What do you think?
Rate this book


72 pages, Paperback
First published February 28, 1988
When I was newer to the movement, I didn’t understand this at all. I thought the main point of criticism was to keep everyone feeling good and to keep things running smoothly. When more politically experienced people struggled over ideas, I nearly always thought they were being sectarian or unkind. But the more I learned about the experience of different liberation movements, the more I could see that criticism had a more profound purpose. Movements that took wrong directions were defeated or sold out. Movements that were able to learn from their mistakes were able to revolutionize their societies and change the lives of millions. So in a very real way, our ability to give useful criticism/self-criticism depends on developing ourselves politically and ideologically. This means studying the experiences of different revolutionary movements and the history of the U.S, and collectively carrying out and evaluating political work. (35)
"But if anyone accused me of sounding unnatural in this effort, I was prepared to give them Marshall Rosenberg’s famous line: “Look buddy, it’s your choice: either you can bear with me while I try to listen to you, or we can try it in my natural style– I’ll just call you a horse’s ass and we’ll be done with it.”