What do you think?
Rate this book
Second Chances
SECOND CHANCES, an anthology featuring four reissued novellas by New York Times bestselling author, Mary Balogh.
Another Dream
Eleanor Thompson, spinster owner and headmistress of a girls' school in Bath, finds herself somewhat lonely and not as happy with her chosen way of life as she had expected. Then, on her way to help celebrate the birthday of the Duke of Bewcastle, her brother-in-law, she is stranded by a storm at a country inn, where she indulges in a brief, sweet flirtation with a gentleman who is also stranded there with his two young children. Neither adult realizes that they are bound for the same house party.
The Treasure Hunt
Constance Manning is eagerly looking forward to her twentieth birthday, when her secret engagement to the man who has been her dearest friend all her life is finally to be revealed to her family and friends. He is having second thoughts, however, and persuades his brother to go in his stead and make his excuses—the brother who has long loved Constance without her knowledge.
The Forbidden Daffodils
For five years Kate Buchanan has been living in exile with her aunts in a remote part of Wales. She has come to love them and the place and has convinced herself that she is happy with her quiet life. But her hard-won peace is put to the test when the Marquess of Ashendon takes up residence nearby—the very man who caused her banishment.
The Betrothal Ball
The Earl of Dearborne had returned to his country home to host a house party and pay court to the beautiful daughter of one of his guests. Laura Melfort, his ward’s governess, is everything he most abhors in a woman. She is intelligent and well-read as well as being plainly dressed and unalluring. Yet it is the governess to whose company he finds himself repeatedly drawn. And it is the governess with whom he chooses to waltz at his own betrothal ball.
330 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 5, 2019
307 people are currently reading
486 people want to read
About the author
Mary Balogh
200 books6,343 followersMary Jenkins was born in 1944 in Swansea, Wales, UK. After graduating from university, moved to Saskatchewan, Canada, to teach high school English, on a two-year teaching contract in 1967. She married her Canadian husband, Robert Balogh, and had three children, Jacqueline, Christopher and Sian. When she's not writing, she enjoys reading, music and knitting. She also enjoys watching tennis and curling.
Mary Balogh started writing in the evenings as a hobby. Her first book, a Regency love story, was published in 1985 as A Masked Deception under her married name. In 1988, she retired from teaching after 20 years to pursue her dream to write full-time. She has written more than seventy novels and almost thirty novellas since then, including the New York Times bestselling 'Slightly' sextet and 'Simply' quartet. She has won numerous awards, including Bestselling Historical of the Year from the Borders Group, and her novel Simply Magic was a finalist in the Quill Awards. She has won seven Waldenbooks Awards and two B. Dalton Awards for her bestselling novels, as well as a Romantic Times Lifetime Achievement Award.
Mary Balogh started writing in the evenings as a hobby. Her first book, a Regency love story, was published in 1985 as A Masked Deception under her married name. In 1988, she retired from teaching after 20 years to pursue her dream to write full-time. She has written more than seventy novels and almost thirty novellas since then, including the New York Times bestselling 'Slightly' sextet and 'Simply' quartet. She has won numerous awards, including Bestselling Historical of the Year from the Borders Group, and her novel Simply Magic was a finalist in the Quill Awards. She has won seven Waldenbooks Awards and two B. Dalton Awards for her bestselling novels, as well as a Romantic Times Lifetime Achievement Award.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
December 4, 2025
It’s hard to rate the whole book because the first novella was nice and the others were… not. But since I read it for Eleanor’s story and the rest was just bonus, I’m giving it three stars. I’m in a generous mood today.
Another Dream ⭑ ⭑ ⭑ ⭑
Eleanor’s story was so saccharine sweet that I have a toothache now. But I don’t care, sweet is good.
————
Treasure Hunt ⭑ but actually no stars at all…
He tried to kiss her when she wasn’t even 16 and he was 24 🤮🤮🤮
But his lips had only grazed her cheek because she had turned her head in panic, and had torn her hand from his arm and made a sound that was not quite squeak, not quite scream, but an approximation of both. “Don’t be frightened,” he had said, grasping her arm, and smiling at her—as he would have smiled at a very young child. “You are too young, aren’t you, Constance? Just a child still. You had better run along and play with Sidney.” She had run. And felt dreadful humiliation for days afterward.
This isn’t romantic, Mary, this is assault.
————
The Forbidden Daffodils ⭑
What did this story teach us, dear children? Yes, we learned that when a lady says ‘no,’ she actually means ‘yes.’ We also learned that there’s a fine line between romance and stalking.
————
The Betrothal Ball ⭑ ⭑
Also known as me and #metoo.
Another Dream ⭑ ⭑ ⭑ ⭑
Eleanor’s story was so saccharine sweet that I have a toothache now. But I don’t care, sweet is good.
————
Treasure Hunt ⭑ but actually no stars at all…
He tried to kiss her when she wasn’t even 16 and he was 24 🤮🤮🤮
But his lips had only grazed her cheek because she had turned her head in panic, and had torn her hand from his arm and made a sound that was not quite squeak, not quite scream, but an approximation of both. “Don’t be frightened,” he had said, grasping her arm, and smiling at her—as he would have smiled at a very young child. “You are too young, aren’t you, Constance? Just a child still. You had better run along and play with Sidney.” She had run. And felt dreadful humiliation for days afterward.
This isn’t romantic, Mary, this is assault.
————
The Forbidden Daffodils ⭑
What did this story teach us, dear children? Yes, we learned that when a lady says ‘no,’ she actually means ‘yes.’ We also learned that there’s a fine line between romance and stalking.
————
The Betrothal Ball ⭑ ⭑
Also known as me and #metoo.
November 30, 2025
I want to thank my Goodreads friend Jan for recommending the novella Another Dream to me. It's one of four Balogh novellas in this eBook and the only one covered in this review. The story takes place five years after the Duke of Bewcastle (Wulfric Bedwyn) marries Christine Thompson. It's a great short story.
If a person's read the sixth Bedwyn series book, Slightly Dangerous, then the reader should already be familiar with FMC Eleanor Thompson. Eleanor is Christine's older sister and is a 39 year old spinster. Christine is hosting a two week house party at Lindsey Hall, the Duke's estate in Hampshire, to celebrate Wulfric's 40th birthday. All of the Bedwyn and Thompson family members and close friends are invited. Eleanor is being transported from Bath to Hampshire when a storm arises and they are forced to stop at an inn for the night. At this inn, Eleanor meets 40 year old MMC Michael Benning (a/k/a the Earl of Staunton) when his daughter escapes her room and makes friends with Miss Thompson in the dining hall of the inn.
Normally, Wulfric is the scene stealer in the Bedwyn books. He is in this one also, but Georgette Benning definitely gives him a run for his money! The little girl is Earl Staunton's daughter. She's ten years old going on 35. After getting to know Eleanor, she decides to play matchmaker between Miss Thompson and her father. She also enlists the aid of her six year old little bother Robert, to assist in the process.
When Lord Staunton (a widower) and Eleanor Thompson meet, he finds her attractive but notices that she is older and wiser than the younger women who made their debuts during the recently ended "season." While they share a good conversation, neither one discloses exactly where they're headed. But the reader knows. So it's no surprise when both parties show up at Lindsey Hall for the two week house party.
It's a great story where the Duke, as always, figures out and fixes what other character's maneuver's are up to. In this case it's Lady Connaught and her daughter, Miss Everly. These two women provide "tension" in the story that kept this reader turning the pages.
I liked Georgette the best though. This little girl absolutely makes the story work.
Again, thank you Jan for recommending this novella. It was the icing on top of the cake that was Wulfric and Christine's story that I read not that long ago. So everything from Slightly Dangerous was still fresh in my memory.
A solid five stars.
If a person's read the sixth Bedwyn series book, Slightly Dangerous, then the reader should already be familiar with FMC Eleanor Thompson. Eleanor is Christine's older sister and is a 39 year old spinster. Christine is hosting a two week house party at Lindsey Hall, the Duke's estate in Hampshire, to celebrate Wulfric's 40th birthday. All of the Bedwyn and Thompson family members and close friends are invited. Eleanor is being transported from Bath to Hampshire when a storm arises and they are forced to stop at an inn for the night. At this inn, Eleanor meets 40 year old MMC Michael Benning (a/k/a the Earl of Staunton) when his daughter escapes her room and makes friends with Miss Thompson in the dining hall of the inn.
Normally, Wulfric is the scene stealer in the Bedwyn books. He is in this one also, but Georgette Benning definitely gives him a run for his money! The little girl is Earl Staunton's daughter. She's ten years old going on 35. After getting to know Eleanor, she decides to play matchmaker between Miss Thompson and her father. She also enlists the aid of her six year old little bother Robert, to assist in the process.
When Lord Staunton (a widower) and Eleanor Thompson meet, he finds her attractive but notices that she is older and wiser than the younger women who made their debuts during the recently ended "season." While they share a good conversation, neither one discloses exactly where they're headed. But the reader knows. So it's no surprise when both parties show up at Lindsey Hall for the two week house party.
It's a great story where the Duke, as always, figures out and fixes what other character's maneuver's are up to. In this case it's Lady Connaught and her daughter, Miss Everly. These two women provide "tension" in the story that kept this reader turning the pages.
I liked Georgette the best though. This little girl absolutely makes the story work.
Again, thank you Jan for recommending this novella. It was the icing on top of the cake that was Wulfric and Christine's story that I read not that long ago. So everything from Slightly Dangerous was still fresh in my memory.
A solid five stars.
November 6, 2025
Re-read 11/2025
Another Dream and The Forbidden Daffodils are favourite comfort reads for me, I simply adore them.
Treasure Hunt and The Betrothal Ball are nice but forgettable.
-----------------
Re-read in part 01/2023:
-ANOTHER DREAM is one of the most beautiful hr novellas for me. I'm in awe how the author manages to entertain me with her words and characters. Love this so so much.
I'll come back to this soon enough, it just makes me feel so good.
5 stars.
-Love the novella THE FORBIDDEN DAFFODILS sooooo much.
5 stars.
-------
04/2022
ANOTHER DREAM:
I loved being back with the Bedwyns, and I loved so much that I got to see more of Eleanor! Reading Slightly Dangerous I had hoped for her own book, but since Another Dream is not listed as part of the Bedwyn - series, I just came across it by chance, having bought some books by Mary Balogh each with 4 short stories.
This is with 121 pages the longest of the 4 stories in the book Second Chances.
I'm so happy I found Eleanor 's book!
I really truly loved it.
The characters, the writing style, the emotions... but most of all I loved Georgette.
Definitely one of my favorite installments in the Bedwyn series.
5 stars.
TREASURE HUNT:
A rather quick read, just 77 pages, but nevertheless entertaining.
4 stars.
THE FORBIDDEN DAFFODILS:
It's amazing how Mary Balogh was able to get me invested in Kate's happiness although the story was only 77 pages long. What had happened to Kate and had caused Kate's hate toward the Marquess of Ashendon was unfolded at the end in such a beautiful way, I loved it.
5 stars.
THE BETROTHAL BALL :
Very short (35 pages) but sweet.
4 stars.
Another Dream and The Forbidden Daffodils are favourite comfort reads for me, I simply adore them.
Treasure Hunt and The Betrothal Ball are nice but forgettable.
-----------------
Re-read in part 01/2023:
-ANOTHER DREAM is one of the most beautiful hr novellas for me. I'm in awe how the author manages to entertain me with her words and characters. Love this so so much.
I'll come back to this soon enough, it just makes me feel so good.
5 stars.
-Love the novella THE FORBIDDEN DAFFODILS sooooo much.
5 stars.
-------
04/2022
ANOTHER DREAM:
I loved being back with the Bedwyns, and I loved so much that I got to see more of Eleanor! Reading Slightly Dangerous I had hoped for her own book, but since Another Dream is not listed as part of the Bedwyn - series, I just came across it by chance, having bought some books by Mary Balogh each with 4 short stories.
This is with 121 pages the longest of the 4 stories in the book Second Chances.
I'm so happy I found Eleanor 's book!
I really truly loved it.
The characters, the writing style, the emotions... but most of all I loved Georgette.
Definitely one of my favorite installments in the Bedwyn series.
5 stars.
TREASURE HUNT:
A rather quick read, just 77 pages, but nevertheless entertaining.
4 stars.
THE FORBIDDEN DAFFODILS:
It's amazing how Mary Balogh was able to get me invested in Kate's happiness although the story was only 77 pages long. What had happened to Kate and had caused Kate's hate toward the Marquess of Ashendon was unfolded at the end in such a beautiful way, I loved it.
5 stars.
THE BETROTHAL BALL :
Very short (35 pages) but sweet.
4 stars.
December 3, 2025
4 novellas, but only the first was a cut above.
Another Dream
4.5 stars
Lovely novella in which Bewcastle’s sister-in-law Eleanor finds her HEA long after believing the dream of a husband and family has passed her by.
Forced to seek shelter from violent storms at a roadside inn on her way to a house party celebrating Wulfric’s 40th birthday, Eleanor is accosted—there’s no other word for it—by Georgette, the ten-year-old daughter of a fellow storm refugee, Michael Benning, Earl of Staunton. They have a lively conversation over tea cakes and when Georgette’s father discovers them, Eleanor is invited to dine with the earl that evening, a meal that ends with a light, accidental kiss.
They part ways the next morning only to discover later that they are both attending the same house party, which delights Michael until he discovers he’s been chased into the country by a mother-daughter duo determined to grab his title through marriage.
The first half of this novella was perfect: the second half used page space to recount the events and attendees of the house party which would have been better spent on deepening the relationship between Eleanor and Michael. Their “I love you’s” felt a tiny bit weightless as a result, and it’s a little disheartening to think that their HEA would never have happened without Georgette’s machinations. Georgette was right: adults are stupid.
But this novella certainly isn’t.
The Treasure Hunt
3 stars
Well-written but unconvincing. I got whiplash from how fast Constance switched her love from one brother to another.
Sid asks his older brother Jon to break it to his childhood friend Constance that he doesn’t want to formalize the betrothal they privately agreed to the summer before. Constance expects him to ask her father for her hand in marriage and announce the engagement at her 20th birthday party, but Sid has cold feet and hies off to Brighton, sending his brother to do his dirty work. Jon, who has supposedly carried a torch for Constance in absentia for the last four years, never gets around to telling her that Sid is dumping her. Instead he gets closer to her himself, and mutual feelings grow, but Constance keeps reminding herself that she loves Sid. Just when Jon is ready to declare himself, Sid shows up, ready to do the honorable thing.
This story needed more room to grow and unfold, but I’m not sure I would have enjoyed it more even then.
The Forbidden Daffodils
2 stars
Lack of communication on steroids. An irrational, willful, and downright cruel FMC just cannot get it through her head that a handsome Marquess who foils her “elopement” attempt with a scoundrel, who proposes marriage, who refuses to give up on marrying her, who chases her into Wales after waiting five years to marry her, actually WANTS to marry her. It’s his sense of duty, she insists. Obligation, she insists. Honor, she insists.
Talk about a pointless waste of five years! These two are idiots. But at least he’s a lovely idiot. She’s a demon in a cloak.
The Betrothal Ball
2.5 stars
Too truncated to generate a lot of interest, but it was okay. Earl falls for governess at the speed of light, and the ending was unbelievable, but had a touch of sweetness.
Another Dream
4.5 stars
Lovely novella in which Bewcastle’s sister-in-law Eleanor finds her HEA long after believing the dream of a husband and family has passed her by.
Forced to seek shelter from violent storms at a roadside inn on her way to a house party celebrating Wulfric’s 40th birthday, Eleanor is accosted—there’s no other word for it—by Georgette, the ten-year-old daughter of a fellow storm refugee, Michael Benning, Earl of Staunton. They have a lively conversation over tea cakes and when Georgette’s father discovers them, Eleanor is invited to dine with the earl that evening, a meal that ends with a light, accidental kiss.
They part ways the next morning only to discover later that they are both attending the same house party, which delights Michael until he discovers he’s been chased into the country by a mother-daughter duo determined to grab his title through marriage.
The first half of this novella was perfect: the second half used page space to recount the events and attendees of the house party which would have been better spent on deepening the relationship between Eleanor and Michael. Their “I love you’s” felt a tiny bit weightless as a result, and it’s a little disheartening to think that their HEA would never have happened without Georgette’s machinations. Georgette was right: adults are stupid.
But this novella certainly isn’t.
The Treasure Hunt
3 stars
Well-written but unconvincing. I got whiplash from how fast Constance switched her love from one brother to another.
Sid asks his older brother Jon to break it to his childhood friend Constance that he doesn’t want to formalize the betrothal they privately agreed to the summer before. Constance expects him to ask her father for her hand in marriage and announce the engagement at her 20th birthday party, but Sid has cold feet and hies off to Brighton, sending his brother to do his dirty work. Jon, who has supposedly carried a torch for Constance in absentia for the last four years, never gets around to telling her that Sid is dumping her. Instead he gets closer to her himself, and mutual feelings grow, but Constance keeps reminding herself that she loves Sid. Just when Jon is ready to declare himself, Sid shows up, ready to do the honorable thing.
This story needed more room to grow and unfold, but I’m not sure I would have enjoyed it more even then.
The Forbidden Daffodils
2 stars
Lack of communication on steroids. An irrational, willful, and downright cruel FMC just cannot get it through her head that a handsome Marquess who foils her “elopement” attempt with a scoundrel, who proposes marriage, who refuses to give up on marrying her, who chases her into Wales after waiting five years to marry her, actually WANTS to marry her. It’s his sense of duty, she insists. Obligation, she insists. Honor, she insists.
Talk about a pointless waste of five years! These two are idiots. But at least he’s a lovely idiot. She’s a demon in a cloak.
The Betrothal Ball
2.5 stars
Too truncated to generate a lot of interest, but it was okay. Earl falls for governess at the speed of light, and the ending was unbelievable, but had a touch of sweetness.
December 15, 2025
"Miss Thompson, why are adults so stupid? Why do they not say what they mean? And what they feel?"
I'm really glad that Gloria insisted that I read this novella when I wanted to skip it. It is a wonderful and heartwarming story, connected to the Bedwyn and the Simply series.
Eleanor Thompson and Michael Benning, Lord Staunton, meet at an inn during a storm and spend a wonderful evening together. It ends with a kiss and confusing feelings but none of them thinks they will ever meet again.
Little do they know.
As it turns out, they are both headed to the same house party—the celebration of Wulfric Bedwyns's 40th birthday. The house party lasts two weeks, which gives Michael's children, blunt Georgette (10) and shy Robert (5), plenty of time to bring their father together with their chosen new mama. Both children are adorable, but the charming chatterbox Georgette undoubtedly steals the show. (I guess the girl alone would be reason enough for Eleanor to marry Michael, since they have an instant connection!)
However, Michael and Eleanor do fall in love, even though it takes them some time to believe in each other's feelings. For people their age—39 years old—, they act pretty awkwardly at times, but they are still a great couple and deserve all the happiness in the world!
4.5
Disclaimer: I've only read the first Balogh novella in this anthology, Another Dream, so please note that my rating is only for this story, not for the entire book.
(Read in December 2025)
I'm really glad that Gloria insisted that I read this novella when I wanted to skip it. It is a wonderful and heartwarming story, connected to the Bedwyn and the Simply series.
Eleanor Thompson and Michael Benning, Lord Staunton, meet at an inn during a storm and spend a wonderful evening together. It ends with a kiss and confusing feelings but none of them thinks they will ever meet again.
Little do they know.
As it turns out, they are both headed to the same house party—the celebration of Wulfric Bedwyns's 40th birthday. The house party lasts two weeks, which gives Michael's children, blunt Georgette (10) and shy Robert (5), plenty of time to bring their father together with their chosen new mama. Both children are adorable, but the charming chatterbox Georgette undoubtedly steals the show. (I guess the girl alone would be reason enough for Eleanor to marry Michael, since they have an instant connection!)
However, Michael and Eleanor do fall in love, even though it takes them some time to believe in each other's feelings. For people their age—39 years old—, they act pretty awkwardly at times, but they are still a great couple and deserve all the happiness in the world!
4.5
Disclaimer: I've only read the first Balogh novella in this anthology, Another Dream, so please note that my rating is only for this story, not for the entire book.
(Read in December 2025)
March 20, 2022
As close to perfection as it gets when it comes to novellas. ‘Second chance’ is a romance theme that’s always fascinated me, and any book delving into it is an automatic TBR.
Many of Balogh’s full length novels excel in this and this collection was no exception. While I enjoyed each novella, ‘The Forbidden Daffodils’ definitely stood out to me for its powerful melancholy and unspoken tenderness. It’s one story I can see myself revisiting in the future.
Many of Balogh’s full length novels excel in this and this collection was no exception. While I enjoyed each novella, ‘The Forbidden Daffodils’ definitely stood out to me for its powerful melancholy and unspoken tenderness. It’s one story I can see myself revisiting in the future.
November 19, 2020
I read this for the Bedwyn short story, which was sweet - almost cloyingly so.
The other short stories were published in the 90s. The first two were classic Balogh, especially the second: pretty moving, for reasons which sneak up on you, unseen and unexpected. They’re both quiet and a little unusual and would probably work better if they were longer and had more room to stretch out.
And then there’s that last short story. YIKES. There’s dated and then there’s “from a planet I would never want to visit”. Absolutely nothing about it was compelling: the hero went from harassing Our Timid-Seeming Governess (that’s a character introduction I could do without) to insulting his guests and his household in the name of True Love. Everything about it was uncomfortable and appalling and nothing about it suggested a happily-ever-after.
The other short stories were published in the 90s. The first two were classic Balogh, especially the second: pretty moving, for reasons which sneak up on you, unseen and unexpected. They’re both quiet and a little unusual and would probably work better if they were longer and had more room to stretch out.
And then there’s that last short story. YIKES. There’s dated and then there’s “from a planet I would never want to visit”. Absolutely nothing about it was compelling: the hero went from harassing Our Timid-Seeming Governess (that’s a character introduction I could do without) to insulting his guests and his household in the name of True Love. Everything about it was uncomfortable and appalling and nothing about it suggested a happily-ever-after.
February 5, 2019
I would buy Second Chances simply for a chance to read "The Forbidden Daffodils" ... it's intense and moving and vintage Balogh. I have all of these short stories but it's such a treat to have these four stories gathered together under one umbrella.
October 14, 2023
My favorite of these four reissued novellas was "Another Dream," because of the characters and storyline; it was moving and sweet. The FMC in the third novella, "The Forbidden Daffodils" seemed determined to remain unhappy and act against her own desires (her behavior and hostility towards the MMC made no sense to me). And I'd skip the last novella, "Betrothal Ball" - there was nothing to it.
May 1, 2023
Solid 4 stars ⭐️
Another Dream - 5 ⭐️
Part of the Bedwyn saga. We finally get Eleanor’s story. She is a wonderful lovely heroine. Im so glad she got her second chance at love and a family.🥰
Treasure Hunt - 4 ⭐️ (too short)
The smitten Hero finally gets his chance to woo the young daughter of his neighbor who he has had a crush on for some years ☺️sigh
The Forbidden Daffodils- 4 ⭐️ (too short)
A hate to love trope, a bit more angsty than the previous story. The heroine resents the Hero for witnessing her humiliation a few years ago. The Hero has been besotted ever since and this time, will not let his chance pass. An emotional read and a truly faithful Hero. ❤️
The Betrothal Ball - 3 ⭐️ (way too short)
The Hero decides by the end of the short story that he would rather have love, companionship and conversation in his marriage than, looks and breeding. The intelligent heroine gets her chance at last. This was too short but MB did show a few interactions between the couple to cement their attraction to each other.
All in all a truly wonderful sigh worthy book!! Not to be missed especially for the first 3 stories.
Another Dream - 5 ⭐️
Part of the Bedwyn saga. We finally get Eleanor’s story. She is a wonderful lovely heroine. Im so glad she got her second chance at love and a family.🥰
Treasure Hunt - 4 ⭐️ (too short)
The smitten Hero finally gets his chance to woo the young daughter of his neighbor who he has had a crush on for some years ☺️sigh
The Forbidden Daffodils- 4 ⭐️ (too short)
A hate to love trope, a bit more angsty than the previous story. The heroine resents the Hero for witnessing her humiliation a few years ago. The Hero has been besotted ever since and this time, will not let his chance pass. An emotional read and a truly faithful Hero. ❤️
The Betrothal Ball - 3 ⭐️ (way too short)
The Hero decides by the end of the short story that he would rather have love, companionship and conversation in his marriage than, looks and breeding. The intelligent heroine gets her chance at last. This was too short but MB did show a few interactions between the couple to cement their attraction to each other.
All in all a truly wonderful sigh worthy book!! Not to be missed especially for the first 3 stories.
March 11, 2022
Rating is only for story 1, “Another Dream.” Definitely strong insta-love energy (probably to be expected from a novella), but I’m always happy to see an HEA for protagonists in their 40s or older. Very precocious kids present but I enjoyed them and their interactions with Eleanor made me smile. A quick and fun read.
I started reading story 2 in the book but was instantly DNFed because of the squick factor. I don’t mind an age gap but when the male protagonist says he fell in love with—and kissed—the female protagonist when she was 15 and he was 24, it’s a no from me.
I started reading story 2 in the book but was instantly DNFed because of the squick factor. I don’t mind an age gap but when the male protagonist says he fell in love with—and kissed—the female protagonist when she was 15 and he was 24, it’s a no from me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 7, 2019
This is an anthology of four unconnected stories which were previously published.
ANOTHER DREAM: This is the story of Eleanor Thompson, an independent woman of almost forty. On the way to visit her sister, the Duchess of Bewcastle, she is forced to seek shelter at an inn because of the weather. There she meets Michael Benning, Earl of Staunton and his two precocious children. These two mature adults find sweet platonic companionship with one another but never expect to meet again. When they do, at Eleanor's sister's home, they discover that Michael's children already have plans for Eleanor to be their new mother.This story was reserved and sweet. It is book 6.5 in the Bedwyn series and, for me, the best part was seeing all my favorite characters from that series again. The relationship between Eleanor and Michael was not complicated and they are rather reserved characters, but I enjoyed their romance because it wrapped up some lose ends from the series and I like that these more mature characters also get their happy ending. The children in this story are simply adorable as well. Rating: 4 stars.
THE TREASURE HUNT: Jonathan Hayes, Viscount Whitley, has been sent by his brother to face Constance Manning. Constance has been waiting for Jonathan's brother so that they can reveal their secret engagement, but her fiance has second thoughts and sends his brother instead. Jonathan has a secret as well -- he has been in love with Connie for years. This story didn't really work for me because of the short time frame involved and Connie changing from "loving" Jonathan's brother to recognizing her own love for Jonathan. That being said, I loved the sweetness of the relationship between Connie and Jonathan and willingness to put her happiness above his own. Rating: 2.5 stars.
THE FORBIDDEN DAFFODILS: Kate Buchanan was banished by her father for refusing to marry the Marquess of Ashendon after they spent two nights alone together. Now Ashendon has traveled to Wales to see Kate and try again to gain her consent for them to marry. But Kate's hate for Ashendon has not abated in the five years since her banishment. I really liked this story. It is short and somewhat old fashioned in its tone, but the characters actually have some interest here. I really did feel the two of them had something between them. Rating: 3.5 stars.
THE BETROTHAL BALL: Laura Melfort is the governess for the niece of the Earl of Dearbourne. Dearbourne intends on marrying and has his potential bride in attendance, but finds himself constantly intrigued by the bluestocking governess. This one was just okay. There were some funny moments which I enjoyed, but I didn't really see the connection between the characters. The short length of the story felt more like a fairy tale than a serious romance. Rating: 2 stars.This review was originally posted on Top10RomanceBooks.com
ANOTHER DREAM: This is the story of Eleanor Thompson, an independent woman of almost forty. On the way to visit her sister, the Duchess of Bewcastle, she is forced to seek shelter at an inn because of the weather. There she meets Michael Benning, Earl of Staunton and his two precocious children. These two mature adults find sweet platonic companionship with one another but never expect to meet again. When they do, at Eleanor's sister's home, they discover that Michael's children already have plans for Eleanor to be their new mother.This story was reserved and sweet. It is book 6.5 in the Bedwyn series and, for me, the best part was seeing all my favorite characters from that series again. The relationship between Eleanor and Michael was not complicated and they are rather reserved characters, but I enjoyed their romance because it wrapped up some lose ends from the series and I like that these more mature characters also get their happy ending. The children in this story are simply adorable as well. Rating: 4 stars.
THE TREASURE HUNT: Jonathan Hayes, Viscount Whitley, has been sent by his brother to face Constance Manning. Constance has been waiting for Jonathan's brother so that they can reveal their secret engagement, but her fiance has second thoughts and sends his brother instead. Jonathan has a secret as well -- he has been in love with Connie for years. This story didn't really work for me because of the short time frame involved and Connie changing from "loving" Jonathan's brother to recognizing her own love for Jonathan. That being said, I loved the sweetness of the relationship between Connie and Jonathan and willingness to put her happiness above his own. Rating: 2.5 stars.
THE FORBIDDEN DAFFODILS: Kate Buchanan was banished by her father for refusing to marry the Marquess of Ashendon after they spent two nights alone together. Now Ashendon has traveled to Wales to see Kate and try again to gain her consent for them to marry. But Kate's hate for Ashendon has not abated in the five years since her banishment. I really liked this story. It is short and somewhat old fashioned in its tone, but the characters actually have some interest here. I really did feel the two of them had something between them. Rating: 3.5 stars.
THE BETROTHAL BALL: Laura Melfort is the governess for the niece of the Earl of Dearbourne. Dearbourne intends on marrying and has his potential bride in attendance, but finds himself constantly intrigued by the bluestocking governess. This one was just okay. There were some funny moments which I enjoyed, but I didn't really see the connection between the characters. The short length of the story felt more like a fairy tale than a serious romance. Rating: 2 stars.This review was originally posted on Top10RomanceBooks.com
October 19, 2020
Second Chances
An anthology of short stories
Mary Balogh, author
What wonderful sweet stories by the beloved author.
Another Dream
Bedwyn Saga, Book 6.5
I was especially happy to fine the novella in print for Bedwyn Saga. I found the reunion of the large boisterous family to be enchanting. Of course, there was a budding new romance that took place at the summer house party. Little Georgette was absolutely precocious and adorable.
An anthology of short stories
Mary Balogh, author
What wonderful sweet stories by the beloved author.
Another Dream
Bedwyn Saga, Book 6.5
I was especially happy to fine the novella in print for Bedwyn Saga. I found the reunion of the large boisterous family to be enchanting. Of course, there was a budding new romance that took place at the summer house party. Little Georgette was absolutely precocious and adorable.
March 4, 2019
4 stars for 4 stories. The first one stuck out in my memory with a school headmistress and a widower with children. I love the connection to a book series.
The second one I enjoyed, but couldn't remeber it in comparison to the first.
The third I really enjoyed and felt the angst and loved the remote Wales setting.
The fourth was cute, and felt the shortest.. my lat favorite.
The second one I enjoyed, but couldn't remeber it in comparison to the first.
The third I really enjoyed and felt the angst and loved the remote Wales setting.
The fourth was cute, and felt the shortest.. my lat favorite.
February 18, 2024
Enjoyable collection of short stories involving “Second Chances” for Happily-Ever-Afters previously deferred by various circumstances. . .I am a sucker for wrongs made right at last. This does the trick.
August 27, 2021
Upgrading it from 4 stars to 5 upon a re-read.
I decided I don't mind recycling storylines when it's done so well.
***
Rating and review for "Forbidden Daffodils" only. I haven't read any other story in this antology.
I loved it though I probably read variation of this story by Ms Balogh couple of times before.
Classic second chance at love story with maybe too abrupt turnabout by heroine. I loved stoic and faithful hero.
I decided I don't mind recycling storylines when it's done so well.
***
Rating and review for "Forbidden Daffodils" only. I haven't read any other story in this antology.
I loved it though I probably read variation of this story by Ms Balogh couple of times before.
Classic second chance at love story with maybe too abrupt turnabout by heroine. I loved stoic and faithful hero.
February 7, 2020
Four of Ms. Balogh’s wonderful novellas about love and second chances.
September 24, 2021
I was mainly drawn to reading this for the first story because I knew the character from the Slightly and Simply series and for the inevitable cameos but as they were quick easy reads I went on to read all the stories in the book.
Another dream
It was much as I expected, a very sweet romance. The kids were cute. It lacks some depth but Novellas always do. The characters probably aren't strong enough to warrant a full blown novel anyway. I liked seeing the old characters and getting little updates on them. The base plot reminded me of Simply Perfect a bit in that the heroine was the perfect person to help the hero raise his children and you had the wholly unsuitable other woman hanging around. The misunderstandings between the Hero and Heroine - how they misconstrued each others demeanours and were always questioning what their actions truly meant gave me a Jane Austen vibe. Glad I’ve read it to complete the series of characters. I’ve recently read the first book in the survivors series which was Gwens book. Based on certain things said about how many children other characters had I think this is set about a year after that book.
The Treasure Hunt.
This was another cute little story. But I couldn’t entirely get past the fact that Constance was 15 and Jon was 24 when he first fancied her. It’s just a bit weird. What 24 year old man would fancy a 15 year old, even if she was 16 turning 17 it would be a bit odd. On the one hand I suppose people did marry young those days so it isn’t so unusual that she was so young and Jon does wrestle with his conscience over that fact - thank god. I also thought Jon weak for not telling her the truth about Sid. I know he didn’t want to hurt her but he would have made his own life easier if he’d just told her the truth. The actual courtship was cute though and it was also very sweet how Jon was prepared to take a step back and let Sid marry her if it made both her and his brother happy. That shows true love and depth of character.
The Forbidden Daffodils
I really liked this one. It had more layers to it than I originally expected. It felt like a riff on Pride and Prejudice what with John following after Katherine and her shitty officer beau and paying him off. That is where the similarity ends though as he then offered for her to save her ruined reputation and of course in P&P it is the heroines sister the hero saves not the heroine herself.
At first I thought Katherine was quite childish and stubborn in refusing John when he was offering her a way out of a shit situation. But actually I suppose she was very strong to give up an easy life and choose the hard one.
Turns out she and John actually banged on the journey home and at first it sounded like there was a consent issue going on but as the story developed it became clear that it was an entirely mutual banging.
Not being funny but she must be a bloody good shag if Jon is still obsessed with her after 5 years. 🤣 I do love a pining hero.
I thought he could have resolved the situation much sooner by admitting his love her for instead of listing all the practical reasons they should marry. She practically spelled it out to him that that was what she wanted.
But more layers were revealed and we learn that John’s upbringing is what made him so emotionally stunted AND that Katherine never eloped willing in the first place. She was trying to make John jealous the whole time. Suddenly the level of her hurt makes sense! She had been in love with him all along and felt like she was getting nothing back. I can totally understand why she would chose exile over a marriage of seemingly unrequited love.
The finale on the beach was worth the build up. Finally they bared the truth to one another and John smiled! That gave me Mr Darcy vibes again. Very cute that he made her a spoon and even cuter that they will return to the manor every year to see the Daffodils.
The Betrothal Ball
This was maybe my least favourite in the book. The hero was a bit of an Alpha-hole. Some of his views on women were questionable but appropriate to the time so I can’t really begrudge him that I suppose. He talks about wanting a woman with straw in her head but in fact can’t resist the lure of an intelligent woman he could actually share his life with. The heroine is decent. I don’t really have a lot to say about her, she was quite generic, but I am glad she got her happy ending. She was a good woman and she deserved it. I can’t help but feel slightly sorry for the woman he would have married. I know we are not supposed to like her but she is a product of her environment at the end of the day and she will be horribly embarrassed by the betrothal announcement.
Another dream
It was much as I expected, a very sweet romance. The kids were cute. It lacks some depth but Novellas always do. The characters probably aren't strong enough to warrant a full blown novel anyway. I liked seeing the old characters and getting little updates on them. The base plot reminded me of Simply Perfect a bit in that the heroine was the perfect person to help the hero raise his children and you had the wholly unsuitable other woman hanging around. The misunderstandings between the Hero and Heroine - how they misconstrued each others demeanours and were always questioning what their actions truly meant gave me a Jane Austen vibe. Glad I’ve read it to complete the series of characters. I’ve recently read the first book in the survivors series which was Gwens book. Based on certain things said about how many children other characters had I think this is set about a year after that book.
The Treasure Hunt.
This was another cute little story. But I couldn’t entirely get past the fact that Constance was 15 and Jon was 24 when he first fancied her. It’s just a bit weird. What 24 year old man would fancy a 15 year old, even if she was 16 turning 17 it would be a bit odd. On the one hand I suppose people did marry young those days so it isn’t so unusual that she was so young and Jon does wrestle with his conscience over that fact - thank god. I also thought Jon weak for not telling her the truth about Sid. I know he didn’t want to hurt her but he would have made his own life easier if he’d just told her the truth. The actual courtship was cute though and it was also very sweet how Jon was prepared to take a step back and let Sid marry her if it made both her and his brother happy. That shows true love and depth of character.
The Forbidden Daffodils
I really liked this one. It had more layers to it than I originally expected. It felt like a riff on Pride and Prejudice what with John following after Katherine and her shitty officer beau and paying him off. That is where the similarity ends though as he then offered for her to save her ruined reputation and of course in P&P it is the heroines sister the hero saves not the heroine herself.
At first I thought Katherine was quite childish and stubborn in refusing John when he was offering her a way out of a shit situation. But actually I suppose she was very strong to give up an easy life and choose the hard one.
Turns out she and John actually banged on the journey home and at first it sounded like there was a consent issue going on but as the story developed it became clear that it was an entirely mutual banging.
Not being funny but she must be a bloody good shag if Jon is still obsessed with her after 5 years. 🤣 I do love a pining hero.
I thought he could have resolved the situation much sooner by admitting his love her for instead of listing all the practical reasons they should marry. She practically spelled it out to him that that was what she wanted.
But more layers were revealed and we learn that John’s upbringing is what made him so emotionally stunted AND that Katherine never eloped willing in the first place. She was trying to make John jealous the whole time. Suddenly the level of her hurt makes sense! She had been in love with him all along and felt like she was getting nothing back. I can totally understand why she would chose exile over a marriage of seemingly unrequited love.
The finale on the beach was worth the build up. Finally they bared the truth to one another and John smiled! That gave me Mr Darcy vibes again. Very cute that he made her a spoon and even cuter that they will return to the manor every year to see the Daffodils.
The Betrothal Ball
This was maybe my least favourite in the book. The hero was a bit of an Alpha-hole. Some of his views on women were questionable but appropriate to the time so I can’t really begrudge him that I suppose. He talks about wanting a woman with straw in her head but in fact can’t resist the lure of an intelligent woman he could actually share his life with. The heroine is decent. I don’t really have a lot to say about her, she was quite generic, but I am glad she got her happy ending. She was a good woman and she deserved it. I can’t help but feel slightly sorry for the woman he would have married. I know we are not supposed to like her but she is a product of her environment at the end of the day and she will be horribly embarrassed by the betrothal announcement.
June 8, 2021
This is a sweet, delightful anthology of second chance romances that grabbed my heart and made me smile. I love second chance stories stories, especially when they include wonderful banter and charming heroines and heroes, and this collection met both of those criteria in spades. Even though these yarns are short, they captured my imagination and the essence of a wonderful tale and romance.
The first book in the anthology “Another Dream” is the longest of the stories and is a sweet romantic tale that shows that another dream is a possibility if you are willing to look for it. Eleanor, a spinster teacher and school owner, meets Michael, a widower, & his two adorable children Georgette & Robert after an unexpected stop at an inn due to inclement weather never knowing that he is an Earl or that they are all on the way to the same house party. The children are integral to the plot development and thus the romance and Mary Balogh has created two different but charming personalities in Georgette and Robert. It was hard not to be charmed by the precocious Georgette or not to want to hug and spoil the shy Robert. The family and party scenes were lovely and believable. This is a wonderful uplifting romance that is both intriguing & entertaining.
The second story “The Treasure Hunt” is a sweet story that focuses on the upcoming 20th birthday party of Constance. She has been friends with neighbour brothers Sidney and Jonathon since childhood and is looking forward to the arrival of her secret intended so that a betrothal can be announced at her party ball. But, will a betrothal occur and if so to whom and will it be one of the brothers? The romance here was very subtle and although the second chance romance was for the resulting couple the hero played the more major role. I so felt for the hero and loved his honour and the love that he felt for Constance. A charming tale.
“The Forbidden Daffodils”, the third novella, is a much more emotional and anguish filled story that pulled at my heartstrings. The past relationship is slowly drawn out and I cried with Kate and John when they were finally able to resolve their past differences and move forward. I so wish that there had been an epilogue to this story because it was so romantic.
The last narrative is a very short but fun and uplifting story about a gentlewoman, Laura, who has had to seek employment as a governess to survive and believes that at the age of 26 she has missed her chance for a romance and marriage. Could her employer the Earl of Dearborne change her future? The length of this story made the romance seem more rushed but still made me smile and wish for a happpily ever after for Laura and her love.
All in all, these are 4 extremely charming and sweet second chance romances that made me fall in love all over again with historical romances and the writing of Mary Balogh.
The first book in the anthology “Another Dream” is the longest of the stories and is a sweet romantic tale that shows that another dream is a possibility if you are willing to look for it. Eleanor, a spinster teacher and school owner, meets Michael, a widower, & his two adorable children Georgette & Robert after an unexpected stop at an inn due to inclement weather never knowing that he is an Earl or that they are all on the way to the same house party. The children are integral to the plot development and thus the romance and Mary Balogh has created two different but charming personalities in Georgette and Robert. It was hard not to be charmed by the precocious Georgette or not to want to hug and spoil the shy Robert. The family and party scenes were lovely and believable. This is a wonderful uplifting romance that is both intriguing & entertaining.
The second story “The Treasure Hunt” is a sweet story that focuses on the upcoming 20th birthday party of Constance. She has been friends with neighbour brothers Sidney and Jonathon since childhood and is looking forward to the arrival of her secret intended so that a betrothal can be announced at her party ball. But, will a betrothal occur and if so to whom and will it be one of the brothers? The romance here was very subtle and although the second chance romance was for the resulting couple the hero played the more major role. I so felt for the hero and loved his honour and the love that he felt for Constance. A charming tale.
“The Forbidden Daffodils”, the third novella, is a much more emotional and anguish filled story that pulled at my heartstrings. The past relationship is slowly drawn out and I cried with Kate and John when they were finally able to resolve their past differences and move forward. I so wish that there had been an epilogue to this story because it was so romantic.
The last narrative is a very short but fun and uplifting story about a gentlewoman, Laura, who has had to seek employment as a governess to survive and believes that at the age of 26 she has missed her chance for a romance and marriage. Could her employer the Earl of Dearborne change her future? The length of this story made the romance seem more rushed but still made me smile and wish for a happpily ever after for Laura and her love.
All in all, these are 4 extremely charming and sweet second chance romances that made me fall in love all over again with historical romances and the writing of Mary Balogh.
July 22, 2019
These are pretty good, more like 3.5.
The first one is about 40-year old spinster Eleanor Thompson, sister of Christine, the heroine of Slightly Dangerous, and Michael, a widower with two young children. They meet and have a strong connection when they're stranded at an inn during a rainstorm, and then are shocked to meet again the next day when they arrive at the same house party. It's the longest story in the collection, and Michael's children play a significant role.
The second story is about Constance, who is about to celebrate her 20th birthday, and two brothers, Jonathan and Sidney, who have been her lifelong neighbors. Jonathan is several years older and Sid is Connie's age. The previous summer, when she was 18-19, she and Sid became (secretly) romantically involved and vowed to become betrothed on Connie's 20th birthday, but a few weeks before the big event, Sid realizes he doesn't want to go through with it, and leaves it to Jon to explain things to Connie. Of course, Sid doesn't realize that Jon has been in love with Connie for years, since she was 15. This one does not age well, not in this post-#MeToo/Jeffrey Epstein era -- a 20-something year old Jon's love for a 15-year old girl feels really gross.
The third story was my least favorite -- Kate, who had been a spoiled debutante, has lived quietly in exile in Wales for five years because she was compromised during her Season. The marquess who had offered to marry her to save her from scandal -- an offer she strongly rejected, thus ensuring her exile -- has showed up in Wales to ask her again. I just had a hard time understanding how these two people could have had feelings for each other five years prior, and I had a hard time believing that their feelings for each other would have lasted. Finally, Kate is hard-headed and difficult.
The fourth and final story is about Bram and Laura. He's an earl with a 15-year old niece; she is the niece's governess. They have instant chemistry and end up having some intense conversations. He also, early on, inappropriately kisses her. Like seriously, dude, don't kiss the governess a day after you've met her. He brings a prospective bride to the house and ends up realizing the governess is who he'd rather be with. Other than Bram's condescending manner with Laura, I think I might like this one the most.
Three of the four men -- the ones in stories 2, 3 and 4 -- are patronizing. It's not an attractive trait.
The first one is about 40-year old spinster Eleanor Thompson, sister of Christine, the heroine of Slightly Dangerous, and Michael, a widower with two young children. They meet and have a strong connection when they're stranded at an inn during a rainstorm, and then are shocked to meet again the next day when they arrive at the same house party. It's the longest story in the collection, and Michael's children play a significant role.
The second story is about Constance, who is about to celebrate her 20th birthday, and two brothers, Jonathan and Sidney, who have been her lifelong neighbors. Jonathan is several years older and Sid is Connie's age. The previous summer, when she was 18-19, she and Sid became (secretly) romantically involved and vowed to become betrothed on Connie's 20th birthday, but a few weeks before the big event, Sid realizes he doesn't want to go through with it, and leaves it to Jon to explain things to Connie. Of course, Sid doesn't realize that Jon has been in love with Connie for years, since she was 15. This one does not age well, not in this post-#MeToo/Jeffrey Epstein era -- a 20-something year old Jon's love for a 15-year old girl feels really gross.
The third story was my least favorite -- Kate, who had been a spoiled debutante, has lived quietly in exile in Wales for five years because she was compromised during her Season. The marquess who had offered to marry her to save her from scandal -- an offer she strongly rejected, thus ensuring her exile -- has showed up in Wales to ask her again. I just had a hard time understanding how these two people could have had feelings for each other five years prior, and I had a hard time believing that their feelings for each other would have lasted. Finally, Kate is hard-headed and difficult.
The fourth and final story is about Bram and Laura. He's an earl with a 15-year old niece; she is the niece's governess. They have instant chemistry and end up having some intense conversations. He also, early on, inappropriately kisses her. Like seriously, dude, don't kiss the governess a day after you've met her. He brings a prospective bride to the house and ends up realizing the governess is who he'd rather be with. Other than Bram's condescending manner with Laura, I think I might like this one the most.
Three of the four men -- the ones in stories 2, 3 and 4 -- are patronizing. It's not an attractive trait.
February 6, 2019
Mary Balogh is my absolute favorite historical romance author and I'm rarely disappointed by her work. As such, I immediately purchased a copy of this book upon publication knowing that I wouldn't be disappointed.
Another Dream
This was the story I most eagerly looked forward to since 'Slightly Dangerous' is my favorite historical romance ever. Taken back into the bosom of the Bedwyn family, this story is about Christine's elder sister, Eleanor. A calm, mature and kind woman, Eleanor is the perfect partner to the hero. Michael is a widow with two young children who are just too precious and are immediately taken with Eleanor. This was a very sweet story about two mature people looking for happiness and love, at the assistance of two mischievous kids.
The Treasure Hunt
Constance and the Hayes brothers are childhood friends. However, Constance's friendship with the youngest brother, Sid, has always been the strongest and most comfortable. Around the older brother, the viscount, she's always either hero-worshiped him or been nervous. I found it cute that Jonathan (the viscount) was in love with her but intent on ensuring her happiness, even if it meant acknowledging that she would be his sister-in-law. Constance was sweet and really confused about her feelings, making her seem very very young and immature, but in a cute way.
The Forbidden Daffodils
This story was pretty much about the essence of lack of communication between two people when it comes to feelings. Kate has despised her former suitor, Ashendon, since he ruined her five years ago. Ashendon is desperately in love with her still and is back to persuade her to marry him. Kate acted very immaturely in the past and continues to act immature with his arrival. Luckily for her, the hero is persistent despite her constant rejection.
The Betrothal Ball
I'm a sucker for social class romance. The hero is the employer of the heroine whom is the governess of his ward. He's instantly attracted to her and that attraction develops even more with their banters. Laura is a bluestocking and believes a lady should have intellect, not just thoughts of gowns and balls. This was a very Cinderella-like story.
Another Dream
This was the story I most eagerly looked forward to since 'Slightly Dangerous' is my favorite historical romance ever. Taken back into the bosom of the Bedwyn family, this story is about Christine's elder sister, Eleanor. A calm, mature and kind woman, Eleanor is the perfect partner to the hero. Michael is a widow with two young children who are just too precious and are immediately taken with Eleanor. This was a very sweet story about two mature people looking for happiness and love, at the assistance of two mischievous kids.
The Treasure Hunt
Constance and the Hayes brothers are childhood friends. However, Constance's friendship with the youngest brother, Sid, has always been the strongest and most comfortable. Around the older brother, the viscount, she's always either hero-worshiped him or been nervous. I found it cute that Jonathan (the viscount) was in love with her but intent on ensuring her happiness, even if it meant acknowledging that she would be his sister-in-law. Constance was sweet and really confused about her feelings, making her seem very very young and immature, but in a cute way.
The Forbidden Daffodils
This story was pretty much about the essence of lack of communication between two people when it comes to feelings. Kate has despised her former suitor, Ashendon, since he ruined her five years ago. Ashendon is desperately in love with her still and is back to persuade her to marry him. Kate acted very immaturely in the past and continues to act immature with his arrival. Luckily for her, the hero is persistent despite her constant rejection.
The Betrothal Ball
I'm a sucker for social class romance. The hero is the employer of the heroine whom is the governess of his ward. He's instantly attracted to her and that attraction develops even more with their banters. Laura is a bluestocking and believes a lady should have intellect, not just thoughts of gowns and balls. This was a very Cinderella-like story.
February 9, 2019
Four novella with the purported theme of Second Chances. I mention “purported” because the weakest of the four (The Betrothal Ball) to my mind has zilch reference to any second chance, with the h and H unknown to one another at the beginning of the story. Not only is the romance less than credible but I hate the device of an aristocrat who invites a young woman and her family to a house party at his property, with such an obvious intent of offering marriage to her that all the guests, neighbours and servants know about it and then humiliates her without warning. Moreover, the library scene is such an overdone cliche that it is mind-numbingly boring. One star.
The other three short stories don’t need to be great to be better than this. Of them, I enjoyed The Treasure Hunt best, in the main because it is the H who is at a loss, struggling to do the right thing to the young woman he believes he has wronged and who he has loved for years. Four stars.
The next story, Another Dream, is also a four star effort and I must be honest and admit that this is probably because of the regular appearances of Wulfric - as well as the excruciating scene in the billiard room, which is well done. It’s also charming to have a 39 year old heroine, with laughter lines, a fine mind and warm heart, as well as a hero who is mainly described as kind and caring, who loves his children and who has the fondest of memories of his first wife. Four stars.
I remember reading the fourth story, The Forbidden Daffodil, some years ago and enjoying it much more than this time, when I think that it suffers from comparison with Balogh’s other treatment of a similar theme in the short story The Anniversary. The angst is so over the top, but unpeeled too quickly at the end. It’s still a much better effort than The Betrothal Ball. Three stars.
The other three short stories don’t need to be great to be better than this. Of them, I enjoyed The Treasure Hunt best, in the main because it is the H who is at a loss, struggling to do the right thing to the young woman he believes he has wronged and who he has loved for years. Four stars.
The next story, Another Dream, is also a four star effort and I must be honest and admit that this is probably because of the regular appearances of Wulfric - as well as the excruciating scene in the billiard room, which is well done. It’s also charming to have a 39 year old heroine, with laughter lines, a fine mind and warm heart, as well as a hero who is mainly described as kind and caring, who loves his children and who has the fondest of memories of his first wife. Four stars.
I remember reading the fourth story, The Forbidden Daffodil, some years ago and enjoying it much more than this time, when I think that it suffers from comparison with Balogh’s other treatment of a similar theme in the short story The Anniversary. The angst is so over the top, but unpeeled too quickly at the end. It’s still a much better effort than The Betrothal Ball. Three stars.
March 14, 2025
I had high hopes for this collection of romantic short stories. Persuasion is my second favorite Jane Austen novel, and that's a second chance romance, so I looked forward to seeing what Mary Balogh could do in that subgenre of romance. Sadly, she failed to deliver for me on any of these stories. As with most of the novella collections put out in this line of Balogh's works, three of the four stories in this anthology were stories written for previous anthologies made up of writings from various authors. How they stacked up with the other stories in their original collections, I couldn't say, but on their own, they were sadly underwhelming.
"Another Dream" was a decent beginning to the collection (and, I believe, an original submission for this anthology). It's the only one of the entries that is broken up into chapters, but all this does is make the story feel unbearably long, even though it's not any longer than the other entries. The plot line is decent, but it does rely on the reader finding precocious children to be "cute" a little too much for my enjoyment (I find children rather tiresome, on the whole) and it goes the easy route of making the romantic rival detestable in order to make the love story work. I understand why Balogh took this route for a novella, but it does make the story trite and predictable. 2/5 stars
"Treasure Hunt" is the kind of story that I find cute and tends to make me smile. It's easily my favorite of the collection. There's nothing here that you haven't read elsewhere and probably done better in those other places though. 3/5 stars.
"The Forbidden Daffodils" would have worked as a fully fleshed out novel where we can read the characters' back story with each other and get more details into what led to the whole situation they find themselves in years later. As it stands, however, neither of them are ones the reader can sympathize with and both come across as spoiled and uninteresting. A good idea, but not one that really works when you're going with a novella format. 1/ 5 stars.
"The Betrothal Ball" should not have been in this collection because it is not a second chance romance. The main female character may be in her late 20s, but she's never had a romantic relationship before and therefore her getting together with ANYONE is not a "second chance." In addition to that, this is your typical Balogh period romance short story and brings absolutely nothing new or interesting to the table. 0/5 stars.
"Another Dream" was a decent beginning to the collection (and, I believe, an original submission for this anthology). It's the only one of the entries that is broken up into chapters, but all this does is make the story feel unbearably long, even though it's not any longer than the other entries. The plot line is decent, but it does rely on the reader finding precocious children to be "cute" a little too much for my enjoyment (I find children rather tiresome, on the whole) and it goes the easy route of making the romantic rival detestable in order to make the love story work. I understand why Balogh took this route for a novella, but it does make the story trite and predictable. 2/5 stars
"Treasure Hunt" is the kind of story that I find cute and tends to make me smile. It's easily my favorite of the collection. There's nothing here that you haven't read elsewhere and probably done better in those other places though. 3/5 stars.
"The Forbidden Daffodils" would have worked as a fully fleshed out novel where we can read the characters' back story with each other and get more details into what led to the whole situation they find themselves in years later. As it stands, however, neither of them are ones the reader can sympathize with and both come across as spoiled and uninteresting. A good idea, but not one that really works when you're going with a novella format. 1/ 5 stars.
"The Betrothal Ball" should not have been in this collection because it is not a second chance romance. The main female character may be in her late 20s, but she's never had a romantic relationship before and therefore her getting together with ANYONE is not a "second chance." In addition to that, this is your typical Balogh period romance short story and brings absolutely nothing new or interesting to the table. 0/5 stars.
June 21, 2025
It's hard to rate a short story collection. If you like one and hate another, do you average out?
At any rate, I liked "Another Dream", though it did feel as though it'd make a better novel than a short story. "The Treasure Hunt" had a similar problem, it just felt rushed as a short story.
"The Forbidden Daffodils" and "The Betrothal Ball" were quite obviously written significantly earlier than either the previous two short stories or The Bedwyn Saga. They are full of 80s/early 90s "no doesn't actually mean no" bodice-ripper nonsense. I've avoided going back much further in Balogh's catalogue than The Huxtable Quintet because many of her early works fall into the offensive bodice-ripper category.
(It's not entirely her fault, at least 80% of historical romance was like that at the time. Even now there are a lot of contemporary romance authors who don't seem to get that you can't just call a guy dominant or morally grey to erase the fact that he's a rapey creep.)
Anyway. Those last two weren't great even aside from the dated aspects. Too rushed, no character development. They're the bones of novels rather than self-contained short stories. It's a common failing amongst novel writers, and one I'm not surprised to find that the generally long-winded Balogh is particularly bad about.
At any rate, I liked "Another Dream", though it did feel as though it'd make a better novel than a short story. "The Treasure Hunt" had a similar problem, it just felt rushed as a short story.
"The Forbidden Daffodils" and "The Betrothal Ball" were quite obviously written significantly earlier than either the previous two short stories or The Bedwyn Saga. They are full of 80s/early 90s "no doesn't actually mean no" bodice-ripper nonsense. I've avoided going back much further in Balogh's catalogue than The Huxtable Quintet because many of her early works fall into the offensive bodice-ripper category.
(It's not entirely her fault, at least 80% of historical romance was like that at the time. Even now there are a lot of contemporary romance authors who don't seem to get that you can't just call a guy dominant or morally grey to erase the fact that he's a rapey creep.)
Anyway. Those last two weren't great even aside from the dated aspects. Too rushed, no character development. They're the bones of novels rather than self-contained short stories. It's a common failing amongst novel writers, and one I'm not surprised to find that the generally long-winded Balogh is particularly bad about.
February 22, 2019
Great romantic novellas
I loved 3 out of the 4, liked the 4th one, and am quite pleased that I got this! I loved the first story. It was the longest one and had characters from other books that I had enjoyed. The other stories were much shorter. They were not able to go into as much depth. The characters are typical of a Mary Balogh story. They are all well written and vivid. The variety of storylines was great. I think I could tell that most were earlier works, but they are still enticing to read. This collection is a bargain at the price, and of interest to anyone who enjoys light Recency romances with no real steam, but lots of great character development. Enjoy!
I loved 3 out of the 4, liked the 4th one, and am quite pleased that I got this! I loved the first story. It was the longest one and had characters from other books that I had enjoyed. The other stories were much shorter. They were not able to go into as much depth. The characters are typical of a Mary Balogh story. They are all well written and vivid. The variety of storylines was great. I think I could tell that most were earlier works, but they are still enticing to read. This collection is a bargain at the price, and of interest to anyone who enjoys light Recency romances with no real steam, but lots of great character development. Enjoy!
October 4, 2019
Magical and Enchanting
I adored reading the magical "Another Dream". I was thoroughly charmed and transported from reality with the first page to the last. The minor characters are vividly and richly drawn, an entire delightful extended family, their friends and countless boisterous children. Children described so well they pull the reader into the story to join them in their games. As the overview of this collection is named, the reader is treated to the story of two mature people bumbling their way into a second chance for love.
With the final story, "The Betrothal Ball", my reality again faded this time into the enchantment of a 19th century ballroom with a couple twirling to the notes of the newly introduced waltz.
Mary Balogh is simply a magician - story after story and book after book - simply enchanting.
I adored reading the magical "Another Dream". I was thoroughly charmed and transported from reality with the first page to the last. The minor characters are vividly and richly drawn, an entire delightful extended family, their friends and countless boisterous children. Children described so well they pull the reader into the story to join them in their games. As the overview of this collection is named, the reader is treated to the story of two mature people bumbling their way into a second chance for love.
With the final story, "The Betrothal Ball", my reality again faded this time into the enchantment of a 19th century ballroom with a couple twirling to the notes of the newly introduced waltz.
Mary Balogh is simply a magician - story after story and book after book - simply enchanting.
February 17, 2019
As usual, I’ll read anything by Balogh. I thought a collection of novellas and short stories would be a good idea for a busy time. I wouldn’t get too sucked in and distracted by the temptation of a longer novel. Didn’t work. I got sucked into each one and like potato chips I couldn’t read just one and quit.
February 28, 2019
Charming Christmas stories
Lovely light Christmas novellas. Mary Balogh.
Is one of my favorite authors. The other stories are sweet and very enjoyable in the holiday mode. The heroes are all romantic, the heroines. Are delightful. Just enough plot to keep you reading. An enjoyable eveng of reading no matter if the is over or just coming.
Lovely light Christmas novellas. Mary Balogh.
Is one of my favorite authors. The other stories are sweet and very enjoyable in the holiday mode. The heroes are all romantic, the heroines. Are delightful. Just enough plot to keep you reading. An enjoyable eveng of reading no matter if the is over or just coming.
September 20, 2025
Anything for a second chance
Mary Balogh has always delivered wonderful characters, locations and plots. What a joy to discover earlier works now in eprint!
Second Chances just gives the foundation of her ability to bring together seemingly unlikely people. All the novellas are so well-written I can't choose a favorite......thank you, Mary!
Mary Balogh has always delivered wonderful characters, locations and plots. What a joy to discover earlier works now in eprint!
Second Chances just gives the foundation of her ability to bring together seemingly unlikely people. All the novellas are so well-written I can't choose a favorite......thank you, Mary!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews