Summary: This is JK Rowling’s contemporary crime series, featuring private detectives Cormoran Strike and Robin Ellacott. He’s a rough-edged former MP[1] who lost a leg in Afghanistan, she’s an office temp who’s long harbored a secret dream of being an investigator. Together they fight crime, and support each other through various personal crises with friendship and mutual respect. Through all three books, there is a running thread of the toxic effects of fame, both on the famous and on those in their orbit. I don’t know if this is deliberate, or just indicative of what Rowling considers a compelling motivator of murderous intent. (It is something I expect she probably has some direct experience with. Toxic effects of fame, I mean, not murder.) Either way, it provides a unifying theme for the series.
That being said, the heart and soul of these books is not the crime; it’s the characters and their mutually supportive relationship. While Cormoran and Robin are quite different on the surface, they have a lot in common. They are both highly observant and intelligent. They both have had shitty long-term romantic relationships (in the first book, Strike has just left his emotionally abusive partner of 16 years; Robin is still with her douche-y fiance in Book 3). Moreover, both their lives have been shaped by trauma (and both of them deny it), and they both motivated by a passion for justice and for uncovering the truth.
Thoughts: These books are great. They’re about as far from Harry Potter as you can get, in terms of subject matter (thus the pseudonym). The murders are all pretty gruesome, so they’re not for everyone, but I recommend them to anyone who likes detective fiction of the hard-boiled or procedural varieties, and who also likes good character drama. Both Strike and Robin are well-drawn, complex characters in their own right. One of the pleasures of reading these books is seeing Robin’s development from an office temp with ambitions into a skilled investigator. Somewhat less pleasurable (but still on the uplifting side) is watching her defy and overcome her fiance’s attempts to undermine her confidence. He’s not abusive like Strike’s ex, but he’s the type of insecure man who builds himself up by subtly knocking other people down. Hopefully she’ll dump him for good, one of these books. As for Strike, he struggles with the demons of an unstable childhood and an abusive relationship that he doesn’t even recognize as such. Which sounds like a well-trodden and tiresome path until I tell you that all that shit didn’t make him into an angsty temperamental brooder. Rather, he’s well aware of the ways his fucked-up past can influence his thinking in bad ways, and makes a conscious effort to prevent it from doing so. His past, along with his disability, creates a sense of vulnerability about the character, which makes him far more interesting than the standard-issue gruff detective he could have been in a lesser writer’s hands. And what’s best is that the relationship between the two principals is one of earned mutual support and respect, with a minimum of macho bullshit from Strike, and a minimum of damselry on her part.
One thing to note: Whether or not you like Harry Potter, will have little to no bearing on whether you’ll like these books. They are very different, written for a completely different audience.
[1] MP=Military Police, not Member of Parliament.
Escapist Rating: 4/4
Recommended for: People who like detective fiction with a strong character element, people who like intricate murder mysteries
Dis-Recommended for: People who can't stand depictions of gruesome murder or violence against women