Caveat: I'm a very critical reader and I DNF books like it's my job. I often hate a lot of fantasy books because after three days, I cannot remember the FMC's name.
---
There are lots of things to like about this book. The premise, for one, is interesting. Even if you've read a lot of books about witches, "small medieval towns with arrogant rulers who war for no real reason", werewolves, and "virginal girls who are abused and then discover their inner strength," there's still a unique story here that was not immediately forgettable or irritating.
There is a large cast of female characters to love. They don't get nearly enough airtime. I would have loved to spend more time on the friendship and frictions between the women. It's rare to have such a large cast of female characters and I love that. In that particular way, this book very much reminded me of ACOTAR. We have the sister, the antagonist, the vampire, the witch, the other maidens... all who are different and memorable and have potential storylines that I'm keen to hear.
The bad: Where things fell apart is that the author had the characters in the exact same setting for (I guess, at least?) 60% of the book, which is just "wandering in the woods". There were some lines in the book that were exact duplications (search "thick rich tears" for instance). There are multiple scenes of "being in a freezing cold river." I don't know if there's some reasonable standard for how much time to spend in worldbuilding but this book definitely spends many pages describing mountains, trees, and dirt.
The FMC is frustrating. She fights when it doesn't make sense, she freezes when it doesn't make sense, she gets enraged over minor things, and lets big insults go by.
I have no idea why, but I was under the impression that this was a reverse harem. It isn't. It is a virginal girl who has sex with the first man who is near her. When she met a new man (a vampire), I was thrilled, because the book got more exciting.
**That being said**, there were so many things to like about it. It feels fresh and unique. I genuinely want to know what happens next. I'm in for the long haul!