ARC provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Actual Rating: 3.75 stars
Okay, this was cute.
I seem to be in the minority of people that have enjoyed this one, surprisingly. I think a lot of that stems from how much younger this book reads than other works in this series. Which makes sense since Jen Calonita is most well known for her middle grade series, Flunked. People most likely went into this expecting something a little bit darker, a little bit more graphic, and felt, instead, like they were reading a children's book.
Which is fair.
Even though I enjoyed this, I still felt myself rolling my eyes at how juvenile some of the scenes were. And the nicknames. My gosh. I get that it's a cute thing in the movie but somehow reading it four times on nearly every page completely loses all charm. If I had to read "Wonder Boy" or "Peg" or "Red" one more time, I was convinced I was going to lose it.
However! This was still one of my favorite Twisted Tales I've read thus far?
Admittedly, the plot is quite similar to my favorite Twisted Tale, Reflection (no one can hold a candle to Elizabeth Lim and I would like that to be known) so perhaps I am a fan of the 'character has to travel to the underworld and learn about themselves in the process' plot. But that wasn't what I appreciated the most about this book.
My favorite aspect was seeing Meg be forced a bit out of her stubborn independence. I know other reviewers have said that she was far too hot-headed in this book, and I agree, but I don't necessarily feel like it was out of character. At the beginning of the book, we see her far less... rash than at the end of the book. As she feels like she's failing, she becomes more and more desperate to prove just how much of a failure she isn't, thus creating many of the scenarios that got on other reviewers' nerves. Which, again, is valid, but it's also - from my experience, at least - realistic? People tend to do stupid things when they're desperate, especially when said person feels that being vulnerable is a weakness.
In my opinion, it was a very in-character thing for Meg to do. I mean, my gosh, she traded her soul for her boyfriend's life out of desperation and you're shocked that she jumped into things?
Anyway, that brings me into my next (and final) point: the characterization. Whenever someone's adapting characters from such a beloved film into a book, people are going to have problems with it. I'm not too picky when it comes to these things, but I'll be as annoyed as the next person when Ariel seems nothing like herself (that was 100% a dig at Part of Your World)
And when it comes to this book, it reminded me of the direct-to-video sequel. The early morning, poorly animated tv show sequel. The characters were... sort of the same, but also... not quite. It can feel quite forced at times, but the outline is still there and it's still a fun time.
To sum up my thoughts, this book was sweet. It reminded me of watching a VHS in my room at night with only the light from the tv, cuddled in blankets and honestly? That's exactly what I wanted it to do. So even though this book is far from perfect, I'd still recommend it to Disney lovers and maybe people in need of a little dose of nostalgia.