For the Haters versus Lovers of this book
Let me start with Haters, their reasoning..
All the haters are correct that this book contains lot of cliches with no actual tutorial on how to build your own system. A lot of chapters are anecdotes, famous quotes, and even baseball analogies that seem awfully far stretched from trading. All of the complaints are correct, and I wouldn't argue with any of them.
Let me end with why this book is the ultimate book for learning about trend following...
I can imagine that most people who hate on this book, carry the same attitude in life toward anything they endeavor on. The haters simply wanted to be told a very specific method so they can start using and quit their mundane jobs and all become millionaires.
Any hater who superficially scan for the holy grail will be disappointed, of course they will, because they can't think long enough about why this book was written.
Imagine if Michael Jordan publishes a book about his success, and you purchase it and get disappointed why Jordan didn't include his holy grail for his basketball success. How would you feel if your friend complained that Jordan didn't tell people specifically how he succeeded?
The ultimate truth is, trading is pretty much like a sport, can't be taught but it can be learned, through numerous trial-and-error, self doubting and endless nights of questioning.
Richard Dennis once said, he could publish all his rules in news paper and no one would use it.
Alexander Elder and Tom Basso discovered that entry really didn't matter, as long as exits are well taken care of.
William Eckhardt said that emotional intelligence is probably the determining factor in trading success.
Anyone can starting using the rules published in Covel's complete turtle book, the 4 week high entry with 2x ATR price stop coupled with perhaps 20day moving average time stop. But to which extent are you able to use that system perfectly depending primarily on your ability to stick to the system without doubting.
Of course time-to-time you will modify the system due to new experience gained.
But the specific setup, there is no holy grail.
Covel's book is good in inspiring people who already have a deep understanding of trend following, however it does not serve to teach you how to trend follow. Much like no basketball player will teach you specifically how to cross and shake an opponent, because it's not possible to teach. Any book promising to teach you how to pick up chicks at a bar are usually charlatan who's making false promises.
No skills whatsoever in any arena in life can be taught. The best hackers are self taught, the best photoshop users are self taught, the best rappers are self taught. The idea that someone can transfer his/her knowledge to you through a speech/book is just nonsense. Experience cannot be replaced by simply reading a book, or listening to audiobook on Youtube.
My reasons why I love this book:
Because it shows that trend following works, and it makes sense to me. Trend following system hibernates during ranging period that whipsaw, forcing you to trade smaller and smaller using the 1%/2% equity risk rule, and makes you trade larger during trending period. The purchasing power is well protected/preserved during unfavorable market. If this doesn't make sense to you then I don't know what makes sense.
Trend following does not discriminate against any asset classes, or previous highs/lows. Any trending signal will be picked up and force the trader to ride until it dies down. Any news, fundamental figures, comments from analyst are ignored because trend followers expect that future cannot be predicted but trend won't stop until it "stops". This makes total sense to me and I'm happy to put my money on the line because it sounds logical.
Conclusion:
Don't pick up this book if you're hoping to be taught and transformed into a trend following trader and start making millions, you won't, just like any book that teach you how to pick up chicks and dating won't transform you into an alpha male with super jacked muscle.
Do read this book if you want an extensive background info on why trend following works, and how the successful traders look at the markets.
You have to ultimately put in the work to gain that experience to succeed as a trader, which isn't easy, and 99% of us retail traders won't make it there.
But any arena in life is like that. However it is worth a try isn't it? You have your dreams waiting for you right?