I'm actually kind of shocked that this book has a 4 star average. In terms of mysteries, I suppose it was interesting, but it didn't quite stick the landing at the end.
Basically the premise is that within two weeks of each other, two women and a child go missing in a small town. 11 years later, the child seemingly reappears and stirs up interest in the circumstances of her disappearance again.
My complaints with this book are many. I will attempt to list and explain them:
1. This one is minor, but irritating to me. They're supposedly in a smallish suburb of Chicago that is somehow only 30mins from downtown by train, but is susceptible to tornadoes? Did no one think to research this factoid when going through edits? I live in Chicago and am 30mins from downtown by Amtrak. There isn't a suburb, even north of here, that is tornado central and that close by commute.
2. The story really makes you connect with the little girl through her chapters while she's imprisoned in the basement, but once she gets free we literally do not get her perspective again for the rest of the novel??? I don't care about Leo. I'm sorry, but all the other perspectives were female and it would've made the book stronger to keep it that way. OR still include her POV and keep Leo's as a contrast to what their experiences are. It was such a disservice to what we had to experience alongside her, just to have her swept neatly aside when the author obviously didn't know how to bury the lede from her POV.
I also didn't appreciate how they just wrote off Gus in a few sentences. No follow up on the trauma there, just a neat little, "oh it was a coping mechanism because of her sensory deprivation, ho hum! We won't focus anymore on this and will act like it never happened moving forward!"
3. Basically, there was a lot of early build up re: plotlines that are never actually resolved. We assume Marty is "Sam," so does that mean he's the father of Shelby's baby? There's a throwaway like about how a paternity test showed it was Jason's kid and the baby was sent to be with "the real father." Like, what?? Explain this please! You invested readers in this mystery and then don't even give is the courtesy of a resolution.
There was also a lot of focus on Leo being bullied at daycare that added nothing to the plot. You could take that out and still have the story remain the same, especially since he never mentions it in his chapters.
4. The ENDING my god, the ending. The reveal that the girl isn't Delilah but is Carly, another missing girl who conveniently looks passingly like Delilah/Meredith. And that this was only discovered by Leo being told about a cleft chin? Gimme a break. I know the police are incompetent, but the second that DNA test came back as not a match, child see ices would've swept that kid up and taken her out of that home. One officer couldn't cover that up on her own.
And then Delilah gets broken free from the garage closet, and oh wow! Look at how well adjusted she is, going right back to playing with her brother and being a normal, pretty teenager! As if she hasn't been kept captive by her neighbor who and witnessed hitting her mother in the head with a hammer and will have no issues. Lucky that she is okay and not wild and uneducated like that OTHER girl, who had to stab her way out and readjust to sunlight and real food and society as a whole after being treated worse than an animal for 11 years.
Speaking of poor Carly, she is another example of an unsatisfying ending. There's a quick blurb about how they identified her and the people who took her were copycats of the Delilah abduction case, and she was being reunited with her family. Not even being able to see that, and again being completely blocked from her perspective for the majority of the book, is such a disservice to her character.
Anyway, all in all I didn't love this book. The premise was interesting, and the actual perpetrator was okay, but it didn't feel like it earned it and it felt like it came out of absolutely nowhere. Another modern mystery novel that throws a thousand distractions in a reader's way, and it turns out to be an accident that caused it all.