I am only giving this such a high rating out of nostalgia. Around 2011, the Otherworld series was one of my all-time favorite series. I was obsessed.
This, sadly, was not really a worthy installment. The issue isn't just that it was YA. It was that the characters kept indulging their angst. And even with a few dead bodies and people fighting for their lives, the stakes felt very low. Characters kept losing each other, and would openly remark upon how they were acting out horror movie tropes. I agree with another review on here saying that the characters kept feeling the need to have weird little PSA moments. That when they are dealing with a demon, one who openly admits to wanting to foment chaos, the characters have to take the time to gently reprove other characters not to misgender the demon.
Characters wasted a lot of time on teen romantic drama, or Generation Z "I don't like labels" nonsense, that should really have taken a back seat to the demonic threat. And as a gay man, I find the author's attempt to be LGBTQ-inclusive problematic.
In an earlier foray into YA fiction set in the Otherworld, the Darkness Rising series, Armstrong included one lesbian character. She gave this lesbian short, spiky hair, and a tendency to punch people. She had the character openly call herself a stereotype. When she came out to the protagonist, Armstrong had the protagonist *reprimand* her, and I only dimly recall why. For being concerned how straight people would react? Something like that. At the time, I thought Armstrong had no idea how to write gay characters, and I stand by that opinion.
We already know from last book that Logan isn't sure what his orientation is. That, all by itself, I have problems with. Here, Armstrong states that he masturbates about as much as normal, but feels no particularly deep attraction to anyone. To the point that when he walked up to a female character, whom had not expressed any interest in him, more than a paragraph was dedicated to him waxing on about how he was NOT attracted to her.
... So what is he masturbating to? Sorry to be crass, and I know I don't speak for everyone, especially not people with female genitalia. But when he sees penises or he sees breasts, he either gets aroused or he does not. For a man it is obvious. Arousal or lack thereof. Simple. Binary.
Armstrong writes him as a bisexual with an exceedingly low sex drive, right up until she says he still masturbates like normal. Then what the Hell is he fantasizing about?! I can't speak for everyone, but based on my experience? He should know whether he is gay at puberty. After that it is a question of whether he wants to admit it to himself.
This is perhaps unsurprising. I also think Armstrong doesn't know how to write a realistic molestation victim in Elena. She alternates between having a guarded, frigid personality, and ravenously sexual, within the space of the *same book*.
We are given a new origin for werewolves here. Now, matching the short-lived television series loosely based on the books, werewolves are characterized as "cursed." They weren't for the last 20 years, but, ok. ... Is Paige going to sleep with Nick now, too? If the books are trying to match the absurd changes of the tv show?
The quality of writing here was sub-par. The adult characters I wanted to see mostly just appeared as cameos, at most. The fight scenes were possibly the best part. But our teenage protagonists weren't allowed to have the satisfaction of actually killing anyone.
Overall a swing and a miss.