Mmkay, so I normally don't count shorter picture books (Train to Somewhere was my exception, but it was deep and made me cry, so that's why), but I read this one out loud 27 times this week, so I feel like I'm allowed. By Tuesday afternoon I barely had to glance at the pages, thanks to the rhythm and repetition in the story. It really made the book fun, because it allowed my students to engage and "read" along with me! We had a really good time with it--even the older kiddos! The illustrations looked a little mleh to me, but the children never said anything. They DID open a discussion on does-this-story-necessarily-have-to-be-a-Christmas-story, due to their flowery nature.
(I typically do NOT read the same book to all grade levels, but we are going to do lessons with different versions + our Christmas program this year is the story with a twist, so we had to learn the background.)