While the rating I give this book might say otherwise, the expectations with which I went into this read were pretty much met fully and unapologetically and I'm glad that I didn't ruin this experience by wanting more.
It's easy to bash on this, and it's just as easy to overpraise it, so I want to quickly run through the most obvious problems: the poem structures become forced and feel too rigid by the third time each of them gets reused (because all of them get reused to death, with a couple of exceptions, the only notable ones being If I've ever made something beautiful and I want you to look at the moon), the imagery, while brilliant, starts to feel like filler meant to replace actual metaphors (because it's impossible to read two lines without having adjectives thrown at you like sand to blind you to the fact that not much has been said in the two lines) and the whole experience boils down to how much you are willing to project onto what's being said and set up throughout each poem, as, while it's clear that a lot of emotion went into it, it's just as clear that technically there isn't much going on.
Now, to get into the nitty-gritty of my experience with Sweetdark; I am neither impressed nor too disappointed with it. I got what I wanted: beautiful images and easy-to-digest poems, something to read as a welcomed break to heavier books and poetry volumes. This book is in no way shallow dribble, but it gets dangerously close to it at points, saving itself abruptly with cool ideas and unique combinations of words. I would've loved to see more wordplay, maybe some clever rhyme schemes, but I'd be lying to say that the poems don't work otherwise.
Solid three stars overall, not much else to say.