As a librarian, I see a LOT of emails from publishers, book sellers, JLG, ALA, blahblahblah. I put Me Moth in my library wishlist queue because of one of those emails, and I borrowed it. It has over 4 stars (which I did not know before reading it) on Goodreads. I like (wish italics we're available) many books written in verse. Out of the Dust, well the first 2/3 was amazing. Brilliant. Moving.
I started reading Me Moth. At the beginning of the book, I thought, okay, two beautiful, broken outcasts who are talented enough to go to Juilliard happen to come together after meeting AT SCHOOL, where one does work, gets grades, and receives a report card, no? But I digress. It's a little much, I thought, but I'll keep with it. As it's a book in verse, the similes were creative and descriptive until they weren't. The repetition was powerful until it wasn't. By close to the end, I was begging for it to be over. My skin crawled every time an overused simile or metaphor appeared, and I yelled at the book when the repetition was painful. Like, really, really painful. The book became trite, overdone with every cliche, and the worst cliche of all - the ending (insert an obscene amount of throw up emojis here)... GAAAAAAAH! I have not disliked a book this much in years. I haven't even written a review in years because I read so many YA books, I just rate them then crack open another. I just finished this right now, and it's bedtime, and I know I'm not going to be able to sleep because this book was so overwhelmingly and densely something. I don't even know what word I can use. Gooey maybe. But not good gooey. Despite all the candy bar similes and the spilling out caramel crap, it's a bad, bad type of gooey. What's gooey but skin-crawly? Gummy. Drippy. Yucky. This book was yucky. I really can't think of anything that is unpleasant enough.
Please help me find the right word.
Blech. I haven't read any Goodreads-user comments about this book, but I can just imagine the gooey grossness of how deep and meaningful and wonderful and artistic and creative and deep and meaningful and poignant and magical and beautiful and deep and meaningful and emotional and special and poetic and deep and meaningful this book is.
Ew.
Ew.