A very tidy, chaste romance -- that may sound like I'm damning with faint praise, but this was advertised as a romance with "no steam", so it definitely accomplished that aspect of its goal!
I'm always weak for Beauty and the Beast retellings, and like many elder millenials one of my formative influence was Gargoyles, so this book grabbed my attention very quickly. It's well-written from a technical angle (I only found a few typos, but nothing immersion-breaking), and Ember and Dyrerisan are clear on the page. I appreciate that they also had positive relationships outside of their own, even though the premise of the novel is that neither of them are really able to connect, for various reasons. Those reasons are very plausible within the world of the novel, so I didn't have one of those "huh, this doesn't make sense" moments.
It's also decently paced, and I really liked the whole parallel curses aspect of the story. So why three stars?
Because -- and this is an issue I see in a lot of romance novels -- the romance just appears on the page, without much build-up, or without any apparent reason. Why do Ember and Dyrerisan care about each other? For the first half of the novel, they're either annoyed by or made nervous by the other; what may have been meant as flirty banter just comes across as two people being a bit rude to each other. Even if a novel has no steam or smut, there still needs to be chemistry, common interests, curiosity, silliness...all the things a real relationship is made of. That's lacking here, and it keeps the book from reaching its full potential.
And, it has to be said, not enough is done with the fact that Dyrerisan is living stone. Why does he need to eat? Is he stronger than a flesh-and-blood person? Does he have any magic abilities? Does it hurt to be made of stone?
A nice way to pass a few hours, one way or another -- I just wish it had gone a bit further with its concept and its leads.