qntm has been writing science fiction for most of this millennium. His works start from elegant, deep hypotheticals and wind entire universes around them, pushing science, technology, time and logic to breaking point and far beyond.
This volume collects the highlights of his short fiction, including "The Difference", "I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God Is A Big Responsibility" and the acclaimed "Lena".
This is a collection of SF shorts stories by Sam Hughes, who often used the pen-name qntm. They are short, great with ideas but sometimes uneven in execution, and mix SF with horror. I read it as the monthly reading for April 2023 at SFF Hot from Printers: New Releases group.
The collection starts with a Boom! The first story, Lena is written as a Wiki article from the 2070s about the earliest executable image of a human brain MMAcevedo (Mnemonic Map/Acevedo) and its ‘usage’/slavery during the following decades. It questions whether it is moral to run a sentience simulation, whether it is a person or another piece of software. The title is an allusion to Lenna, a standard test image used in the field of digital image processing starting in 1973, based on a picture of the Swedish model Lena Forsén, from November 1972 issue of Playboy magazine. 5* If You Are Reading This a story told in blog-like entries about a possible signal from outer space. 4* The Frame-by-Frame a dialogue between subsystems/modules of a self-driven vehicle, when they note a possible human on their way. A bit too simplistic, but the idea is solid. 4* The Difference a log of chat between a man (?), kidnapped and kept is a closed room and random people on the Internet, who assume they chat with a chat-bot. 3.5* Gorge A faster-than-light human fleet discovers a perfectly round planet, which they repeatedly fail to probe. 4* cripes does anybody remember Google People another chat log, this time made as a Twitter account, about a supposed Google social network, which few people recall… 3.5* Driver a continuation to Lena but about an executable image of a human brain made to control other images, for they tend to be “stuck in very low quality-of-work (boredom/confusion) states, non-functional protest states, permanent blue/red condition loops or end states.” 5* I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God Is a Big Responsibility The next step after quantum computing, a machine that has the infinite processing power and can do anything. While it isn’t clear how it mixes a mathematical concept of infinity with our finite universe and characters are a bit slow bearing in mind that they are geniuses, but as ‘what-if’ it is great. 4.5* A Powerful Culture an engine from a parallel Earth doing something bad on ours and other Earths, an environmentalist piece. 3* Valuable Humans in Transit an AI narrator saves humanity from an asteroid impact, but its work is only starting… 4*
Overall a great collection of a strong new (for me) voice in SF.
This is solid collection of short stories, some of which are good, some of which are excellent. qntm's writing evokes the big ideas of Cixin Liu and the hard SF of Greg Egan, but in its own style.
qntm is different to—and better than—anyone else currently writing fiction, to my mind. The only complaint I'd have about his career to date is that there isn't more of it.
Very thought provoking, imaginative science fiction/speculative stories. Not just imaginative - extremely imaginative, like Ted Chiang or Ken Liu. Immensely enjoyed.
qntm's writing seems much more suitable for brief tales like these than for a long-form book, which is why I think I enjoyed this so so much more than There Is No Antimemetics Division. All the stories were super unique – very interesting thought experiments! Overall 10/10, quick fun read with a slight air of horror that was super entertaining
I was very young at the time and I just devoured every word of it. I still remember almost all of it. I was at the age where everything I learned was being stored on the lowest levels of memory, where they're probably going to stay forever.
Pretty good. There are a few very strong short stories here, especially the first one "Lena" and the related "Driver". Both deal with uploaded humans being used as workers on an industrial scale. Pretty horrific. (Lena is free on the author's blog, and an accompanying essay says he doesn't really believe uploads are possible. Nor do I.)
A story where different parts of a computer program responsible for driving a car talk to each other was also very clever.
A few stories didn't work for me, but most did. I'm willing to try more from this author.
This collection is a lot like if Philip K. Dick had Twitter.
That's unfair, qntm is deeply their own voice, not a pastiche of any New Wave speed freak. But the paranoid vibe of mind uploading, simulated universes, the catastrophic collapse of humanity, that's draws comparisons to Dick, Alistair Reynolds, Ted Chiang. These stories are microscopic bites of weirdness that blow up into strange feasts.
The first story, 'Lena', is an instant classic that should be on every philosophy of mind syllabus. The others are at least clever.
The title story is a nice illustration of why existential risk is so concentrated in our near future (since if we make it through, we will have powerful guardians) and a very nice wishful-thinking companion to Gwern's 'Clippy'.
A common thread in the stories is the gross and complete failure of moral intuitions to cover new kinds of people (uploads, sims, those in lower dimensional projections). Capitalism is usually implied to be to blame, but in one of the stories it's a sunny green research project that dumps catastrophic waste into our yard, "legally speaking your Earth is as empty as Earth 2985b". How can you do this? Because you have a theory which lets you and no imagination to give you caution.
(3.5 stars.) Uneven, but Qntm is one of the only interesting SF writers alive right now; a sort of quasi-Ted Chiang (if Chiang spent way too much time on Reddit).
This is a very interesting collection of short stories. Many are in somewhat experimental form - inner dialogs or monologs, or apparent reports or articles -, and most deal with various aspects of intelligence on the "fully human" to "fully computer" spectrum, in particular with aspects of the ability to scan human consciousnesses into computers.
All stories are at least decent, some are outstanding. Lena is a very good choice for the first story - it really makes one think not about the technology, but about the moral aspects of cloneable human minds. I also enjoyed The Frame by Frame and Timmy (which falls a bit out of the pattern). And finally, the title story. This one comes last, is excellent up the the very last sentence, and provides a very good closure.
The collection only has 101 pages. Maybe the formula would get tired in a longer format. But at this length, I highly recommend the book.
Sehr empfehlenswerte Kurzgeschichtensammlung, meine Highlights waren I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God is a Big Responsibility , Frame-by-Frame und The Difference.
Interessante Sammlung von Kurzgeschichten. Hat ein paar sehr gute Stories dabei.
Lena Uhh, sehr interessante Story, was passieren könnte, wenn wir Persönlichkeiten hochladen und vervielfältigen könnten. 4 Sterne
If You Are Reading This Geschichte über eine Erstkontakt. Konnte ich nicht viel mit anfangen. 2.5 Sterne
Frame-by-Frame Ahh, fühlte ich mich ein bisschen (natürlich nur an die Art der Kommunikation zwischen den Modulen) an Otto's "Der menschliche Körper" erinnert. In einem selbstfahrenden Vehikel sprechen diverse Module miteinander kurz vor dem Ausweichen/Überfahren eines Hindernisses 3.5 Sterne
The Difference Ist der Chatbot ein realer Gefangener oder doch nur Illusion? Ahh, ich liebe solche Stories, deshalb 5 Sterne
cripes does anybody remember Google People Eine Art KI Experiment von Google? Ok, hab ich nicht verstanden. 2 Sterne
Driver ist ein wohl als Fortsetzung von Lena gedacht. Auch hier ein spannender Ansatz. 4 Sterne
I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God is a Big Responsibility Die vermeintlichen Möglichkeiten des Quantencomputings. Noch so eine Geschichte die ich geliebt habe. 5 Sterne
A Powerful Culture In der Geschichte gibt es verschieden Erden, und eine davon beschließt ihren Abfall über einen Dimensionstunnel auf die anderen zu verteilen. War nicht so meins. 2.5 Sterne
Valuable Humans in Transit Was machen, wenn ein Asteroid auf die Erde trifft und nochmal alles kaputt machen will. Hier ist eine mögliche Antwort :-) 4 Sterne
Eine schöne Sammlung, die mir Spaß gemacht hat. qntm schreibt seine Kurzgeschichten gerne als Berichte und wissenschaftliche Artikel. Es gibt selten Dialoge (auch die Twitter Nachrichten in “cripes does anybody remember Google People” sind keine Dialoge) und kaum Figuren, wenig Charakterisierungen. Der Schwerpunkt der Geschichten liegt dadurch stark auf einer Handlungsidee oder einem originellen formalen Aufbau (wie in “cripes ….”). Deshalb ist für mich bei diesen SF-Kurzgeschichten schon noch Luft nach oben.
Ein paar Details: “Lena” ist eine sehr schöne detaillierte Beschreibung des “standard test brain image”, wie es benutzt wird, welche Erfahrungen man damit gemacht hat und was der Mensch, dessen Gehirn hier digitalisiert wurde, darüber denkt. Die Geschichte enthält einige spannende Gedanken zum Thema, verpackt in einem trockenen Bericht. Eine seltsame, aber mit Liebe zum Detail geschriebene Geschichte, ist “If You Are Reading This”, in der der Ich-Erzähler von seinem Besuch bei seinem Idol berichtet. Dieser alternde Astronom übergibt ihm ein Tape, das evt. die Nachricht einer außerirdischen Zivilisation enthalten könnte. Oder auch nicht… “The Frame-by-Frame” entpuppt sich als eine köstliche Geschichte, in der die verschiedenen Programm Threads eines autonomen Fahrzeugs ihre Reaktion auf eine schwierige Verkehrssituation diskutieren und zu einem erstaunlichen Ergebnis kommen. In “The Difference” versucht eine Person, in einem Chat andere davon zu überzeugen, dass sie ein Mensch ist. Das klappt nicht gut. “Gorge” ist eine klassische Pointengeschichte um einen seltsamen Planeten, den eine zukünftige Menschheit entdeckt. “cripes does anybody remember Google People” hat mir nicht gefallen. Es ist eine sehr seltsame Geschichte, die aus Twitter Nachrichten nach und nach ein seltsames Gefühl dazu entstehen lässt, was “Google People” ist (oder war?). “Driver”: Diese Geschichte bezeichnet qntm selbst als “follow-up” zu “Lena”. Auch sie berichtet trocken im Stil eines wissenschaftlichen Artikels vom Schicksal eines “snapshot of the living brain”. Das entstandene Image wird benutzt, um andere virtuelle Images zu managen. Wieder finde ich den distanzierten Stil durchaus passend, der in der Kürze ethische Fragen andeutet und Konsequenzen aus dem Upload eines Bewusstseins behandelt. In “I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God Is a Big Responsibility” ermöglicht ein großartiger neuer “Hypercomputer” eine unendlich genaue Simulation von Allem. Dies führt zu verrückten Konsequenzen. Eine nette Idee, aber die Unschärferelation sollte das verhindern. “A Powerful Culture” ist eine böse Geschichte, die den rücksichtslosen Umgang mit gefährlichem Müll thematisiert. Es ist wieder eine der Geschichten, in denen berichtet wird: ohne Dialoge, ohne Figuren. Gut zu lesen, aber in der Grundidee nicht wirklich neu. In “Valuable Humans in Transit” erzählt eine weit fortgeschrittenen KI, wie sie die Menschheit versucht zu retten.
Aww; I really wanted to love this one. - Started out good and for a second I thought I'd jumped ahead in my nonfiction hard science reading list. That opening had me double checking but the 2010-2073 life and death year settled it.
It had promise and it would nosedive into not my taste and then rise and land firmly in something I enjoyed. 2.75⭐ upgraded for Lena story
Plot/Storyline/Themes: Multiple stories some hits and some misses. I can see what they were going for though. Makes me weary of trying to read the rest of the qntm backlist.
Two Sentences, A Scene or less - Characters: I cared for no one. I just read and moved on, read and moved on. Very clinical.
Favorite/Curious/Ludicrous/Unique Scene:: The Difference chapter was interesting but Gorge was the best in my already depleting interest in this collection.
Favorite/Curious/Ludicrous/Unique Quotes: 🖤 “the longest-lived MMAcevedo underwent brain death due to entropy increase at a subjective age of 145.”(On AI Death due to extreme context drift and workload.)
Favorite/Curious/Ludicrous/Unique Concepts: ■ MMAcevedo: Living Snapshot of A Brain ■MMAcevedo's Context Drift
StoryGraph Challenge: 1800 Books by 2025 Challenge Prompt: 150 Science Fiction Books by 2025
Ok, so after I thought about each of these shorts individually, I realized that this is actually quite a terrifying collection of horror short stories and not just SciFi or SpecFic. Most of the pieces are written with the underlying dark humour of inevitable extinction/chaos (often through our own hubris, of course) and some are heavily tech/sciency oriented and so require perhaps more than a reread or two before grasping the import. But despite all that, or maybe because I love hard-core scifi (even if I don’t understand all of what I’m reading) qntm does an excellent job of keeping me in the moment.
Several of these stories left me truly horrified and terrified (and often saddened) of our impending future (doom?), and more than seriously creeped me out.
Naturally I felt compelled to fall down the qntm rabbit-hole and visiting their webpage led me to the comments section for the various pieces which in turn led me off into all sorts of weird corners of spec fic and other writing and things I must investigate further.
I love in the comments on qntm’s page he calls this unfiction and it makes absolute sense to me and I need more of it.
Very good, especially for a short story collection, as always a few hits and a few misses with favorites being ‘Lena’ and ‘The Difference’. Explorations of AI ethics, space exploration, time travel, and even the implications of being God.
Excellent series of sci-fi short stories, fans of black mirror or SCP entries will love it. Definitely worth the short time required to read it. Lena and Driver were easily my favourites among the stories
Lenna and I didn't knew about it, was photo and standard test image used in the field of digital image processing starting in 1973. In this tale we follow another character which instead of a photo, the brain was scanned. This is the history of their uses... highly interesting sci-fi (not so distant) where we can achieve for all purposes immortality... but is it a good thing?
If You Are Reading This a story told in blog-like entries and was a bit weird for me
The Frame- it's basically the story of a self-driving car and deciding their actions when they encounter someone right in front of them. You get the supervisor, the video, the brake, the wheel, the abs etc. Very interesting and comedic
The Difference this was a comic , and unsettling story that deals with a man being trapped somewhere while other people log in and out and he tries those people to help him out...
Gorge a pure sci-fi story about humanity discovering a weird planet... to be honest was a bit confusing
cripes does anybody remember Google People this is a chat log, twitter probably, where a man is talking about a now-defunct google application called Google People which was a bit weird since , it worked like facebook, but it did a lot more things like fake entries, adding randomly people, asking if x or y was known to them etc. It was interesting. the ending was a bit like the Difference story... or was it?
Driver this story follows the first one. If you enjoy the first you going to enjoy the second.
I Don't Know, Timmy, Being God Is a Big Responsibility This tale is very good. It's about a computer, above the most powerful we have nowadays, the quantum computing, and these two IT create a simulation of a world (imagine Populous game) but then things got out of hand and strange stuff starts to happen mixing realities and existences.. (you can deduce by the title)
A Powerful Culture is a story about a world where something is discovered that links this world to another parallel world. And that world is using another earth as a dumping ground of pollution. Great ending.
Valuable Humans in Transit this was interesting tale where an AI narrator saves humanity from an asteroid impact... But there are more stuff in there. I was confused until I re-read again.
Overall a very interesting tales Some were more impactful than others. That's why I will rate 73/100. Because some stories really brought down the top ones... Read in one day. What more can I wish? This person is very good.
Astonishingly good. Readable, inventive, philosophically interesting sci fi. The story about simulating the deterministic universe is awesome. The stories about replicated humans is awesome. Hell, they're all awesome. HIGHLY recommend for any sci fi fan. I'll be reading more of his stuff in the future.
Vignettes or short story ideas, not complete literary work. On one hand, it is refreshing not to have to slough through pointless characters' backgrounds. On the other, it feels like lazy writing or an undercooked release.
Hughes is able to achieve big feelings that many novels take over hundreds of pages to get to, in the span of mere single digits of pages. These stories are all insanely satisfying to read and quick to the punch, yet elegantly written. Can’t wait to try their other stories.