What do you think?
Rate this book
True Colors
The Gray Chamber
Step into True Colors -- a new series of Historical Stories of Romance and American Crime
Will Edyth prove her sanity before it is too late?
On Blackwell Island, New York, a hospital was built to keep its patients from ever leaving.
With her late father’s fortune under her uncle’s care until her twenty-fifth birthday in the year 1887, Edyth Foster does not feel pressured to marry or to bow to society’s demands. She freely indulges in eccentric hobbies like fencing and riding her velocipede in her cycling costume about the city for all to see. Finding a loophole in the will, though, her uncle whisks Edyth off to the women’s lunatic asylum just weeks before her birthday. Do any of Edyth’s friends care that she disappeared?
At the asylum she meets another inmate, who upon discovering Edyth’s plight, confesses that she is Nellie Bly, an undercover journalist for The World. Will either woman find a way to leave the terrifying island and reclaim her true self?
Will Edyth prove her sanity before it is too late?
On Blackwell Island, New York, a hospital was built to keep its patients from ever leaving.
With her late father’s fortune under her uncle’s care until her twenty-fifth birthday in the year 1887, Edyth Foster does not feel pressured to marry or to bow to society’s demands. She freely indulges in eccentric hobbies like fencing and riding her velocipede in her cycling costume about the city for all to see. Finding a loophole in the will, though, her uncle whisks Edyth off to the women’s lunatic asylum just weeks before her birthday. Do any of Edyth’s friends care that she disappeared?
At the asylum she meets another inmate, who upon discovering Edyth’s plight, confesses that she is Nellie Bly, an undercover journalist for The World. Will either woman find a way to leave the terrifying island and reclaim her true self?
256 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2020
187 people are currently reading
4077 people want to read
About the author
Grace Hitchcock
25 books1,012 followersGrace Hitchcock is an award-winning author of multiple historical novels and novellas. She holds a Masters in Creative Writing and a Bachelor of Arts in English with a minor in History. Grace lives near New Orleans with her husband, Dakota, sons and daughter. Connect with her online at GraceHitchcock.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 337 reviews
November 23, 2019
"Mothers never fail to present their daughters as a marriageable option...[Edyth Foster was]...one of the few women who had her future secured without needing to put on a facade to secure a husband's pocketbook." The year was 1887, the place was New York City.
Edyth, a twenty-four year old "free spirit", answered to the beat of her own drum. She enjoyed riding her velocipede "in lieu of a respectable carriage". She preferred uncorseted, split skirts to fashionable gowns. "Books were too quiet a pastime. She needed to be in motion or fiercely concentrating". Edyth loved fencing, especially with her close friend and fencing instructor Raoul Banebridge. The Banebridge and Foster families traveled in the same social circles.
Edyth's so-called "eccentricities" were soon to be perceived as signs of insanity. In the late 1800's, a women might be committed to an asylum on the word of her husband or family for insanity caused by childbirth, overwork, infidelity, or in Edyth's case, eccentricity.Upon the death of her parents, Uncle Boris had become her guardian. In a matter of months, Edyth would come into her inheritance...but...not if Boris could apply a clause discovered in the family will. "...if [Edyth dies] unmarried and childless, or is declared mad and committed to an asylum, the fortune reverts to [Uncle Boris] and [his] heir."
"The Gray Chamber" by Grace Hitchcock is a work of historical romance focusing on the true crime of imprisoning women on Blackwell's Island, arguably based upon scanty proof, often an act of convenience achieved by lining the pockets of doctors willing to recommend placement in a brutal facility of the time period. Edyth's mutual support team included Poppy, Nellie Bly and Raoul Banebridge (Bane).
Blackwell Island, located on the East River between Manhattan and Queens, housed a lunatic asylum, jail, and workhouse. In 1887, journalist Nellie Bly went undercover "under assignment from Joseph Pulitzer", by assuming the cloak of insanity. Her expose was later published in the book "Ten Days in a Mad-House".
Thank you Barbour Books and Net Galley for the opportunity to read and review "The Gray Chamber".
Edyth, a twenty-four year old "free spirit", answered to the beat of her own drum. She enjoyed riding her velocipede "in lieu of a respectable carriage". She preferred uncorseted, split skirts to fashionable gowns. "Books were too quiet a pastime. She needed to be in motion or fiercely concentrating". Edyth loved fencing, especially with her close friend and fencing instructor Raoul Banebridge. The Banebridge and Foster families traveled in the same social circles.
Edyth's so-called "eccentricities" were soon to be perceived as signs of insanity. In the late 1800's, a women might be committed to an asylum on the word of her husband or family for insanity caused by childbirth, overwork, infidelity, or in Edyth's case, eccentricity.Upon the death of her parents, Uncle Boris had become her guardian. In a matter of months, Edyth would come into her inheritance...but...not if Boris could apply a clause discovered in the family will. "...if [Edyth dies] unmarried and childless, or is declared mad and committed to an asylum, the fortune reverts to [Uncle Boris] and [his] heir."
"The Gray Chamber" by Grace Hitchcock is a work of historical romance focusing on the true crime of imprisoning women on Blackwell's Island, arguably based upon scanty proof, often an act of convenience achieved by lining the pockets of doctors willing to recommend placement in a brutal facility of the time period. Edyth's mutual support team included Poppy, Nellie Bly and Raoul Banebridge (Bane).
Blackwell Island, located on the East River between Manhattan and Queens, housed a lunatic asylum, jail, and workhouse. In 1887, journalist Nellie Bly went undercover "under assignment from Joseph Pulitzer", by assuming the cloak of insanity. Her expose was later published in the book "Ten Days in a Mad-House".
Thank you Barbour Books and Net Galley for the opportunity to read and review "The Gray Chamber".
January 6, 2020
A chilling fictional account based on true happenings at the Blackwell Lunatic Asylum in NYC back in the late 1800's. Women were forcibly committed for any reason, and not expected to ever leave.
Edyth Foster, a woman of 24, was under the guardianship of her uncle after her parents died in an accident. She was a likable, unconventional young woman who rode her bicycle around town, wore different clothing, and took fencing lessons from Raoul Banebridge, whom she fell in love with.
Her uncle, wishing to collect her large inheritance before she turned 25, had her committed to the asylum. Conditions were so deplorable, it was hard to read knowing that these things really happened back then! The scenes of the mistreatment were real, having been documented by Nellie Bly who went undercover as a patient for 10 days there and wrote about it.
Edyth's faith was displayed in her prayers and reading Bible verses while an inmate. I hesitate to call this Christian fiction, as so little was mentioned until much later in the book, but it was an excellent read. You will be glued to the pages! It is quite dark, suspenseful, and it does have a bit of romance.
I could not put this book down and finished it in one day!
Edyth Foster, a woman of 24, was under the guardianship of her uncle after her parents died in an accident. She was a likable, unconventional young woman who rode her bicycle around town, wore different clothing, and took fencing lessons from Raoul Banebridge, whom she fell in love with.
Her uncle, wishing to collect her large inheritance before she turned 25, had her committed to the asylum. Conditions were so deplorable, it was hard to read knowing that these things really happened back then! The scenes of the mistreatment were real, having been documented by Nellie Bly who went undercover as a patient for 10 days there and wrote about it.
Edyth's faith was displayed in her prayers and reading Bible verses while an inmate. I hesitate to call this Christian fiction, as so little was mentioned until much later in the book, but it was an excellent read. You will be glued to the pages! It is quite dark, suspenseful, and it does have a bit of romance.
I could not put this book down and finished it in one day!
December 31, 2019
She lifted her lips to him. His brows shot up and he grinned, that tantalizing dimple appearing in his cheek. " What's this ? I suppose you're asking for a kiss ?"
" That would be most agreeable ,sir. "
Quote from The Gray Chamber by Grace Hitchcock.
I have been really enjoying this True Colors series Barbour has put out. It's a fictional crime series based on true historical crimes.
The majority of the story takes place on Blackwell Island, New York in an asylum built to prevent it's patients from ever leaving.
The lack of knowledge people had during the 1800's concerning treatment of mental illnesses is sad to see. People were kidnapped and put into asylums with no chance of release for normal human behavior like depression after having a baby. Mental illness has better treatment today but still misunderstood.
The plot really flowed, grabbing my attention with the suspense and the slow burning romance.
The writing style is well thought out and you will be cheering for our very relatable heroine, Edyth .
Highly recommend this book!
Pub Date 01 Jan 2020
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you!
All opinions expressed are my own.
January 28, 2020
Disclaimer: This book was sent to me by the publisher, Barbour Publishing, Inc., via Netgalley for an honest review.
Etiquette, propriety, courting, and men who don’t think much of women.
It’s like a Jane Austen novel, but with an asylum!
The Gray Chamber is set in the later part of the 1800’s in high society, following a young woman named Edyth Foster as she nears her twenty-fifth birthday. Though Edyth has grown up privileged and accustomed to playing the role of a lady, she is a quirky woman who lives her life by her own set of rules. She wears relaxed dress-wear without the bother of a corset, and prefers beating men at fencing to sitting on a cushion looking primped and puffed for eligible suitors. And with the fortune her parents left her becoming available to her on her birthday, she is able to forgo the stress and pressures of securing a husband.
That is until her uncle throws her in an insane asylum.
I LOVE a historical fiction tale just like the next Jane Austen lover. There’s just nothing more romantic than a woman being courted using proper English and gentlemanly manners. Mix in beautiful gowns, arrogant men, tittering females and a mental institution…and you’ve just opened up the gates of heaven to me. I found this story to be thoroughly addicting and positively riveting. The language was perfectly on point, the time-period was well-portrayed and it showcased how easy it was during that time for men to dispose of “problem women”. Anyone who didn’t fall in line with society or do as a man said was at risk of being thrust aside.
Corset forbid any of these ladies have some individuality!
When we meet Edyth she is enjoying her life in leisure and comfort. She goes to the fencing club where her crush Bane is the instructor, sketches and paints in her free-time, is carefree with a sunny disposition, and even houses her Uncle and his new bride. Though the relationship with her uncle SEEMS fine to begin with, we obviously know it’s not. Unbeknownst to Edyth, her uncle brings doctors from Blackwell Island, the infamous Women’s Insane Asylum nearby, to have her evaluated for her eccentricities and “odd behavior” in order to have her committed so he can steal her fortune. But once she is shipped off, things got a little sour for me.
After Edyth arrives at Blackwell Island, she began to turn me off a bit. Gone was this strong and independent woman with a humble head on her shoulders, and in her place was a character who whined like a teenager and stomped her foot. Granted, the poor dear HAS just been committed and fears she will spend the rest of her days there…but come on. She acted like a spoiled child who had spent her entire life with a silver spoon in her mouth, and didn’t understand why she wasn’t getting her hair done. Seriously. She asked if a chambermaid would be coming in to do her hair. In an insane asylum.
*sigh*
But her time locked up wasn’t all sunshine and daisies. The orderlies were brutal to all of the patients, and there seemed to only be one nurse that actually had a soul. The women were all washed in the same disgusting bath water, were given food that was barely considered food, dressed in thin pieces of fabric that did nothing to keep them warm, and were sleeping in horrid conditions. It sounded dreadful, and Edyth attempting to escape the institution gave me SUCH anxiety as she was running through the halls trying to flee!
I liked where the author took the story and how she threw in a few twists and blindsides. I found Bane to be a dreamy and perfect romantic interest for Edyth, but I do wish the poor guy would have realized she was a gem BEFORE deciding so after seeing her in a fancy gown and with makeup on. *facepalm* But even so, their relationship was very sweet and gave me little flutters. Bane’s determination to find Edyth was so pure, and it really showed how strong of a friendship they had that he knew something was up as soon as she missed their date. How things tied up with them was perfect, innocent and very romantic.
All in all, I really liked this American Crime/Historical fiction tale. It kept my attention, the setting and dialogue felt authentic to the era, and it showcased the atrocities that some women were subjected to. I do think the last 15% of the story was a bit unnecessary and was dragged out a little more than was needed, but it didn’t bother me enough to make me stop reading until the very last word. This was my first read from this True Colors series, so I definitely want to read the other stories and see how the other authors constructed their tales.
Etiquette, propriety, courting, and men who don’t think much of women.
It’s like a Jane Austen novel, but with an asylum!
The Gray Chamber is set in the later part of the 1800’s in high society, following a young woman named Edyth Foster as she nears her twenty-fifth birthday. Though Edyth has grown up privileged and accustomed to playing the role of a lady, she is a quirky woman who lives her life by her own set of rules. She wears relaxed dress-wear without the bother of a corset, and prefers beating men at fencing to sitting on a cushion looking primped and puffed for eligible suitors. And with the fortune her parents left her becoming available to her on her birthday, she is able to forgo the stress and pressures of securing a husband.
That is until her uncle throws her in an insane asylum.
I LOVE a historical fiction tale just like the next Jane Austen lover. There’s just nothing more romantic than a woman being courted using proper English and gentlemanly manners. Mix in beautiful gowns, arrogant men, tittering females and a mental institution…and you’ve just opened up the gates of heaven to me. I found this story to be thoroughly addicting and positively riveting. The language was perfectly on point, the time-period was well-portrayed and it showcased how easy it was during that time for men to dispose of “problem women”. Anyone who didn’t fall in line with society or do as a man said was at risk of being thrust aside.
Corset forbid any of these ladies have some individuality!
When we meet Edyth she is enjoying her life in leisure and comfort. She goes to the fencing club where her crush Bane is the instructor, sketches and paints in her free-time, is carefree with a sunny disposition, and even houses her Uncle and his new bride. Though the relationship with her uncle SEEMS fine to begin with, we obviously know it’s not. Unbeknownst to Edyth, her uncle brings doctors from Blackwell Island, the infamous Women’s Insane Asylum nearby, to have her evaluated for her eccentricities and “odd behavior” in order to have her committed so he can steal her fortune. But once she is shipped off, things got a little sour for me.
After Edyth arrives at Blackwell Island, she began to turn me off a bit. Gone was this strong and independent woman with a humble head on her shoulders, and in her place was a character who whined like a teenager and stomped her foot. Granted, the poor dear HAS just been committed and fears she will spend the rest of her days there…but come on. She acted like a spoiled child who had spent her entire life with a silver spoon in her mouth, and didn’t understand why she wasn’t getting her hair done. Seriously. She asked if a chambermaid would be coming in to do her hair. In an insane asylum.
*sigh*
But her time locked up wasn’t all sunshine and daisies. The orderlies were brutal to all of the patients, and there seemed to only be one nurse that actually had a soul. The women were all washed in the same disgusting bath water, were given food that was barely considered food, dressed in thin pieces of fabric that did nothing to keep them warm, and were sleeping in horrid conditions. It sounded dreadful, and Edyth attempting to escape the institution gave me SUCH anxiety as she was running through the halls trying to flee!
I liked where the author took the story and how she threw in a few twists and blindsides. I found Bane to be a dreamy and perfect romantic interest for Edyth, but I do wish the poor guy would have realized she was a gem BEFORE deciding so after seeing her in a fancy gown and with makeup on. *facepalm* But even so, their relationship was very sweet and gave me little flutters. Bane’s determination to find Edyth was so pure, and it really showed how strong of a friendship they had that he knew something was up as soon as she missed their date. How things tied up with them was perfect, innocent and very romantic.
All in all, I really liked this American Crime/Historical fiction tale. It kept my attention, the setting and dialogue felt authentic to the era, and it showcased the atrocities that some women were subjected to. I do think the last 15% of the story was a bit unnecessary and was dragged out a little more than was needed, but it didn’t bother me enough to make me stop reading until the very last word. This was my first read from this True Colors series, so I definitely want to read the other stories and see how the other authors constructed their tales.
January 20, 2020
As she did in her previous novel for the True Colors series, in The Gray Chamber Hitchcock has given readers a glimpse into a morbidly fascinating bit of criminal history. Women are held to an entirely different set of standards, and not only did this often disenfranchise them, it often put them in danger, as it does for main character Edyth Foster.
Edyth is forward-thinking; she fences when this is considered a man's sport; she pays no heed to what society dictates. This plays well into the schemes set into play by members of her family, and it also serves her well when she finds herself unfairly locked up in an asylum and her fortune removed from her. Her longtime friend, Bane, is an endearing character as well, though I was a bit put off at his change of heart when it came to Edyth - it comes off as a bit abrupt and somewhat superficial, as he couldn't see Edyth's good qualities without fancy trimmings. I did enjoy their interactions together, and there are some tension-filled moments when they are both trying to save her from the asylum on Blackwell's Island.
The details of the treatment of those in the asylum are hard to read about and a dark blot indeed on mental healthcare - thank goodness many strides have been made in that field, and kudos to Hitchcock for shedding light on this time in history.
Hitchcock is an author that I've come to expect good things from, after having read her debut novel and two novellas. Though I didn't enjoy The Gray Chamber quite as much as The White City, I'm glad that I read it, and recommend it for readers of romantic historical mysteries.
I received a complimentary copy of the novel from the author; I was not required to post a review, and these are my honest thoughts and opinions.
Edyth is forward-thinking; she fences when this is considered a man's sport; she pays no heed to what society dictates. This plays well into the schemes set into play by members of her family, and it also serves her well when she finds herself unfairly locked up in an asylum and her fortune removed from her. Her longtime friend, Bane, is an endearing character as well, though I was a bit put off at his change of heart when it came to Edyth - it comes off as a bit abrupt and somewhat superficial, as he couldn't see Edyth's good qualities without fancy trimmings. I did enjoy their interactions together, and there are some tension-filled moments when they are both trying to save her from the asylum on Blackwell's Island.
The details of the treatment of those in the asylum are hard to read about and a dark blot indeed on mental healthcare - thank goodness many strides have been made in that field, and kudos to Hitchcock for shedding light on this time in history.
Hitchcock is an author that I've come to expect good things from, after having read her debut novel and two novellas. Though I didn't enjoy The Gray Chamber quite as much as The White City, I'm glad that I read it, and recommend it for readers of romantic historical mysteries.
I received a complimentary copy of the novel from the author; I was not required to post a review, and these are my honest thoughts and opinions.
February 17, 2025
Some prisons have bars of iron. Others are built from whispered lies and signed papers, locking the innocent away with no escape.
Miss Blaire in Blackwell’s Island is a story of chains—some forged by wicked men, others by fear itself. And yet, through the darkness of that asylum, light still shines. In a world that deems her mad, Edyth’s faith flickers like a candle in the wind, and I clung to every moment of her fight for truth, dignity, and freedom.
Bane’s whispered plea, “Make the path known. Show me the way, Lord,” resonated deep. Isn’t that the cry of every soul facing injustice, the desperate prayer of those walking through a valley with no end in sight? This book doesn’t just tell a tale - it breathes it, pulling the reader into the raw ache of unanswered prayers and the steady, unwavering sovereignty and love of God.
I treasure books that don’t merely mention faith but live it out on the page. This is one of those rare gems. The writing is so vivid, I felt the cold walls of Blackwell’s, the hopelessness pressing in. But more than that, I felt the hand of God at work, unseen but never absent.
The combination of exceptional storytelling and intense subject matter renders the book almost unbearable to read at times, yet impossible to put down. Miss Blaire may have been locked away, but the truth cannot be caged. And neither can the love of a God who never abandons His own.
Highly recommended.
I received a digital ARC of this book from the publisher and Celebrate Lit Publicity Group. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the writing and story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.
Miss Blaire in Blackwell’s Island is a story of chains—some forged by wicked men, others by fear itself. And yet, through the darkness of that asylum, light still shines. In a world that deems her mad, Edyth’s faith flickers like a candle in the wind, and I clung to every moment of her fight for truth, dignity, and freedom.
Bane’s whispered plea, “Make the path known. Show me the way, Lord,” resonated deep. Isn’t that the cry of every soul facing injustice, the desperate prayer of those walking through a valley with no end in sight? This book doesn’t just tell a tale - it breathes it, pulling the reader into the raw ache of unanswered prayers and the steady, unwavering sovereignty and love of God.
I treasure books that don’t merely mention faith but live it out on the page. This is one of those rare gems. The writing is so vivid, I felt the cold walls of Blackwell’s, the hopelessness pressing in. But more than that, I felt the hand of God at work, unseen but never absent.
The combination of exceptional storytelling and intense subject matter renders the book almost unbearable to read at times, yet impossible to put down. Miss Blaire may have been locked away, but the truth cannot be caged. And neither can the love of a God who never abandons His own.
Highly recommended.
I received a digital ARC of this book from the publisher and Celebrate Lit Publicity Group. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the writing and story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.
February 4, 2020
Spoilers may follow....
Honestly, this one was a real struggle to get through. The author did an excellent job studying the conditions in the madhouse and expressing that (~30% of the book) and did some good work on fencing lingo. Beyond that, though, the research seems to have been left behind for modern tropes and misconceptions. Velocipede/bike: first, this isn’t interchangeable and these are two different contraptions, not synonyms. Second, it wasn’t all that scandalous for a lady to use one. Corset: it’s like a modern woman going without a bra to be without one in public. This is such a common thing for a modern author to show a woman being independent that it’s becoming a huge stereotype and it’s a pet peeve. Next, if her cousin had a larger bosom and a smaller waist than her, there’s no way they would share a corset. Corsets are 100% custom items and took several weeks to be ordered to suit. Not to mention the necessary “training” period a woman went through with loose lacing. And the powder puff fake bosom which explodes? Ugh. It couldn’t work for me.
As far as the fencing angle, I’d have liked that just fine. She wasn’t all that scandalous to do that either. However, when she grabs a rapier at a party and forces a duel on a guy she dislikes...she’d have been arrested instantly for attempted murder and illegal duelling. If it was going to be a joke, and something she’d done before, it would have been done with foils (unsharpened or protected blades), not rapiers (sharp). This was a criminal act and then to hear that wasn’t her first quarrel??
The instalove didn’t work for me either. The guy goes from suddenly noticing her as a woman when she fixes up (eye roll) to being ready to die for her within the week. We were told he loved her but were never shown why. After all, she spends the first third of the book defiant, the second third helpless, and the final third haunted and weak.
She found out the meaning of the three hands but we never got told what.
Basically it’s high drama and romance and that really isn’t my genre. Throwing in over 50% of the book with glaring historical inaccuracy was a deal breaker for me. I’d be glad to try this author again with a contemporary setting.
Thanks to the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
Honestly, this one was a real struggle to get through. The author did an excellent job studying the conditions in the madhouse and expressing that (~30% of the book) and did some good work on fencing lingo. Beyond that, though, the research seems to have been left behind for modern tropes and misconceptions. Velocipede/bike: first, this isn’t interchangeable and these are two different contraptions, not synonyms. Second, it wasn’t all that scandalous for a lady to use one. Corset: it’s like a modern woman going without a bra to be without one in public. This is such a common thing for a modern author to show a woman being independent that it’s becoming a huge stereotype and it’s a pet peeve. Next, if her cousin had a larger bosom and a smaller waist than her, there’s no way they would share a corset. Corsets are 100% custom items and took several weeks to be ordered to suit. Not to mention the necessary “training” period a woman went through with loose lacing. And the powder puff fake bosom which explodes? Ugh. It couldn’t work for me.
As far as the fencing angle, I’d have liked that just fine. She wasn’t all that scandalous to do that either. However, when she grabs a rapier at a party and forces a duel on a guy she dislikes...she’d have been arrested instantly for attempted murder and illegal duelling. If it was going to be a joke, and something she’d done before, it would have been done with foils (unsharpened or protected blades), not rapiers (sharp). This was a criminal act and then to hear that wasn’t her first quarrel??
The instalove didn’t work for me either. The guy goes from suddenly noticing her as a woman when she fixes up (eye roll) to being ready to die for her within the week. We were told he loved her but were never shown why. After all, she spends the first third of the book defiant, the second third helpless, and the final third haunted and weak.
She found out the meaning of the three hands but we never got told what.
Basically it’s high drama and romance and that really isn’t my genre. Throwing in over 50% of the book with glaring historical inaccuracy was a deal breaker for me. I’d be glad to try this author again with a contemporary setting.
Thanks to the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.
January 27, 2020
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
The Gray Chamber
By: Grace Hitchcock
*REVIEW* 🌟🌟🌟🌟
The Gray Chamber is a compelling tale of the atrocities visited upon women committed to Blackwell's Asylum during the 1880s. This institution, located on the East River near Manhattan and Queens, was the place where Nelly Bly spent ten days undercover in order to expose the abhorrent conditions. This story occurs during this time when Edyth, and orphan about to claim her inheritance, is deemed insane and committed to Blackwell's by her uncle. It was shockingly easy to declare a woman crazy. A few instances of unladylike behavior would suffice. Edyth's story is heartbreaking indeed, but there is a little ray of hope with a bit of romance involved. Most striking about this story are the descriptions of the inhumane conditions within the asylum and the animalistic treatment of the patients. It's informative, eye opening and unforgettable. The author obviously researched Blackwell's as evidenced in her depiction of this tragic place. I recommend for historical fiction readers with intrest in this era.
The Gray Chamber
By: Grace Hitchcock
*REVIEW* 🌟🌟🌟🌟
The Gray Chamber is a compelling tale of the atrocities visited upon women committed to Blackwell's Asylum during the 1880s. This institution, located on the East River near Manhattan and Queens, was the place where Nelly Bly spent ten days undercover in order to expose the abhorrent conditions. This story occurs during this time when Edyth, and orphan about to claim her inheritance, is deemed insane and committed to Blackwell's by her uncle. It was shockingly easy to declare a woman crazy. A few instances of unladylike behavior would suffice. Edyth's story is heartbreaking indeed, but there is a little ray of hope with a bit of romance involved. Most striking about this story are the descriptions of the inhumane conditions within the asylum and the animalistic treatment of the patients. It's informative, eye opening and unforgettable. The author obviously researched Blackwell's as evidenced in her depiction of this tragic place. I recommend for historical fiction readers with intrest in this era.
May 4, 2020
For such a dower subject, I quite enjoyed the story of Edyth and Bane - her struggle to prove she was not insane and his love for her to get her out. I had heard of women being sent to asylums just because their husband's/families didn't know what to do with them, or they didn't want them anymore, or they just wanted their money, it was really quite easy for them to do in those days. As is the case with Edyth, and her greedy aunt and uncle. Sent away because she had money, Edyth kept her wits and knew someone would find her and get her out of Blackwell Island's dark halls. But how far into those halls Edyth got, was more terrifying every day. But Bane would not give up on her and would do anything in his power to get her out.
The book brought the time and feelings of those patients to life. I have heard a little bit of Nellie Bly's days in the institution and this brought that to life a little more. I received this from NetGalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc., and wish to thank them for this advance copy.
The book brought the time and feelings of those patients to life. I have heard a little bit of Nellie Bly's days in the institution and this brought that to life a little more. I received this from NetGalley and Barbour Publishing, Inc., and wish to thank them for this advance copy.
October 8, 2019
I was hooked by the time I was 25% through this book. It's not your typical chick lit, & it's based on actual historical events. The protagonist is a strong, strong-willed, unconventional young woman who used her position to live a life of intention instead of one of leisure, which cost her her freedom & very nearly her life.
February 25, 2025
Wow! What a fantastic story! The writing is just amazing! This was my first ever True Crime story so I was a little nervous going in. This story is based on an article, Ten Days in a Mad-House written by Nellie Bly on her findings of Blackwell Island. What goes on is so saddening and heartbreaking. Our poor heroine Edyth Blaire has been forced into Blackwell Island as mad, by her Uncle so that he may inherit her fortune. Just awful! I felt so bad for her. However, she is so tough and brave while she is there. She also has the man she loves searching for her and doing everything he can to get her out. I also liked that Nellie Bly was in the story. The suspense in this story is so good, I couldn’t put it down! Just fantastic! Also great Christian content throughout! I definitely recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Content:
lots of abuse to patients: hitting, hair pulling, starving, unsanitary baths, near drownings and strangling, etc.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Content:
lots of abuse to patients: hitting, hair pulling, starving, unsanitary baths, near drownings and strangling, etc.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
January 31, 2020
I cannot get enough of this series! Every single story is full of captivating characters, eerie situations (yes they creep me out a little!), suspense, and amazement. The Gray Chamber is no exception to that. Hitchcock had my attention from the very first line, and didn’t lose it until the end.
Edyth was such an interesting character. I loved her attitude about things. I mean, in the very beginning scene she is riding her velocipede (which I did look up by the way because I wanted to see a picture of it), not caring what the world thinks of her, or if society might look at her in disgust. That’s just how she wants to travel and therefore that’s how it’s going to be! Honestly, as the story started to unfold of her being forced to the asylum, I liked her even more. She was strong, courageous, and not willing to back down. I love strong heroines like that.
The inclusion of Nellie Bly was a fantastic idea, and really brought the story to life even more! And Nellie wasn’t there to steal the show, which I have to admit I was a little worried about. But no, the focus remained on Edyth and the truth she was trying to uncover. And honestly, Hitchcock made me feel as if I was right there along the journey. I love it when an author is able to include you in the story. It just adds to the whole experience!
Hitchcock has written a brilliant story here, one that readers will find themselves devouring in one sitting. I cannot wait to see what comes next in this fantastic series! I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Edyth was such an interesting character. I loved her attitude about things. I mean, in the very beginning scene she is riding her velocipede (which I did look up by the way because I wanted to see a picture of it), not caring what the world thinks of her, or if society might look at her in disgust. That’s just how she wants to travel and therefore that’s how it’s going to be! Honestly, as the story started to unfold of her being forced to the asylum, I liked her even more. She was strong, courageous, and not willing to back down. I love strong heroines like that.
The inclusion of Nellie Bly was a fantastic idea, and really brought the story to life even more! And Nellie wasn’t there to steal the show, which I have to admit I was a little worried about. But no, the focus remained on Edyth and the truth she was trying to uncover. And honestly, Hitchcock made me feel as if I was right there along the journey. I love it when an author is able to include you in the story. It just adds to the whole experience!
Hitchcock has written a brilliant story here, one that readers will find themselves devouring in one sitting. I cannot wait to see what comes next in this fantastic series! I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
January 14, 2020
A little scary... but, in the best way possible.
This was a difficult book to read. The point of the "True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime" series is to show real events in history that many people are not aware of or choose to ignore. The author used a lot of restraint in what she shared, and I'm sure in how much more she didn't. The story had plenty of suspense and could have turned to full-blown horror with the material it covered. The conditions described were beyond deplorable and if ever there was a place of hopelessness, this was it.
The characters themselves were delightful right from the start. Deep and complex and fun to grow with. I enjoyed the slight mystery involved and the numerous details the author included in every setting.
Usually, my complaint with many books like this is the extremely quick way the author ties up every lose end in the matter or one or two final chapters in a book. This was not the case here. The ending was actually slightly drawn out, but for specific reasons. I think the author was wise to include the PTSD, etc. that had ripple effects for much time to come. Trauma has many layers of healing that need to take place and this book was a good reminder of this.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
This was a difficult book to read. The point of the "True Colors: Historical Stories of American Crime" series is to show real events in history that many people are not aware of or choose to ignore. The author used a lot of restraint in what she shared, and I'm sure in how much more she didn't. The story had plenty of suspense and could have turned to full-blown horror with the material it covered. The conditions described were beyond deplorable and if ever there was a place of hopelessness, this was it.
The characters themselves were delightful right from the start. Deep and complex and fun to grow with. I enjoyed the slight mystery involved and the numerous details the author included in every setting.
Usually, my complaint with many books like this is the extremely quick way the author ties up every lose end in the matter or one or two final chapters in a book. This was not the case here. The ending was actually slightly drawn out, but for specific reasons. I think the author was wise to include the PTSD, etc. that had ripple effects for much time to come. Trauma has many layers of healing that need to take place and this book was a good reminder of this.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
January 24, 2020
When I saw this series about stories based on real life historic crimes, it definitely peaked my interest. The past 2 books was however just okay for me, but this book definitely exceeded my experience again.
Edyth was such a vibrant lively character who was misunderstood because she did not fit the box society wanted to fit her into. Bane came across as a bit of a self-focused and shallow man who only focused on a women's external beauty, but he did win me over in his never ending search for Edyth.
I loved the interactions between Edyth, Bane and Lavinia. The author gives an interesting voice t the characters. Then she took a difficult subject of life in an asylum and brought it to life. The way the author wrote the story made me feel Edyth's fear, betrayal and lost of hope. It is horrific to see how women were treated ad wrongly placed in asylums just because. The suspense was nail-biting and I found myself flipping through the pages to see how everything will end.
This was a great addition to the series and one of my favourite installments. The other also being by this author.
Looking forward to continue with this series.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.*
Edyth was such a vibrant lively character who was misunderstood because she did not fit the box society wanted to fit her into. Bane came across as a bit of a self-focused and shallow man who only focused on a women's external beauty, but he did win me over in his never ending search for Edyth.
I loved the interactions between Edyth, Bane and Lavinia. The author gives an interesting voice t the characters. Then she took a difficult subject of life in an asylum and brought it to life. The way the author wrote the story made me feel Edyth's fear, betrayal and lost of hope. It is horrific to see how women were treated ad wrongly placed in asylums just because. The suspense was nail-biting and I found myself flipping through the pages to see how everything will end.
This was a great addition to the series and one of my favourite installments. The other also being by this author.
Looking forward to continue with this series.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.*
November 8, 2019
There is a lot to like about The Gray Chamber. There's the admirable hero and heroine, a heroine that is ahead of her time in participating in fencing and a novel based upon actual events.
After reading and very much enjoying The White City, my expectations for The Gray Chamber were rather high. The bits of humor that I loved in The White City were very rare in The Gray Chamber. The fictional story line wasn't as engaging for me. The change in Bane's opinion of Edyth from friendship to seeing her in a romantic light happened rather abruptly. Some events were a little cliche.
My favorite character was secondary character Lavinia. I expected that she would be bratty but was actually looking for true friendship and genuinely cared for others. That was a lovely surprise. I also liked how Poppy was described and the background of how she got to her mental state. Both of these characters were written plausibly.
Overall, The Gray Chamber was a good novel. It just wasn't as charming as The White City.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
After reading and very much enjoying The White City, my expectations for The Gray Chamber were rather high. The bits of humor that I loved in The White City were very rare in The Gray Chamber. The fictional story line wasn't as engaging for me. The change in Bane's opinion of Edyth from friendship to seeing her in a romantic light happened rather abruptly. Some events were a little cliche.
My favorite character was secondary character Lavinia. I expected that she would be bratty but was actually looking for true friendship and genuinely cared for others. That was a lovely surprise. I also liked how Poppy was described and the background of how she got to her mental state. Both of these characters were written plausibly.
Overall, The Gray Chamber was a good novel. It just wasn't as charming as The White City.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
January 7, 2022
The Gray Chamber is part of the True Colors series. They are historical fiction based on events that are not well know or forgotten, all crimes. In this book, Grace Hitchcock highlights how men were able to get female family members committed to asylums for their own reasons, not because the women had mental health issues. Edyth Foster's parents died when she was young and she was raised by her bachelor uncle. She is an heiress and will come into her fortune in a few months when she turns 25. Her uncle has recently married and little does Edyth know, but he has resented her all the years he has to take care of her. He and his wife concoct a plan to have her committed to Blackwell Island Asylum. With a clause in her father's will that if she goes insane, her uncle will inherit everything. While in the asylum, she meets Nellie Brown (aka Nellie Bly) who also seems to be as sane as she is.
I really liked this story. I had heard about the practice over the years and have read other stories where this happened to women. Men whose wives didn't produce a male heir, or who suffered from post partum depression. Some just wanted to marry someone else, so had them committed, such a sad time for women. This story was well written and did have a romance story tied in as well. Edyth had been in love with a friend for years and just before she disappears, he realizes that he cares for her as more than just a friend. Can they mount a rescue before her uncle takes possession of everything that she owns. I liked the various characters, except for the villains of course, but would have liked to have more background on them. The Nellie Bly angle was interesting and I do want to see if I can find the book Ten Days in a Madhouse that she wrote that began reforms. There is a bit of a Christian undertone to this story, where Edyth prays for strength and support, but it does not overpower the story. The narrator is Stina Nielsen, one I have listened to many times. I enjoy her performances that use her expression, tone and inflection to portray emotion and the various characters. I recommend this one to those who enjoy historical fiction based on crimes committed over the years.
I really liked this story. I had heard about the practice over the years and have read other stories where this happened to women. Men whose wives didn't produce a male heir, or who suffered from post partum depression. Some just wanted to marry someone else, so had them committed, such a sad time for women. This story was well written and did have a romance story tied in as well. Edyth had been in love with a friend for years and just before she disappears, he realizes that he cares for her as more than just a friend. Can they mount a rescue before her uncle takes possession of everything that she owns. I liked the various characters, except for the villains of course, but would have liked to have more background on them. The Nellie Bly angle was interesting and I do want to see if I can find the book Ten Days in a Madhouse that she wrote that began reforms. There is a bit of a Christian undertone to this story, where Edyth prays for strength and support, but it does not overpower the story. The narrator is Stina Nielsen, one I have listened to many times. I enjoy her performances that use her expression, tone and inflection to portray emotion and the various characters. I recommend this one to those who enjoy historical fiction based on crimes committed over the years.
December 19, 2020
Possibly the best of all of the True Crime Series (it's a daily toss-up on that), The Gray Chamber offers a realistic look into the seedy side of late nineteenth and early twentieth-century mental institutions and how corrupt they were. Seeing the story of Nellie Bly, reporter, through the eyes of a semi-fictional character is done with honesty, brilliance, and compassion.
I sat on the edge of my seat the whole way through. I'd purchased an ebook copy of the book to read for my podcast, but after reading it, I knew I had to have the paperback for my personal collection. Excellent characterization, no anachronisms that I recall, and spiritual content that tugged at your heart. A five-star read for sure.
I sat on the edge of my seat the whole way through. I'd purchased an ebook copy of the book to read for my podcast, but after reading it, I knew I had to have the paperback for my personal collection. Excellent characterization, no anachronisms that I recall, and spiritual content that tugged at your heart. A five-star read for sure.
January 8, 2020
3.5 stars
"Once you have tasted flight, you will forever walk the earth with your eyes skyward, for there you have been , and there you will always long to return." Leonardo da Vinci
Would she ever be free to walk the earth again with her eyes turned skyward, or had her world turned forever gray? Edyth Foster was terrified that color had been forever removed, that love had become forever denied, and that justice had been drowned in the depths of the sea. How had it come to this?
Exceptionally eccentric, but undeniably vivacious, heiress Edyth Foster never imagined that her unusual hobbies and accidental tendences would forfeit her entire future. Deemed insane by her greedy uncle, Edyth is whisked off to a mental asylum on Blackwell's Island without a trace. Desperate to find his beloved, Raoul Banebridge works feverishly to find her, while the answer to Edyth's predicament may be found within hospital's walls . . .. or will everyone be too late?
"Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil; for thou art with me." Psalm 23:4
What an outstanding story; a balance of hope and desperation that so many readers will identify as timeless.
"Once you have tasted flight, you will forever walk the earth with your eyes skyward, for there you have been , and there you will always long to return." Leonardo da Vinci
Would she ever be free to walk the earth again with her eyes turned skyward, or had her world turned forever gray? Edyth Foster was terrified that color had been forever removed, that love had become forever denied, and that justice had been drowned in the depths of the sea. How had it come to this?
Exceptionally eccentric, but undeniably vivacious, heiress Edyth Foster never imagined that her unusual hobbies and accidental tendences would forfeit her entire future. Deemed insane by her greedy uncle, Edyth is whisked off to a mental asylum on Blackwell's Island without a trace. Desperate to find his beloved, Raoul Banebridge works feverishly to find her, while the answer to Edyth's predicament may be found within hospital's walls . . .. or will everyone be too late?
"Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil; for thou art with me." Psalm 23:4
What an outstanding story; a balance of hope and desperation that so many readers will identify as timeless.
January 30, 2020
3.5
Edyth Foster does not favor traditional female pursuits and instead, chooses to fence, cycle, and get into all sorts of unintended mischief. When greed for her fortune overcomes her uncle, her eccentricities seem to support his claim of madness, and she ends up in Blackwell Island’s lunatic asylum. When everything she does reinforces her “diagnosis,” how can she ever hope to get out?
Historical stories set in an asylum are maddening, to say the least. Edyth has little reason to hope from within the walls of her prison—faced with endless threats, abuse, and “treatments”—yet she never gives up. With intrepid reporter Nellie Bly at her side, dashing fencing instructor Raoul Banebridge at work on the outside, and a necessary reminder of her faith, she is never as alone as she feels.
With all the complications of Edyth’s experience, Grace Hitchcock’s The Gray Chamber proves to be quite the suspenseful (and romantic) read. I will admit that the cheesy-sounding dialogue lessen my enjoyment a tad, but the overall stress of the situation still kept me enthralled from beginning to end. I look forward to reading more True Colors novels as they release.
This review is also posted on Hallie Reads.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and the opportunity to provide an honest review. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own.
Edyth Foster does not favor traditional female pursuits and instead, chooses to fence, cycle, and get into all sorts of unintended mischief. When greed for her fortune overcomes her uncle, her eccentricities seem to support his claim of madness, and she ends up in Blackwell Island’s lunatic asylum. When everything she does reinforces her “diagnosis,” how can she ever hope to get out?
Historical stories set in an asylum are maddening, to say the least. Edyth has little reason to hope from within the walls of her prison—faced with endless threats, abuse, and “treatments”—yet she never gives up. With intrepid reporter Nellie Bly at her side, dashing fencing instructor Raoul Banebridge at work on the outside, and a necessary reminder of her faith, she is never as alone as she feels.
With all the complications of Edyth’s experience, Grace Hitchcock’s The Gray Chamber proves to be quite the suspenseful (and romantic) read. I will admit that the cheesy-sounding dialogue lessen my enjoyment a tad, but the overall stress of the situation still kept me enthralled from beginning to end. I look forward to reading more True Colors novels as they release.
This review is also posted on Hallie Reads.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and the opportunity to provide an honest review. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own.
January 16, 2025
This was a great read, but it did give me nightmares, and mainly because it is based on fact. This horrible place really existed, and was used to actually destroy people, sick and sad.
There are smiles to be found when we follow our daring Ms. Edyth as she goes about NY City, doing what we take for granted, but back in the late 1880’s was considered unladylike.
Then we have her Uncle, yes, he is her guardian, at least for a few more weeks, she will then be 25, and able to assume control over her fortune. She also seems to finally gotten the attention of the man she loves, but can it ever be?
What we have here, plain and simple greed, and how they go about stealing the money, is just plain horrible.
Make sure you read the author’s notes at the end of this book, sad but true!
I received this book through Celebrate Lit. and was not required to give a positive review.
There are smiles to be found when we follow our daring Ms. Edyth as she goes about NY City, doing what we take for granted, but back in the late 1880’s was considered unladylike.
Then we have her Uncle, yes, he is her guardian, at least for a few more weeks, she will then be 25, and able to assume control over her fortune. She also seems to finally gotten the attention of the man she loves, but can it ever be?
What we have here, plain and simple greed, and how they go about stealing the money, is just plain horrible.
Make sure you read the author’s notes at the end of this book, sad but true!
I received this book through Celebrate Lit. and was not required to give a positive review.
January 24, 2020
The Gray Chamber by Grace Hitchcock is a powerful Christian historical tale set in 1887. It surrounds the asylum where women could be sent to for no good reason, forgotten and ill-treated. It is horrifying and barbaric. The novel has its roots in fact, around which, Grace Hitchcock has woven her tale.
Money and status are terrible masters, corrupting lives whose hearts lie in riches. There is nothing wrong with money and status if our hearts are aligned with God but when they are the foundations for our lives, we are in for a fall.
The lead character is a very modern, forward thinking young lady and as such, the establishment feels challenged by her.
We see the faithfulness of God who provides a peace in spite of our circumstances. There are times when all we can do is cling on to hope and trust that God is good.
It is beautiful to watch both friendships and love bud and blossom within the tale.
I am loving this True Crime series which The Gray Chamber is a part of. This series is highlighting periods in history where horrific things have happened that I was unaware of. I am being educated whilst I read and also inspired to do further research to delve deeper into history.
Thank you Grace Hitchcock for a powerful novel.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
Money and status are terrible masters, corrupting lives whose hearts lie in riches. There is nothing wrong with money and status if our hearts are aligned with God but when they are the foundations for our lives, we are in for a fall.
The lead character is a very modern, forward thinking young lady and as such, the establishment feels challenged by her.
We see the faithfulness of God who provides a peace in spite of our circumstances. There are times when all we can do is cling on to hope and trust that God is good.
It is beautiful to watch both friendships and love bud and blossom within the tale.
I am loving this True Crime series which The Gray Chamber is a part of. This series is highlighting periods in history where horrific things have happened that I was unaware of. I am being educated whilst I read and also inspired to do further research to delve deeper into history.
Thank you Grace Hitchcock for a powerful novel.
I received this book for free. A favourable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
February 16, 2020
Wow - what a book! The cover was very mysterious and held a dark secret.
The year is 1887 in New York City. Edyth Foster is a kind and giving young lady of 25. She is eccentric and years ahead of many women in this era. She loves to fence, wear outlandish outfits and ride her velocipede. She has a very good friend with the nickname of Bane - he is her fencing instructor.
Many people don't understand Edyth. Her uncle decides to have her committed so that he can spend her inheritance. What a mean and fiendish man! His wife is no better.
Edyth tries to prove to everyone that she is not insane. No one will listen. In the asylum Edyth makes friends with two young women - Poppy and Nellie Brown. Little did Edyth know at the time about Nellie's true identity. If it wasn't for Bane and Nellie and Edyth using her very strong instincts and wits, Edyth's life would have been endangered.
This novel was written from a true story. I cannot imagine the horrors that many women in this facility endured and only because they were different.
I highly recommend this book - it was one that kept me in suspense.
The year is 1887 in New York City. Edyth Foster is a kind and giving young lady of 25. She is eccentric and years ahead of many women in this era. She loves to fence, wear outlandish outfits and ride her velocipede. She has a very good friend with the nickname of Bane - he is her fencing instructor.
Many people don't understand Edyth. Her uncle decides to have her committed so that he can spend her inheritance. What a mean and fiendish man! His wife is no better.
Edyth tries to prove to everyone that she is not insane. No one will listen. In the asylum Edyth makes friends with two young women - Poppy and Nellie Brown. Little did Edyth know at the time about Nellie's true identity. If it wasn't for Bane and Nellie and Edyth using her very strong instincts and wits, Edyth's life would have been endangered.
This novel was written from a true story. I cannot imagine the horrors that many women in this facility endured and only because they were different.
I highly recommend this book - it was one that kept me in suspense.
October 16, 2019
Another thrilling story in the True Crimes series! A romantic suspense that swept me up in the reading and held my rapt attention throughout. I couldn't read it fast enough!
"Fear not, for the Lord will be with you."
I found myself quickly attached to the main characters, and held my breath when it seemed all hope was lost. A few Bible verses and prayers of the characters, especially when in peril, kept the story from becoming too dark, and brought inspiration to the tale. I shudder to think that some of these events actually happened. The treatment of the mentally ill in the 1880's and corruption of the system were horrible. Nellie Bly's account and her part in the tale was well done, adding authenticity to poor Edyth's experience. The conclusion was done smoothly, with a gentle wrap up, making for a very satisfying read.
Recommend for readers who enjoy historical romantic suspense with faith, based on real events. For further reading about the historical treatment of the mentally ill, I recommend Jane Kirkpatrick's book, One Glorious Ambition, about the work of Dorothea Dix.
5 stars!
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
"Fear not, for the Lord will be with you."
I found myself quickly attached to the main characters, and held my breath when it seemed all hope was lost. A few Bible verses and prayers of the characters, especially when in peril, kept the story from becoming too dark, and brought inspiration to the tale. I shudder to think that some of these events actually happened. The treatment of the mentally ill in the 1880's and corruption of the system were horrible. Nellie Bly's account and her part in the tale was well done, adding authenticity to poor Edyth's experience. The conclusion was done smoothly, with a gentle wrap up, making for a very satisfying read.
Recommend for readers who enjoy historical romantic suspense with faith, based on real events. For further reading about the historical treatment of the mentally ill, I recommend Jane Kirkpatrick's book, One Glorious Ambition, about the work of Dorothea Dix.
5 stars!
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
October 25, 2023
highlighted the mistreatment of those mentally ill (and those locked away who aren't)
January 14, 2020
If you have not read any of the True Colors series, a series based on true American crimes, I highly recommend that you do. Each book can be read as a standalone and is written by different authors. Not only have I enjoyed reading books by some of my favorite authors, I have met a few more through reading the books in this series. I first read Grace Hitchcock's writings in this series.
Ms. Hitchcock's lyrical prose paints a picture of the horrors of the women's asylum on Blackwell Island. While the story of abuse, negligence and false diagnoses of Blackwell Island are based on historical fact, Edythe and her story are fictional. We do have a cameo appearance of a real historical figure, Nelly Bly, the reporter who uncovered the horrors of Blackwell Island and consequently published a series of incriminating articles that caused change for the treatment of patients in asylums.
I loved Edythe's story. Ms. Hitchcock gives her readers a heroine that is filled with grit. At first, I felt that she displayed some of the entitled expectations that were associated with those of her class. But I couldn't help but be drawn into her plight, and found that she exhibited courage and compassion in horrible circumstances. It was her journey of faith that tugged at my heart bringing light to an otherwise dark story.
This story had enough history, suspense and romance to hold me spellbound. I look forward to reading more of this series and more of MS. Hitchcock's works.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Ms. Hitchcock's lyrical prose paints a picture of the horrors of the women's asylum on Blackwell Island. While the story of abuse, negligence and false diagnoses of Blackwell Island are based on historical fact, Edythe and her story are fictional. We do have a cameo appearance of a real historical figure, Nelly Bly, the reporter who uncovered the horrors of Blackwell Island and consequently published a series of incriminating articles that caused change for the treatment of patients in asylums.
I loved Edythe's story. Ms. Hitchcock gives her readers a heroine that is filled with grit. At first, I felt that she displayed some of the entitled expectations that were associated with those of her class. But I couldn't help but be drawn into her plight, and found that she exhibited courage and compassion in horrible circumstances. It was her journey of faith that tugged at my heart bringing light to an otherwise dark story.
This story had enough history, suspense and romance to hold me spellbound. I look forward to reading more of this series and more of MS. Hitchcock's works.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
October 19, 2019
I am really enjoying the True Colors series from Barbour Publishing! The Gray Chamber did not disappoint! First of all this cover is really haunting and really reflects the atmosphere that is created in the book. The story was intriguing and the characters were smart, capable, and easy to like. This novel really showcased some of the unfair and brutal treatments that some patients endured on Blackwell Island. It was chilling. As soon as Edyth entered the asylum I felt tense and anxious. There was such a sense of hopelessness to her situation, but she didn't lose hope in spite of her dire circumstances. There were several intense and suspenseful scenes in this book that had me on the edge of my seat! I was happy with the conclusion of the book and also felt like I had learned a bit of history within the context of this story.
February 25, 2025
Wowzers! This book gave me the creeps, but in a good way. Grace Hitchcock captures the time and place and you feel like you are trapped in the lunatic asylum with Edyth and the real life character Nellie Bly. Edyth is an engaging character who has eccentric likes for the time period, such as fencing & riding a velocipede. I felt like I was sucked into 1887 and the times for declaring someone, especially women mentally ill were atrocious. You don’t know who is trustworthy and who is shady and self seeking. This book has all the elements of a great read. You will be captivated from the beginning and sitting on the edge of your seat by the end. I highly recommend this, as it is totally captivating.
I received a complimentary copy from CelebrateLit/author. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
I received a complimentary copy from CelebrateLit/author. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
March 5, 2020
They say she's crazy...but is she really...?
I've seriously been getting into the True Colors series and The Gray Chamber was no exception. Grace Hitchcock's second offering in the series was exciting, romantic, and creepy. Really, did you think you could have a book partially set in the women's lunatic asylum on Blackwell Island and not have some creep factor going on?
One of the most shocking things about the 1800s is just how little it took for a woman to be committed to a mental asylum. No joke, more than one woman was committed for reading novels. Good thing I didn't live back then! Journalist Nellie Bly went undercover as patient at Blackwell Island and big changes were made at the facility because of her testimony as to what went on. My school history book mentioned Nellie Bly's work, but, as so often happens with fiction, The Gray Chamber really brought the whole dark business home.
Grace Hitchcock has a winner in The Gray Chamber. I very much enjoyed reading it, from the quirky antics of the heroine to the danger in the asylum to the final showdown with the villain. If you are into historical fiction based on real history you should check out this book from Grace Hitchcock, as well as the rest of the books in the True Colors series...
(I received a copy of this book from the author. All opinions are entirely my own.)
I've seriously been getting into the True Colors series and The Gray Chamber was no exception. Grace Hitchcock's second offering in the series was exciting, romantic, and creepy. Really, did you think you could have a book partially set in the women's lunatic asylum on Blackwell Island and not have some creep factor going on?
One of the most shocking things about the 1800s is just how little it took for a woman to be committed to a mental asylum. No joke, more than one woman was committed for reading novels. Good thing I didn't live back then! Journalist Nellie Bly went undercover as patient at Blackwell Island and big changes were made at the facility because of her testimony as to what went on. My school history book mentioned Nellie Bly's work, but, as so often happens with fiction, The Gray Chamber really brought the whole dark business home.
Grace Hitchcock has a winner in The Gray Chamber. I very much enjoyed reading it, from the quirky antics of the heroine to the danger in the asylum to the final showdown with the villain. If you are into historical fiction based on real history you should check out this book from Grace Hitchcock, as well as the rest of the books in the True Colors series...
(I received a copy of this book from the author. All opinions are entirely my own.)
October 16, 2022
I expected this to be one of my favorite ones as I've always been an admirer of what Nelly Bly accomplished in her undercover in the asylum. But I really struggled with this one.
I don't think it has anything to so with the author because I really enjoyed her White City. I think it has to do with the fact I really couldn't do the horror of the abuse that went on. I picked this one up almost last. I think the Pink Bonnet will also be a struggle for me. So I was mentally trying to prepare for this. As a whole story, it was good. I loved seeing Edyth go from casual belief to clinging the Truth found in simple childlike faith with another inmate, Poppy.
I skimmed over much. I emotionally couldn't do it. We think we have come so far in our treatment of people, but it's all under a different blanket now.
One thing I really appreciated about how Grace Hitchcock ended the book was to show how there was residual trauma with Edyth. It wasn't all over and done with the day she returned to "normal".
I hope my review gives adequate explanation for my star rating. Is it a book *I* enjoyed? Not as much as the others. But that has more to do with the setting of the book than what the author wrote.
I don't think it has anything to so with the author because I really enjoyed her White City. I think it has to do with the fact I really couldn't do the horror of the abuse that went on. I picked this one up almost last. I think the Pink Bonnet will also be a struggle for me. So I was mentally trying to prepare for this. As a whole story, it was good. I loved seeing Edyth go from casual belief to clinging the Truth found in simple childlike faith with another inmate, Poppy.
I skimmed over much. I emotionally couldn't do it. We think we have come so far in our treatment of people, but it's all under a different blanket now.
One thing I really appreciated about how Grace Hitchcock ended the book was to show how there was residual trauma with Edyth. It wasn't all over and done with the day she returned to "normal".
I hope my review gives adequate explanation for my star rating. Is it a book *I* enjoyed? Not as much as the others. But that has more to do with the setting of the book than what the author wrote.
January 1, 2020
The Gray Chamber by Grace Hitchcock is a delightful glance into the world of insane asylums during the 1900's. I have always known that asylums were some pretty creepy places during the 1900's, but Hitchcock does a fabulous job at showing the horrors that occurred to normal woman who were sent there by the men who claimed to love them. No wonder some of the women actually went crazy. Horrible things and abuse happened to them while they were imprisoned in these places. I couldn't imagine the horror, uncleanliness, and the abuse some of these sane women had to put up with. I really enjoyed how Hitchcock made Edyth a fighter who struggled for her freedom and was willing to help others escape too. I really liked the element of including Nellie Bly in the story too. I knew some of what she did, but this made it a little more realistic. Overall, The Gray Chamber was a quick and delightful read. I enjoyed this book and hope for more mysteries from Hitchcock. If you enjoyed this story, then pick up Elizabeth Blyer Younts novel The Bright Unknown.
I received a complimentary copy of The Gray Chamber by Grace Hitchcock from Barbour Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
I received a complimentary copy of The Gray Chamber by Grace Hitchcock from Barbour Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 337 reviews