Prairie Style is about the breakdown of location and voice. It lays out a landscape of habitations (Frank Lloyd Wright's designs for "servantless families," fox dens in an embankment, the two-mile long face of Chicago’s Robert Taylor public housing project, etc.) and crosses and recrosses the line between poetry and prose. The book is an acknowledgment of the “terrible frankness” of color, pleasure’s distance, and the similarity of equivocation and argument. Prairie Style is the turn inland. “Inland, one needs something more racial, say bigger, than mountains.”
The direction going out--in the business past direction then and avoiding love's blunt teeth there. Done with houses and wanting to be seen as a boundary or as a line of plot re-appearing, done with all that too. Houses cleave and, to me, it all gets hammered out in overstatement-- love's a terror, a revelation cleaving to contours. Love's a terror, in town and out of town too.
I was an unqualified marker, some days the ache of an implicit region. Nothing to the bear but bad hair. Having missed the trace the first time through I found coming a specificity hard to pronounce: rive of unaccented speech, a single voice to mark it all off. Well this is namelessness up here, this inward, and nothing but the curl will do.
Love's over there, to me, the old terror.
PRAIRIE STYLE
A sexual image about the prairie ought to be a good idea: it'd have no meaning in a larger context and its existence, furiously local, might make outline itself a high level of vernacular--the image might be the sum of dire and hopeless songs, more of an after-image really. Love might be, in general, a revelation but sex could have a shape or a figure with which one could remember it; the speaker could recognize it or could himself cause recognition to occur. Love might be a terror-- the hesitation past town--but sex could be content and outline both, until the watcher (or the listener) turns away.
Male, female. Black men say trim. An outline's sameness is, finally, a reference. Towns, at a distance, are that--how they appear at first, a dim cluster, and then from five or six miles off; how they look when you're only three miles away. Inbetween sightings is the prairie itself to get across: trek, trace, the trick of landscape. Love suffers its wish- fulness--it's an allegorical value and the speaker mimes allegory with descriptions of yearning, like the prairie's joke on us (among us). In- land's a name, a factory, something to say; the thing upon which the image verges, the thing push articulates.
Prairie Style is a reference to Frank Lloyd Wright’s architectural approach, but it is also a reference to any architecture, or property, such as the Robert Taylor homes of south Chicago, and the prairie of southern Illinois, where the poet lived for many years. A middle section is about Indianapolis, so these prairies are Midwest. The collection is a series of prose poems, reflections, sometimes lyrical, about location, language, voice, race. In his acknowledgements section he thanks Amtrak, where he wrote some of it. Railroads span geography. Music is also central, deft observation, and a wry sense of humor in places.
"If you put a monster in a big town there’ll be a story you can open like a book but you need the town, the monster being just old terror without it—a roaming hull, a speech balloon. You need a grid (for temptation to have come to location). I’d be the same whether I tried to get closer to love or not; I’d dawdle or I’d inch in, either way. Let love rub itself up against pleasure. You need some boulevards for the monster to cross like he was anybody coming through the camp."
An interesting collision of themes--black identity in the midwest, external space as an extension of internal state, love and desire as separate and in interaction, a historical colony of black settlers called the Tribe of Ishmael, and a strange surreal Guardian-of-the-Abyss or Trickster-type at the beginning of the book named Mistah Fox. And the book is chock-full of gorgeous single lines, arresting images. And while the threads of thought are expansive and marvelous, Giscombe's meditations feel like they are written in a sort of impenetrable shorthand -- not a problem if length of inquiry allows me syntactical/vernacular and topical entry. But the space between these ideas, points of obsession, whatever you want to call them, gaped. The more time I spent trying to find the lines of thought between two points, the reason they sat together, the greater that space yawned. On any combination of these ideas, I would have loved to see an extended and concentrated inquiry. Prairie style strikes me as a sprawling and highly idiosyncratic meditation. Just not really my jam.
Giscombe's prose poetic line in PS is spare yet sinuously jazzy, flat yet monumental, befitting a mid-American landscape in which the plane surface is the template and the high place but a mirage. See my review of Prairie Style in the Summer 2009 on-line edition of Rain Taxi at http://www.raintaxi.com/online/2009su....
Interested in subject but not how related. Could understand on a conceptual level the gaps, the prose style and am never afraid of difficulty but found this flat. I know that prairies are flat but not really. Should maybe read Giscombe Road instead? Or am I missing something?
This is the best book of poetry I've read in a long while, and this probably has something to do with the instant friction established with location . in giscombe, language is it's own landscape that gets peopled and spoken in, in a rhetoric of argument that is shifty in it's terms. and there is a fascinating study of Authority here, how does the voice of authority operate and how to craft a universe in the poem that both reveals and subjects and yearns to shed. the underpinnings of power. eros weaves his way in between the foxes & monsters and is, himself, a fox & monster. history appears as (i want to say character, but seemingly history is more permanent than character here) location . history as locality & we are reminded the roots of the Nazis eugenics were on this land, when we steralized the Tribe of Ishmael and the Native Americans and the Blacks. in these poems, language is a flat monument somehow erected. and for 'somehow' you'll just have to read yrself.
from DOWNSTATE:
If you put a monster in a big town there'll be a story you can open like a book but you need the town, the monster being just old terror without it--a roaming hull, a speech baloon. You need a grid (for temptation to have come to location). I'd be the same whether I tried to get closer to love or not; I'd dawdle or I'd inch in, either way. Let love rub itself up against pleasure. You need some boulevards for the monster to cross like he was anybody coming through the camp.
Deceptive like the flatness of the prairie, where a town on the horizon, what you can distinguish, seems so near, where a word of ordinary speech, what you know, seems so understandable, is not. This book uses a vocabulary, recognizable as part of the Giscombe lexicon from his earlier books but which is honed here in its multiplicity of meanings, to discuss issues of locale and people living there, here the relationship of African Americans to the Midwest: the vernacular, the humor playing with expectation and stereotype, placement in city spaces, the values of these spaces. He meditates on love and sound in their own abstract qualities and associates such as eros and music, but then grounds them in the fox and cornet.
Language and location intertwine throughout C.S. Giscombe's Prairie Style, allowing the reader to see language as a landscape. The prairie seems both visible and invisible, drawing the reader to the immense horizon in the distance, and to the fox trotting at their feet.
I wasn't overly fond of this book until reading 'Giscombe Road,' which rendered it somewhat less opaque and made other parts stand out as strikingly odd in relation to the earlier book.