When a generation ship that's traveled for a thousand years suddenly stops, one man, the lone "sinner" who can read books, must risk his life to complete the mission. A thrilling space adventure from the author of "Way Station," "City," and "Mastodonia."
"He was honored by fans with three Hugo awards and by colleagues with one Nebula award and was named the third Grand Master by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA) in 1977." (Wikipedia)
Not for nothing was Simak a journalist/popularizer of science. This generation-ship tale is short, so doesn't go into a lot of details about *how* a thousand-year voyage through space would be accomplished without human maintenance of its workings, and how it came to be that twentieth-century English was the lingua franca of the Ship, and whether the Ship's breeding program took account of skin color variations, and why The Little Woman was still in her place...the list goes on.
But what I see in Simak's story is the basic story I read SF for. It is about the tiny little prisons Humankind builds and calls Paradise. It is about the unquestioning and overly trusting way we accept what is given and hunger only for more, not radically and materially different. Novelty is more important than innovation...gossip more important than erudition. Wake up, Author Simak shouted at the Folk of 1953 who read this story, Life is short so wake up!
His fix-up novel, City, was in much the same vein. The Earth is subject to disasters and cataclysms, but savvy Humankind was ready for that and.... As I think we can imagine, since Simak lived through the Cold War (died only three years before it ended, if we take 1991's collapse of the Soviet Union as The End), that was more a triumph of hope over experience. But his fiction, not precisely deft in execution, was always aimed at making a point about doing your own best, convincing others to do theirs, making the best of the stuff you had to hand. Teddy Roosevelt's formulation would've appealed to Simak, I think: "Do what you can, with what you have, where you are."
And that's all the Folk on the Ship have done. It isn't perfect but they're still alive, and Humanity can chug along somehow. But Mr. Simak, what I wouldn't give to ramp your ideas about women above the helpmeet/homemaker/uterus bearer. Mary Hoff, Mrs. Hero, sees a whole new world and her first thought is, "can we have a baby now?" She's *asking*permission*from*her*husband* to have a baby on a wide-open new planet.
Feminists are duly warned: Probably not enough substance here to outweigh the deep, dark, dank cave of regression Simak lived in. I'm not resentful that I read it. I won't go out of my way to urge you to. But Simak's view of Humanity seems to accord with mine: Pretty damned lazy, really happy to remain stupid, and full of hate and spite, but love 'em or leave 'em.
Does the Shipping News cover off-planet departures?
When the Mutter began everyone about the ship became nervous. And then when “the floor became a wall and the wall a floor,” and the stars stood still, they all panicked. But the panic was short lived, because everyone knew that despite these foretold signs of the End, the ship will keep them safe. But one man, Jon Hoff, knows otherwise. He’s the one heretic that can read, and he knows that without human guidance, the ship, the starship, will burn up in an alien sun and the mission of forty generations and a thousand year along with everyone aboard will come to a dead End.
Much like Robert Heinlein’s earlier Orphans of the Sky (1941) and Ben Bova’s later End of Exile (1975), Simak’s story deals with the decedents of an original crew that have devolved into a primitive superstitious society ignorant of their origin, the purpose of their journey, or even that they are on a journey.
Spacebred Generations authored by Simak and published in 1953 tells the story of a society of humans living on a ship, which, unknown to its inhabitants, was a colony ship sent to a habitable planet. Society's understanding of their surroundings has significantly degraded over the 1000 years of faring. Furthermore, they have developed a religion at the center of which was the beginning, known as the Myth, and the End, known as the Legend, towards which their fates were spun. The religion included sacred elements such as pictures with trees, flowers, and rivers. One end result of this religion was the burning of the books that were considered sacrilegious. As a matter of fact, any sort of knowledge and curiosity was forbidden. The End has arrived, the stars have stopped moving and no one really knew what was to happen now. In that society was a man given a task. Jon had been given a Letter, passed along the generations within his family. He opened the Letter which said there is no such thing as Myth and Legend, that the End is merely the Ship’s destination. Jon has used the Book, a dictionary, to understand the meaning of that word. He decided to access a learning device that was teaching him various sciences. Additionally, he found keys to the engine room of the ship and a gun. When he went to open the engine room, his childhood friend, Joe, followed him. When Joe learned that Jon was a heretic he began running away. Jon shot his friend because it would risk the lives of everyone once Jon was killed for his heresy. Then, an older man, Joshua, who was a heretic too by way of being curious about things, joined Jon in the engine room who was trying to figure out how to find the planets and on which one to land. When Joshua went to find food, he never came back and the population of the ship tried to stop Jon. Having nowhere to go, he hid himself in the engine room and spent the whole time determining where to land the ship. He found out that one of the planets exactly resembled the sacred images. The ship locked itself landed, and everyone on it was given the ultimatum of either they will get killed by the automatic release of gas or they would inhabit the new Earth. According to Jon, this was all planned by the humans from the old Earth. The story resembles the process of scientific discovery through laws, reason, and purpose. Joshua told Jon that every law must have a reason, and the reason is what mattered when following the law. This closely resembles the philosophical view of scientific discoveries where every law of nature must have a reason–mechanism–which guides it. In parallel, Simak also adds one of the known theories that in lieu of religion, everything had a purpose, hence a reason, and a guiding mechanism which drove the scientific revolution in Europe and, of course, Asia. There is also the tension between law and reason, which, according to Joshua, “for if the reason is bad, then the law itself is bad, for a law is no more than a rule designed for a certain reason or to carry out a purpose.” Purpose is the second track that generates a law. This diverges from pure scientific discovery; in contrast, it speaks of logic embedded in the universe, and points towards optimistic determinism in which the laws of nature can be observed from phenomena. In the story, those observations are made by Jon using various instruments. “The ship was automatic… It needed only the hand and brain of Man to tell it what to do,” run the lines by which Simak is saying that the laws of nature are automatic and independent of “Man,” but man could intervene in that automaticity. Simak ties intelligent design observed in nature to something that precedes humanity. Jon noted after landing the ship that “every step was planned” of the ship’s purpose. The final sentence that Jon has gleaned off was that “for when the men of Earth had planned so well, they would not have failed in the final moment to have left a letter of instructions for the starting over.” Sounds all too familiar! Is not the Bible considered a God-inspired guide? The point that Simak is making goes beyond the point that religion was invented by humans. He is arguing that humans being able to observe intelligent design points towards a purpose that precedes and encapsulates the current human knowledge. It could be God, it could be a more intelligent alien race than us. We don’t know. What we do know, and Simak is trying to point out, is that there are clearly laws, reason, and purpose.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
When the Journey Matters More Than the Destination
Clifford D. Simak’s short story "Target Generation" isn’t so much about space as it is about people — their faith, their doubts, and the fragile systems they build to hold onto meaning. The story unfolds aboard a spaceship that has been traveling for generations toward a distant star. For the current inhabitants, the destination has become more myth than mission — a kind of sacred truth no one really questions anymore. They simply live within a framework that was decided long before their time.
Simak weaves several complex themes into the narrative. There’s the "inner religion" of the ship, the efforts of a few individuals to reexamine reality, and the inevitable tension between those who want to preserve order and those who seek truth. The real intrigue lies in watching these forces collide. The characters don’t just argue — they live through their conflicts, suffer, and make hard choices. It becomes clear that the whole spacefaring premise is a backdrop for a deeper exploration of human nature.
What makes this story stand out is that it’s deeply human. There are no long technical expositions about engines or navigation systems, but there’s plenty of raw emotion. The characters are flawed: some fear change, some stir conflict, some wrestle with the inability to believe as their ancestors did. Simak conveys all this with a light touch, as if observing from within.
The ending is powerful. It carries tension, twists, and a moment of truth. The final pages fly by, not just as a resolution, but as the culmination of everything the characters have struggled with — their hopes, doubts, and inner battles.
Though short, the story is rich. It’s not bloated or overcomplicated, yet it gives you plenty to reflect on. And while it was written in the mid-20th century, it reads as if it could’ve been written today. The questions Simak raises are timeless.
This isn’t a story about space. It’s a story about us — about those who search for meaning, even when the road is long and uncertain. And that’s where its true power lies.
another excellent short-story from Clifford Simak's. I am a fan of Simak , but sometimes his books lose focus. This short story has a nice narrow focus. Short premise (slight spoiler): Earth Spaceship on a 1000 year journey to another star system. The ship is self contained (they grow food etc). It is a model for complete efficiency and recycling etc. This story has the normal strange twists normal to simak's writings..