4.5 stars
Robert McCammon is a writer that definitely deserves more attention. While he does not identify as a horror writer, he is often classified as such and if he is classified as such, his work contends against heavyweights such as Stephen King and Dean Koontz. I read Boy's Life in 2019 and thought it was fantastic. Mystery Walk is also a great novel and among his earlier novels. For a period of time, this was the oldest novel that he recognized, but he has since started recognizing his first four novels and has allowed for them to be reprinted. I would argue that McCammon's works blend various genres with one another, especially those that incorporate speculative fiction. The amazing thing about his work, though, is that even the supernatural elements within his works have realistic explanations and that makes it all the more mind boggling.
Mystery Walk follows Billy Creekmore, who lives with his parents, John and Ramona, in Hawthorne, Alabama, and is 25% Choctaw. His mother, Ramona, is 50% Choctaw, while his maternal grandmother, Rebekah Fairmountain, is 100% Choctaw. His father, John, is a man of Christian faith, but is also a Klansman. While he cares for his family, his need to fit into society by being a Klansman leaves quite a stain to his reputation (maybe not to his and to this community, but to the general population and to those of us reading this book). Billy has a coming of age moment and discovers that he can sense death upon being drawn into the Booker house, the Bookers being friends of John's, as he is friend's with the man of the house, Dave, an abusive man that is connected to the deaths of his wife and children.
Upon Billy's horrifying encounter, the Creekmores go to the Falconers service, where Jimmy Jed Falconer leads the service, while his son, Wayne, has the ability to rid people of their demons. The interaction between Billy and Wayne leads to a demonic encounter when Billy tries to confess his sins and seek Wayne's help of ridding him of his demons.
A great strength of McCammon's is his ability to create a great deal of dimension within his characters. Wayne Falconer may be viewed as Billy's most direct antagonist, but Wayne comes to plenty of flaws and complexities in his own right, which also leads him to question his motives and abilities on occasion. Jimmy Jed, meanwhile, cares most for the well being of his son and while he wants to make the most of his abilities to heal people, knows that there are things that even Wayne has to leave up to God.
The greatest horrors within this piece are not even the moments that are supernatural, but those that are real and relevant to this world, particularly the generational continuity of hatred that leads to deadly consequences. Among the most horrifying is the hatred from children that stems from their parents or guardians, who should be providing a better example instead of instigating their children to be hurtful to those that are not like themselves. The Leightons, Ralph and Duke, are perhaps the finest example within this piece. In a greater retrospect, the relevance of the KKK in 1961 in Hawthorne being remnant to a piece that was released in 1983 is quite chilling and to view natives as demonic is quite horrifying and despicable. The name "Hawthorne" is also fitting in how taking away the "w" gives you "Hathorne" as in John Hathorne, perhaps the most willing to jump to conclusions among Salem Witch Trial judges, both in real life and as depicted in Arthur Miller's The Crucible.
While there is a great deal of hatred, prejudice, and bias displayed among many of Hawthorne's citizens, the Choctaw in this piece display a great sense of wisdom. Billy's grandmother, Rebekah, probably displays the wisest of words on page 117 (in the paperback):
"Now where was I? Oh, yes. The giver of breath. God of the Choctaws. God of the white man. He also gives gifts of talent, Billy, to use for his good. Inhale the smoke, all the way. Yes, that's right. Some people can paint beautiful pictures, some can make sweet music, others work with their hands, and some with their wits; but in all people is the seed of talent, to do something of value in this world. And doing that- perfecting that talent, making the seed grow to good fruit- should be the aim of this life."
These are wise words that we should all live by, using our talents and strengths in order to contribute to making the world and those that live within this world a better place. Billy's grandmother is the one that sends him on his mystery walk, but while it is initially vague, it seems to result in the sense of coming to terms and realizing the kind of world in which we live.
Another realization within this text is that when enough horrifying things take place in one's lifetime, how much does it matter what the final result is like? This applies to reality as well and that ability is a great strength within McCammon's writing. McCammon is a solid success when it comes to creating multidimensional characters that are flawed, make poor choices, but ultimately mean well. This challenges one's ability to develop a sense of empathy, but if one is able to do so, it can really make them a better person with a stronger character. This is a challenge that Billy faces, but we can easily find ourselves in Billy's position while giving and taking a few of the details.
Mystery Walk is a very haunting, thought-provoking story, because he honestly depicts the world as a scary place and people as a scary species, but one that is far more complex that we can wrap our heads around. It is definitely worth reading and I definitely want to read more by Robert McCammon.