“Daughter of the Morning Star” is the seventeenth book in the “Longmire” mystery series, continuing the fictional adventures of Walt Longmire, Sheriff of Absaroka County, Wyoming; his daughter, Cady, the world’s greatest lawyer; his best friend, Henry Standing Bear; his loyal and outspoken deputy, Vic Moretti; his loyal and less outspoken deputy, and Dog, his faithful animal companion.
When we last left our fearless law enforcement officer at the end of the last book, “Next to last Stand”, Walt was back home and seemingly almost recovered emotionally from his final showdown with Thomas Bidarte, international hit man, in the previous book “Depth of Winter”. I cannot say physically recovered because he took on more injuries and wounds during his investigation and recovery of the famous Custer painting.
When “Daughter of the Morning Star” starts, we find our hero having been hired by the Tribal Police Chief Lolo Long to investigate death threats that her niece, Jaya "Longshot" Long, is receiving. Jaya is a high school senior and star of the Lame Deer Lady Stars High School basketball team. She is considered one of the best players in the state and is being recruited by some of the best colleges in the country. In order to help provide protection for Jaya, Walt brings along his best friend, Henry Standing Bear.
However, there are bigger problems facing Walt. He finds out that Jaya’s older sister, Jeanie One Moon, also received similar death threats and then disappeared under mysterious circumstances a year previously. He’s concerned the same stalker could be following Jaya and repeating the same activity. Walt is too aware that statistics are not on the side of native woman that go missing and he hopes to use law enforcement and the media to gain public attention to the situation.
Before he knows it, Walt finds himself taken far out of his comfort zone, dealing with Indian mysticism with Henry, running into one of his first girlfriends, and being pulled in to coach a high school girls basketball team, and facing a deadly adversary that appears in both our world and the beyond.
Normally, I would say that there are a lot of things to like about this book because I am a die-hard Longmire and Craig Johnson fan. However, honesty requires that I admit that is not exactly the case with this book. There were good things that I really enjoyed. Walt and Henry together on any adventure is always awesome. Under-Sherriff, Vic Moretti, had some good moments, and Chief Lolo is such an uptight character that you almost want to scream for her to let her guard down. Unfortunately, most of the Sherriff’s team members make small appearances or are absent in this outing. Even the most wonderful daughter in the world, Cady, is only seen in a brief phone call.
As much as I love Longmire and his world, I have some real problems with the structure and plotting of this book. Although I do my best to stay away from **spoilers** I was left with a lot of unanswered questions and a pseudo ending that really leaves a lot of resolution to be continued into the next book. It’s not a cliffhanger ending, but it’s really like a “to be continued” narrative that leaves a lot unresolved and little explained.
As for my frustrations, let’s get started. Has anyone noticed that Walt has had the literal crap kicked out of him in the last four books? In this book alone, he hits his head on the rocks and passes out for over 24 hours, barely escapes a serious explosion blast, and never gets any kind of medical treatment, nor time for physical recovery. If you add up all his gunshot wounds, stabbings, and fighting injuries in the last four books alone, he deserves his own super hero cape.
As for my unanswered questions, let’s start with Jeanie One Moon. She certainly seems dead, but the ghosting appears to be awfully over the top, even for a mystical element. And if she is dead, we really don’t know who the killer is at this point. At least I am not buying who was blamed for her death in the slightest. I think the real murderer is still out there. And what was Artie Small’s role in all of this? It was never fully explored or explained. Is the Éveohtsé-heómėse real or not? I guess we’ll find out in the next book. The same with the mysterious and secret closed boarding school for Native boys that seems to scare anyone who looks at a picture of it. Obviously more to come on that… I must say that, for me, the mysticism became a bit stretched in the last 100 pages, and I wasn’t sure what Johnson was trying to achieve. It would have helped me a lot to have known when starting this book that it was really the first book of a 2-book set. At least now that I am finished with it, I am hoping that is the case. If not, I will be really frustrated.
Overall, “Daughter of the Morning Star” started out as a fairly interesting mystery for the first 100 – 150 pages, and then devolved into a disjointed combination of Hoosiers basketball and mystical characters in which the sum of the parts did not come together as well as it could of. Not bad, but not he usual excellent delivery that we fans have come to expect and count on each year.
Since it appears that Johnson will be continuing this mystery in his next book coming out in 2022, I can only hope that it will tie all of the loose pieces together and provide some desperately needed closure. And please… Bring back more of Cady…