A Dozen Books in One - And All Good
On some level this may be one of the most densely layered middle grade books I've ever read. By that I mean that it would probably engage readers from the early chapter book level all the way up to confident early YA readers. It's just that subtle, well crafted and ambitious. It is good humored, laugh-out-loud funny, generous and lovely.
In its most basic form this is the story of a shy, neurotic germaphobe kid, Franklin, and the tough-egg new fifth grade girl, Sarah, who upsets his safe routines. It has some scenes that verge on slapstick and a fair amount of school-daze comedy. There are some funny lines and bits and some predictable elementary school humor.
Looking deeper we have a hero who knows he needs to grow out of his shell and a heroine whose confidence, stubbornness and energy drive him on. There are insights about independence, loyalty, character and friendship that dawn on Franklin, mainly by virtue of being displayed by Sarah.
Beyond and above that we have a hero who becomes more of a passive observer in his own story, (think Nick Carraway from "The Great Gatsby"), who learns about growing up by watching the transformation of Sarah. Half way through this becomes Sarah's story, Sarah's book, and Sarah's tragedy/comedy. The story becomes one about hope and overcoming adversity.
Even beyond that, and moving into adult territory, we follow Franklin's mother's hopes for an independent son and a stable life as they are transformed and realized by her contact with and involvement in the life of Sarah. We see hints of and aspects of adult drama and real life issues through the unreliable and often uncomprehending eyes of Franklin, who doesn't understand the import of half of what he's relating, even though we do.
The amazing thing is that any reader can read and enjoy this book on any of those levels. And get this - no matter where you are in your reading comprehension, and no matter how much or how little you invest in teasing out the book's subtleties, it is funny and heart warming. Franklin's little observations and throwaway lines are priceless. His timing is superb, and his vaguely grumpy, oddball, neurotic approach to the narrative is pithy and memorable. This book is loaded with funny lines.
And, the book is built on a wide variety of remarkably distinct and not-cliched characters. Each one , (a librarian, the fifth grade teacher, a pharmacist who appears in only one scene, Sarah's father), is fully realized and essential to the book working on all its levels. And the dialogue. Some of Franklin's conversations with his Mom or with Gloria the safety consultant, read like transcripts of old improv bits by smart, fine-tuned comedy teams like Nichols and May, or Stiller and Meara. It's that good.
So - funny, touching, tender, hopeful, ambitious and honest - this is gentle, well conceived and gracefully knowing humor. This goes on the bookshelf.
Please note that I found this book while browsing in our local library. I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.