’t a love triangle situation cz I would hate it. I kind of want the book to start with Az already moving on from Elain and starting to like Gwyn.
〰 If this book doesn’t have an Azriel and Gwyn Karaoke scene I will riot 🎤
〰 I want Gwyn to be a siren and I want us to explore life under the sea (maybe she will have some kind of connection to Tharion, who knows).
〰 I am so ready for all the drama that will unfold because of that stupid necklace lool.
〰 I read a theory that said that Gwyn is Tamlin’s daughter and the only thing I could think of is that the idea of Azriel being Tamlin’s son in law brings literal tears to my eyes.
〰 As the lovely Evelin has pointed out, Az’s shadows sing when they’re around Gwyn. I personally believe that they’re silent around Elain because they’re shriveling with disgust at the thought of their host touching that garden hose. The thought makes me happy😌
〰 Will add more once I think of other things lol.
_____________________________
🔹Random thoughts:
〰 Although it was hinted at in ACOMAF, my soul will leave my body and never return if this turns out to be about Azriel and Elain.
〰 I hope this isn’t a love triangle situation cz I would hate it. I kind of want the book to start with Az already moving on from Elain and starting to like Gwyn.
〰 If this book doesn’t have an Azriel and Gwyn Karaoke scene I will riot 🎤
〰 I want Gwyn to be a siren and I want us to explore life under the sea (maybe she will have some kind of connection to Tharion, who knows).
〰 I am so ready for all the drama that will unfold because of that stupid necklace lool.
〰 I read a theory that said that Gwyn is Tamlin’s daughter and the only thing I could think of is that the idea of Azriel being Tamlin’s son in law brings literal tears to my eyes.
〰 As the lovely Evelin has pointed out, Az’s shadows sing when they’re around Gwyn. I personally believe that they’re silent around Elain because they’re shriveling with disgust at the thought of their host touching that garden hose. The thought makes me happy😌
〰 Will add more once I think of other things lol.
Want to Read
February 19, 2021 *Spoilers for A Court Of Wings and Ruin *
Do you think there could be something between Elain and Mor? I know it's stupid and I don't even know why I thought of it, honestly 😂
Please God, LET IT BE AZRIEL AND GWYN ❤
Do you think there could be something between Elain and Mor? I know it's stupid and I don't even know why I thought of it, honestly 😂
Please God, LET IT BE AZRIEL AND GWYN ❤
Want to Read
February 18, 2021The wait might kill me...worth it.
Want to Read
August 20, 2026Wait a gosh dang minute. A title? A cover? A PUBLICATION DATE?
IS THIS FINALLY HAPPENING?!?
Ps. I might be in the minority BUT bring back the old covers! When was corporate logos with white text ever the aesthetic?
UPDATE: FOR ALL THOSE WHO HATE THE NEW COVERS:
The same artist StarsThatDreamShop who redid the A Court of Silvered Flames cover to match the old style has let me know that she's going to redo these covers as well. Hallelujah.
Her previous work:
IS THIS FINALLY HAPPENING?!?
Ps. I might be in the minority BUT bring back the old covers! When was corporate logos with white text ever the aesthetic?
UPDATE: FOR ALL THOSE WHO HATE THE NEW COVERS:
The same artist StarsThatDreamShop who redid the A Court of Silvered Flames cover to match the old style has let me know that she's going to redo these covers as well. Hallelujah.
Her previous work:
Want to Read
July 14, 2018MOTHER ABOVE!
BY THE WYRD!
CAULDRON SAVE ME!
MORE MAAS BOOKS!!
BY THE WYRD!
CAULDRON SAVE ME!
MORE MAAS BOOKS!!
Review of advance copy
So I get the whole point of this particular story/title is that allies and people are splintering the harmony they'd previously had to set up the next two books...but one issue I have with this author in particular (and I say this as a lifelong fan of her work) is that sometimes she'll write characters that to ME seem OOC to further the plot. Instead of writing what narratively fits that character, she'll have the character act the way she wants to in that moment regardless of it makes sense or not. Idk if I'm wording this well, but hopefully you get what I mean.
I also didn't like how many POV's this one had...if this is essentially Volume 1 of a BIG big book, it didn't set up to me too clearly what to expect in the next one? Why did we not get an Elain POV when the other sisters had their own story?
SJM has talked for years now about writing and planning for Elain's book, only to make her share her story with like ten other POVs? She has SO much story to tell, we know next to nothing about her seer powers, if she has any others? Why does the cauldron favor her so much? Will she break the mating bond? Will a blood duel happen? Will she follow where her heart seems to be leading even if it's forbidden? I had such high expectations for this one and the only time we really see Elain get a chance to speak up is through Mor at the very end. Like, Mor? Really? You couldn't make that last POV Elain to set up her story?
It just really felt like Elain is the punching bag of this fandom and author, who repeatedly made her out to be the bad guy in this book when it was NOT necessary while at the same time pandering to the boy moms of the fandom by giving Lucien and Azriel POV's to make them more sympathetic than the girl in the triangle....
I truly understand that an Elain POV is 100% probably happening in the next book, but is it really even going to be satisfying when she's sharing her story with everyone else? How much focus will she really be able to get with so much going on? I don't understand why we couldn't have made this next book all Elain and then the final one multiple POV to wrap things up? I digress.
I STILL don't care about Nesta and Cassian as a couple and maybe SJM isn't done with their story but I was just bored with their repeated problems and they still don't seem like a good fit to me. Also controversial opinion since I know so many love Nesta to death, but I just don't care to have more of her POV at this time, we JUST had a huge book of her and she's still getting this much focus? I don't mind her playing a part as a side but again, can we move onto something new?
I did enjoy seeing Feyre as a mom and how she didn't lose her ambition and worth and focus as a character just because she suddenly became a mom, that was probably the highlight of the book to me. I had missed being in her head.
Idk, I just feel let down with the direction of this series going forward and I worry that her best writing may be behind her. I hope SJM proves me wrong.
I also didn't like how many POV's this one had...if this is essentially Volume 1 of a BIG big book, it didn't set up to me too clearly what to expect in the next one? Why did we not get an Elain POV when the other sisters had their own story?
SJM has talked for years now about writing and planning for Elain's book, only to make her share her story with like ten other POVs? She has SO much story to tell, we know next to nothing about her seer powers, if she has any others? Why does the cauldron favor her so much? Will she break the mating bond? Will a blood duel happen? Will she follow where her heart seems to be leading even if it's forbidden? I had such high expectations for this one and the only time we really see Elain get a chance to speak up is through Mor at the very end. Like, Mor? Really? You couldn't make that last POV Elain to set up her story?
It just really felt like Elain is the punching bag of this fandom and author, who repeatedly made her out to be the bad guy in this book when it was NOT necessary while at the same time pandering to the boy moms of the fandom by giving Lucien and Azriel POV's to make them more sympathetic than the girl in the triangle....
I truly understand that an Elain POV is 100% probably happening in the next book, but is it really even going to be satisfying when she's sharing her story with everyone else? How much focus will she really be able to get with so much going on? I don't understand why we couldn't have made this next book all Elain and then the final one multiple POV to wrap things up? I digress.
I STILL don't care about Nesta and Cassian as a couple and maybe SJM isn't done with their story but I was just bored with their repeated problems and they still don't seem like a good fit to me. Also controversial opinion since I know so many love Nesta to death, but I just don't care to have more of her POV at this time, we JUST had a huge book of her and she's still getting this much focus? I don't mind her playing a part as a side but again, can we move onto something new?
I did enjoy seeing Feyre as a mom and how she didn't lose her ambition and worth and focus as a character just because she suddenly became a mom, that was probably the highlight of the book to me. I had missed being in her head.
Idk, I just feel let down with the direction of this series going forward and I worry that her best writing may be behind her. I hope SJM proves me wrong.
Want to Read
February 12, 2021this better be elriel
Want to Read
March 5, 2021ACOSF SPOILERS
March 5th: ⇢ Gwyn and Azriel, that's all I'm asking for. They are perfect 😌
⇢ Elain is extremely boring, I'm not interested in her story at all. Let her die or something.
⇢ I demand Tamlin’s redemption and Rhysand’s last name (stop playing with us, SJM).
⇢ Eris seems nice, I want to know his background story with Mor.
⇢ Are you telling me that Emerie and Mor could be mates? Are you seriously telling me that SJM could write their story? That’s definitely a plot twist 🧐
March 5th: ⇢ Gwyn and Azriel, that's all I'm asking for. They are perfect 😌
⇢ Elain is extremely boring, I'm not interested in her story at all. Let her die or something.
⇢ I demand Tamlin’s redemption and Rhysand’s last name (stop playing with us, SJM).
⇢ Eris seems nice, I want to know his background story with Mor.
⇢ Are you telling me that Emerie and Mor could be mates? Are you seriously telling me that SJM could write their story? That’s definitely a plot twist 🧐
breathlessly-anticipating
August 22, 2026Give me elriel fucking or fucking give me elriel I need them one way or another sjm I’ve been waiting too damn long
Want to Read
December 30, 2020Gwynriel is coming home to ME 🥹
Want to Read
February 17, 2021azriel’s bonus scene has got me on my knees🧎🏽♀️
Want to Read
February 21, 2021Since there seems to be a lot of hate going around when it comes to the Azriel/Elain ship, let me throw them some love here - I would LOVE to read about Azriel and Elain's relationship!
Is it kind of cheesy if all three sisters get together with the three 'brothers' of the Night Court? Sure. Do I care? Hell no. Give me some pining and forbidden love and Elain becoming a badass seer and Azriel opening up to her and also everyone else minding their own business when it comes to their relationship. That would be so nice.
P.S. no hate to Gwyn, I really like the girl. But for me, it's kind of...odd with everything she went through, to have her entire purpose in a book potentially be just about a guy. But that's just me.
Alright, I'm going to go wait (not so) patiently for this book to come out. For the love of God, please let it be in a year and not three. <3
Is it kind of cheesy if all three sisters get together with the three 'brothers' of the Night Court? Sure. Do I care? Hell no. Give me some pining and forbidden love and Elain becoming a badass seer and Azriel opening up to her and also everyone else minding their own business when it comes to their relationship. That would be so nice.
P.S. no hate to Gwyn, I really like the girl. But for me, it's kind of...odd with everything she went through, to have her entire purpose in a book potentially be just about a guy. But that's just me.
Alright, I'm going to go wait (not so) patiently for this book to come out. For the love of God, please let it be in a year and not three. <3
Want to Read
February 21, 2021Give me elriel or give me death
Want to Read
March 18, 2021The rage i will feel if SJM publishes Cresent City #2 before this one
And yes i expect this to be an 800 page ode to my husband Azriel.
I'll cry if we get anything less
And yes i expect this to be an 800 page ode to my husband Azriel.
I'll cry if we get anything less
Want to Read
February 20, 2021Please let this be about Azriel and Elain.
***
Update (March 13/26):
I still need this book to be about Azriel and Elain. I don’t see Azriel and Gwyn at all and I will be so disappointed if it is.
Three sisters, three stories and this is how it should be. It would be so fascinating to read about a relationship that prevails without a mating bond.
#elriel ♾️
***
Update (July 31/26):
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE HAVE THIS BOOK BE ABOUT AZRIEL AND ELAIN. I swear I will riot if it is not.
***
Update (March 13/26):
I still need this book to be about Azriel and Elain. I don’t see Azriel and Gwyn at all and I will be so disappointed if it is.
Three sisters, three stories and this is how it should be. It would be so fascinating to read about a relationship that prevails without a mating bond.
#elriel ♾️
***
Update (July 31/26):
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE HAVE THIS BOOK BE ABOUT AZRIEL AND ELAIN. I swear I will riot if it is not.
Want to Read
August 7, 2026SHAKING WITH EXCITEMENTT
smut pls and thank you. begging shamelessly. also only that with gwyn....or make him gay and get him with eris. but if I see that elain bitch anywhere near az ill sue.
smut pls and thank you. begging shamelessly. also only that with gwyn....or make him gay and get him with eris. but if I see that elain bitch anywhere near az ill sue.
Want to Read
April 14, 2021
interested-in
March 5, 2026keep Elain away from Azriel .. PLEASE I BEG
Want to Read
February 21, 2021What I hope SJM avoids:
1- A love triangle (Elain can end up with whomever just please no feelings for 2 people at once..)
2- Another mission only Elain or Az (I'm supposing this book is about one of them at least) "can do" gets old after using it in every damn series.
3- A magic, that has no clear rules, resolving our problems
What I hope SJm does:
AZ AND GWYN RELATIONSHIP. PLEASE. I BEG YOU.
1- A love triangle (Elain can end up with whomever just please no feelings for 2 people at once..)
2- Another mission only Elain or Az (I'm supposing this book is about one of them at least) "can do" gets old after using it in every damn series.
3- A magic, that has no clear rules, resolving our problems
What I hope SJm does:
AZ AND GWYN RELATIONSHIP. PLEASE. I BEG YOU.
Want to Read
February 16, 202102/16/2021: I’m an emotional wreck after finishing ACoSF and now it’s time for me to obsess over the next book. Azriel, baby it’s your time to shine!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 858 reviews