I’ve been reading James Patterson books for over twenty years. During that time, like most of his fans, my favorite character has always been Alex Cross. He was Patterson’s first detective series that helped lay the foundation for his kingdom of several bestselling series and stand-alone novels. For me, Alex has remained a fierce, intellectual knight of moral character and one of the world’s greatest serial hunters.
I remember reading the Alex’s first adventure, “Along came a Spider” and almost cried when Alex, then a widower, faced the loss of his new love in an ending twist I would never forget. In the twenty-seven years following, there have been some good (and excellent) adventures, including about four books back when Alex discovered and met his father, who was thought dead for many years. There were also some less-than-stellar outings along the way, but I generally looked forward to the end of each year when another Alex Cross adventure was published.
Now, the 27th book in the series – “Criss Cross” – is in my hands and the reading completed.
The book opens with Alex and his longtime partner and best friend, John Sampson, witnessing the execution of a killer, Michael Edgerton, they helped get convicted. Immediately following that emotional act, they are called to the scene of a crime back in their hometown where they find a murdered wife and a note personal y left for Alex that reads – "You messed up big time, Dr. Cross" and signed, simply – “M”. This is the fourth note over the last twelve years that Alex has found left for him, and the worst part is that he thought they had already removed this killer when Edgerton was executed.
Alex must figure out whether they get the wrong person or if is this a copy-cat killer as “M” sends Cross on a roller-coaster ride of multiple criminal activities, including kidnaping and multiple homicides, all set-up to trick and humiliate him. Each crime sends Alex down a false trail and leaving him frustrated, and his family at risk. As “M” decides to come after Alex’s family members and make him pay for the sins of his past…
As any avid fan would expect, Patterson runs multiple plots, jumping all over the place from Alex’s professional life one moment to his family situations the next. In this outing though, much of the novel is spent with Cross running from one criminal activity to another, leaving him and the reader little time to process what happened and how it fits into the bigger storyline picture. Alex spends most of the book chasing and being manipulated by the elusive villain that is called “M”.
Like a typical Patterson thriller, the tempo is fastmoving with lots of action and drama, as well as violence and death. The plotlines pretty much follow’s Patterson’s usual developments, including curveballs thrown in to make the outcome more interesting. However, things move along at such a breakneck speed that it created two problems for me.
The first is that the plot lost several layers of reality. Yes, those plot choices made the story more entertaining, but it went too far at times. That disjointed, breakneck speed of plotting took some of the heart out of the story and left it a bit too mechanical and predictable at key moments. All of the running around took away from the human attachment that connects us with the strength and power of Alex Cross’ character
Second, and more importantly, it seems that Patterson is having challenges with creating strong foes to challenge Cross. Ever since Alex’s greatest foe, Kyle Craig, was finally vanquished (or was he?), finding a worthy opponent has sometimes been lacking. To be fair, it’s probably not easy to come up with new and interesting serial killers that provide Alex a real test. As much as the build-up to who “M” is and what drives him or her to terrorize Cross and his family, the ending was a bit predictable, as well as a letdown.
Overall, this was an okay book for me, but not one of his stronger books. Patterson tends to focus on large -scale plotlines that end-up going all over the place in a schizophrenic, shotgun approach that ends up being messy and disconnected. In contrast, I find that I enjoy a more personalized Alex Cross story where his hunt for a serial killer is layered, builds steadily and consistently with quality clues, and his family members are fully involved in active roles. The pace and villain detracted from the mystery and tension, and the story really felt like it could have been better developed and less predictable. Here’s hoping to better outing next time…