What do you think?
Rate this book
Hold Fast
Morgan Turner, agent to the Winthrop estate, owes everything to his benefactor. When the late baronet’s will tasks him with finding the lost heir and making a gentleman of him, he is determined to succeed.
Thirteen years ago, Evelyn Winthrop ran away to sea. Now that his hated patriarch is dead, the ancestral home he returns to is more shadowed than what he left behind. Ungrateful relations and old friends alike tie a knot of scandal and depravity only a sailor could hope to unravel. And all the while, the siren song of the sea calls him to return at the first opportunity.
Neither anticipated forming more tender attachments.
To Evelyn, his unexpectedly handsome agent is the only thing anchoring him to shore. He sees a captain’s soul within Morgan, and his heart is caught upon the hook of command—if only Morgan would return his affections.
To Morgan, his new employer’s charms threaten to tear down the thorns that have grown around his heart—thorns he cultivated to restrain his unnatural instincts.
When the estate and all who live there are threatened by a maelstrom of bitter secrets and sinister plots, it is down to Morgan to take command, down to Evelyn to hold fast, and down to them both to navigate their own treacherous sea.
Thirteen years ago, Evelyn Winthrop ran away to sea. Now that his hated patriarch is dead, the ancestral home he returns to is more shadowed than what he left behind. Ungrateful relations and old friends alike tie a knot of scandal and depravity only a sailor could hope to unravel. And all the while, the siren song of the sea calls him to return at the first opportunity.
Neither anticipated forming more tender attachments.
To Evelyn, his unexpectedly handsome agent is the only thing anchoring him to shore. He sees a captain’s soul within Morgan, and his heart is caught upon the hook of command—if only Morgan would return his affections.
To Morgan, his new employer’s charms threaten to tear down the thorns that have grown around his heart—thorns he cultivated to restrain his unnatural instincts.
When the estate and all who live there are threatened by a maelstrom of bitter secrets and sinister plots, it is down to Morgan to take command, down to Evelyn to hold fast, and down to them both to navigate their own treacherous sea.
294 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 31, 2018
20 people are currently reading
538 people want to read
About the author
Sebastian Nothwell
8 books361 followersSebastian Nothwell writes queer romance. When he is not writing, he is counting down the minutes until he is permitted to return to writing. He is absolutely not a ghost and definitely did not die in 1895.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
April 27, 2019
This author's writing style keeps me engaged with his characters, even though the plot sometimes pushed the bounds of reality.
Evelyn Winthrop was 14 and heir to a baronetcy when his father caught him with another boy, and he escaped and ran away to sea on a whaling ship. Evelyn fell out of touch, and his younger brother Basil has been the presumed heir since, but Evelyn's father on his deathbed reveals that he believes his older son is alive, and directs his agent, Morgan, to find the young man who will inherit everything, leaving Basil with crumbs.
Morgan sends messages out to bring Evelyn home. He has no idea that the reason Evelyn ran is akin to the sin which he himself tries to overcome. When these two gay men meet, the attraction is immediate and powerful. Morgan tries to do his job, to help Evelyn gain the skills he will need to govern his estate, while Evelyn keeps telling himself it's all temporary till he's off to sea again.
But several of the manor staff quit, due to disdain for Evelyn's sailor ways, putting pressure on the rest. Evelyn also realizes his younger brother Basil has become a drunken, dissolute young man who would be the ruin of the estate, which makes leaving feel irresponsible. And as Evelyn begins to fall more deeply for Morgan, leaving also seems less appealing. If Evelyn stays, though, he's going to have to transform into a gentleman, and that's not as simple as it sounds. Especially when an old friend with questionable intentions arrives in Basil's wake.
Some of the conflicts/difficulties I anticipated in this book were swept aside, and there was a lack of shades of gray, but it was a fun read.
The ending was a bit messy and over the top - I wasn't convinced that Morgan and Evelyn had all the evidence they needed to justify their final action (versus a supposition) which bothered me in otherwise heroic characters. There was also less emotional resonance after their actions than I would have expected, especially given Morgan's supposed mental state. I'd have loved to see the story run a bit longer to show how Morgan got past those events and how the living arrangements were worked out (one of my curiosities with any historical that suggest an HEA.) But yay for strong female characters, and some unusual hobbies (fern collecting and scrimshaw) and historical details. There were a lot of fun elements to this story.
Trigger warnings for
Evelyn Winthrop was 14 and heir to a baronetcy when his father caught him with another boy, and he escaped and ran away to sea on a whaling ship. Evelyn fell out of touch, and his younger brother Basil has been the presumed heir since, but Evelyn's father on his deathbed reveals that he believes his older son is alive, and directs his agent, Morgan, to find the young man who will inherit everything, leaving Basil with crumbs.
Morgan sends messages out to bring Evelyn home. He has no idea that the reason Evelyn ran is akin to the sin which he himself tries to overcome. When these two gay men meet, the attraction is immediate and powerful. Morgan tries to do his job, to help Evelyn gain the skills he will need to govern his estate, while Evelyn keeps telling himself it's all temporary till he's off to sea again.
But several of the manor staff quit, due to disdain for Evelyn's sailor ways, putting pressure on the rest. Evelyn also realizes his younger brother Basil has become a drunken, dissolute young man who would be the ruin of the estate, which makes leaving feel irresponsible. And as Evelyn begins to fall more deeply for Morgan, leaving also seems less appealing. If Evelyn stays, though, he's going to have to transform into a gentleman, and that's not as simple as it sounds. Especially when an old friend with questionable intentions arrives in Basil's wake.
Some of the conflicts/difficulties I anticipated in this book were swept aside, and there was a lack of shades of gray, but it was a fun read.
The ending was a bit messy and over the top - I wasn't convinced that Morgan and Evelyn had all the evidence they needed to justify their final action (versus a supposition) which bothered me in otherwise heroic characters. There was also less emotional resonance after their actions than I would have expected, especially given Morgan's supposed mental state. I'd have loved to see the story run a bit longer to show how Morgan got past those events and how the living arrangements were worked out (one of my curiosities with any historical that suggest an HEA.) But yay for strong female characters, and some unusual hobbies (fern collecting and scrimshaw) and historical details. There were a lot of fun elements to this story.
Trigger warnings for
July 15, 2020
This is my second time reading Sebastian Nothwell's work and it didn't disappoint. Well researched subjects, wonderful use of words and turn of phrase, diverse characters and authentic historical feel. Despite the typical trope of rough around the edges lord needing tutelage in manners, the author brought new things to the table: power play between employer and employee, lord's slightly ambiguous character and all the angst one could stand all wrapped up in aristocratic world of intrigue, social niceties and so-called noblesse oblige. I liked the crossed lines between people of different classes, the at times sweet affection and the strength of character required to do what must be done. The novel is aptly named Hold Fast, for both men needed to hold fast to their feelings, convictions and resolve to stay alive and together.
The romance between lost and found baron Evelyn Winthrop and his agent Morgan Turner is not cut and dry. Two men learn to love, to let go and to trust each other. While Evelyn is easy-going and a bit flighty due to his years spending a-whaling away from class differences and rules, Morgan is the epitome of survivor who rose from personal tragedy, abuse and always being looked down at. I liked that both men took each other's traits: Evelyn got a bit more responsible while Morgan learned to relax a bit. There was no shortage of steam (I love intimate scenes in historical setting) that author wrote with emotion and authenticity, and so much turmoil and personal self discovery. I loved every page.
The villainous characters of the story were truly despicable. They caused me to bite my nails in my desire to do them bodily harm, so much pain and suffering they've caused. But never fear, the author didn't leave us in a lurch, but gave them their comeuppance. I enjoyed the secondary characters that showcased the MCs in wonderful light. I wavered in my opinion about Evelyn at times since he nearly did unforgivable things, but stayed in line just so in order for me not to hate him. I liked how he was with Morgan though, the amount of love and devotion was unmistakable in the end. The conclusion of the story was very satisfying and left me knowing that both men found their place in each other's arms and in society. Wonderful historical romance with elements of power exchange in intimate setting, well paced plot and an array of characters that made me love, hate them and everything in between. I recommend this story! Copy received for my honest and unbiased review
The romance between lost and found baron Evelyn Winthrop and his agent Morgan Turner is not cut and dry. Two men learn to love, to let go and to trust each other. While Evelyn is easy-going and a bit flighty due to his years spending a-whaling away from class differences and rules, Morgan is the epitome of survivor who rose from personal tragedy, abuse and always being looked down at. I liked that both men took each other's traits: Evelyn got a bit more responsible while Morgan learned to relax a bit. There was no shortage of steam (I love intimate scenes in historical setting) that author wrote with emotion and authenticity, and so much turmoil and personal self discovery. I loved every page.
The villainous characters of the story were truly despicable. They caused me to bite my nails in my desire to do them bodily harm, so much pain and suffering they've caused. But never fear, the author didn't leave us in a lurch, but gave them their comeuppance. I enjoyed the secondary characters that showcased the MCs in wonderful light. I wavered in my opinion about Evelyn at times since he nearly did unforgivable things, but stayed in line just so in order for me not to hate him. I liked how he was with Morgan though, the amount of love and devotion was unmistakable in the end. The conclusion of the story was very satisfying and left me knowing that both men found their place in each other's arms and in society. Wonderful historical romance with elements of power exchange in intimate setting, well paced plot and an array of characters that made me love, hate them and everything in between. I recommend this story! Copy received for my honest and unbiased review
February 23, 2019
Note: This was originally published with the title "Take me like a sailor" - just so you don't accidentally buy it twice. "Hold Fast" is a much better title, btw.
This is another highly engaging historical romance by this author. Although I frequently wanted to slap the characters I found myself thoroughly entertained. My only criticism is that the book could do with a little tightning and that the villains were maybe a tiny bit OTT but at the end of the day it is a pretty good historical romance with very relatable characters. I'm looking forward to the next book by this author.
Recommended.
This is another highly engaging historical romance by this author. Although I frequently wanted to slap the characters I found myself thoroughly entertained. My only criticism is that the book could do with a little tightning and that the villains were maybe a tiny bit OTT but at the end of the day it is a pretty good historical romance with very relatable characters. I'm looking forward to the next book by this author.
Recommended.
April 12, 2024
Don't mind me; just determinedly making my way through Sebastian's backlist like a woman possessed.
Whaling is sexy. You heard it here first, folks. Whaling. is. fucking. sexy. (mind you, in a entirely fictional sense - we love the whales)
This was everything I hoped it would be and more. Following the death of a baronet, for whom Morgan is an agent, Morgan searches for the man's runaway son like a pirate in search of treasure. He finds him; a brawny, sunshine-y Adonis covered in tattoos - some that point to a considerable piece of treasure on his very person (X marks the spot, indeed). But nothing is more valuable than the connection these two share.
I love everything about this story and I wouldn't change a single word. The gorgeous prose (as always), Morgan's obsession with ferns, Evelyn's obsession with Morgan, the subtle (but artfully written) BDSM elements, the side characters (even the more nefarious characters who I love to hate).
Add Sebastian Nothwell to the list of authors who could write damn near anything and I'm sure I'd love it. I'd read his grocery list if he let me.
Whaling is sexy. You heard it here first, folks. Whaling. is. fucking. sexy. (mind you, in a entirely fictional sense - we love the whales)
This was everything I hoped it would be and more. Following the death of a baronet, for whom Morgan is an agent, Morgan searches for the man's runaway son like a pirate in search of treasure. He finds him; a brawny, sunshine-y Adonis covered in tattoos - some that point to a considerable piece of treasure on his very person (X marks the spot, indeed). But nothing is more valuable than the connection these two share.
I love everything about this story and I wouldn't change a single word. The gorgeous prose (as always), Morgan's obsession with ferns, Evelyn's obsession with Morgan, the subtle (but artfully written) BDSM elements, the side characters (even the more nefarious characters who I love to hate).
Add Sebastian Nothwell to the list of authors who could write damn near anything and I'm sure I'd love it. I'd read his grocery list if he let me.
April 10, 2024
I'm a Sebastian Nothwell truther, what can I say?
It is a truth universally acknowledged that when I hold a Sebastian Nothwell book in my hands, I must fly through it at the speed of light. I don't make the rules, I'm afraid! It was just that good!
This is different than some of Nothwell's other works somehow, but just as good. It reminds me of my favorite Cat Sebastian books with a little more kick to them. Here we have two men who are fixed in their duties and the things they enjoy, but somehow end up compromising with one another and finding themselves all the better for it. I reached a certain point in this novel at which I felt like I would simply pass away if I didn't find out what happened next.
I don't want to discuss the plot too much for fear of spoiling it, but just know that if you're a fan of Nothwell's work, this book delivers on all the usual delights: swoony romance, top-tier spice, high stakes in an otherwise softer setting, and (of course) a happy ending.
Reading this book makes me excited for the other works the author has in progress and I will be eagerly awaiting them!
It is a truth universally acknowledged that when I hold a Sebastian Nothwell book in my hands, I must fly through it at the speed of light. I don't make the rules, I'm afraid! It was just that good!
This is different than some of Nothwell's other works somehow, but just as good. It reminds me of my favorite Cat Sebastian books with a little more kick to them. Here we have two men who are fixed in their duties and the things they enjoy, but somehow end up compromising with one another and finding themselves all the better for it. I reached a certain point in this novel at which I felt like I would simply pass away if I didn't find out what happened next.
I don't want to discuss the plot too much for fear of spoiling it, but just know that if you're a fan of Nothwell's work, this book delivers on all the usual delights: swoony romance, top-tier spice, high stakes in an otherwise softer setting, and (of course) a happy ending.
Reading this book makes me excited for the other works the author has in progress and I will be eagerly awaiting them!
September 20, 2025
This was stunning. Marvelous. I was torn, at all times, between consuming this book in one bite or savoring it. Somewhere amidst falling in love with the main characters, their lovely household, and the charming Deveraux siblings, I managed to slow-crawl through the first bit before devouring the last 70% in a day.
At the time of this review, Hold Fast only has 296 other ratings—that feels like a crime, dammit! With two Nothwell titles under my belt, I can happily declare I’ll read anything this man writes.
I’ll even overlook the giving of Basil, my most beloved name, to such an abhorrent character. 😒
At the time of this review, Hold Fast only has 296 other ratings—that feels like a crime, dammit! With two Nothwell titles under my belt, I can happily declare I’ll read anything this man writes.
April 28, 2021
Another convincing period piece by Sebastian Nothwell.
My favourite still remains the lovely Mr Warren's Profession but this novel does deliver some interesting characters and a plot full with twists and turns that make the story a real page-turner.
Morgan is endearing and long-suffering, Evelyn an out-of-place baronet if ever there was one. And together, they make a lovely couple (despite a distinct tendency of avoiding communication, but this serves the plot well).
Very entertaining!
My favourite still remains the lovely Mr Warren's Profession but this novel does deliver some interesting characters and a plot full with twists and turns that make the story a real page-turner.
Morgan is endearing and long-suffering, Evelyn an out-of-place baronet if ever there was one. And together, they make a lovely couple (despite a distinct tendency of avoiding communication, but this serves the plot well).
Very entertaining!
February 1, 2019
Dealing with the Past in order for Love to Flourish!
A search for a long lost heir, a ‘My Fair Lady’ like training of said heir and dealing disfuncional families & friends are all elements of the Morgan Turner & Lord Evelyn story.
This novel should be classified as a dramatic story with a side order of romance and sexy times.
Don’t let the cover fool you...this is a very good Historical story with unexpected twists and turns.
Well-written, well-developed MCs and co-characters. I really enjoyed this book.
With that said, there are parts that puzzled me, such as how the younger Turner turn up at the Winthrop Manor on foot, when as adult he had to take a train and carriage. Or that Evelyn flirts so openly before he knew of Turner preference. Just a few little things that sometimes bug me.
Overall, I recommend this book.
A search for a long lost heir, a ‘My Fair Lady’ like training of said heir and dealing disfuncional families & friends are all elements of the Morgan Turner & Lord Evelyn story.
This novel should be classified as a dramatic story with a side order of romance and sexy times.
Don’t let the cover fool you...this is a very good Historical story with unexpected twists and turns.
Well-written, well-developed MCs and co-characters. I really enjoyed this book.
With that said, there are parts that puzzled me, such as how the younger Turner turn up at the Winthrop Manor on foot, when as adult he had to take a train and carriage. Or that Evelyn flirts so openly before he knew of Turner preference. Just a few little things that sometimes bug me.
Overall, I recommend this book.
July 10, 2025
3.5 stars
Same brand of historical novel of the other one I’ve read by this author (Mr. Warren’s Profession). Meaning that this is not the book to pick if you’re looking for complete realism and plausibility in a historical setting, in particular in regard to form of speech and attitude towards homosexuality, both read a bit too contemporary.
On the other hand, Sebastian Nothwell delivers interesting MCs, I don’t think I’ve ever read about one coming from the whaling industry and one having fern collection as a hobby. If you’re willing to overlook some unrealistic and sometimes over-the-top turns of the plot, this story makes for an entertaining read, despite something that bothered me.
My main issue is that I found a part of this book extremely frustrating to read, I always do when the plot relies on misunderstandings. It wasn’t as bad as I feared at first, but it was bad enough and, for a little while, it didn’t make for a pleasant reading experience. It wasn’t contrived just for drama’s sake, which helped. It was pretty realistic that Still, I wanted to slap some sense into him sometimes, even though he made up for it later.
Content warning for
Same brand of historical novel of the other one I’ve read by this author (Mr. Warren’s Profession). Meaning that this is not the book to pick if you’re looking for complete realism and plausibility in a historical setting, in particular in regard to form of speech and attitude towards homosexuality, both read a bit too contemporary.
On the other hand, Sebastian Nothwell delivers interesting MCs, I don’t think I’ve ever read about one coming from the whaling industry and one having fern collection as a hobby. If you’re willing to overlook some unrealistic and sometimes over-the-top turns of the plot, this story makes for an entertaining read, despite something that bothered me.
My main issue is that I found a part of this book extremely frustrating to read, I always do when the plot relies on misunderstandings. It wasn’t as bad as I feared at first, but it was bad enough and, for a little while, it didn’t make for a pleasant reading experience. It wasn’t contrived just for drama’s sake, which helped. It was pretty realistic that Still, I wanted to slap some sense into him sometimes, even though he made up for it later.
Content warning for
July 9, 2020
The book was provided for free by the author in exchange for an honest review via the MMRG Don’t Buy My Love Program
I thoroughly enjoyed the book. Even though it's pretty long and I often had trouble concentrating on books while stuck at home, I pretty much raced through it in just a few days.
It feels like a historically mostly accurate soap opera, or an old time adventure novel just with a more solid romance.
The main characters as well as most of the side cast are well drawn and fleshed out, though the villains of the piece ended up being rather one-dimensionally bad with little to redeem them. Which is interesting, because the main characters are certainly not portrait as bright white, but rather with some shades of gray. But maybe that is just my interpretation, because the book doesn't really concern itself overmuch with the justification of some of their actions.
While the romance is not exactly the main focus throughout the whole book, I liked that their affections for each other and troubles with each other threaded through the whole plot and informed most of their actions.
That said, I found the romantic parts absolutely lovely and I especially liked the light D/s dynamic that is happening with Morgan as the dominant part. It's nothing too kinky, just some commands and some rough handling.
Usually I'm not a fan of very drama-filled books, but I really liked it in this one. For one, because it seemed over the top and not very realistic, but at the same time felt sensible and coherent in the context of the characters and world laid out, if that makes sense.
It also reminded my a lot of the adventure books I read as a kid (Jules Verne mostly), though there's not much actual adventuring going on, most of the book plays out on the estate, all whaling stories are retold, though still pretty interesting and vivid. And bloody.
Having read the authors first novel I found quite a few similarities at first glance, though I'm happy to say the story is unique enough that it's just superficialities. I actually preferred the plot of this story to the first book, because it feels a lot more believable and coherent, though it's a wash between the two couples, because I really adored both of them equality.
I thoroughly enjoyed the book. Even though it's pretty long and I often had trouble concentrating on books while stuck at home, I pretty much raced through it in just a few days.
It feels like a historically mostly accurate soap opera, or an old time adventure novel just with a more solid romance.
The main characters as well as most of the side cast are well drawn and fleshed out, though the villains of the piece ended up being rather one-dimensionally bad with little to redeem them. Which is interesting, because the main characters are certainly not portrait as bright white, but rather with some shades of gray. But maybe that is just my interpretation, because the book doesn't really concern itself overmuch with the justification of some of their actions.
While the romance is not exactly the main focus throughout the whole book, I liked that their affections for each other and troubles with each other threaded through the whole plot and informed most of their actions.
That said, I found the romantic parts absolutely lovely and I especially liked the light D/s dynamic that is happening with Morgan as the dominant part. It's nothing too kinky, just some commands and some rough handling.
Usually I'm not a fan of very drama-filled books, but I really liked it in this one. For one, because it seemed over the top and not very realistic, but at the same time felt sensible and coherent in the context of the characters and world laid out, if that makes sense.
It also reminded my a lot of the adventure books I read as a kid (Jules Verne mostly), though there's not much actual adventuring going on, most of the book plays out on the estate, all whaling stories are retold, though still pretty interesting and vivid. And bloody.
Having read the authors first novel I found quite a few similarities at first glance, though I'm happy to say the story is unique enough that it's just superficialities. I actually preferred the plot of this story to the first book, because it feels a lot more believable and coherent, though it's a wash between the two couples, because I really adored both of them equality.
August 6, 2018
Well this was a delight.
Any romance novel where you spend half the book yelling at the characters, but in a good way, is a good one.
Any romance novel where you spend half the book yelling at the characters, but in a good way, is a good one.
July 16, 2020
2.5 out of 5 - Only a Fair Gay 90s My Fair Lady/Prodigal Son
[Thanks to the author and Goodreads' MMRG Don't Buy My Love program for a free copy in exchange for an honest review]
Having enjoyed Mr Warren's Profession, I was disappointed that this had too many things to forgive for me to forget. While I still like the historical, the characters were interesting but not as endearing, the tropes not overcome, and the romantic language too over-the-top purple for even my taste.
I was really into it at first, having been in My Fair Lady to enjoy the heathen sailor returning as a prodigal son, and in Wilde's The Importance of Being Ernest to enjoy the sniping at high society. But from there on little things began to irritate me.
I still thought Sebastian Nothwell's style was easy to read, and mostly depicted the times. I particularly liked learning about whaling and the Victorian fad of pteridomania. And what rang true was the homophobic persecution from society and resultant shame of oneself. which is unfortunately timeless, even to today. But little inaccuracies took me out of the story - e.g., men danced with the lady's right hand in hand, 12 years became decades, and dueling was anachronistic by 1890s.
Nothwell continued with the trope of class difference, but not as poignant this time and just the usual from what I've seen of upstairs/downstairs stories. And again it seemed money could solve anything, or being rich and gentry meant you were better than anyone else and could treat lessers accordingly. It was actually more frustrating than tension inducing to see the high society hooligans' machinations, lies and abuse, thinking they have a right to it. And here again was our noble's naivety that did not fit as well with a worldly sailor.
The MCs were nice enough, but both fell too easily into the trope of secret fears and miscommunication. And then all of a sudden, the sex scenes came out of nowhere, not fitting in smoothly with what was happening just previously. Hmm, even as a guy, and despite all the secret angst and sexual tension, I can't say going from a persistent 0 to 100 in 1 min. after what just happened worked or made sense even in a romance. And then there were the villains, who were mostly one-note just to make sure we didn't like them; and then a resolution that felt off.
I'll end with a few samples of where my usual forgiveness of "romance" being overly dramatic and purple ended up being a bit a too much even for me...
"...Morgan watched how Sir Evelyn’s lips brushed over the slick silver spoon, how his Adam’s apple bobbed as the hot liquid slid down his throat, how his eyes fell shut to savour the taste, lashes fluttering..."
"...Morgan spent the rest of the course sweeping his eyes over the tablecloth in search of stains. He found none, save the stain on his own soul..."
"...The curtains could do with dusting. That was the trouble with velvet. That, and how the velvet of the curtains reminded him of the velvet softness Sir Evelyn’s curiously full lips appeared to possess..."
But to each his own; if you like your prose deep purple, then this is for you.
[Thanks to the author and Goodreads' MMRG Don't Buy My Love program for a free copy in exchange for an honest review]
Having enjoyed Mr Warren's Profession, I was disappointed that this had too many things to forgive for me to forget. While I still like the historical, the characters were interesting but not as endearing, the tropes not overcome, and the romantic language too over-the-top purple for even my taste.
I was really into it at first, having been in My Fair Lady to enjoy the heathen sailor returning as a prodigal son, and in Wilde's The Importance of Being Ernest to enjoy the sniping at high society. But from there on little things began to irritate me.
I still thought Sebastian Nothwell's style was easy to read, and mostly depicted the times. I particularly liked learning about whaling and the Victorian fad of pteridomania. And what rang true was the homophobic persecution from society and resultant shame of oneself. which is unfortunately timeless, even to today. But little inaccuracies took me out of the story - e.g., men danced with the lady's right hand in hand, 12 years became decades, and dueling was anachronistic by 1890s.
Nothwell continued with the trope of class difference, but not as poignant this time and just the usual from what I've seen of upstairs/downstairs stories. And again it seemed money could solve anything, or being rich and gentry meant you were better than anyone else and could treat lessers accordingly. It was actually more frustrating than tension inducing to see the high society hooligans' machinations, lies and abuse, thinking they have a right to it. And here again was our noble's naivety that did not fit as well with a worldly sailor.
The MCs were nice enough, but both fell too easily into the trope of secret fears and miscommunication. And then all of a sudden, the sex scenes came out of nowhere, not fitting in smoothly with what was happening just previously. Hmm, even as a guy, and despite all the secret angst and sexual tension, I can't say going from a persistent 0 to 100 in 1 min. after what just happened worked or made sense even in a romance. And then there were the villains, who were mostly one-note just to make sure we didn't like them; and then a resolution that felt off.
I'll end with a few samples of where my usual forgiveness of "romance" being overly dramatic and purple ended up being a bit a too much even for me...
"...Morgan watched how Sir Evelyn’s lips brushed over the slick silver spoon, how his Adam’s apple bobbed as the hot liquid slid down his throat, how his eyes fell shut to savour the taste, lashes fluttering..."
"...Morgan spent the rest of the course sweeping his eyes over the tablecloth in search of stains. He found none, save the stain on his own soul..."
"...The curtains could do with dusting. That was the trouble with velvet. That, and how the velvet of the curtains reminded him of the velvet softness Sir Evelyn’s curiously full lips appeared to possess..."
But to each his own; if you like your prose deep purple, then this is for you.
January 2, 2020
Brilliantly Complicated
The cover is really perfect, with the prodigal son Sir Evelyn Winthrop holding his whaling harpoon as a symbolic carnal temptation for his just inherited estate's manager Morgan Turner. That auburn-haired beauty slams into Evelyn's heart upon meeting but he never suspects that the way Morgan's knowledge, and secrets, unfold one-by-one in such a brilliantly plotted manner as to take your breath away upon occasion.
These characters are completely opposite in how they perceive each other, and life, than you would expect. It would be churlish of me to give you all the details because I was surprised every step of the way at how deeply unhappy Evelyn became every time Morgan flip-flopped in their relationship.
What saved the day for me was the exceptional character development of the other players in the book--from Evelyn's vacuous and vicious brother Basil to his childhood friend and teen lover Ned, to Lady Winthrop, Evelyn's maiden aunt and her companion, to the Deveraux siblings and even the maid Maud and Cook.
What is most interesting as well is how author Sebastian Northwell brings various classic literature into play, especially the works of Herman Melville, which, of course, the ex-whaler Sir Evelyn adored. But he also imbued Evelyn with the surprising adoration he had for another work of art by a literary masterpiece by the name of Whitman. And it works!
What really surprised me, however, was the way the book took off on a wild ride at the Hunter's Ball that was the expected reintroduction of Evelyn into society. From there to a number of major incidents to the finale kept me up well past my bedtime, and I thank Mr. Northwell for doing that.
The cover is really perfect, with the prodigal son Sir Evelyn Winthrop holding his whaling harpoon as a symbolic carnal temptation for his just inherited estate's manager Morgan Turner. That auburn-haired beauty slams into Evelyn's heart upon meeting but he never suspects that the way Morgan's knowledge, and secrets, unfold one-by-one in such a brilliantly plotted manner as to take your breath away upon occasion.
These characters are completely opposite in how they perceive each other, and life, than you would expect. It would be churlish of me to give you all the details because I was surprised every step of the way at how deeply unhappy Evelyn became every time Morgan flip-flopped in their relationship.
What saved the day for me was the exceptional character development of the other players in the book--from Evelyn's vacuous and vicious brother Basil to his childhood friend and teen lover Ned, to Lady Winthrop, Evelyn's maiden aunt and her companion, to the Deveraux siblings and even the maid Maud and Cook.
What is most interesting as well is how author Sebastian Northwell brings various classic literature into play, especially the works of Herman Melville, which, of course, the ex-whaler Sir Evelyn adored. But he also imbued Evelyn with the surprising adoration he had for another work of art by a literary masterpiece by the name of Whitman. And it works!
What really surprised me, however, was the way the book took off on a wild ride at the Hunter's Ball that was the expected reintroduction of Evelyn into society. From there to a number of major incidents to the finale kept me up well past my bedtime, and I thank Mr. Northwell for doing that.
February 21, 2019
I adore Sebastian Nothwell’s writing style and ability to tell a story, but his characters are always what leave the strongest lasting impression. Our MCs, Evelyn and Morgan, are beautifully realized with histories that inform their actions. Other reviewers have mentioned the lack of open communication between them for a majority of the book, but I think Morgan’s unwillingness to be honest about his past makes total sense He’s never had anyone he could safely unpack his complicated feelings with, and
Nothwell’s secondary characters are always a joy as well. I found the Devereaux siblings delightful in completely different ways, and the character of Aunt Cecily takes the archetypal forbidding aunt and gives background and reason to her stern, judgmental, and proper manner. The cook was also a particular favorite.
Nothwell’s secondary characters are always a joy as well. I found the Devereaux siblings delightful in completely different ways, and the character of Aunt Cecily takes the archetypal forbidding aunt and gives background and reason to her stern, judgmental, and proper manner. The cook was also a particular favorite.
April 16, 2019
I'd started to compose the review in the middle of reading. So hot, I thought, so kinky. I've changed my mind by the end of it.
It is not just hot, it is astonishingly good. The characters are complex and multidimensional, the story of abuse and rage is not simple and one-sided, human drama is rich and believeable.
I want more of these two!
It is not just hot, it is astonishingly good. The characters are complex and multidimensional, the story of abuse and rage is not simple and one-sided, human drama is rich and believeable.
I want more of these two!
Want to read
December 28, 201812/27/18 Currently 25% off at Smashwords ($2.99): https://www.smashwords.com/books/view...
August 12, 2023
Oh Captain, my captain.
4.5 stars rounded up on vibes alone.
4.5 stars rounded up on vibes alone.
March 2, 2020
Not as charming as the first novel by this author - the hapless idiot noble with a heart of gold played much better the first time, when the idiot is always willing to learn and believes their beloved's every word absolutely. Mr Warren's Profession has a charming Bertie Wooster character following around his Jeeves, this one just has a kinda crappy guy who doesn't trust his lover.
And yeah, the ending is completely ridiculous but don't act like you haven't fantasized about Why should our historical fantasies be limited to romance?
And yeah, the ending is completely ridiculous but don't act like you haven't fantasized about Why should our historical fantasies be limited to romance?
April 24, 2019
Fantastic opening sentences. And some of the whaling lore was interesting, I’ll bet some derived from the museum in New Bedford not too far from me. (Although of course whaling itself is reprehensible, one can understand how the characters didn’t know that in 1891.)
The leads were pleasant enough, although the blonde hair and love at first site was too much like the author’s last book. I liked the overall women’s rep and lesbian rep. As well as populating the downstairs with recognizable types of characters.
However, the action part of this, including duels and physical fights, was not my thing. One section in particular was utterly unbelievable because not physically possible no matter how much you hate your enemy. It felt over the top.
This is a sort of starter novel I think. The author has talent, great research skills, and hopefully many more books to mature in.
The leads were pleasant enough, although the blonde hair and love at first site was too much like the author’s last book. I liked the overall women’s rep and lesbian rep. As well as populating the downstairs with recognizable types of characters.
However, the action part of this, including duels and physical fights, was not my thing. One section in particular was utterly unbelievable because not physically possible no matter how much you hate your enemy. It felt over the top.
This is a sort of starter novel I think. The author has talent, great research skills, and hopefully many more books to mature in.
June 14, 2021
4.25 stars.
SCREECHES! I think this is the best-written of all of Sebastian Nothwell's work, and it's what has cemented me into a fan. Queer historical romance is already really rare... but his books manage the perfect balance between traditional historical romance vibes, gothic drama, and of course, the queerness and modern sensibilities!
So FYI this novel is more over the top than most. It reads like a soap opera or a good old-fashioned gothic novel with the forbidden love, children out of wedlock, and fighting over the inheritance. But that is exactly why I loved it. The drama had gripped me by the throat, and I was so invested that I was legitimately mad and muttering to myself when terrible things happened to the heroes. So yeah, this novel has failed to prove my sanity to my family, but it's worth it.
This is one of those rare books where the side characters have as much depth and color as our protagonists. From hilariously dramatic maid Sally, to so-obsessed-with-medicine-that-everyone's-a-specimen Percy, to his strong-willed sister, to Aunt Cecily with the stiff upper lip but strong constitution... it was a wonderful, very likeable cast. Morgan and Evelyn are thoughtful regardless of anyone's station; it's the villains who are awful nobility.
But you're here for the romance so... yes. The romance is swoonworthy and surprisingly really kinky (I did not expect BDSM in historical romance but that's my mistake lol. Mild spoiler: the huge muscular guy is the bottom and the sub, if that's your thing.). It's equally sweet, dramatic, and honestly funny. I kept giggling out loud, which again, is proof that I shouldn't read this in public. Morgan is a precious baby that must be protected at all costs. Evelyn is honestly stupid, but he means well, and he's like a more macho Golden Retriever around Morgan. It's kind of funny.
The villain/s... well, they are awful, no redemption whatsoever. But at least it didn't feel as cartoonish as the author's other books. I loved when they got their comeuppance. Hehe.
Anyway, Sebastian Nothwell, please write more books. I am now a marooned sailor, desperate for your stories :(
SCREECHES! I think this is the best-written of all of Sebastian Nothwell's work, and it's what has cemented me into a fan. Queer historical romance is already really rare... but his books manage the perfect balance between traditional historical romance vibes, gothic drama, and of course, the queerness and modern sensibilities!
So FYI this novel is more over the top than most. It reads like a soap opera or a good old-fashioned gothic novel with the forbidden love, children out of wedlock, and fighting over the inheritance. But that is exactly why I loved it. The drama had gripped me by the throat, and I was so invested that I was legitimately mad and muttering to myself when terrible things happened to the heroes. So yeah, this novel has failed to prove my sanity to my family, but it's worth it.
This is one of those rare books where the side characters have as much depth and color as our protagonists. From hilariously dramatic maid Sally, to so-obsessed-with-medicine-that-everyone's-a-specimen Percy, to his strong-willed sister, to Aunt Cecily with the stiff upper lip but strong constitution... it was a wonderful, very likeable cast. Morgan and Evelyn are thoughtful regardless of anyone's station; it's the villains who are awful nobility.
But you're here for the romance so... yes. The romance is swoonworthy and surprisingly really kinky (I did not expect BDSM in historical romance but that's my mistake lol. Mild spoiler: the huge muscular guy is the bottom and the sub, if that's your thing.). It's equally sweet, dramatic, and honestly funny. I kept giggling out loud, which again, is proof that I shouldn't read this in public. Morgan is a precious baby that must be protected at all costs. Evelyn is honestly stupid, but he means well, and he's like a more macho Golden Retriever around Morgan. It's kind of funny.
The villain/s... well, they are awful, no redemption whatsoever. But at least it didn't feel as cartoonish as the author's other books. I loved when they got their comeuppance. Hehe.
Anyway, Sebastian Nothwell, please write more books. I am now a marooned sailor, desperate for your stories :(
July 11, 2023
Afraid it took me a long time to get into this one, which certainly wasn't the case with Mr Warren's Profession. The squire's son Evelyn is caught in flagrante delicto with a school friend at the age of 13, and instead of running away to join the circus, decides to hop on a sailing ship bound for New England as a cabin boy, and eventually takes up a position on a whaling ship as a harpooner. When his father dies, he is chased around the globe by his father's agent as he has been named heir to the estate. Meanwhile, the other MC Morgan [who is the agent]...well, his background remains quite mysterious, and only fully unravels towards the end of the story.
This is probably a 'me' thing, but Evelyn's background didn't endear the story to me, and things went downhill from there, although I have to say most of the story is taken up by the attempts to turn Evelyn into a squire who will stay at home to run the estate.
Yes, I know that a lot of countries used to hunt and kill whales [and some stupid, barbaric countries still do 😠]. According to the author's page, New England is his home which of course has a lot of history and affinity with whaling ships, whalers and the hunting of whales...BUT that still doesn't mean I have to like it 😕...I'm very anti-whaling. Everything the author described was probably authentic to the time and period, and the actual business of whale hunting...but it's not a subject I can be rational about, sorry. 🙁 3.5 stars rounded up.
This is probably a 'me' thing, but Evelyn's background didn't endear the story to me, and things went downhill from there, although I have to say most of the story is taken up by the attempts to turn Evelyn into a squire who will stay at home to run the estate.
Yes, I know that a lot of countries used to hunt and kill whales [and some stupid, barbaric countries still do 😠]. According to the author's page, New England is his home which of course has a lot of history and affinity with whaling ships, whalers and the hunting of whales...BUT that still doesn't mean I have to like it 😕...I'm very anti-whaling. Everything the author described was probably authentic to the time and period, and the actual business of whale hunting...but it's not a subject I can be rational about, sorry. 🙁 3.5 stars rounded up.
October 29, 2018
Light BDSM with Evelyn submitting to Morgan as his "landlocked captain." Not a lot of sex, but what there is, is great. Morgan's fern collecting hobby is sort of adorable. I got irritated in the middle with the lack of communication about Ned the half-brother. This seems to be a common complaint in the reviews, but I'm glad I didn't let that turn me off as the book was worth it once they opened up to each other.
Warnings: Incest (more details in spoilers, but the MCs aren't related), Gore (whaling descriptions get pretty gory for the whales and the sailors)
Tag explanations and spoilers:
Warnings: Incest (more details in spoilers, but the MCs aren't related), Gore (whaling descriptions get pretty gory for the whales and the sailors)
Tag explanations and spoilers:
August 4, 2018
A fun little historical romance that takes some unexpected turns! It features an engaging supporting cast, and well-developed protagonists who I found myself rooting for early on (and wailing "just TALK to each other, goddamnit" at my ipad). It shows overall very good attention to historical authenticity and, as someone with a keen interest in maritime history, I was very pleased to note all the little authentic details that placed the novel firmly in its time period.
The premise of the son of a baronet running off to the least respected and most dirty and dangerous possible maritime occupation, rather than entering the navy or a company like the EIC or HBC, threw me for a bit of a loop at first, but I found myself convinced of the plausibility of Evelyn's choices as I was drawn in to the novel.
The premise of the son of a baronet running off to the least respected and most dirty and dangerous possible maritime occupation, rather than entering the navy or a company like the EIC or HBC, threw me for a bit of a loop at first, but I found myself convinced of the plausibility of Evelyn's choices as I was drawn in to the novel.
August 30, 2018
Trigger warnings for the book (cause it kinda needs it, but hidden cause its kinda spoiler-y):
Okay, now with this noted, lets get to the book itselt. This book surprised me, mostly because I read books by Cat Sebastian lately and this book is much more raw than what I was used to. Not in a bad way, I just didn't expect it. I liked both main heroes and their romance felt realistic. Though sometimes I couldnt help but be frustrated like "talk to each other properly, dudes!"
I really liked the female side characters (like the aunt).
My fave part was when main hero talked about his whaling past, it felt very real and well researched.
Good book if you like historical gay romances, but note the warnings.
Okay, now with this noted, lets get to the book itselt. This book surprised me, mostly because I read books by Cat Sebastian lately and this book is much more raw than what I was used to. Not in a bad way, I just didn't expect it. I liked both main heroes and their romance felt realistic. Though sometimes I couldnt help but be frustrated like "talk to each other properly, dudes!"
I really liked the female side characters (like the aunt).
My fave part was when main hero talked about his whaling past, it felt very real and well researched.
Good book if you like historical gay romances, but note the warnings.
October 12, 2018
I do kind of like that there are no real derring-do heroes or heroines in this book and most of the people whose opinions may matter their own 'little secret' as well. So very little self-righteous condemnation to sling around.
It's a pity about Ned as IMO, he could be redemptive as Basil may very well turn out to be, or not? Did Basil really do as Evelyn told him? Will he ever sincerely change at all? Unless, Sebastian Nothwell continue this story with Basil's own, I'll just apply to my imagination to fill in the gaps.
Regardless, this was a fabulous read and hope to read more historical mm for this author.
It's a pity about Ned as IMO, he could be redemptive as Basil may very well turn out to be, or not? Did Basil really do as Evelyn told him? Will he ever sincerely change at all? Unless, Sebastian Nothwell continue this story with Basil's own, I'll just apply to my imagination to fill in the gaps.
Regardless, this was a fabulous read and hope to read more historical mm for this author.
February 5, 2019
I liked it very much up until the ending. There, it got a little overly dramatic for me - and also, cold-blooded and unrepentent murder, no matter how bad the victim was, tends to make me dislike the characters....Also, there was indication that Morgan felt shame about what happened, but I expect more angst when someone tries to committ suicide
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 18, 2018
Me, yelling at the characters: just talk to each other! Use your words! Explain the situation!
Aside from my frustration at the miscommunication tropes, I thought this was a nice book.
(Evelyn is the subbiest sub to ever sub)
Aside from my frustration at the miscommunication tropes, I thought this was a nice book.
(Evelyn is the subbiest sub to ever sub)
July 31, 2019
Another great book by this author thoroughly enjoyed it, I have another favourite couple. Most frustrating part was at 80-something%, just when something huge was going to happen, my Kindle died. I had to wait while it re-charged enough for me to finish the story.
February 9, 2023
Just a note that this book contains past incest and off-page sexual assault (not between the MCs).
Well-rounded MCs, horrible villains, awkward dinner parties, and a truly realized historical setting? Yeah, it’s a Nothwell book.
Well-rounded MCs, horrible villains, awkward dinner parties, and a truly realized historical setting? Yeah, it’s a Nothwell book.
August 3, 2018
3.75 stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews